Canonical Classics ← 第四十一回
第四十一回
心xīn猿yuán遭zāo火huǒ敗bài
木mù母mǔ被bèi魔mó擒qín

The Mind-Ape Suffers Defeat by Fire · The Wood-Mother Is Seized by the Demon

那個是你賢姪
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

那個是你賢姪 Which of Us Is Your Nephew?

那nà怪guài聞wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng大dà怒nù,咄duō的de一yì聲shēng喝hè道dào:「那nà潑pō猴hóu頭tóu!我wǒ與yǔ你nǐ有yǒu甚shén親qīn情qíng?你nǐ在zài這zhè裡lǐ滿mǎn口kǒu胡hú柴chái,綽chāo甚shén聲shēng經jīng兒er?那nǎ個gè是shì你nǐ賢xián姪zhí?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「哥gē哥ge,是shì你nǐ也yě不bù曉xiǎo得de。當dāng年nián我wǒ與yǔ你nǐ令lìng尊zūn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng時shí,你nǐ還hái不bù知zhī在zài那nǎ裡lǐ哩li。」那nà怪guài道dào:「這zhè猴hóu子zi一yì發fā胡hú說shuō!你nǐ是shì那nǎ裡lǐ人rén,我wǒ是shì那nǎ裡lǐ人rén,怎zěn麼me得dé與yǔ我wǒ父fù親qīn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng?」那nà怪guài闻wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng大dà怒nù,咄duō的de一yì声shēng喝hè道dào:「那nà泼pō猴hóu头tóu!我wǒ与yǔ你nǐ有yǒu甚shén亲qīn情qíng?你nǐ在zài这zhè里lǐ满mǎn口kǒu胡hú柴chái,绰chāo甚shén声shēng经jīng儿er?那nǎ个gè是shì你nǐ贤xián姪zhí?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「哥gē哥ge,是shì你nǐ也yě不bù晓xiǎo得de。当dāng年nián我wǒ与yǔ你nǐ令lìng尊zūn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng时shí,你nǐ还hái不bù知zhī在zài那nǎ里lǐ哩li。」那nà怪guài道dào:「这zhè猴hóu子zi一yì发fā胡hú说shuō!你nǐ是shì那nǎ里lǐ人rén,我wǒ是shì那nǎ里lǐ人rén,怎zěn么me得dé与yǔ我wǒ父fù亲qīn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng?」


逐句解 Line by line

那nà怪guài聞wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng大dà怒nù,咄duō的de一yì聲shēng喝hè道dào:「那nà潑pō猴hóu頭tóu! 那nà怪guài闻wén言yán,心xīn中zhōng大dà怒nù,咄duō的de一yì声shēng喝hè道dào:「那nà泼pō猴hóu头tóu!

The demon, hearing this, was greatly enraged, and with a snort bellowed: ‘You insolent ape-head!

咄的一聲 is a bark of contempt, the noise you make to drive off a dog. 潑猴頭, insolent ape-head, is the standard abuse aimed at Wukong throughout the novel; he is called it so often it functions almost as a nickname. Both uses of 那 here are nà, plain pointing -- which is worth holding onto, because the demon is about to use the same character the other way.

我wǒ與yǔ你nǐ有yǒu甚shén親qīn情qíng? 我wǒ与yǔ你nǐ有yǒu甚shén亲qīn情qíng?

What kinship is there between you and me?

有甚親情, "what kinship is there?" 甚 is shén, the "what" of a question, not the shèn that means extremely. The question is not really a question -- it is a flat denial with a question mark on it.

你nǐ在zài這zhè裡lǐ滿mǎn口kǒu胡hú柴chái,綽chāo甚shén聲shēng經jīng兒er? 你nǐ在zài这zhè里lǐ满mǎn口kǒu胡hú柴chái,绰chāo甚shén声shēng经jīng儿er?

Here you stand spouting nonsense by the mouthful — what is all this jabber you take up?

