Canonical Classics ← 第四十九回
第四十九回
sānzàngyǒuzāichénshuǐzhái
guānyīnjiùnànxiànlán

Tripitaka Meets Disaster and Sinks in the Water Mansion · Guanyin, Saving from Peril, Appears with the Fish Basket

門前對詰
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

門前對詰 The Quarrel at the Gate

yāoxiéchūménláisuíhòuyǒubǎishíxiǎoyāolūnqiāngjiànbǎikāiliǎngshàoduìjièdào:「shìshàngwèishéndàoxuānrǎng?」jièdào:「zhèdeqiándǐngzuǐjīntuīzhīláiwènběnshìdōngtángshèngsēngzhīwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngzhěnòngxuánjiǎzuòshénmelínggǎnwángzhuānzàichénjiāzhuāngyàochītóngnántóngběnshìchénqīngjiāchèngjīnrènme?」yāoguàidào:「zhèshàngshènméidàobiànzuòchèngjīngāimàomíngdǐngzhīzuìdàocéngchīfǎnbèishāngleshǒubèirànglezěnmeyòuxúnshàngdeménlái?」jièdào:「ràngquèzěnmeyòunònglěngfēngxiàxuědòngjiéjiānbīnghàishīkuàizǎosòngshīchūláiwànshìjiēxiūbèngbànzhǐkànkànshǒuzhōngjuéráo。」yāoxiéwényánwēiwēilěngxiàodào:「zhèshàngmàichángshékuākǒuguǒránshìzuòlěngxiàxuědòngshèshījīnrǎngshàngménláiliángtǎozhǐzhèfānfānleshíjiéyīnhuìcéngdàibīngzhòngshāngjīnqiěxiūyàozǒujiāosānsānguòhuánshīguòliánchīle。」yāoxiéchūménláisuíhòuyǒubǎishíxiǎoyāolūnqiāngjiànbǎikāiliǎngshàoduìjièdào:「shìshàngwèishéndàoxuānrǎng?」jièdào:「zhèdeqiándǐngzuǐjīntuīzhīláiwènběnshìdōngtángshèngsēngzhīwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngzhěnòngxuánjiǎzuòshénmelínggǎnwángzhuānzàichénjiāzhuāngyàochītóngnántóngběnshìchénqīngjiāchèngjīnrènme?」yāoguàidào:「zhèshàngshènméidàobiànzuòchèngjīngāimàomíngdǐngzhīzuìdàocéngchīfǎnbèishāngleshǒubèirànglezěnmeyòuxúnshàngdeménlái?」jièdào:「ràngquèzěnmeyòunònglěngfēngxiàxuědòngjiéjiānbīnghàishīkuàizǎosòngshīchūláiwànshìjiēxiūbèngbànzhǐkànkànshǒuzhōngjuéráo。」yāoxiéwényánwēiwēilěngxiàodào:「zhèshàngmàichángshékuākǒuguǒránshìzuòlěngxiàxuědòngshèshījīnrǎngshàngménláiliángtǎozhǐzhèfānfānleshíjiéyīnhuìcéngdàibīngzhòngshāngjīnqiěxiūyàozǒujiāosānsānguòhuánshīguòliánchīle。」


逐句解 Line by line

yāoxiéchūménláisuíhòuyǒubǎishíxiǎoyāolūnqiāngjiànbǎikāiliǎngshào yāoxiéchūménláisuíhòuyǒubǎishíxiǎoyāolūnqiāngjiànbǎikāiliǎngshào

The fiend got out through his gate, and behind him came a hundred and more little demons, every one whirling a spear or brandishing a sword, drawn up in two files.

出得門來: , the "managed to" form. 兩哨 is two files or pickets — the household turning out as a guard detail.

duìjièdào:「shìshàng duìjièdào:「shìshàng

He said to Eight Rules: "From which monastery are you, monk?

那寺裡 asks: , "which."

wèishéndàoxuānrǎng?」 wèishéndàoxuānrǎng?」

And why do you come here raising an uproar?"

