Canonical Classics ← 第二十七回
第二十七回
shīsāntángsānzàng
shèngsēnghènzhúměihóuwáng

The Corpse-Fiend Thrice Mocks Tang Tripitaka · The Holy Monk in Wrath Banishes the Handsome Monkey King

八戒動心
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

八戒動心 The Idiot's Carnal Heart

jièjiànshēngdejùnqiàodāizijiùdònglefánxīnrěnzhùyánluànjiàodào:「wǎngshǒuzheshìshénmedōng西?」fēnmíngshìyāoguàiquènéngrèndeliánshēngyìngdào:「zhǎnglǎozhèqīngguànshìxiāngfànpíngshìchǎomiànjīnláichùyīnhuánshìyuànyàozhāisēng。」jièwényán滿mǎnxīnhuānchōushēnjiùpǎolezhūdiānfēngbàosānzàngdào:「shī,『rényǒutiānbào』,shīèlejiàoshīxiōnghuàzhāihóuzizhīzhāitáoershuǎziletáozichīduōleyǒuxiēcáorényòuyǒuxiēxiàzhuìkànshìzhāisēngdeláile?」tángsēngxìndào:「zhèhānghuòchánmenzǒulezhèxiànghǎoréncéngzháozhāisēngdecóngérlái!」jièdào:「shīzhèdàole?」jièjiànshēngdejùnqiàodāizijiùdònglefánxīnrěnzhùyánluànjiàodào:「wǎngshǒuzheshìshénmedōng西?」fēnmíngshìyāoguàiquènéngrèndeliánshēngyìngdào:「zhǎnglǎozhèqīngguànshìxiāngfàn绿píngshìchǎomiànjīnláichùyīnhuánshìyuànyàozhāisēng。」jièwényánmǎnxīnhuānchōushēnjiùpǎolezhūdiānfēngbàosānzàngdào:「shī,『rényǒutiānbào』,shī饿èlejiàoshīxiōnghuàzhāihóuzizhīzhāitáoershuǎziletáozichīduōleyǒuxiēcáorényòuyǒuxiēxiàzhuìkànshìzhāisēngdeláile?」tángsēngxìndào:「zhèhānghuòchánmenzǒulezhèxiànghǎoréncéngzháozhāisēngdecóngérlái!」jièdào:「shīzhèdàole?」


逐句解 Line by line

jièjiànshēngdejùnqiàodāizijiùdònglefánxīnrěnzhùyánluànjiàodào:「wǎng jièjiànshēngdejùnqiàodāizijiùdònglefánxīnrěnzhùyánluànjiàodào:「wǎng

When Eight Rules saw how pretty she was, carnal thoughts stirred in the idiot at once, and unable to hold his tongue he babbled all manner of nonsense, calling out: "Lady Bodhisattva, where are you off to?

生得俊俏 "made pretty," 得 (de) (complement). 動了凡心 (dòng le fán xīn) "his mortal heart was stirred" — the 凡心 "worldly heart" is exactly the appetite Bajie is vowed to have set aside. 女菩薩 "Lady Bodhisattva," an obsequious address. Two : 那八戒 = (demonstrative, first occurrence), 往那裡去 = (place-word "where," second occurrence).

shǒuzheshìshénmedōng西?」 shǒuzheshìshénmedōng西?」

"And what's that you're carrying in your hands?"

提著 "carrying," 著 (zhe). 甚麼 "what," 甚 (shén). Bajie's leering curiosity about the vessels sets up the demon's alms-giving reply.

fēnmíngshìyāoguàiquènéngrènde fēnmíngshìyāoguàiquènéngrènde

Plainly she was a monster, yet he could not tell.

The narrator's aside: 分明 "clearly," 認得 "to recognize," 得 (de). Blinded by lust, Bajie fails to see what the reader sees at once — a failure the whole party, save the absent Wukong, will share.

liánshēngyìngdào:「zhǎnglǎozhèqīngguànshìxiāngfànpíngshìchǎomiànjīn liánshēngyìngdào:「zhǎnglǎozhèqīngguànshìxiāngfàn绿píngshìchǎomiànjīn

The woman answered readily: "Reverend, in this green jar is fragrant rice, and in the green bottle stir-fried wheat-gluten.

那女子 "that woman," 那 (nà), 子 (zǐ). 答應 "to answer," 應 (yìng) (respond, not 應 (yīng) "ought"). 長老 "reverend," 長 (zhǎng). 麵筋 (miàn jīn) "wheat-gluten," a vegetarian food that fits the alms pretext.

láichùyīnhuánshìyuànyàozhāisēng。」 láichùyīnhuánshìyuànyàozhāisēng。」

"I have come here for no other reason than to feed monks, in fulfilment of a vow."

