Canonical Classics ← 第四十一回
第四十一回
xīnyuánzāohuǒbài
bèiqín

The Mind-Ape Suffers Defeat by Fire · The Wood-Mother Is Seized by the Demon

開卷詞
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

開卷詞 The Opening Lyric

shànèshíwàngniànróngdōuguānxīnshànèshíwàngniànróngdōuguānxīn
huìmíngyǐnxiànrènchénhuìmíngyǐnxiànrènchén
suífèncānyǐnsuífèncānyǐn
shénjìngzhànránchánghūnmíng便biànyǒuqīnshénjìngzhànránchánghūnmíng便biànyǒuqīn
xíngdēngcèngchánlínxíngdēngcèngchánlín
fēngdòngránhánlǐnfēngdòngránhánlǐn

逐句解 Line by line

shànèshíwàngniànróngdōuguānxīn shànèshíwàngniànróngdōuguānxīn

Let good and ill be, for a moment, put out of mind; let flourishing and withering trouble the heart not at all.

Chapters often open with a set song rather than a scene, and this is one of them: a lyric to the tune 西江月, "The West River Moon," whose two verses each run six syllables, six, seven, six. The advice is to let opposites go. 一時 yì shí is "for a moment," or "all at once"; here is dōu, "at all, in the least," which sharpens the refusal that follows it in 不關心, "let it not touch the heart." The song is stating the chapter's theme before a single thing has happened.

huìmíngyǐnxiànrènchén huìmíngyǐnxiànrènchén

Dark and bright, hidden and shown — leave them to rise and sink as they will.

Two pairs of opposites in four characters: 晦明 dark and bright, 隱現 hidden and shown. Then 任浮沉, "let them float or sink" -- stop swimming against the current. Nothing tricky in the readings here.

suífèncānyǐn suífèncānyǐn

As one's lot allows, eat when hungry and drink when dry.

隨分 suí fèn means "according to your allotted share," so, contentedly -- a stock phrase in Chan writing. is fèn, the "portion, lot" reading, not the everyday fēn of "divide" or "a tenth." 饑餐渴飲, "eat when hungry, drink when thirsty," is the old image of doing the natural thing at the natural time and nothing more.

shénjìngzhànránchánghūnmíng便biànyǒuqīn shénjìngzhànránchánghūnmíng便biànyǒuqīn

When the spirit is still — clear, limpid, forever at rest; but let it cloud and darken, and at once the demon breaks in.

Here the song turns, and this is the hinge of the whole Red Boy episode. A quiet mind (神靜湛然常寂, still and clear and at rest) is safe; the moment it clouds over (昏冥), the demon walks in. is the ordinary word for a demon and also the Chinese rendering of Sanskrit *mara*, the tempter -- so the line reads at once as a warning about monsters and a warning about one's own state of mind. Hold that thought: the fire that nearly kills Wukong later is exactly this , let in.

xíngdēngcèngchánlín xíngdēngcèngchánlín

The Five Phases stumble and lurch, and the grove of Chan is broken.

五行 wǔ xíng, the Five Phases -- metal, wood, water, fire, earth -- the five-part scheme Chinese thought used to explain how anything turns into anything else. 蹬蹭 dēng cèng is to stumble and lurch. 禪林, "the grove of Chan," pictures the disciplined mind as a monastery wood, so the line has the Five Phases blundering through it and knocking it flat. Watch for this line to come literally true: the demon's fire is raised from five carts set out by the Five Phases. is xíng here, never héng.

fēngdòngránhánlǐn fēngdòngránhánlǐn

Let the wind but stir, and a killing chill must surely follow.

The closing line. Any stir of wind (風動) must bring a killing cold (寒凜) after it -- the small first movement that ruins stillness. It lands the song back where it started.


總評 Commentary

Most chapters open with a scene. This one opens with an argument. The lyric is set to the tune 西江月, "The West River Moon," and it is not describing anything that happens -- it is stating, in compressed form, the doctrine the whole Red Boy sequence will act out. A settled spirit cannot be got at. The instant it clouds, the demon () is inside, and the Five Phases fall out of their order.

Read it after finishing the chapter and it works as a warning label. The fire that overwhelms Wukong is the 三昧真火, the fire of concentration itself -- born, the tradition holds, of the mind's own agitation, which is precisely why plain water will not put it out. The reader is handed the moral before the fight starts, and then gets to watch three pilgrims fail to apply it.

The song even supplies the chapter's title in advance. 五行蹬蹭破禪林 -- the Five Phases stumble and the Chan grove breaks -- is the couplet 心猿遭火敗 waiting to happen.