Canonical Classics ← 第二十七回
第二十七回
shīsāntángsānzàng
shèngsēnghènzhúměihóuwáng

The Corpse-Fiend Thrice Mocks Tang Tripitaka · The Holy Monk in Wrath Banishes the Handsome Monkey King

堅執不吃
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

堅執不吃 The Monk Will Not Eat

sānzàngdào:「shànzāishànzāiyǒuzhāiguǒzilejiùláigǎnchījiǎshàngchīlefànzhàngxiǎodequèzuìzuòpínsēng?」jiàntángsēngkěnchīquèyòu滿mǎnmiànchūnshēngdào:「shīazhāisēngháishìxiǎozhànggèngshìshànrénshēnghǎodeshìxiūqiáoàilǎoliánpíndàntīngjiànshuōzhèfànsòngshīchīleqíngshàngxúnchánggèngshìtóng。」sānzàngzhǐshìchīsānzàngdào:「shànzāishànzāiyǒuzhāiguǒzilejiùláigǎnchījiǎshàngchīlefànzhàngxiǎodequèzuìzuòpínsēng?」jiàntángsēngkěnchīquèyòumǎnmiànchūnshēngdào:「shīazhāisēngháishìxiǎozhànggèngshìshànrénshēnghǎodeshìxiūqiáoàilǎoliánpíndàntīngjiànshuōzhèfànsòngshīchīleqíngshàngxúnchánggèngshìtóng。」sānzàngzhǐshìchī


逐句解 Line by line

sānzàngdào:「shànzāi sānzàngdào:「shànzāi

Tripitaka said, "How good!

善哉 (shàn zāi) "excellent! how good!" — a Buddhist exclamation of approval (Sanskrit sādhu). Won over by the pious tale, the monk warms toward the offering.

shànzāi shànzāi

"How good!

The doubled 善哉 conveys Tripitaka's genuine, if credulous, approbation of what he takes to be an act of merit.

yǒuzhāiguǒzilejiùlái yǒuzhāiguǒzilejiùlái

"But I have a disciple gone to pick fruit, who will be back directly.

果子 "fruit," 子 (zi). The mention of the absent Wukong is quietly ominous — the one disciple who would unmask her is expected back at any moment, and the demon must act before he comes.

gǎnchījiǎshàngchīlefànzhàngxiǎodequèzuìzuòpínsēng?」 gǎnchījiǎshàngchīlefànzhàngxiǎodequèzuìzuòpínsēng?」

"I dare not eat it. Suppose I, a monk, ate your food and your husband found out and cursed you — would not the blame fall upon this poor cleric?"

曉得 "to find out, come to know," 得 (de). 罪坐 "to have blame settled upon one"; 貧僧 "this poor monk," Tripitaka's humble self-reference. His refusal is scrupulous and considerate — anxious for the woman's domestic peace — and entirely misdirected.

jiàntángsēngkěnchīquèyòu滿mǎnmiànchūnshēngdào:「shīazhāisēngháishìxiǎo jiàntángsēngkěnchīquèyòumǎnmiànchūnshēngdào:「shīazhāisēngháishìxiǎo

Seeing the Tang Monk would not eat, the woman, her face all abloom with spring warmth, pressed on: "Master, ah — my parents' alms-giving to monks is a small thing;

滿面春生 "spring blooming all over her face," i.e. beaming warmly. 那女子, 那 (nà), 子 (zǐ). 還是小可 "is still a trifle," 還 (hái) (still) — distinct from the 還 (huán) of 還誓願. The demon shifts ground, now appealing through her husband's supposed goodness.

zhànggèngshìshànrénshēnghǎodeshìxiūqiáoàilǎoliánpín zhànggèngshìshànrénshēnghǎodeshìxiūqiáoàilǎoliánpín

"but my husband is a good man beyond that — all his life he has loved to mend bridges and repair roads, and to cherish the old and pity the poor.

更是 "even more so," 更 (gèng). 修橋補路 "mending bridges and roads," 愛老憐貧 "loving the aged, pitying the poor" — the stock catalogue of lay-Buddhist good works, here credited to the fictitious husband to overcome the monk's scruple.

dàntīngjiànshuōzhèfànsòngshīchīleqíngshàngxúnchánggèngshìtóng。」 dàntīngjiànshuōzhèfànsòngshīchīleqíngshàngxúnchánggèngshìtóng。」

"Were he but to hear that this food had been given to you, Master, to eat, then in his love for me as his wife he would be more pleased than ever."

夫妻情上 "in the matter of husband-and-wife affection"; 比尋常更是不同 "more so than usual, beyond the ordinary," 更 (gèng). The demon turns Tripitaka's own objection inside out: far from angering the husband, the gift would gladden him.

sānzàngzhǐshìchī sānzàngzhǐshìchī

But Tripitaka simply would not eat.

A flat, terse close: 只是不吃 "just would not eat." For all the demon's eloquence the monk's stubborn refusal holds — the last barrier standing before Wukong's return shatters the whole scene.


總評 Commentary

Won to the woman's piety (善哉!善哉!), the monk nonetheless refuses the food — not from suspicion but from delicacy, fearing to bring a wife trouble with her husband. It is a characteristically fine-grained moral scruple, and characteristically beside the point: he weighs a domestic impropriety while blind to the fiend standing before him.

Each refusal draws a fresh appeal — now the husband's charity, now his supposed delight at the gift. Yet the passage twice glances at the true threat to the demon's plan: the disciple "gone to pick fruit" who "will be back directly." Her mounting urgency is measured against Wukong's imminent return.

The stalemate — she cannot make him eat, he cannot see what she is — is the still point before the storm. It will break in the next passage, when Wukong drops out of the sky, sees at a single glance what a whole chapter of monks could not, and swings his cudgel.