Canonical Classics ← 第九回
第九回
陳chén光guāng蕊ruǐ赴fù任rèn逢féng災zāi
江jiāng流liú僧sēng復fù讎chóu報bào本běn

Chen Guangrui, Going to His Post, Meets Disaster · The River-Float Monk Avenges the Wrong and Requites His Origin

母子相認
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

母子相認 Mother and Son Recognized

小xiǎo姐jiě將jiāng從cóng婢bì打dǎ發fā開kāi去qù,問wèn道dào:「你nǐ這zhè小xiǎo師shī父fù,還hái是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā的de,還hái是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā的de?姓xìng甚shèn名míng誰shuí?可kě有yǒu父fù母mǔ否fǒu?」玄xuán奘zàng答dá道dào:「我wǒ也yě不bú是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā,我wǒ也yě不bú是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā,我wǒ說shuō起qǐ來lái,冤yuān有yǒu天tiān來lái大dà,仇chóu有yǒu海hǎi樣yàng深shēn:我wǒ父fù被bèi人rén謀móu死sǐ,我wǒ母mǔ卻què被bèi賊zéi人rén占zhàn了le。我wǒ師shī父fù法fǎ明míng長zhǎng老lǎo教jiào我wǒ在zài江jiāng州zhōu衙yá內nèi尋xún取qǔ母mǔ親qīn。」小xiǎo姐jiě問wèn道dào:「你nǐ母mǔ姓xìng甚shèn?」玄xuán奘zàng道dào:「我wǒ母mǔ姓xìng殷yīn,名míng喚huàn溫wēn嬌jiāo。我wǒ父fù姓xìng陳chén,名míng光guāng蕊ruǐ。我wǒ小xiǎo名míng叫jiào做zuò江jiāng流liú,法fǎ名míng取qǔ為wéi玄xuán奘zàng。」小xiǎo姐jiě道dào:「溫wēn嬌jiāo就jiù是shì我wǒ。但dàn你nǐ今jīn有yǒu何hé憑píng據jù?」玄xuán奘zàng聽tīng說shuō是shì他tā母mǔ親qīn,雙shuāng膝xī跪guì下xià,哀āi哀āi大dà哭kū:「我wǒ娘niáng若ruò不bú信xìn,見jiàn有yǒu血xuè書shū、汗hàn衫shān為wéi證zhèng。」溫wēn嬌jiāo取qǔ過guò一yí看kàn,果guǒ然rán是shì真zhēn,母mǔ子zǐ相xiāng抱bào而ér哭kū。小xiǎo姐jiě将jiāng从cóng婢bì打dǎ发fā开kāi去qù,问wèn道dào:「你nǐ这zhè小xiǎo师shī父fù,还hái是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā的de,还hái是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā的de?姓xìng甚shèn名míng谁shuí?可kě有yǒu父fù母mǔ否fǒu?」玄xuán奘zàng答dá道dào:「我wǒ也yě不bú是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā,我wǒ也yě不bú是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā,我wǒ说shuō起qǐ来lái,冤yuān有yǒu天tiān来lái大dà,仇chóu有yǒu海hǎi样yàng深shēn:我wǒ父fù被bèi人rén谋móu死sǐ,我wǒ母mǔ却què被bèi贼zéi人rén占zhàn了le。我wǒ师shī父fù法fǎ明míng长zhǎng老lǎo教jiào我wǒ在zài江jiāng州zhōu衙yá内nèi寻xún取qǔ母mǔ亲qīn。」小xiǎo姐jiě问wèn道dào:「你nǐ母mǔ姓xìng甚shèn?」玄xuán奘zàng道dào:「我wǒ母mǔ姓xìng殷yīn,名míng唤huàn温wēn娇jiāo。我wǒ父fù姓xìng陈chén,名míng光guāng蕊ruǐ。我wǒ小xiǎo名míng叫jiào做zuò江jiāng流liú,法fǎ名míng取qǔ为wéi玄xuán奘zàng。」小xiǎo姐jiě道dào:「温wēn娇jiāo就jiù是shì我wǒ。但dàn你nǐ今jīn有yǒu何hé凭píng据jù?」玄xuán奘zàng听tīng说shuō是shì他tā母mǔ亲qīn,双shuāng膝xī跪guì下xià,哀āi哀āi大dà哭kū:「我wǒ娘niáng若ruò不bú信xìn,见jiàn有yǒu血xuè书shū、汗hàn衫shān为wéi证zhèng。」温wēn娇jiāo取qǔ过guò一yí看kàn,果guǒ然rán是shì真zhēn,母mǔ子zǐ相xiāng抱bào而ér哭kū。


