Canonical Classics ← 第十四回
第十四回
心xīn猿yuán歸guī正zhèng
六liù賊zéi無wú蹤zōng

The Mind-Monkey Returns to the Right · The Six Robbers Vanish Without a Trace

詩曰
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

詩曰 The Opening Poem

佛fó即jí心xīn兮xī心xīn即jí佛fó,心xīn佛fó從cóng來lái皆jiē要yào物wù。佛fó即jí心xīn兮xī心xīn即jí佛fó,心xīn佛fó从cóng来lái皆jiē要yào物wù。
若ruò知zhī無wú物wù又yòu無wú心xīn,便biàn是shì真zhēn心xīn法fǎ身shēn佛fó。若ruò知zhī无wú物wù又yòu无wú心xīn,便biàn是shì真zhēn心xīn法fǎ身shēn佛fó。
法fǎ身shēn佛fó,沒méi模mú樣yàng,一yì顆kē圓yuán光guāng涵hán萬wàn象xiàng。法fǎ身shēn佛fó,没méi模mú样yàng,一yì颗kē圆yuán光guāng涵hán万wàn象xiàng。
無wú體tǐ之zhī體tǐ即jí真zhēn體tǐ,無wú相xiàng之zhī相xiàng即jí實shí相xiàng。无wú体tǐ之zhī体tǐ即jí真zhēn体tǐ,无wú相xiàng之zhī相xiàng即jí实shí相xiàng。
非fēi色sè非fēi空kōng非fēi不bù空kōng,不bù來lái不bú向xiàng不bù回huí向xiàng。非fēi色sè非fēi空kōng非fēi不bù空kōng,不bù来lái不bú向xiàng不bù回huí向xiàng。
無wú異yì無wú同tóng無wú有yǒu無wú,難nán捨shě難nán取qǔ難nán聽tīng望wàng。无wú异yì无wú同tóng无wú有yǒu无wú,难nán舍shě难nán取qǔ难nán听tīng望wàng。
內nèi外wài靈líng光guāng到dào處chù同tóng,一yì佛fó國guó在zài一yì沙shā中zhōng。内nèi外wài灵líng光guāng到dào处chù同tóng,一yì佛fó国guó在zài一yì沙shā中zhōng。
一yí粒lì沙shā含hán大dà千qiān界jiè,一yí個gè身shēn心xīn萬wàn法fǎ同tóng。一yí粒lì沙shā含hán大dà千qiān界jiè,一yí个gè身shēn心xīn万wàn法fǎ同tóng。
知zhī之zhī須xū會huì無wú心xīn訣jué,不bù染rǎn不bú滯zhì為wéi淨jìng業yè。知zhī之zhī须xū会huì无wú心xīn诀jué,不bù染rǎn不bú滞zhì为wéi净jìng业yè。
善shàn惡è千qiān端duān無wú所suǒ為wéi,便biàn是shì南ná無mó釋shì迦jiā葉shè。善shàn恶è千qiān端duān无wú所suǒ为wéi,便biàn是shì南ná无mó释shì迦jiā叶shè。

逐句解 Line by line

佛fó即jí心xīn兮xī心xīn即jí佛fó,心xīn佛fó從cóng來lái皆jiē要yào物wù。 佛fó即jí心xīn兮xī心xīn即jí佛fó,心xīn佛fó从cóng来lái皆jiē要yào物wù。

The Buddha is nothing but mind, and mind is nothing but Buddha; yet mind and Buddha, from of old, have each been taken for a thing.

Most chapters open with scenery. This one opens with a riddle, and the riddle turns out to be the chapter's subject. Mind and Buddha are one and the same thing — 即心即佛, a slogan traced to the Tang teacher Mazu Daoyi and one of the great catchphrases of Chan (Zen) Buddhism. Then the second line pulls the rug out. The moment you hold that identity as a truth you own, it has become one more thing to grip: 要物 is literally 'to require a thing', and requiring is the whole trouble.

若ruò知zhī無wú物wù又yòu無wú心xīn,便biàn是shì真zhēn心xīn法fǎ身shēn佛fó。 若ruò知zhī无wú物wù又yòu无wú心xīn,便biàn是shì真zhēn心xīn法fǎ身shēn佛fó。

If you know there is no thing, and no mind either, that is the true mind — the Buddha of the Dharma-body.

After all that denying, the payoff. See through 'thing', see through 'mind', and what is left is not blankness but the true mind. 法身 (fǎ shēn) is the Chinese for the Sanskrit dharmakāya, the truth-body of a Buddha: no shape, no conditions, the same thing as reality itself — as against the flesh-and-blood 色身.

法fǎ身shēn佛fó,沒méi模mú樣yàng,一yì顆kē圓yuán光guāng涵hán萬wàn象xiàng。 法fǎ身shēn佛fó,没méi模mú样yàng,一yì颗kē圆yuán光guāng涵hán万wàn象xiàng。

The Dharma-body Buddha has no shape or likeness: a single orb of perfect light that holds the myriad images within.

沒模樣, 'no shape, no likeness', forbids you to picture the truth-body at all. Then the poem hands you a picture anyway: one round lamp of 圓光, whole undivided light, holding 萬象, the ten thousand things, inside it. The trick is the ordinary one of white light, which has no colour of its own and contains every colour. Emptiness and fullness are not rivals here; they are the same fact looked at twice.

無wú體tǐ之zhī體tǐ即jí真zhēn體tǐ,無wú相xiàng之zhī相xiàng即jí實shí相xiàng。 无wú体tǐ之zhī体tǐ即jí真zhēn体tǐ,无wú相xiàng之zhī相xiàng即jí实shí相xiàng。

The substance of what has no substance is the true substance; the form of what has no form is the very Real Form.

