Canonical Classics ← 第九回
第九回
chénguāngruǐrènféngzāi
jiāngliúsēngchóubàoběn

Chen Guangrui, Going to His Post, Meets Disaster · The River-Float Monk Avenges the Wrong and Requites His Origin

長安形勝
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

長安形勝 The Splendor of Chang'an

huàbiǎoshǎn西guóchángānchéngnǎidàiwángjiànzhīzhōuqínhànláisānzhōuhuājǐnshuǐràochéngliúzhēnshìmíngshèngzhībāngshíshìtángtàizōnghuángdēnggǎiyuánzhēnguāndēngshísānniánsuìzàitiānxiàtàipíngfāngjìngònghǎichēngchénhuàbiǎoshǎn西guóchángānchéngnǎidàiwángjiànzhīzhōuqínhànláisānzhōuhuājǐnshuǐràochéngliúzhēnshìmíngshèngzhībāngshíshìtángtàizōnghuángdēnggǎiyuánzhēnguāndēngshísānniánsuìzàitiānxiàtàipíngfāngjìngònghǎichēngchén


逐句解 Line by line

huàbiǎoshǎn西guóchángānchéngnǎidàiwángjiànzhī huàbiǎoshǎn西guóchángānchéngnǎidàiwángjiànzhī

Our tale tells of the great realm of Shaanxi and the city of Cháng'ān, the seat where emperors of successive ages had founded their capitals.

The tale opens by planting a flag on the map. 長安, Chang'an, was the Tang capital, set on the Wei River plain, and dynasty after dynasty had put its throne there before the Tang arrived. Two readings worth catching now, because both recur all chapter: the place-name takes as cháng, and 建都, to found a capital, takes as rather than the more familiar dōu.

zhōuqínhànláisānzhōuhuājǐnshuǐràochéngliúzhēnshìmíngshèngzhībāng zhōuqínhànláisānzhōuhuājǐnshuǐràochéngliúzhēnshìmíngshèngzhībāng

Ever since the Zhou, the Qin, and the Han, its three districts had bloomed like brocade and its eight rivers wound about the walls — truly a land of storied splendor.

This is tourist-brochure prose, and meant to be. The 八水, eight rivers, are the streams that ringed Tang Chang'an, and 花似錦, blossoms like brocade, is stock praise you could paste onto any celebrated city — here reads . One textual wrinkle: some editions print 三川, three rivers, where this one has 三州, three districts.

shíshìtángtàizōnghuángdēnggǎiyuánzhēnguāndēngshísānniánsuìzàitiānxiàtàipíngfāngjìngònghǎichēngchén shíshìtángtàizōnghuángdēnggǎiyuánzhēnguāndēngshísānniánsuìzàitiānxiàtàipíngfāngjìngònghǎichēngchén

At that time the Emperor Taizong of the great Tang had ascended the throne and changed the reign-style to Zhenguan. He had reigned thirteen years — the year being jǐsì — and all under Heaven was at peace, the eight quarters bringing tribute and the four seas owning themselves his subjects.

Here the novel sets its clock, and sets it wrong. 貞觀, Zhenguan, was Taizong's reign-era, 627 to 649, and the text puts the action in its thirteenth year, which it calls 己巳. Count it out on the sixty-year cycle of stems and branches, though, and the thirteenth year of Zhenguan is 639, which falls in 己亥. The novel is full of these loose date-markers. They are atmosphere, not chronology.


總評 Commentary

Start with a warning label: this chapter is a latecomer, and no part of the novel as it was first printed. The 1592 Shidetang edition 世德堂本, the base text here, has nothing like it in this slot — its ninth chapter is 袁守誠妙算無私曲老龍王拙計犯天條, the fortune-teller and the doomed Dragon King. The Chen Guangrui story was attached later, as an appendix, 附錄, by the Qing editors 汪象旭 and 黃周星 in their Kangxi-era 《西遊證道書》, and from there it slid into the popular 通行本 as Chapter 9 and stayed. Anthony C. Yu prints it as Chapter 9 of his translation. Glen Dudbridge's The Hsi-yu chi: A Study of Antecedents to the Sixteenth-Century Chinese Novel remains the standard account of where the episode came from and how it grows out of the older 江流和尚 legend. This edition gives the 通行本 chapter whole, and says plainly that it is second-hand.

The scene itself is a wide establishing shot. Taizong (太宗, r. 626–649) is on the throne, the Zhenguan era has begun, and that is exactly the historical moment the pilgrimage will later set out from — so the chapter is doing frame-work as well as backstory. The praise of Chang'an is pure formula: eight rivers looping the walls, three districts flowering like brocade, an empire so settled that tribute arrives from every direction. None of it is meant to be checked. It is the hush before somebody gets thrown in a river.