逐句解 Line by line

小xiǎo姐jiě將jiāng從cóng婢bì打dǎ發fā開kāi去qù,問wèn道dào: 小xiǎo姐jiě将jiāng从cóng婢bì打dǎ发fā开kāi去qù,问wèn道dào:

The lady sent her attendant maids away and asked,

從婢, the maids who attend her. Clearing them out is the first practical step, and she takes it before she asks a single question.

「你nǐ這zhè小xiǎo師shī父fù,還hái是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā的de,還hái是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā的de?姓xìng甚shèn名míng誰shuí?可kě有yǒu父fù母mǔ否fǒu?」 「你nǐ这zhè小xiǎo师shī父fù,还hái是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā的de,还hái是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā的de?姓xìng甚shèn名míng谁shuí?可kě有yǒu父fù母mǔ否fǒu?」

'You, little master — did you take orders as a child, or in your middle years? What is your name? Have you father and mother?'

還是…還是 sets up an either-or, with 還 as hái; 中年, middle age, takes 中 as zhōng. Four questions, and the last is the one she actually wants answered: have you parents? She buries it at the end, the way people do when they are afraid of the reply.

玄xuán奘zàng答dá道dào:「我wǒ也yě不bú是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā,我wǒ也yě不bú是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā, 玄xuán奘zàng答dá道dào:「我wǒ也yě不bú是shì自zì幼yòu出chū家jiā,我wǒ也yě不bú是shì中zhōng年nián出chū家jiā,

Xuanzang answered, 'I did not take orders as a child, nor in middle years.'

He answers the small question twice over, in parallel, and answers neither half of it. It is a run-up: two negatives to build a rhythm before the thing he has to say.

我wǒ說shuō起qǐ來lái,冤yuān有yǒu天tiān來lái大dà,仇chóu有yǒu海hǎi樣yàng深shēn: 我wǒ说shuō起qǐ来lái,冤yuān有yǒu天tiān来lái大dà,仇chóu有yǒu海hǎi样yàng深shēn:

'When I tell it — my wrong is as great as the sky, my grievance deep as the sea:'

冤有天來大,仇有海樣深 — the wrong as big as the sky, the grievance as deep as the sea. Two lines built to match each other clause for clause, which is what popular storytelling reaches for when a feeling needs a container.

我wǒ父fù被bèi人rén謀móu死sǐ,我wǒ母mǔ卻què被bèi賊zéi人rén占zhàn了le。 我wǒ父fù被bèi人rén谋móu死sǐ,我wǒ母mǔ却què被bèi贼zéi人rén占zhàn了le。

'my father was murdered, and my mother seized by the villain.'

占 is to occupy, to take and hold: the word you use of ground. Applied to a person it is as ugly as it sounds, and the novel does nothing to soften it.

我wǒ師shī父fù法fǎ明míng長zhǎng老lǎo教jiào我wǒ在zài江jiāng州zhōu衙yá內nèi尋xún取qǔ母mǔ親qīn。」 我wǒ师shī父fù法fǎ明míng长zhǎng老lǎo教jiào我wǒ在zài江jiāng州zhōu衙yá内nèi寻xún取qǔ母mǔ亲qīn。」

'My master, the elder Faming, bade me seek my mother within the Jiangzhou yamen.'

尋取, to seek and get — searching with an object in mind rather than wandering hopefully. He has just told a stranger, standing in her own house, that he is looking for his mother somewhere inside this building.

小xiǎo姐jiě問wèn道dào:「你nǐ母mǔ姓xìng甚shèn?」 小xiǎo姐jiě问wèn道dào:「你nǐ母mǔ姓xìng甚shèn?」

The lady asked, 'What is your mother's surname?'

Four characters, and everything rides on them. 姓甚, surnamed what, takes 甚 as shèn.

