Canonical Classics ← 第七十回
第七十回
yāobǎofàngyānshāhuǒ
kōngdàojīnlíng

The Fiend's Treasure Looses Smoke, Sand and Fire · Wukong by Stratagem Steals the Purple-Gold Bells

天理難容
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

天理難容 Heaven Will Not Allow It

zhèguówángzhànzhànwáng使shǐyānhuǒfēishāguówángjūnchénbǎixìngděngxiǎnghuóshíděngzhànledechéngchíwángchēngděngchēngchénsuīrányǒuxiǎoguānjuézhǐshìtiānnánróng。」zhèguówángzhànzhànwáng使shǐyānhuǒfēishāguówángjūnchénbǎixìngděngxiǎnghuóshíděngzhànledechéngchíwángchēngděngchēngchénsuīrányǒuxiǎoguānjuézhǐshìtiānnánróng。」


逐句解 Line by line

zhèguówángzhànzhàn zhèguówángzhànzhàn

"On this errand, if that king will not fight, well and good; but if he fights it must go badly for him."

則可 is a literary formula marking the acceptable branch of an either-or, and it sounds oddly stiff in a mouth that has just said some-such-war-letter twice. He slips into the register of the documents he is carrying the moment he starts predicting.

wáng使shǐyānhuǒfēishāguówángjūnchénbǎixìngděngxiǎnghuó wáng使shǐyānhuǒfēishāguówángjūnchénbǎixìngděngxiǎnghuó

"When our Great King looses his smoke and fire and flying sand, that king and his ministers and his commons — not one of them may hope to come out alive."

is , to manage to, following 莫想 — do not imagine you will. The three weapons get named in one breath by somebody who has never had to stand in them, and in a third order again: the chapter's title has them smoke, sand, fire; the narrative delivered them fire, smoke, sand; and he says smoke, fire, sand.

shíděngzhànledechéngchíwángchēngděngchēngchén shíděngzhànledechéngchíwángchēngděngchēngchén

"Then we shall have taken his walls and moats, and the Great King will style himself emperor and we shall style ourselves his ministers."

twice in eight characters, once for the master and once for the followers, and the same verb does for both — to style oneself, which is a claim rather than an appointment. 城池 is walls-and-moat together, the standing pair for a city considered as a thing that can be taken.

suīrányǒuxiǎoguānjuézhǐshìtiānnánróng。」 suīrányǒuxiǎoguānjuézhǐshìtiānnánróng。」

"There will be ranks and offices for us, high and low, no doubt — only Heaven's own principle will never allow it."

is nán, hard to, not the nàn of disaster: 天理難容 says Heaven can hardly find room for such a thing. Everything before the 只是 is his own side's case, laid out fairly, and then he refuses it.


總評 Commentary

He lays out the campaign competently and correctly — smoke, fire, sand, a certain massacre, the walls taken, the titles handed round — and then ends on a sentence that undoes the lot. He is not persuaded by his own side. He has worked out what the promotion is worth and concluded that Heaven will not stand for what earns it.

He has already passed judgement on his master once in this speech, calling him cruel-hearted at its opening; this is the same verdict again with Heaven behind it, delivered to nobody on an empty road. Wukong is sitting on the despatch bag listening, so the one audience for the verdict is the person already committed to enforcing it.

The prediction is right in every particular except its conclusion. The smoke and fire and sand are real and would do exactly what he says; the walls could be taken. What he has wrong is only that the match for his master — the one he has just dismissed as some Sun Pilgrim or other — is riding on his back.