Each half of the line folds a word back on itself — 體, substance, without substance; 相, form, without form. 實相 (shí xiàng), the Real Form, translates the Sanskrit dharmatā: the true character of things, which turns out to be that they have no fixed character. 相 is doing Buddhist work here and takes xiàng.

非fēi色sè非fēi空kōng非fēi不bù空kōng,不bù來lái不bú向xiàng不bù回huí向xiàng。 非fēi色sè非fēi空kōng非fēi不bù空kōng,不bù来lái不bú向xiàng不bù回huí向xiàng。

Neither matter nor emptiness, nor yet not-empty; neither coming nor going forth, nor turning-back-in-merit.

A string of denials in the manner of the 《心經》, the Heart Sutra: reality is 非色非空, catchable neither by 'form' nor by 'emptiness'. 回向 (huí xiàng) is the technical term for dedicating merit — signing the spiritual credit of a good deed over to someone else, or to all beings at once. To be past even that is to be off the ledger entirely, out of the whole business of banking and transferring merit.

無wú異yì無wú同tóng無wú有yǒu無wú,難nán捨shě難nán取qǔ難nán聽tīng望wàng。 无wú异yì无wú同tóng无wú有yǒu无wú,难nán舍shě难nán取qǔ难nán听tīng望wàng。

No difference, no sameness, neither being nor non-being; hard to let go, hard to take hold of, hard to hear or to behold.

The denials climb until being and non-being are both refused — the four-cornered move of Indian logic, in which a thing is neither so, nor not so, nor both, nor neither. Then the poem admits how awkward this is to use. What cannot be held as an object cannot be let go of either, cannot be picked up, and cannot be heard or seen in the ordinary way.

內nèi外wài靈líng光guāng到dào處chù同tóng,一yì佛fó國guó在zài一yì沙shā中zhōng。 内nèi外wài灵líng光guāng到dào处chù同tóng,一yì佛fó国guó在zài一yì沙shā中zhōng。

The numinous light, within and without, is everywhere the same; one whole Buddha-land lies within a single grain of sand.

靈光, the strange inner light of a woken mind, does not change when you turn it outward: it is one light, and the same one, in both directions. Then the famous image of a whole Buddha-land inside a single grain of sand, which comes out of the 《華嚴經》, the Avataṃsaka Sutra, whose great theme is mutual containment — the enormous sitting comfortably inside the tiny.

一yí粒lì沙shā含hán大dà千qiān界jiè,一yí個gè身shēn心xīn萬wàn法fǎ同tóng。 一yí粒lì沙shā含hán大dà千qiān界jiè,一yí个gè身shēn心xīn万wàn法fǎ同tóng。

A single grain of sand holds the Great Thousandfold World; one body-and-mind is one with all ten thousand dharmas.

大千界 is shorthand for 三千大千世界, the whole immense span that a single Buddha's teaching reaches. Packing it into one grain restates the Huayan school's 事事無礙: thing and thing do not obstruct each other, so everything can be inside everything else at once without anything being crowded.

知zhī之zhī須xū會huì無wú心xīn訣jué,不bù染rǎn不bú滯zhì為wéi淨jìng業yè。 知zhī之zhī须xū会huì无wú心xīn诀jué,不bù染rǎn不bú滞zhì为wéi净jìng业yè。

To know this you must master the secret of no-mind: unstained, unhindered — this is the pure work of enlightenment.

Here the poem stops denying and gives instructions. 無心訣 is the knack of no-mind: a mind that takes hold of nothing. 淨業 (jìng yè), pure work or pure karma, is what you do when nothing sticks to you while you are doing it — action that leaves no smear behind it, and so no debt to be settled later.

善shàn惡è千qiān端duān無wú所suǒ為wéi,便biàn是shì南ná無mó釋shì迦jiā葉shè。 善shàn恶è千qiān端duān无wú所suǒ为wéi,便biàn是shì南ná无mó释shì迦jiā叶shè。

With good and evil in their thousand forms, cling to nothing done — and this is to say: Homage to Śākyamuni.

Ten lines of denial, and the poem ends by kneeling. 南無 is the Chinese for the Sanskrit namo — homage, I take refuge in — and in chanted use it is read ná mó, not the everyday nán wú. The last character of 釋迦葉 is read shè. The name points at Śākyamuni and at the same time rings against 迦葉, Kāśyapa, the disciple who received the Buddha's teaching without a word being spoken — which is precisely the no-mind this whole poem has been circling.


總評 Commentary

Every chapter of the novel opens with a poem set apart from the story, and this one is unusual: no landscape, no scene-setting, but a tight piece of Chan reasoning about mind and Buddha-nature. It sits outside the running text — it is rendered here, but not counted in the chapter's collation — and works as a key handed to the reader before the door is opened.

What it is about is exactly what the chapter is about. The title-couplet calls Sun Wukong the 心猿, the mind-monkey, and this poem spells out what taming that mind will involve: seeing through the habit of turning 'mind' and 'Buddha' into objects, resting in 無心, no-mind, and acting without clinging. A few pages on, Wukong kills the Six Robbers, who are the six senses wearing coats and carrying spears — and the poem's advice to stay unstained and unhindered is what that scene acts out.

In form it is a hybrid, regulated lines jostling looser runs of three and seven syllables, and it is thick with Mahāyāna vocabulary: 法身 (dharmakāya), 實相 (the Real Form), 回向 (the dedication of merit), and the Huayan picture of a Buddha-land in a grain of sand. Then, in character, it folds every abstraction back into one act of refuge.