Canonical Classics ← 第二十七回
第二十七回
屍shī魔mó三sān戲xì唐táng三sān藏zàng
聖shèng僧sēng恨hèn逐zhú美měi猴hóu王wáng

The Corpse-Fiend Thrice Mocks Tang Tripitaka · The Holy Monk in Wrath Banishes the Handsome Monkey King

八戒攛掇
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

八戒攛掇 Bajie Stirs the Pot

行xíng者zhě道dào:「師shī父fù又yòu教jiào我wǒ去qù?回huí去qù便biàn也yě回huí去qù了le,只zhǐ是shì一yí件jiàn不bù相xiāng應yìng。」唐táng僧sēng道dào:「你nǐ有yǒu甚shén麼me不bù相xiāng應yìng處chù?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「師shī父fù,他tā要yào和hé你nǐ分fēn行xíng李lǐ哩li。跟gēn著zhe你nǐ做zuò了le這zhè幾jǐ年nián和hé尚shàng,不bù成chéng空kōng著zhe手shǒu回huí去qù?你nǐ把bǎ那nà包bāo袱fú內nèi的de甚shén麼me舊jiù褊biǎn衫shān,破pò帽mào子zi、分fēn兩liǎng件jiàn與yǔ他tā罷bà。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「师shī父fù又yòu教jiào我wǒ去qù?回huí去qù便biàn也yě回huí去qù了le,只zhǐ是shì一yí件jiàn不bù相xiāng应yìng。」唐táng僧sēng道dào:「你nǐ有yǒu甚shén么me不bù相xiāng应yìng处chù?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「师shī父fù,他tā要yào和hé你nǐ分fēn行xíng李lǐ哩li。跟gēn着zhe你nǐ做zuò了le这zhè几jǐ年nián和hé尚shàng,不bù成chéng空kōng着zhe手shǒu回huí去qù?你nǐ把bǎ那nà包bāo袱fú内nèi的de甚shén么me旧jiù褊biǎn衫shān,破pò帽mào子zi、分fēn两liǎng件jiàn与yǔ他tā罢bà。」


逐句解 Line by line

行xíng者zhě道dào:「師shī父fù又yòu教jiào我wǒ去qù? 行xíng者zhě道dào:「师shī父fù又yòu教jiào我wǒ去qù?

Said Pilgrim, "Master, you send me off again?

又: again. The weariness is all in that one character. (教 is jiào, "to make somebody do something".)

回huí去qù便biàn也yě回huí去qù了le,只zhǐ是shì一yí件jiàn不bù相xiāng應yìng。」 回huí去qù便biàn也yě回huí去qù了le,只zhǐ是shì一yí件jiàn不bù相xiāng应yìng。」

"To go back would be to go back — only there's one thing that isn't right."

相應 (xiāng yìng) is "to match, to correspond, to be fitting", so 不相應 is "there's something here that doesn't sit right". He leaves it vague, which is a mistake — there is somebody in this party who will be delighted to fill in the blank.

唐táng僧sēng道dào:「你nǐ有yǒu甚shén麼me不bù相xiāng應yìng處chù?」 唐táng僧sēng道dào:「你nǐ有yǒu甚shén么me不bù相xiāng应yìng处chù?」

The Tang Monk said, "What is it you find not right?"

The elder asks the obvious question, and in asking it hands Bajie his cue. (甚 is shén; 相應 takes xiāng and yìng.)

八bā戒jiè道dào:「師shī父fù,他tā要yào和hé你nǐ分fēn行xíng李lǐ哩li。 八bā戒jiè道dào:「师shī父fù,他tā要yào和hé你nǐ分fēn行xíng李lǐ哩li。

Said Eight Rules, "Master, he wants to split the luggage with you.

And Bajie answers for him again. What Wukong meant, apparently, is that he wants his share of the luggage. It is pure invention, and beautifully chosen invention: petty, mercenary, entirely plausible, and impossible to deny without sounding defensive. (行李 takes 行 as xíng, not háng.)

跟gēn著zhe你nǐ做zuò了le這zhè幾jǐ年nián和hé尚shàng,不bù成chéng空kōng著zhe手shǒu回huí去qù? 跟gēn着zhe你nǐ做zuò了le这zhè几jǐ年nián和hé尚shàng,不bù成chéng空kōng着zhe手shǒu回huí去qù?

"Having followed you and played the monk these few years, is he to go back empty-handed?

He even supplies the reasoning. A man who has worked for you these several years can hardly go home with nothing in his hands. Put that way it sounds fair, which is exactly what makes it poisonous. (Both instances of 著 are zhe.)

你nǐ把bǎ那nà包bāo袱fú內nèi的de甚shén麼me舊jiù褊biǎn衫shān,破pò帽mào子zi、分fēn兩liǎng件jiàn與yǔ他tā罷bà。」 你nǐ把bǎ那nà包bāo袱fú内nèi的de甚shén么me旧jiù褊biǎn衫shān,破pò帽mào子zi、分fēn两liǎng件jiàn与yǔ他tā罢bà。」

"Out of that bundle, hand him a couple of things — some old tunic, a battered hat — and let him go."

And then the settlement figure: an old tunic and a broken hat. Bajie has invented a grievance on Wukong's behalf and, in the same breath, priced it as low as it will go. That is the real malice of the speech. 褊衫 is a monk's plain shirt-robe. (那 points, nà; 甚 is shén; 帽子 takes the toneless zi.)


總評 Commentary

Bajie's work as the demon's unwitting ally reaches its meanest here. Wukong raises only a vague scruple — one thing isn't right — and Bajie, still smarting, fills the blank with a motive Wukong never expressed: that he wants the luggage split, to be paid off for his years of service. It is invention, and it works precisely because it is petty and plausible.

The malice is in the detail. Bajie proposes fobbing him off with an old tunic and a battered hat, a parting insult calculated to demean. Where the demon supplies the illusions and the master supplies the blindness, Bajie supplies the small corrosive readings that keep the wound open, turning a tragic misunderstanding into something merely sordid.

The scene also sets up the great protest that follows. Stung by the imputation of greed, Wukong answers not with a claim on the baggage but with a recitation of the kingdom he gave up — so that Bajie's cheap slur becomes the occasion for the proudest and most moving assertion of loyalty in the chapter.