Canonical Classics ← 第七十二回
第七十二回
pándòngqíngběn
zhuógòuquánjièwàngxíng

In Spiderweb Cave the Seven Passions Cloud the Root · At Filth-Cleansing Spring Eight Rules Forgets Himself

那曾用剝
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

那曾用剝 No Stripping Required

xíngzhěfàngxiàdào:「nǎiyāojīng穿chuānde。」jièdào:「zěnmejiùyǒuzhèduō?」xíngzhědào:「tào。」jièdào:「dezhèbānróngyòudegānjìng?」xíngzhědào:「céngyòngxíngzhěfàngxiàdào:「nǎiyāojīng穿chuānde。」jièdào:「zěnmejiùyǒuzhèduō?」xíngzhědào:「tào。」jièdào:「dezhèbānróngyòudegānjìng?」xíngzhědào:「céngyòng


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěfàngxiàdào:「nǎiyāojīng穿chuānde。」 xíngzhěfàngxiàdào:「nǎiyāojīng穿chuānde。」

Pilgrim put them down and said, "These are clothes the monsters were wearing."

此乃 is bookish — these are — where the speech around it is colloquial. Pilgrim slides between registers constantly and it is one of the ways the book marks him as older than he behaves.

jièdào:「zěnmejiùyǒuzhèduō?」 jièdào:「zěnmejiùyǒuzhèduō?」

Eight Rules said, "How is it there are so many?"

這許多 — this many, such a lot. Ten characters, and he is counting rather than thinking.

xíngzhědào:「tào。」 xíngzhědào:「tào。」

Pilgrim said, "Seven suits."

Five characters, one of the shortest speeches in the chapter. He does not elaborate because the number is about to do the work.

jièdào:「dezhèbānróngyòudegānjìng?」 jièdào:「dezhèbānróngyòudegānjìng?」

Eight Rules said, "How did you get them stripped off so easily, and so cleanly?"

is de both times, joining the stripping to how it went — not , to obtain. is gān in 乾淨, clean: the other reading qián belongs to the trigram and to 乾坤, heaven and earth. Same character, entirely different word.

xíngzhědào:「céngyòng xíngzhědào:「céngyòng

Pilgrim said, "There was no stripping about it."

is — as if, where would there have been. Seven characters, and it is Pilgrim correcting the assumption behind the question rather than answering it.


總評 Commentary

Eight Rules asks how the clothes came off so easily and so cleanly, and the question tells you what he has assumed happened.

Pilgrim's answer is a flat correction: there was no stripping. He took them off a rack. The two of them are having slightly different conversations, and Eight Rules will keep having his for the rest of the chapter.

One small point of writing. The character for clean here is the same one that means the first trigram of the Book of Changes, heaven itself, in a completely unrelated word. Nothing in the writing distinguishes them; only the company does.