裡迎外合 Inside Meets Outside
行者回轉高崖道:「兄弟們,辛苦啊。」沙僧道:「哥啊,這妖精他在岸上覺得不濟,在水底也盡利害哩,我與二哥左右齊攻,只戰得個兩平。卻怎麼處置,救師父也?」行者道:「不必疑遲,恐被他傷了師父。」八戒道:「哥哥,我這一去哄他出來,你莫做聲,但只在半空中等候。估著他鑽出頭來,卻使個搗蒜打,照他頂門上著著實實一下。縱然打不死他,好道也護疼發暈,卻等老豬趕上一鈀,管教他了帳。」行者道:「正是,正是,這叫做『裡迎外合』,方可濟事。」他兩個復入水中不題。行者回转高崖道:「兄弟们,辛苦啊。」沙僧道:「哥啊,这妖精他在岸上觉得不济,在水底也尽利害哩,我与二哥左右齐攻,只战得个两平。却怎么处置,救师父也?」行者道:「不必疑迟,恐被他伤了师父。」八戒道:「哥哥,我这一去哄他出来,你莫做声,但只在半空中等候。估着他钻出头来,却使个捣蒜打,照他顶门上着着实实一下。纵然打不死他,好道也护疼发晕,却等老猪赶上一钯,管教他了帐。」行者道:「正是,正是,这叫做『里迎外合』,方可济事。」他两个复入水中不题。
逐句解 Line by line
Pilgrim came back to the high cliff and said: "Brothers, you've had hard work of it."
辛苦 as a greeting to people coming back from hard work — roughly "you must be worn out," and still exactly how the phrase is used today. It is the first courtesy anyone in this chapter has offered anyone.
Sha Monk said: "Brother, this fiend feels himself no match on the bank, but in the water he is formidable enough. Second brother and I attacked together from either side, and could fight him only to a draw.
Two jobs for 得 here, settled by position: 覺得 is dé, in the family of 曉得 and 認得, while 戰得個兩平 is the toneless de hooking the verb to its outcome. 不濟, not up to it. And in 盡利害 the character 盡 is standing in for 儘, "thoroughly, downright" — the demon is not finished, he is formidable.
How are we to manage it, and get our master out?"
處置: 處 is chǔ here, the verb "to arrange, to deal with" — not the chù, "a place," it had in 住處 earlier in the chapter.
Pilgrim said: "No use hanging back in doubt — I'm afraid he may do our master harm."
疑遲 is 遲疑, to hesitate, with the two characters swapped; the novel does this often. Wukong's fear is well founded, and the reader knows why: the shrimp hag's timetable gave them only until tomorrow.
Eight Rules said: "Brother, this time I'll go and coax him out. Don't make a sound — just wait in mid-air.
半空中 keeps 中 as zhōng. What follows is Bajie's own plan, thought up by Bajie — rare enough in this novel to be worth marking down.
Reckon the moment he bores his head out, then fetch him a garlic-pounding stroke, straight down on the crown of his skull, and lay it on with all the force you have.
Three occurrences of 著 in one line, and again position settles them: 估著 is zhe, an action going on, while 著著實實 — a doubling of 著實, "in good earnest" — is zhuó twice over. 搗蒜打, a garlic-pounding blow: straight down, with the whole arm, the way you crush garlic in a mortar. 頂門 is the crown of the head.
Even if that doesn't kill him, he'll surely be nursing the hurt and reeling with it, and then let old Hog come up with a stroke of the rake and settle his account for good."
好道 is spoken Chinese for "surely, I'd have thought." 了帳: 了 is liǎo, "to settle up, to close out" — the accounting word, not the little tag le that marks a completed action. Bajie proposes to settle the demon's account. 管教 keeps 教 as jiào.
Pilgrim said: "Just so, just so. This is what's called meeting from within and joining from without — that way the thing can be done."
The 世德堂本 writes 裡迎外合 where the idiom is usually 裡應外合, "answer from inside, join from outside" — the standard phrase for coordinating an attack with someone already within the walls. The edition's wording is kept and the difference recorded here rather than corrected away. 濟事, to actually get the job done.
The two of them went down into the water again — of which no more for the present.
不題, the storyteller putting one thread down to take up another — the same formula that closed the earlier scouting passage, handing us back to the riverbed.
The council after the failure is the first place in the chapter where the pilgrims state their own limits without joking about them. Sha Monk's report is a clean tactical assessment — the demon knows he is weaker on land and stronger in the water, and two of them attacking from both sides can hold him only level — and it is delivered without complaint and without a punchline. The question he finishes on, 卻怎麼處置, how are we to manage it, is the real question of the chapter, and nobody in the party can answer it.
The plan that follows is Bajie's, and it is a good one: bait the demon up, strike overhead from ambush with the whole weight of the blow, finish with the rake. Wukong endorses it with an idiom — 裡迎外合 in this edition, where the received form is 裡應外合 — and the two of them go back down.
Count what the chapter has now tried: reconnaissance, open battle, and an ambush at the waterline. It is about to try this fourth thing, and that will fail as well. The answer, when it comes, is not one the pilgrims can supply.