Canonical Classics ← 第七十二回
第七十二回
pándòngqíngběn
zhuógòuquánjièwàngxíng

In Spiderweb Cave the Seven Passions Cloud the Root · At Filth-Cleansing Spring Eight Rules Forgets Himself

切莫揀人
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

切莫揀人 Not Picking And Choosing

zhòngdào:「zhǎnglǎochūjiārénqièjiǎnrénshī。」zhǎnglǎodào:「zěngǎnzěngǎnshàngfèngtángzhǐ西láiwēishēngsǔnjiànjiùjiùshǒuniānkǒuféngliánzhuìzhēshēnzěngǎnjiǎnzhǔshī?」zhòngdào:「zhǎnglǎochūjiārénqièjiǎnrénshī。」zhǎnglǎodào:「zěngǎnzěngǎnshàngfèngtángzhǐ西láiwēishēngsǔnjiànjiùjiùshǒuniānkǒuféngliánzhuìzhēshēnzěngǎnjiǎnzhǔshī?」


逐句解 Line by line

zhòngdào:「zhǎnglǎochūjiārénqièjiǎnrénshī。」 zhòngdào:「zhǎnglǎochūjiārénqièjiǎnrénshī。」

The women said, "Elder, you are one who has left the household life. You must not pick and choose among those who give alms."

出家人 — one gone out from the house, the standard term for a monk. 佈施 is bù shī, almsgiving, one of the six perfections; 康熙 方部五畫 gives at 式支切, 音詩, and the 設也 sense — to set out, to bestow. They are quoting his own rulebook at him.

zhǎnglǎodào:「zěngǎnzěngǎn zhǎnglǎodào:「zěngǎnzěngǎn

The Elder said, "I would not dare, I would not dare."

怎敢 twice over. He is not conceding the argument; he is protesting that the charge does not apply to him, and the doubling is a man on the back foot.

shàngfèngtángzhǐ西láiwēishēngsǔnjiànjiùjiù shàngfèngtángzhǐ西láiwēishēngsǔnjiànjiùjiù

"This monk travels west by the decree of the Great Tang, and along the whole road I have not harmed the smallest living thing, and have helped whatever suffering I met;"

微生不損 — not harming even minute life — is the first precept taken to its strictest reading. 見苦就救 pairs it with the positive duty: wherever he met suffering, he relieved it. Four clauses, each of four characters, laying out a standing rule of life.

shǒuniānkǒuféngliánzhuìzhēshēn shǒuniānkǒuféngliánzhuìzhēshēn

"where I have come upon a grain of corn I have picked it up with my hand and eaten it, and where I have come upon a thread of silk I have stitched it together to cover myself."

Two matching clauses, 遇穀粒 against 逢絲縷 — a single grain, a single thread, three characters then four in each half. Where the sentence before it stated the rule, this one gives the evidence: a life lived on what is dropped.

zěngǎnjiǎnzhǔshī?」 zěngǎnjiǎnzhǔshī?」

"How should I dare pick and choose among those who give?"

He turns their own word back on them. 揀主 is choosing between donors, where they said 揀人, choosing between people — a small, precise adjustment that makes it about hosts rather than about worth.


總評 Commentary

They accuse him of being a fussy guest and they do it in the vocabulary of his own religion. Almsgiving is a formal virtue; refusing what is offered is a slight to the giver. On the face of it they have him.

His answer is one of the more affecting things in the chapter. He does not argue doctrine. He gives an account of how he lives: a single dropped grain picked up and eaten, a single thread of silk stitched into his clothes. It is a description of somebody who takes as little as it is possible to take.

And it is exactly the wrong argument to be making here, because it concedes their framing — that this is about his manners as a guest. It is not. The food is people. He has been manoeuvred into defending his humility when the objection he actually has is one nobody in the room will say out loud.