為甚: is wèi, the "for the sake of, on account of" reading, and is shén, "what" — together, "what for." Hold on to that : six segments from here the same character turns up as shèn, meaning "extremely."

jièdào:「zhède jièdào:「zhède

Eight Rules bellowed: "You rascally thing that will not die!

我把你這 is a swear left hanging. normally sets up what you are going to do to something, and here the sentence never gets round to saying — it is exactly the English "why, you —".

qiándǐngzuǐjīntuīzhīláiwèn qiándǐngzuǐjīntuīzhīláiwèn

The night before last you traded words with me. How is it that today you push it off as not knowing, and question me?

推不知, to shove a thing aside as none of your business, to play dumb. 前夜 refers to the sacrifice at Chen Village back in chapter 47, where Bajie took the girl's place and the demon got a rake across the hand.

běnshìdōngtángshèngsēngzhīwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngzhě běnshìdōngtángshèngsēngzhīwǎng西tiānbàiqiújīngzhě

I am a disciple of the holy monk of the Great Tang in the Land of the East, bound west to worship the Buddha and seek the scriptures.

The standing self-introduction, repeated with barely a word changed all through the novel — the pilgrims' equivalent of showing a badge. is always .

nòngxuánjiǎzuòshénmelínggǎnwángzhuānzàichénjiāzhuāngyàochītóngnántóng nòngxuánjiǎzuòshénmelínggǎnwángzhuānzàichénjiāzhuāngyàochītóngnántóng

You work your mystifications, set yourself up as some Great King Numinous Response, and do nothing in Chen Village but demand boys and girls to eat.

假做甚麼靈感大王: the 甚麼 here is dismissive — "setting yourself up as some so-called Great King." shén. 專在, to do nothing but.

běnshìchénqīngjiāchèngjīnrènme?」 běnshìchénqīngjiāchèngjīnrènme?」

I myself was Chen Qing's Weight-of-Gold. Do you not know me?"

一秤金, A Full Weight of Gold, is the name of Chen Qing's daughter from chapter 47 — the child Bajie impersonated at the sacrifice. He is claiming the identity as a taunt. chèng; 認得 keeps as .

yāoguàidào:「zhèshàngshènméidào yāoguàidào:「zhèshàngshènméidào

The monster said: "You monk are entirely without reason.

And here is the promised second reading. 甚沒道理: this is shèn, "extremely" — the same character that was shén, "what," twice already in this quarrel. méi.

biànzuòchèngjīngāimàomíngdǐngzhīzuì biànzuòchèngjīngāimàomíngdǐngzhīzuì

You changed yourself into Weight-of-Gold, and that alone earns you the crime of false name and substitution.

冒名頂替 is legal boilerplate — taking another person's name and standing in another person's place. The demon is not swearing back at Bajie; he is charging him under a statute. That is the register he means to keep for the rest of the argument.

dàocéngchīfǎnbèishāngleshǒubèi dàocéngchīfǎnbèishāngleshǒubèi

I never did eat you. On the contrary, it was you who wounded me on the back of the hand.

is dào, the "on the contrary" word, not dǎo, "to topple over" — which is what the same character will mean in the rake's poem a few lines further on. 手背: bèi, the noun.

rànglezěnmeyòuxúnshàngdeménlái?」 rànglezěnmeyòuxúnshàngdeménlái?」

With that I let you off. Why do you come seeking my gate again?"

已此 is written for 以此, "and with that." The demon has been keeping an account, and as far as he is concerned it was settled and closed.

jièdào:「ràngquèzěnmeyòunònglěngfēngxiàxuědòngjiéjiānbīnghàishī jièdào:「ràngquèzěnmeyòunònglěngfēngxiàxuědòngjiéjiānbīnghàishī

Eight Rules said: "If you let me off, why then did you work a cold wind, bring down a great snow, freeze the ice hard, and do my master this harm?

