Canonical Classics ← 第六十五回
第六十五回
yāoxiéjiǎshèxiǎoléiyīn
zhòngjiēzāoènàn

A Fiend Falsely Sets Up a Lesser Thunderclap · The Four Pilgrims All Fall into Great Calamity

遇佛拜佛
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

遇佛拜佛 Where I Meet A Buddha

xíngzhědào:「jìnchùshǎoduōxiōngruòyǒuhuòhuànguài。」sānzàngdào:「jiùshìyǒuxiàngxīnyuànbàiguài?」xíngzhědào:「jìnchùshǎoduōxiōngruòyǒuhuòhuànguài。」sānzàngdào:「jiùshìyǒuxiàngxīnyuànbàiguài?」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhědào:「jìnchùshǎoduōxiōng xíngzhědào:「jìnchùshǎoduōxiōng

Pilgrim said, "We must not go in. There is little luck about this place and much harm."

The last plain warning anybody gives. 少吉多凶 is a four-graph formula out of the fortune-teller's vocabulary, balanced little-against-much, and it picks up the 凶氣 he reported from the ridge — the same word, the same worry, now stated as a forecast.

ruòyǒuhuòhuànguài。」 ruòyǒuhuòhuànguài。」

"If disaster comes of it, do not blame me."

Eight graphs to close his quotation, and he has stopped arguing. Fixing responsibility in advance is what a subordinate does when he has lost and knows it.

sānzàngdào:「jiùshìyǒuxiàng sānzàngdào:「jiùshìyǒuxiàng

Tripitaka said, "Even if there is no Buddha, there is bound to be a Buddha image."

就是 once more, and the premise has slipped a second time: first it was Thunderclap, then a Buddha of some sort, now merely a statue of one. The conclusion has not moved a hair.

xīnyuànbàiguài?」 xīnyuànbàiguài?」

"It is this disciple's own vow: where I meet a Buddha I bow to a Buddha. How should I blame you?"

遇佛拜佛 — where I meet a Buddha I bow to a Buddha. The vow is unimpeachable, and it is being applied without anybody first asking whether the thing in front of him is a Buddha, which is the exact danger Pilgrim named. reads in 弟子, the literary compound, not the throwaway suffix.


總評 Commentary

Two exchanges, and the argument collapses by concession. Tripitaka gives ground on every point of fact — not Thunderclap, perhaps not even a Buddha, perhaps only a statue — and none of it touches his conclusion, because his reason for going in was never a claim about the building in the first place.

遇佛拜佛 is the whole of it. The vow says nothing about checking the Buddha first, and a rule of that shape cannot be argued with by somebody pointing out that this one may be counterfeit. Pilgrim stops trying and settles for a disclaimer.