Canonical Classics ← 第六十二回
第六十二回
滌dí垢gòu洗xǐ心xīn惟wéi掃sǎo塔tǎ
縛fù魔mó歸guī主zhǔ乃nǎi修xiū身shēn

Washing the Filth and Cleansing the Heart Is Only Sweeping the Pagoda · Binding the Fiend and Returning to the Master Is Cultivating the Self

人不可貌相
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

人不可貌相 Not To Be Judged By Looks

國guó王wáng道dào:「高gāo徒tú在zài那nǎ裡lǐ?」三sān藏zàng用yòng手shǒu指zhǐ道dào:「那nà玉yù階jiē旁páng立lì者zhě便biàn是shì。」國guó王wáng見jiàn了le,大dà驚jīng道dào:「聖shèng僧sēng如rú此cǐ丰fēng姿zī,高gāo徒tú怎zěn麼me這zhè等děng像xiàng貌mào?」孫sūn大dà聖shèng聽tīng見jiàn了le,厲lì聲shēng高gāo叫jiào道dào:「陛bì下xià,『人rén不bù可kě貌mào相xiàng,海hǎi水shuǐ不bù可kě斗dǒu量liáng』。若ruò愛ài丰fēng姿zī者zhě,如rú何hé捉zhuō得de妖yāo賊zéi也yě?」国guó王wáng道dào:「高gāo徒tú在zài那nǎ里lǐ?」三sān藏zàng用yòng手shǒu指zhǐ道dào:「那nà玉yù阶jiē旁páng立lì者zhě便biàn是shì。」国guó王wáng见jiàn了le,大dà惊jīng道dào:「圣shèng僧sēng如rú此cǐ丰fēng姿zī,高gāo徒tú怎zěn么me这zhè等děng像xiàng貌mào?」孙sūn大dà圣shèng听tīng见jiàn了le,厉lì声shēng高gāo叫jiào道dào:「陛bì下xià,『人rén不bù可kě貌mào相xiàng,海hǎi水shuǐ不bù可kě斗dǒu量liáng』。若ruò爱ài丰fēng姿zī者zhě,如rú何hé捉zhuō得de妖yāo贼zéi也yě?」


逐句解 Line by line

國guó王wáng道dào:「高gāo徒tú在zài那nǎ裡lǐ?」 国guó王wáng道dào:「高gāo徒tú在zài那nǎ里lǐ?」

The king said, "Where is your worthy disciple?"

那裡 is the question-word here, nǎ — the fifth place in the chapter where 那 asks rather than points.

三sān藏zàng用yòng手shǒu指zhǐ道dào:「那nà玉yù階jiē旁páng立lì者zhě便biàn是shì。」 三sān藏zàng用yòng手shǒu指zhǐ道dào:「那nà玉yù阶jiē旁páng立lì者zhě便biàn是shì。」

Tripitaka pointed with his hand. "That one standing beside the jade steps is he."

And 那 is the pointing one in this sentence, four characters after the question-word in the one before. Nothing on the page tells them apart.

國guó王wáng見jiàn了le,大dà驚jīng道dào:「聖shèng僧sēng如rú此cǐ丰fēng姿zī,高gāo徒tú怎zěn麼me這zhè等děng像xiàng貌mào?」 国guó王wáng见jiàn了le,大dà惊jīng道dào:「圣shèng僧sēng如rú此cǐ丰fēng姿zī,高gāo徒tú怎zěn么me这zhè等děng像xiàng貌mào?」

The king looked, and was greatly startled. "The holy monk is of such fine bearing — how comes your worthy disciple to have a face like that?"

丰姿 is fine bearing and 像貌 is what a person looks like. The king sets one against the other and gets exactly the retort he deserves. This is the second time in the space of a page that the court has been frightened by Pilgrim's face.

孫sūn大dà聖shèng聽tīng見jiàn了le,厲lì聲shēng高gāo叫jiào道dào:「陛bì下xià,『人rén不bù可kě貌mào相xiàng,海hǎi水shuǐ不bù可kě斗dǒu量liáng』。 孙sūn大dà圣shèng听tīng见jiàn了le,厉lì声shēng高gāo叫jiào道dào:「陛bì下xià,『人rén不bù可kě貌mào相xiàng,海hǎi水shuǐ不bù可kě斗dǒu量liáng』。

Sun the Great Sage heard him, and called out in a harsh voice, "Your Majesty — a man is not to be measured by his looks, nor sea water by the dǒu."

Two proverbs in one breath, and the second is the memorable one: 海水不可斗量, you cannot measure the sea with a dǒu. A dǒu is the grain measure, about ten litres of millet — a wooden bucket of a thing, and the joke is the sheer mismatch of scale. The pair is stock and stands in the 增廣昔時賢文 primer and in the 《金瓶梅》, both with 凡 at the head, which the novel drops. 貌相 takes 相 as xiàng, appearance; 斗量 is dǒu liáng.

若ruò愛ài丰fēng姿zī者zhě,如rú何hé捉zhuō得de妖yāo賊zéi也yě?」 若ruò爱ài丰fēng姿zī者zhě,如rú何hé捉zhuō得de妖yāo贼zéi也yě?」

"If it were fine bearing you wanted, how would the fiend-thieves have been caught?"

如何 sets up a how-could shape, so 捉得 takes the light linking de — against 得寶 two segments on, which is a genuine attainment and takes dé. The argument is the one Pilgrim already made about keeping the fiends alive: judge a thing by what it is for.


總評 Commentary

Pilgrim has stood through the whole audience without speaking and without bowing, and the first thing out of his mouth is a proverb, shouted. He is not answering an insult so much as correcting a method: the king has just been shown that his three-year inquiry failed for want of looking properly, and is now judging the man who solved it by his face.

The proverb pairs a man with the sea, and both halves say the same thing — the instrument is wrong for the object. You cannot take the measure of a person by looking, any more than you can bail out an ocean with a grain measure.

It is also, from Pilgrim, a piece of self-description he has had a very long time to prepare. The court whispered that he had the face of the Thunder Duke a few sentences ago and did not dare look at him twice. He now tells them, at volume, that they are using the wrong faculty.