玄xuán奘zàng道dào:「我wǒ母mǔ姓xìng殷yīn,名míng喚huàn溫wēn嬌jiāo。 玄xuán奘zàng道dào:「我wǒ母mǔ姓xìng殷yīn,名míng唤huàn温wēn娇jiāo。

Xuanzang said, 'My mother is surnamed Yin, named Wenjiao.'

名喚, called by the name of. He gives her her own name, and has no idea he is doing it.

我wǒ父fù姓xìng陳chén,名míng光guāng蕊ruǐ。 我wǒ父fù姓xìng陈chén,名míng光guāng蕊ruǐ。

'My father is surnamed Chen, named Guangrui.'

And the second name is her husband's. She now holds both halves of it and has still said nothing.

我wǒ小xiǎo名míng叫jiào做zuò江jiāng流liú,法fǎ名míng取qǔ為wéi玄xuán奘zàng。」 我wǒ小xiǎo名míng叫jiào做zuò江jiāng流liú,法fǎ名míng取qǔ为wéi玄xuán奘zàng。」

'My infant name was Jiangliu, and my dharma-name given as Xuanzang.'

小名, his childhood name, is River-Float — which tells her exactly how he was found, if she needed telling. 法名取為 takes 為 as wéi.

小xiǎo姐jiě道dào:「溫wēn嬌jiāo就jiù是shì我wǒ。但dàn你nǐ今jīn有yǒu何hé憑píng據jù?」 小xiǎo姐jiě道dào:「温wēn娇jiāo就jiù是shì我wǒ。但dàn你nǐ今jīn有yǒu何hé凭píng据jù?」

The lady said, 'Wenjiao is none other than I. But what proof have you now?'

She identifies herself in five characters and then, without pausing, asks for proof. 憑據, evidence to lean on, is the hinge of the whole scene. Eighteen years of hoping have not made her careless.

玄xuán奘zàng聽tīng說shuō是shì他tā母mǔ親qīn,雙shuāng膝xī跪guì下xià,哀āi哀āi大dà哭kū: 玄xuán奘zàng听tīng说shuō是shì他tā母mǔ亲qīn,双shuāng膝xī跪guì下xià,哀āi哀āi大dà哭kū:

Hearing that she was his mother, Xuanzang fell to both knees and wept aloud:

雙膝跪下, down on both knees. One knee is respect. Two is something else entirely.

「我wǒ娘niáng若ruò不bú信xìn,見jiàn有yǒu血xuè書shū、汗hàn衫shān為wéi證zhèng。」 「我wǒ娘niáng若ruò不bú信xìn,见jiàn有yǒu血xuè书shū、汗hàn衫shān为wéi证zhèng。」

'If my mother does not believe me, here are the blood-letter and undershirt for proof.'

為證, as proof, with 為 as wéi. And notice what he calls her: 我娘, my mum — the plain domestic word, not the formal 母親 he has used up to now.

溫wēn嬌jiāo取qǔ過guò一yí看kàn,果guǒ然rán是shì真zhēn,母mǔ子zǐ相xiāng抱bào而ér哭kū。 温wēn娇jiāo取qǔ过guò一yí看kàn,果guǒ然rán是shì真zhēn,母mǔ子zǐ相xiāng抱bào而ér哭kū。

Wenjiao took them and looked, and they were indeed true; mother and son embraced and wept.

果然是真, sure enough, genuine. The verification takes four characters and the embrace takes six. 母子相抱 keeps 子 as zǐ and takes the mutual 相, xiāng — an embrace being, by definition, something two people do to one another.


總評 Commentary

The recognition is conducted like an interview. She sends the maids away, then asks four questions, keeping the one she cares about until last. He answers with his parents' names, and she is holding the whole truth before she has said a word. Then, at the exact point where most stories would have her fall on his neck, she asks for evidence: 但你今有何憑據, what proof do you have?

That demand is the hinge, and it is characteristic. Popular Chinese fiction almost never lets identity rest on assertion, or even on feeling. It wants a 信物 — a token, a physical object that can be produced and matched. The sequence runs word, then name, then thing, and only the thing closes the circuit.

The thing, when it comes, is the letter she wrote in her own blood and the shirt off her own back. She is authenticating her son against evidence she manufactured herself, eighteen years earlier, for precisely this morning. It is the most complete vindication anybody in this chapter gets.