The whole scheme of chapter 48 is read back to him as a charge sheet, in four short clauses: made a cold wind, brought down snow, froze the ice hard, harmed my master.

kuàizǎosòngshīchūláiwànshìjiēxiū kuàizǎosòngshīchūláiwànshìjiēxiū

Send my master out this instant and all is settled;

萬事皆休, "and all of it is over" — the standard offer of terms before a fight starts.

bèngbànzhǐkànkànshǒuzhōngjuéráo。」 bèngbànzhǐkànkànshǒuzhōngjuéráo。」

but let half a 'no' burst out between your teeth, and you may look at the rake in my hand: I'll not spare you."

牙迸半個不字, "let half a no burst out between your teeth" — a wonderfully physical threat, and still the sort of thing spoken Chinese does well. There is a small technical prize here too. The inside the quotation marks is not doing any negating; it is a character being named, like saying "the letter N." So it keeps its own dictionary tone, . In ordinary running speech, standing before a falling tone like would shift up to , and here it does not. 手中 zhōng; 看看 kàn.

yāoxiéwényánwēiwēilěngxiàodào:「zhèshàngmàichángshékuākǒu yāoxiéwényánwēiwēilěngxiàodào:「zhèshàngmàichángshékuākǒu

Hearing this, the fiend gave a thin cold laugh: "This monk peddles a long tongue and brags with a great mouth.

長舌: cháng. 胡誇大口, bragging with a big mouth. Note what the demon does with a death threat: he criticises its style. That is entirely in character.

guǒránshìzuòlěngxiàxuědòngshèshī guǒránshìzuòlěngxiàxuědòngshèshī

It was indeed I who made the cold, sent down the snow, froze the river, and carried off your master.

is to seize and carry off by magic rather than by hand. The confession comes without hesitation, because his defence was never that he is innocent — only that he was provoked first.

jīnrǎngshàngménláiliángtǎozhǐzhèfānfānleshíjiéyīnhuìcéngdàibīngzhòngshāng jīnrǎngshàngménláiliángtǎozhǐzhèfānfānleshíjiéyīnhuìcéngdàibīngzhòngshāng

Now you come bawling to my gate, thinking to demand him back. But I fear this time will not be like the last. On that occasion I was going to a banquet and had brought no weapon, so I took my wound from you by mischance;

誤中你傷: here is zhòng, "to be hit, to take a blow" — not the zhōng, "inside," of 手中 three lines back. 思量 keeps as liáng; 那一番 and 那時節 both point, .

jīnqiěxiūyàozǒujiāosān jīnqiěxiūyàozǒujiāosān

Today you had better not think of running. I'll meet you in three bouts.

三合, three bouts — a wager with a fixed count. He proposes it because he expects to win it. The chapter will bring that number back three separate times, and never once in his favour.

sānguòhuánshī sānguòhuánshī

Hold out against me for three bouts and I'll give your master back;

還你師父: is huán, the verb "to give back," not the adverb hái, "still." 敵得我過 keeps as .

guòliánchīle。」 guòliánchīle。」

fail, and I'll eat you along with him."

一發, "in one go, the whole lot together." He states the terms of eating them as calmly as he would state the terms of a bet, and that calm is the point.


總評 Commentary

The quarrel is conducted almost entirely in the language of a lawsuit. Bajie lays a charge. The demon answers with what a lawyer would call confession and avoidance — yes, he sent the snow and took the monk, but Bajie committed 冒名頂替之罪, the offence of false name and substitution, by taking the girl's place at the sacrifice, and it was the demon who came away wounded. He then claims to have already waived the matter, 已此讓了你, and asks why the file has been reopened. Every move is one a litigant would make, and the novel lets the fact that the subject of the suit is who may eat whom speak entirely for itself.

This is also the densest patch of double-reading characters in the chapter, and every one of them is settled by the sentence rather than by a dictionary. is shén, "what," in 為甚 and 甚麼 but shèn, "extremely," in 甚沒道理. is zhōng, "inside," in 手中 but zhòng, "struck," in 誤中你傷. is the verb huán, "give back," in 還你師父, not the adverb hái. And is dào, "on the contrary," not the dǎo, "topple," that turns up in the rake's poem a few lines later.

The demon's closing excuse — that last time he was on his way to a banquet and had left his weapon at home — is the alibi of every beaten duellist in history, and it sets up the three-bout wager that governs the rest of the fight.