Canonical Classics ← 第十四回
第十四回
xīnyuánguīzhèng
liùzéizōng

The Mind-Monkey Returns to the Right · The Six Robbers Vanish Without a Trace

亂砍無傷
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

亂砍無傷 No Harm from the Blows

zéiwényándedeàideàidedeyōudeyōushàngqiánluànrǎngdào:「zhèshàngdedōng西quánránméiyǒuzhuǎnláiděngyàofēndōng西。」lūnqiāngjiànyōngqiánláizhàoxíngzhětóuluànkǎnpīngpīngpāngpāngkǎnyǒushíxiàkōngtíngzhōngjiānzhǐdāngzhīzéidào:「hǎoshàngzhēndetóuyìng。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「jiāngjiùkàndeguòlemendeshǒukùnlequègāilǎosūnchūzhēnérláishuǎshuǎ。」zéidào:「zhèshàngshìxíngzhēnjiǔdelángzhōngbiàndemenyòubìngzhèngshuōshénmedòngzhēndehuà?」zéiwényándedeàideàidedeyōudeyōushàngqiánluànrǎngdào:「zhèshàngdedōng西quánránméiyǒuzhuǎnláiděngyàofēndōng西。」lūnqiāngjiànyōngqiánláizhàoxíngzhětóuluànkǎnpīngpīngpāngpāngkǎnyǒushíxiàkōngtíngzhōngjiānzhǐdāngzhīzéidào:「hǎoshàngzhēndetóuyìng。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「jiāngjiùkàndeguòlemendeshǒukùnlequègāilǎosūnchūzhēnérláishuǎshuǎ。」zéidào:「zhèshàngshìxíngzhēnjiǔdelángzhōngbiàndemenyòubìngzhèngshuōshénmedòngzhēndehuà?」


逐句解 Line by line

zéiwényándedeàideàidedeyōudeyōushàngqiánluànrǎngdào zéiwényándedeàideàidedeyōudeyōushàngqiánluànrǎngdào

Hearing this, the robbers — the glad one glad, the angry one angry, the loving one loving, the longing one longing, the lustful one lustful, the careworn one careworn — rushed forward together, clamouring:

The wordplay of the names is extended into their reaction: each robber acts out his passion (喜的喜,怒的怒, "the glad one glad, the angry one angry"), keeping the allegory in view even as they attack. 那賊 reads as .

zhèshàngdedōng西quánránméiyǒuzhuǎnláiděngyàofēndōng西。」 zhèshàngdedōng西quánránméiyǒuzhuǎnláiděngyàofēndōng西。」

"This monk has no manners! You have no goods at all, and now you turn round and want a share of ours!"

Their indignation is comic — outrage that the penniless monk should demand a cut. 要分東西 reads as fēn.

lūnqiāngjiànyōngqiánláizhàoxíngzhětóuluànkǎnpīngpīngpāngpāngkǎnyǒushíxià lūnqiāngjiànyōngqiánláizhàoxíngzhětóuluànkǎnpīngpīngpāngpāngkǎnyǒushíxià

They wielded spear and sword and pressed in all together, hacking down at the Pilgrim's head with a clatter and a clang — seventy or eighty blows in all.

The onslaught is loud and futile: seventy or eighty blows raining on the monkey's head, rendered with onomatopoeia (乒乒乓乓). 行者 reads as xíng.

kōngtíngzhōngjiānzhǐdāngzhī kōngtíngzhōngjiānzhǐdāngzhī

Wukong stood planted in their midst, acting as though he felt nothing.

Wukong's invulnerability — a trait from the early chapters, his body tempered adamantine — lets him stand unmoved. 中間 reads as zhōng.

zéidào:「hǎoshàngzhēndetóuyìng。」 zéidào:「hǎoshàngzhēndetóuyìng。」

The robbers said, "What a monk! His head really is hard."

The robbers' astonishment at his hard head sets up his mocking reply.

xíngzhěxiàodào:「jiāngjiùkàndeguòlemendeshǒukùnlequègāilǎosūnchūzhēnérláishuǎshuǎ。」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「jiāngjiùkàndeguòlemendeshǒukùnlequègāilǎosūnchūzhēnérláishuǎshuǎ。」

The Pilgrim laughed and said, "It will pass well enough. And you have beaten till your hands are tired — now it is old Sun's turn to bring out a little needle for some sport."

His teasing — that after their blows it is his turn to "bring out a needle for sport" — refers, of course, to the cudgel disguised behind his ear. 將就 ("make do") reads as jiāng; 看得過 and 打得手困 both take as de.

zéidào:「zhèshàngshìxíngzhēnjiǔdelángzhōngbiànde zéidào:「zhèshàngshìxíngzhēnjiǔdelángzhōngbiànde

The robbers said, "This monk must be some acupuncture doctor in disguise.

The robbers, taking "needle" literally, jeer at him as an acupuncturist. 行針灸 reads as xíng; 郎中 reads as zhōng.

menyòubìngzhèngshuōshénmedòngzhēndehuà?」 menyòubìngzhèngshuōshénmedòngzhēndehuà?」

We have no illness — what talk is this of plying needles?"

Their scoff — no illness, so why talk of needles? — is the last word before the tiny needle becomes the great rod. 說甚麼 reads as shén.


總評 Commentary

The battle is played entirely for comedy and for the allegory. The robbers' futile assault — dozens of blows clanging off Wukong's adamantine skull while he stands unconcerned — recalls the invulnerable body he forged in the novel's opening arc, and reduces the "fearsome" bandits to a rabble beating a stone.

The running joke of the disguised needle carries the scene: Wukong offers to "bring out a needle for some sport," the robbers jeer at the notion of an acupuncturist, and the reader waits for the punchline — the needle that will swell into the iron cudgel. On the allegorical level, the senses' assault on the disciplined mind is shown to be powerless; they can clamour and strike, but they cannot harm what has been tempered.

The passage sets the pivot of the chapter. The comedy is about to turn: in the next moment the cudgel appears and all six are killed — an act that is, at once, the triumphant "vanishing of the Six Robbers" of the title and the reckless slaughter that will fracture the bond between master and disciple.