Canonical Classics ← 第六十五回
第六十五回
妖yāo邪xié假jiǎ設shè小xiǎo雷léi音yīn
四sì眾zhòng皆jiē遭zāo大dà厄è難nàn

A Fiend Falsely Sets Up a Lesser Thunderclap · The Four Pilgrims All Fall into Great Calamity

只有天在上
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

只有天在上 Only Heaven Stands Above

師shī徒tú們men也yě自zì尋xún芳fāng踏tà翠cuì,緩huǎn隨suí馬mǎ步bù。正zhèng行xíng之zhī間jiān,忽hū見jiàn一yí座zuò高gāo山shān,遠yuǎn望wàng著zhe與yǔ天tiān相xiāng接jiē。三sān藏zàng揚yáng鞭biān指zhǐ道dào:「悟wù空kōng,那nà座zuò山shān也yě不bù知zhī有yǒu多duō少shǎo高gāo,可kě便biàn似sì接jiē著zhe青qīng天tiān,透tòu沖chōng碧bì漢hàn。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「古gǔ詩shī不bù云yún:『只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān在zài上shàng,更gèng無wú山shān與yǔ齊qí。』但dàn言yán山shān之zhī極jí高gāo,無wú可kě與yǔ他tā比bǐ並bìng,豈qǐ有yǒu接jiē天tiān之zhī理lǐ?」师shī徒tú们men也yě自zì寻xún芳fāng踏tà翠cuì,缓huǎn随suí马mǎ步bù。正zhèng行xíng之zhī间jiān,忽hū见jiàn一yí座zuò高gāo山shān,远yuǎn望wàng着zhe与yǔ天tiān相xiāng接jiē。三sān藏zàng扬yáng鞭biān指zhǐ道dào:「悟wù空kōng,那nà座zuò山shān也yě不bù知zhī有yǒu多duō少shǎo高gāo,可kě便biàn似sì接jiē着zhe青qīng天tiān,透tòu冲chōng碧bì汉hàn。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「古gǔ诗shī不bù云yún:『只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān在zài上shàng,更gèng无wú山shān与yǔ齐qí。』但dàn言yán山shān之zhī极jí高gāo,无wú可kě与yǔ他tā比bǐ并bìng,岂qǐ有yǒu接jiē天tiān之zhī理lǐ?」


逐句解 Line by line

師shī徒tú們men也yě自zì尋xún芳fāng踏tà翠cuì,緩huǎn隨suí馬mǎ步bù。 师shī徒tú们men也yě自zì寻xún芳fāng踏tà翠cuì,缓huǎn随suí马mǎ步bù。

Master and disciples went looking for the fragrance and treading the green, following the horse's pace at their leisure.

尋芳踏翠, hunting the fragrance and treading the green, is a set phrase for a spring day out, and it is faintly comic applied to a pilgrimage under orders. 緩隨馬步 puts the men behind the horse rather than driving it along — the last relaxed image anyone gets in this chapter.

正zhèng行xíng之zhī間jiān,忽hū見jiàn一yí座zuò高gāo山shān,遠yuǎn望wàng著zhe與yǔ天tiān相xiāng接jiē。 正zhèng行xíng之zhī间jiān,忽hū见jiàn一yí座zuò高gāo山shān,远yuǎn望wàng着zhe与yǔ天tiān相xiāng接jiē。

As they went, a high mountain suddenly came into view; from far off it looked joined to the sky.

A mountain appears, and it looks joined to the sky. 著 here is the little toneless zhe, hung on 望: looking, in the act of it, not the zhuó of putting something on. The character turns up twenty-nine times in this chapter and its reading is settled separately at every one.

三sān藏zàng揚yáng鞭biān指zhǐ道dào:「悟wù空kōng,那nà座zuò山shān也yě不bù知zhī有yǒu多duō少shǎo高gāo,可kě便biàn似sì接jiē著zhe青qīng天tiān,透tòu沖chōng碧bì漢hàn。」 三sān藏zàng扬yáng鞭biān指zhǐ道dào:「悟wù空kōng,那nà座zuò山shān也yě不bù知zhī有yǒu多duō少shǎo高gāo,可kě便biàn似sì接jiē着zhe青qīng天tiān,透tòu冲chōng碧bì汉hàn。」

Tripitaka raised his whip and pointed. "Wukong, there is no telling how high that mountain is. It looks as though it touches the blue sky and drives right up through the sapphire river."

Tripitaka's second clause goes one better than his first: not merely up to the sky but through it. 碧漢 is the Milky Way, the river of heaven. The whole argument that follows grows out of this one loose piece of hyperbole, which is worth remembering the next time he says a thing looks like something else.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「古gǔ詩shī不bù云yún:『只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān在zài上shàng,更gèng無wú山shān與yǔ齊qí。』 行xíng者zhě道dào:「古gǔ诗shī不bù云yún:『只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān在zài上shàng,更gèng无wú山shān与yǔ齐qí。』

Pilgrim said, "Does the old poem not say: Only heaven stands above it, and no mountain is level with it?"

Pilgrim answers hyperbole by citing a poem. The nested quotation takes the second pair of brackets, 『』, which this chapter keeps for a quotation inside a quotation and uses three times in all — and he will reach for the device again four units later.

但dàn言yán山shān之zhī極jí高gāo,無wú可kě與yǔ他tā比bǐ並bìng,豈qǐ有yǒu接jiē天tiān之zhī理lǐ?」 但dàn言yán山shān之zhī极jí高gāo,无wú可kě与yǔ他tā比bǐ并bìng,岂qǐ有yǒu接jiē天tiān之zhī理lǐ?」

"That only says the mountain is extremely high, with nothing to set beside it. How could there be any question of its touching the sky?"

And here is the point he is making. 比並 is the vernacular for setting two things side by side to measure them, so his objection is about measurement: the poem asserts a comparison, not a contact. He is reading a text closely — which is exactly what this chapter is about to ask of everybody, and exactly what nobody else manages.


總評 Commentary

The first real conversation of the chapter is an argument about how to read. Tripitaka sees a mountain that looks as though it touches the sky and says so; Pilgrim produces a couplet saying the same thing and then explains that it does not mean it.

That matters more than it looks. A few hundred characters from here the party will come on a building the text calls 也似雷音, a Thunderclap lookalike, and Tripitaka will insist on going in on the strength of the resemblance while Pilgrim urges caution. The mountain argument is the same quarrel rehearsed with nothing at stake — and Tripitaka loses this one.