Canonical Classics ← 第四十一回
第四十一回
xīnyuánzāohuǒbài
bèiqín

The Mind-Ape Suffers Defeat by Fire · The Wood-Mother Is Seized by the Demon

須請觀音
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

須請觀音 Only Guanyin Can Help

shāsēngdào:「geqiěxiūfánnǎomenzǎoānqǐngbīngzhùjiùshī。」xíngzhědào:「qǐngjiùme?」shāsēngdào:「dāngchūfēnzhuóděngbǎotángsēngcéngmenjiàotiāntiānyìngjiàoyìngqǐngjiù?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎnglǎosūnnàotiāngōngshíxiēshénbīngdōujīndezhèyāojīngshéntōngxiǎoshìlǎosūnshǒuduànxiēdecáixiángdelitiānshénshānéngruòyàoyāoshìqǐngguānyīncáihǎonàiròusuānyāoténgtòngjiàjīndǒuyúnzěnshēngqǐngde?」shāsēngdào:「geqiěxiūfánnǎomenzǎoānqǐngbīngzhùjiùshī。」xíngzhědào:「qǐngjiùme?」shāsēngdào:「dāngchūfēnzhuóděngbǎotángsēngcéngmenjiàotiāntiānyìngjiàoyìngqǐngjiù?」xíngzhědào:「xiǎnglǎosūnnàotiāngōngshíxiēshénbīngdōujīndezhèyāojīngshéntōngxiǎoshìlǎosūnshǒuduànxiēdecáixiángdelitiānshénshānéngruòyàoyāoshìqǐngguānyīncáihǎonàiròusuānyāoténgtòngjiàjīndǒuyúnzěnshēngqǐngde?」


逐句解 Line by line

shāsēngdào:「geqiěxiūfánnǎo shāsēngdào:「geqiěxiūfánnǎo

Sha the Monk said: ‘Brother, do not be distressed.

Sha Monk again, and again he is the one who turns grief into a plan. Stop fretting. It is the same steadying function he performed twenty passages ago when he laughed at the two of them panicking.

menzǎoānqǐngbīngzhùjiùshī。」 menzǎoānqǐngbīngzhùjiùshī。」

Let us make a plan quickly and go somewhere to ask for troops and aid, to rescue the master.’

那裡 here is nǎ lǐ, somewhere or where -- the word is doing double duty as both an indefinite and a question, and Wukong is about to pick up the question half of it.

xíngzhědào:「qǐngjiùme?」 xíngzhědào:「qǐngjiùme?」

The Pilgrim said: ‘Ask for help where?’

Exactly that. Where? Wukong wants a quarter, not a proposal. It is a fair demand: "go and get help" is not a plan until you know from whom.

shāsēngdào:「dāngchūfēnzhuóděngbǎotángsēngcéngmenjiàotiāntiānyìngjiàoyìng shāsēngdào:「dāngchūfēnzhuóděngbǎotángsēngcéngmenjiàotiāntiānyìngjiàoyìng

Sha the Monk said: ‘In the beginning the Bodhisattva charged us to protect the Tang Monk, and promised us: call on Heaven, and Heaven will answer; call on Earth, and Earth will answer.

Sha reaches for the promise. When Guanyin set them to guard the Tang Monk she gave them a guarantee: 叫天天應, 叫地地應 -- call on Heaven and Heaven answers, call on Earth and Earth answers. It is a real undertaking made earlier in the novel and it sounds absolute.

qǐngjiù?」 qǐngjiù?」

Where, then, should we go to ask for help?’

And then Sha immediately runs into the problem with it. If everything answers, that still does not tell you what to call. The universal promise turns out to be useless for choosing. It is a nicely observed piece of exasperation.

xíngzhědào:「xiǎnglǎosūnnàotiāngōngshíxiēshénbīngdōujīnde xíngzhědào:「xiǎnglǎosūnnàotiāngōngshíxiēshénbīngdōujīnde

The Pilgrim said: ‘Consider — when old Sun made his great havoc in Heaven, those celestial troops, every one, could not withstand me.

Wukong starts reasoning it through, and the way he does it is characteristic: from his own record. When I wrecked heaven, none of those celestial troops could stand against me. is jīn here, to withstand. He is not boasting -- he is establishing a baseline for the argument he is about to make.

zhèyāojīngshéntōngxiǎoshìlǎosūnshǒuduànxiēdecáixiángdeli zhèyāojīngshéntōngxiǎoshìlǎosūnshǒuduànxiēdecáixiángdeli

This demon's powers are no small thing; it must take one of greater skill than old Sun to subdue him.

And here is the argument, and it costs him something to make. This demon is stronger than I am, so it will take someone stronger than I am. 比老孫手段大些的 -- one whose skill is somewhat greater than old Sun's. Wukong has spent a hundred chapters insisting on his own sufficiency. This is him doing arithmetic and not liking the answer.

tiānshénshānéngruòyàoyāoshìqǐngguānyīncáihǎo tiānshénshānéngruòyàoyāoshìqǐngguānyīncáihǎo

The celestial gods will not do, the earthly fiends cannot; if this demon is to be taken, we had best go and ask Guanyin Bodhisattva.

The conclusion, by elimination. Gods above will not do; 地煞, the earthly fiends -- the seventy-two malign stars of the lower rank -- cannot. Only Guanyin. The chapter has now ruled out force, water, and both halves of the spirit world.

nàiròusuānyāoténgtòngjiàjīndǒuyúnzěnshēngqǐngde?」 nàiròusuānyāoténgtòngjiàjīndǒuyúnzěnshēngqǐngde?」

But alas, my flesh is sore and numb, my waist and knees ache, I cannot mount the somersault cloud — how am I to go and ask her?’

And then the practical difficulty, which is almost funny after the grandeur of the conclusion: he hurts too much to fly. 駕不起觔斗雲 -- cannot get the somersault cloud up. That cloud crosses a hundred and eight thousand miles in one leap, and today he cannot manage it because his back aches.


總評 Commentary

The pilgrims work through the logic to its only remaining conclusion, and the interest of the scene is in how much it costs Wukong to reach it.

Sha starts with Guanyin's standing promise -- call on Heaven and Heaven answers -- and immediately notices that a promise covering everything gives no guidance about anything. Wukong then reasons from his own record: the armies of heaven could not stop him, and this demon can, so the help has to come from someone above his own level. 比老孫手段大些的才降得他. For a character whose defining trait is confidence in his own sufficiency, that is a considerable admission.

And then the deflation. Having identified the only power that can help, he cannot go and ask, because his waist and knees hurt too much to mount the cloud. The Great Sage is reduced to sending someone else on an errand, and the someone else is Bajie.