Canonical Classics ← 第四十一回
第四十一回
心xīn猿yuán遭zāo火huǒ敗bài
木mù母mǔ被bèi魔mó擒qín

The Mind-Ape Suffers Defeat by Fire · The Wood-Mother Is Seized by the Demon

冷水攻心
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

冷水攻心 Cold Water and the Failing Heart

這zhè大dà聖shèng一yì身shēn煙yān火huǒ,炮pào燥zào難nán禁jīn,徑jìng投tóu於yú澗jiàn水shuǐ內nèi救jiù火huǒ。怎zěn知zhī被bèi冷lěng水shuǐ一yì逼bī,弄nòng得de火huǒ氣qì攻gōng心xīn,三sān魂hún出chū舍shè。可kě憐lián氣qì塞sè胸xiōng堂táng喉hóu舌shé冷lěng,魂hún飛fēi魄pò散sàn喪sàng殘cán生shēng。慌huāng得de那nà四sì海hǎi龍lóng王wáng在zài半bàn空kōng裡lǐ收shōu了le雨yǔ澤zé,高gāo聲shēng大dà叫jiào:「天tiān蓬péng元yuán帥shuài、捲juǎn簾lián將jiāng軍jūn,休xiū在zài林lín中zhōng藏cáng隱yǐn,且qiě尋xún你nǐ師shī兄xiōng出chū來lái。」这zhè大dà圣shèng一yì身shēn烟yān火huǒ,炮pào燥zào难nán禁jīn,径jìng投tóu于yú涧jiàn水shuǐ内nèi救jiù火huǒ。怎zěn知zhī被bèi冷lěng水shuǐ一yì逼bī,弄nòng得de火huǒ气qì攻gōng心xīn,三sān魂hún出chū舍shè。可kě怜lián气qì塞sè胸xiōng堂táng喉hóu舌shé冷lěng,魂hún飞fēi魄pò散sàn丧sàng残cán生shēng。慌huāng得de那nà四sì海hǎi龙lóng王wáng在zài半bàn空kōng里lǐ收shōu了le雨yǔ泽zé,高gāo声shēng大dà叫jiào:「天tiān蓬péng元yuán帅shuài、卷juǎn帘lián将jiāng军jūn,休xiū在zài林lín中zhōng藏cáng隐yǐn,且qiě寻xún你nǐ师shī兄xiōng出chū来lái。」


逐句解 Line by line

這zhè大dà聖shèng一yì身shēn煙yān火huǒ,炮pào燥zào難nán禁jīn,徑jìng投tóu於yú澗jiàn水shuǐ內nèi救jiù火huǒ。 这zhè大dà圣shèng一yì身shēn烟yān火huǒ,炮pào燥zào难nán禁jīn,径jìng投tóu于yú涧jiàn水shuǐ内nèi救jiù火huǒ。

This Great Sage, his whole body smoke and fire, could not bear the scorching heat, and plunged straight into the torrent to quench it.

Driven off, body still full of fire, and he does the obvious thing: dives into the torrent. 炮 is read pào here, the scorching sense, rather than the páo it took in the fire set-piece where it meant refining elixir. 禁 is jīn, to endure -- the heat was unendurable. Every instinct in the line is right and every one of them is about to be wrong.

怎zěn知zhī被bèi冷lěng水shuǐ一yì逼bī,弄nòng得de火huǒ氣qì攻gōng心xīn,三sān魂hún出chū舍shè。 怎zěn知zhī被bèi冷lěng水shuǐ一yì逼bī,弄nòng得de火huǒ气qì攻gōng心xīn,三sān魂hún出chū舍shè。

Little did he know that, forced back by the cold water, the fire-vapour was driven inward to assail his heart, and his three souls departed their dwelling.

And here is why. The cold water hits the outside and drives the fire inward -- 火氣攻心, the fire-vapour assaults the heart. This is not metaphor; it is Chinese medical physiology, in which sudden cold on a heated body traps the heat where it can do damage. Then 三魂出舍, the three souls leave their dwelling. In Chinese thought a person has three cloud-souls and seven white-souls, and when the three depart, you are dying.

可kě憐lián氣qì塞sè胸xiōng堂táng喉hóu舌shé冷lěng,魂hún飛fēi魄pò散sàn喪sàng殘cán生shēng。 可kě怜lián气qì塞sè胸xiōng堂táng喉hóu舌shé冷lěng,魂hún飞fēi魄pò散sàn丧sàng残cán生shēng。

Pitiful! — his breath stopped in the breast, throat and tongue gone cold; soul fled and spirit scattered, his remnant life all but lost.

A couplet, and it reads exactly like verse, but the source gives it no marker so it stays as running prose. Breath blocked in the chest, throat and tongue gone cold, soul flown and spirit scattered. 塞 is read sè, the literary sound for obstruction, not the everyday sāi of stuffing something in. 可憐 -- pitiful -- is the narrator's own voice breaking through, which he does very rarely.

慌huāng得de那nà四sì海hǎi龍lóng王wáng在zài半bàn空kōng裡lǐ收shōu了le雨yǔ澤zé,高gāo聲shēng大dà叫jiào:「天tiān蓬péng元yuán帥shuài、捲juǎn簾lián將jiāng軍jūn,休xiū在zài林lín中zhōng藏cáng隱yǐn,且qiě尋xún你nǐ師shī兄xiōng出chū來lái。」 慌huāng得de那nà四sì海hǎi龙lóng王wáng在zài半bàn空kōng里lǐ收shōu了le雨yǔ泽zé,高gāo声shēng大dà叫jiào:「天tiān蓬péng元yuán帅shuài、卷juǎn帘lián将jiāng军jūn,休xiū在zài林lín中zhōng藏cáng隐yǐn,且qiě寻xún你nǐ师shī兄xiōng出chū来lái。」

So alarmed were the Dragon Kings of the Four Seas that they withdrew their rain in mid-air and cried aloud: ‘Marshal Tianpeng! General Curtain-Roller! Hide no longer in the wood, but go and seek out your elder brother!’

The dragon kings shut off the rain and start shouting for help, and what they shout is interesting: they call Bajie and Sha Monk by their old celestial ranks. 天蓬元帥, Marshal Tianpeng, commanded eighty thousand troops of the Heavenly River before he was thrown down and born as a pig. 捲簾將軍, the Curtain-Rolling General, stood beside the Jade Emperor's throne before he broke a goblet and was exiled to a river. To a dragon king these are colleagues who have come down in the world, and in a crisis he uses the titles he knew them by.


總評 Commentary

Wukong nearly dies, and not from anything the demon did directly. Driven off by smoke, his body still burning, he plunges into cold water -- and that is what almost kills him. The cold seals the heat inside, it strikes at the heart, his breath stops and his three souls leave.

The physiology is real and specific. Chinese medicine holds that sudden cold on an overheated body traps the heat where it can do harm, and the same framework of vapour and organs and souls that the fire set-piece used to explain the Five Phases is now being used to explain a collapse. The chapter is consistent about this: it built its monster out of a cosmological diagram, and it takes its hero apart with the same one.

There is also a plain irony in it. Water was the answer. Water was the whole plan, the reason for the errand to the ocean and the four kings and the pulled-down Milky Way. Water does not put out this fire, and when Wukong finally gets into some, it nearly finishes him.