Canonical Classics ← 第二十七回
第二十七回
shīsāntángsānzàng
shèngsēnghènzhúměihóuwáng

The Corpse-Fiend Thrice Mocks Tang Tripitaka · The Holy Monk in Wrath Banishes the Handsome Monkey King

老僧含羞
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

老僧含羞 The Elder Is Shamed

tángsēngkěnxìnzhǐshuōshìhǎorénxíngzhědào:「shīzhīdàolejiànděngróngmàorándònglefánxīnruòguǒyǒujiàojièshùláishāsēngxúnxiēcǎoláizuòjiàngjiùzàizhèyuánfángchéngshìmenjiāsànlequèshìjiànshìyòushèshénjīng?」zhǎnglǎoyuánshìruǎnshànderénchīdezhèyánxiūdeguāngtóuchèěrtōnghóngtángsēngkěnxìnzhǐshuōshìhǎorénxíngzhědào:「shīzhīdàolejiànděngróngmàorándònglefánxīnruòguǒyǒujiàojièshùláishāsēngxúnxiēcǎoláizuòjiàngjiùzàizhèyuánfángchéngshìmenjiāsànlequèshìjiànshìyòushèshénjīng?」zhǎnglǎoyuánshìruǎnshànderénchīdezhèyánxiūdeguāngtóuchèěrtōnghóng


逐句解 Line by line

tángsēngkěnxìnzhǐshuōshìhǎorén tángsēngkěnxìnzhǐshuōshìhǎorén

But the Tang Monk would by no means believe it, insisting only that she was a good person.

那唐僧 "that Tang Monk," 那 (nà) (demonstrative, first); 那裡肯信 "how would [he] believe," 那裡 (nǎ lǐ) rhetorical, 那 (nǎ) (second). The flat report of the elder's obstinacy — set against Wukong's just-concluded, experience-backed warning — measures how completely appearance has overmastered evidence in his mind.

xíngzhědào:「shīzhīdàolejiànděngróngmàorándònglefánxīn xíngzhědào:「shīzhīdàolejiànděngróngmàorándònglefánxīn

Said Pilgrim, "Master, I know you: seeing a face like hers, you're bound to have felt the stir of a carnal heart.

我知道你了 "I know [what] you [are about]." 那等容貌 "that sort of face," 那 (nà). 動了凡心 (dòng le fán xīn) "stirred a mortal/carnal heart" — Wukong turns on the elder the same charge the narrator laid on Bajie, a barbed and dangerous jest.

ruòguǒyǒujiàojièshùláishāsēngxúnxiēcǎoláizuòjiàngjiùzàizhèyuánfángchéngshìmenjiāsànlequèshìjiànshì ruòguǒyǒujiàojièshùláishāsēngxúnxiēcǎoláizuòjiàngjiùzàizhèyuánfángchéngshìmenjiāsànlequèshìjiànshì

"If that's really your mind, then have Eight Rules fell a few trees and Sha Monk gather some grass, and I'll play carpenter and knock together a hut right here, where you can consummate the match with her and be done — and we'll all go our separate ways. Wouldn't that be a tidy piece of business?

圓房成事 (yuán fáng chéng shì) "to consummate the marriage." 搭個窩鋪 "to put up a rude hut"; 散了 (sàn le) "[we'd] all disband," 散 (sàn). 事業 (shì yè) here ironically "a fine piece of work." Wukong's mockery is deliberately outrageous — proposing the pilgrims build the monk a nuptial hut and abandon the quest — a taunt calculated to wound.

yòushèshénjīng?」 yòushèshénjīng?」

"Why go to all the trouble of the journey — what scriptures would there be left to fetch?"

跋涉 (bá shè) "to trudge, toil over roads and rivers." 取甚經去 "fetch what scriptures" — 甚 (shén) "what." Wukong presses the jibe to its logical end: if the master will yield to a pretty face, the whole pilgrimage is void. It is a cruel argument, and it lands.

zhǎnglǎoyuánshìruǎnshànderénchīdezhèyánxiūdeguāngtóuchèěrtōnghóng zhǎnglǎoyuánshìruǎnshànderénchīdezhèyánxiūdeguāngtóuchèěrtōnghóng

The elder, being by nature a soft and gentle soul, could not stomach words like these, and blushed a burning red from his shaven crown to the tips of his ears.

那長老 "that elder," 那 (nà) (first), 長 (zhǎng); 那裡吃得 "could hardly bear/stomach," 那裡 (nǎ lǐ) rhetorical (那 (nǎ), second), 得 (de) the complement; the second 得 (de) in 羞得 "so ashamed that." 軟善 (ruǎn shàn) "soft and good-natured." The blush from crown to ears is the humiliation that will, in the next passage, harden into anger and the reciting of the spell.


總評 Commentary

Wukong's tactics here shift from warning to taunt, and the shift is a miscalculation as much as a provocation. Stung by the master's refusal, he flings back the very charge the narrator had laid on Bajie — that a pretty face has stirred a "carnal heart" — and then compounds it with the outrageous proposal that the pilgrims build the monk a nuptial hut and abandon the quest. It is wit turned weapon, and it cuts.

The passage turns on Tripitaka's temperament. He is 軟善, soft and gentle, and it is precisely this softness — not stupidity — that cannot "stomach" Wukong's mockery. The blush that spreads from his shaven crown to his ears is shame, and shame in a proud-humble man curdles quickly. The reader can feel the scene tipping: the elder's humiliation is the fuel that the next passage's spell will ignite.

Beneath the comedy runs the chapter's deepest irony. Wukong is right about the demon and wrong in his handling of the master; his correct sight is delivered so woundingly that it guarantees rejection. The tragedy of the White-Bone Demon is authored as much by the disciple's tongue as by the master's blindness.