Canonical Classics ← 第二十七回
第二十七回
shīsāntángsānzàng
shèngsēnghènzhúměihóuwáng

The Corpse-Fiend Thrice Mocks Tang Tripitaka · The Holy Monk in Wrath Banishes the Handsome Monkey King

白骨夫人
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

白骨夫人 The White-Bone Lady

tángsēngjīngdào:「kōngzhèréncáilezěnmejiùhuàzuòduīlóu?」xíngzhědào:「shìqiánlíngzuòguàidejiāngshīzàirénbàiběnbèishājiùxiànleběnxiàngliángshàngyǒuhángjiàozuòbáirén』。」tángsēngwénshuōdàoxìnlezěnjìnjièpángbiānsuōzuǐdào:「shīdeshǒuzhònggùnxiōngrénzhǐniànhuàerbiànhuàzhèyàngyǎndeyǎnli。」tángsēngguǒráněrruǎnyòuxìnlesuíniàntángsēngjīngdào:「kōngzhèréncáilezěnmejiùhuàzuòduīlóu?」xíngzhědào:「shìqiánlíngzuòguàidejiāngshīzàirénbàiběnbèishājiùxiànleběnxiàngliángshàngyǒuhángjiàozuòbáirén』。」tángsēngwénshuōdàoxìnlezěnjìnjièpángbiānsuōzuǐdào:「shīdeshǒuzhònggùnxiōngrénzhǐniànhuàerbiànhuàzhèyàngyǎndeyǎnli。」tángsēngguǒráněrruǎnyòuxìnlesuíniàn


逐句解 Line by line

tángsēngjīngdào:「kōngzhèréncáilezěnmejiùhuàzuòduīlóu?」 tángsēngjīngdào:「kōngzhèréncáilezěnmejiùhuàzuòduīlóu?」

The Tang Monk exclaimed in alarm: "Wukong, this person has only just died — how has she turned into a pile of bones?"

The question is a real one, and it is the first genuinely open thing the elder has said in some while. She died a moment ago — how is she already old bones? He is asking, which means that for a moment he is listening.

xíngzhědào:「shìqiánlíngzuòguàidejiāngshīzàirénbàiběnbèishājiùxiànleběnxiàng xíngzhědào:「shìqiánlíngzuòguàidejiāngshīzàirénbàiběnbèishājiùxiànleběnxiàng

Said Pilgrim, "She is a corpse-fiend with a lurking spirit, a walking dead thing that bewitches folk and ruins their root; struck dead by me, she has reverted to her true form.

僵尸 (jiāng shī) is the walking corpse of Chinese folklore: stiff-limbed, animated by a spirit that never left the body, and the direct ancestor of the hopping vampires of Hong Kong cinema. That is what she is, and it explains the bones — kill the thing properly and what remains is what was always underneath. 迷人敗本 is to bewitch people and ruin their vital root, the being the stock of life-force one is born with. Note the reading: in 本相 is xiàng, "form, appearance", not the xiāng, "mutually", found elsewhere.

liángshàngyǒuhángjiàozuòbáirén』。」 liángshàngyǒuhángjiàozuòbáirén』。」

"On her spine there is a line of writing, reading 'Lady White-Bone.'"

Here at last is the name, and it is written on her spine: 白骨夫人, Lady White-Bone. This is the 屍魔, the Corpse-Fiend of the chapter's title, identified for the first time — the narrator has withheld it through the whole episode. And this is the one place in the entire chapter where is read háng, "a row, a line" of writing, against sixty-five instances of xíng, "to go". A small reading, sitting on the single most important object in the chapter.

tángsēngwénshuōdàoxìnle tángsēngwénshuōdàoxìnle

Hearing this, the Tang Monk was, in fact, inclined to believe him.

倒也 carries a note of mild surprise: he was, after all, inclined to believe it. This is as close as the truth gets to landing. Four characters of belief, and they are about to be talked straight back out of him.

zěnjìnjièpángbiānsuōzuǐdào:「shīdeshǒuzhònggùnxiōngrénzhǐniànhuàerbiànhuàzhèyàngyǎndeyǎnli。」 zěnjìnjièpángbiānsuōzuǐdào:「shīdeshǒuzhònggùnxiōngrénzhǐniànhuàerbiànhuàzhèyàngyǎndeyǎnli。」

But there was no stopping Eight Rules, who slandered from the sidelines: "Master, his hand is heavy and his cudgel cruel — he's beaten a person to death, and only fears you'll recite the spell, so he's deliberately worked this change of shape to pull the wool over your eyes."

And Bajie runs the identical play he ran with the maggots. The true form is not a revelation, he says, it is Wukong's conjuring, thrown up to stop you reciting. 掩你的眼目 is to cover over your eyes — the same idea as the eye-screening trick he alleged the first time. It worked then. It works now. (Both instances of point, ; is zhòng; the of 話兒 is the small tag.)

tángsēngguǒráněrruǎnyòuxìnlesuíniàn tángsēngguǒráněrruǎnyòuxìnlesuíniàn

The Tang Monk, sure enough, was soft of ear, and believed him again, and forthwith began reciting anew.

耳軟 — soft-eared. It is still the ordinary Chinese for somebody who believes whoever spoke last, and the narrator sets it down as a plain diagnosis rather than an insult. That is the flaw, named outright. Not stupidity and not cruelty: an ear that gives way under whatever is pressed against it. And the recitation starts again at once.


總評 Commentary

This passage delivers the demon's true name and the chapter's title-figure: on the skeleton's spine, Lady White-Bone. The revelation is complete — a walking corpse, reverted by a true death to bare bones with her own name written on them. And it is here, on that inscription, that the character takes its rarer reading for the only time in the chapter.

For a moment the truth nearly holds. Faced with bones and a name, the elder was inclined to believe. But the passage turns on the chapter's own diagnosis of why he cannot keep hold of it: 耳軟, soft of ear. Bajie has only to reverse the evidence one last time — the true form is Wukong's trick — and the elder believes him again and resumes the spell. The demon is dead; her ally inside the party fights on.

The narrator's plain naming of the flaw matters to the chapter's moral clarity. Tripitaka is not stupid, and he is not cruel. He is credulous, governed by whoever spoke last and by his own horror of bloodshed. It is a gentle man's weakness, and it is enough, with Bajie's help, to turn the exposure of a demon into fresh grounds for punishing the one who exposed her.