胡柴 (a form of 胡扯) is talking rot, and the demon says Wukong is doing it by the mouthful. Then 綽甚聲經兒, roughly "what is all this racket you are picking up?" The interesting word is 綽, read chāo: the vernacular verb for snatching something up. Two lines earlier the same verb had Red Boy grabbing his spear. Here it is aimed not at an object but at a person's tone of voice -- you can snatch up a weapon, and you can snatch up an attitude. That second use is not a stray oddity; the novel does it five separate times across the hundred chapters, and this is one of them.

那nǎ個gè是shì你nǐ賢xián姪zhí?」 那nǎ个gè是shì你nǐ贤xián姪zhí?」

And which of us is this worthy nephew of yours?’

And now the reversal. Wukong has been using this character to point -- that demon, that ape-head. The demon uses it to ask: 那個 here is nǎ, "which one," the older way of writing what modern Chinese spells with a different character. Which of us, exactly, is this nephew of yours? Same character on the page, opposite job, and the scorn lives in the switch.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「哥gē哥ge,是shì你nǐ也yě不bù曉xiǎo得de。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「哥gē哥ge,是shì你nǐ也yě不bù晓xiǎo得de。

The Pilgrim said: ‘Brother, it is only that you do not know.

Wukong drops from 賢姪 to 哥哥, brother -- climbing down a generation to keep the family line alive. 曉得 is to know, with the light de. 不曉得 keeps bù, since the tone only shifts before a falling tone and 曉 is not one.

當dāng年nián我wǒ與yǔ你nǐ令lìng尊zūn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng時shí,你nǐ還hái不bù知zhī在zài那nǎ裡lǐ哩li。」 当dāng年nián我wǒ与yǔ你nǐ令lìng尊zūn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng时shí,你nǐ还hái不bù知zhī在zài那nǎ里lǐ哩li。」

In the year I became sworn brother to your honoured father, you did not yet know where you were.’

當年 is "back in that year," 當 sounded dāng. Then the same trick as before, in reverse: 你還不知在那裡哩 -- 那裡 read nǎ lǐ, "where," asking rather than pointing. The idiom means you were not anywhere yet, which is to say you had not been born. It is a devastating thing to say to a child and Wukong clearly enjoys it.

那nà怪guài道dào:「這zhè猴hóu子zi一yì發fā胡hú說shuō! 那nà怪guài道dào:「这zhè猴hóu子zi一yì发fā胡hú说shuō!

The demon said: ‘This monkey talks utter nonsense!

一發胡說, talking wilder than ever. The tone on 一 shifts to yì before the level tone of 發. 猴子 takes an unstressed second syllable, hóu zi.

你nǐ是shì那nǎ裡lǐ人rén,我wǒ是shì那nǎ裡lǐ人rén,怎zěn麼me得dé與yǔ我wǒ父fù親qīn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng?」 你nǐ是shì那nǎ里lǐ人rén,我wǒ是shì那nǎ里lǐ人rén,怎zěn么me得dé与yǔ我wǒ父fù亲qīn做zuò弟dì兄xiōng?」

Where are you from, and where am I from, that you should ever have been my father's brother?’

那 twice more, both nǎ, both asking: a person from where, and a person from where? 怎麼得 is "how could you ever manage to," with 得 at its full dé. The demon is making a geographic argument and he thinks it is unanswerable. Wukong is about to answer it with a list.


總評 Commentary

The demon refuses the kinship flatly, and the scene has a small piece of wordplay holding it together. The character 那 does two entirely different jobs in this passage. In Wukong's mouth it points -- that demon, that ape-head. In the demon's mouth it asks -- which one, from where. Read aloud the difference is audible, nà against nǎ; on the page it is the same character, and the reader watches it flip.

那個是你賢姪 and 你是那裡人 are not requests for information. They are denials shaped like questions, and the second one sets a trap: prove the connection, then, since we come from opposite ends of the earth. Wukong takes the bait immediately, and the next passage is him reciting his own legend at a child who did not ask.