還誓願 "to redeem a vow," 還 (huán) (repay, not 還 (hái) "still"). 齋僧 "to give alms-food to monks." The pious motive is calculated to disarm — feeding wandering monks was a recognized act of merit.

jièwényán滿mǎnxīnhuānchōushēnjiùpǎolezhūdiānfēngbàosānzàngdào:「shī,『rényǒutiānbào』,shīèlejiàoshīxiōnghuàzhāihóuzizhīzhāitáoershuǎzile jièwényánmǎnxīnhuānchōushēnjiùpǎolezhūdiānfēngbàosānzàngdào:「shī,『rényǒutiānbào』,shī饿èlejiàoshīxiōnghuàzhāihóuzizhīzhāitáoershuǎzile

Hearing this, Eight Rules was overjoyed; whipping round, he broke into a headlong pig-trot and reported to Tripitaka: "Master! 'The lucky are ever heaven-blessed'! You were hungry and sent Elder Brother off to beg, and that monkey's gone who-knows-where picking peaches and larking about.

豬顛風 (zhū diān fēng) "a pig's mad dash," comic. Two : 那猴子 = (first), 不知那裡 = (place-word, second). 摘桃兒 "picking peaches," 兒 (er) (suffix); 耍子 "to lark about," 子 (zi). Bajie's dig at the absent Wukong is the first crack he drives between master and disciple.

táozichīduōleyǒuxiēcáorényòuyǒuxiēxiàzhuì táozichīduōleyǒuxiēcáorényòuyǒuxiēxiàzhuì

"Eat too many peaches and they gripe the stomach and drag it down, besides.

桃子 "peaches," 子 (zi). 嘈人 (cáo rén) "to unsettle the stomach"; 下墜 (xià zhuì) "a dragging, downward feeling." Bajie disparages Wukong's peaches to talk up the woman's rice — self-interest dressed as concern.

kànshìzhāisēngdeláile?」 kànshìzhāisēngdeláile?」

"Look — isn't that an alms-giver come at last?"

那不是 "isn't that," 那 (nà) (demonstrative "that [person]," not the place-word). Bajie presents the demon as the very answer to the party's hunger.

tángsēngxìndào:「zhèhānghuòchán tángsēngxìndào:「zhèhānghuòchán

The Tang Monk, disbelieving, said, "You blockhead, talking rot.

夯貨 (hāng huò) "clumsy oaf, blockhead," a standard term of abuse for Bajie. 胡纏 "to pester with nonsense." Tellingly, the elder's first instinct here is doubt — a scepticism he will fatally fail to sustain once the stakes rise.

menzǒulezhèxiànghǎoréncéngzháozhāisēngdecóngérlái!」 menzǒulezhèxiànghǎoréncéngzháozhāisēngdecóngérlái!」

"All this stretch we've travelled, we've not met a single decent soul — where would an alms-giver spring from?"

這向 "this while, this stretch of road." 遇著 "to meet," 著 (zháo) (resultative). Tripitaka's reasoning here — no one in this wilderness — is precisely Wukong's, and precisely right; the chapter's grief is that he will abandon it.

jièdào:「shīzhèdàole?」 jièdào:「shīzhèdàole?」

Said Eight Rules, "But Master — hasn't she come right up to us?"

這不到了 "isn't [she] here already?" — Bajie points to the approaching figure as self-evident refutation. His comic insistence masks the demon's success in making him her advocate.


總評 Commentary

The engine of the passage is Bajie's 凡心 — the carnal heart he was supposed to have renounced. Smitten, he becomes the demon's unwitting champion, trotting back to vouch for her and, crucially, to run down the absent Wukong ("that monkey's off larking about"). The wedge that will split the party is first driven here, by appetite, before the demon herself lifts a finger against them.

Against this stands Tripitaka's fatal inconsistency. His opening response is sound scepticism — no decent soul for miles, so whence an alms-giver? — which is Wukong's own logic exactly. The pathos of the chapter lies in watching the elder reason rightly and then, under pressure, discard that reasoning in favour of what he wishes, or fears, to believe.

The narrator's blunt aside, 分明是個妖怪,他卻不能認得 ("plainly a monster, yet he could not tell"), states outright to the reader what none of the pilgrims can see. It makes us complicit witnesses to a deception that turns on nothing but the will — or failure — to see truly.