Canonical Classics ← 第三十三回
第三十三回
wàidàozhēnxìng
yuánshénzhùběnxīn

The Heterodox Way Deludes the True Nature · The Primal Spirit Aids the Fundamental Mind

巧語花言
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

巧語花言 Honeyed Words, a False Tale

guàiqiǎohuāyánqíngjiǎdào:「shīashān西yǒuzuòqīngyōuguànshìguàndedàoshì。」sānzàngdào:「zàiběnguànzhōngshìfèngxiānghuǒyǎnjīngwèizàixiánxíng?」dào:「yīnqiánshānnánshīzhǔjiāyāodàozhòngrángxīngsànláiwǎnshīèrrénérxíngxíngzhìshēnzháozhībānlánměngjiāngxiánpíndàozhànjīngjīngdebēnzǒujiāodiēzàiluànshíshàngshāngletuǐzhīhuíguàiqiǎohuāyánqíngjiǎdào:「shīashān西yǒuzuòqīngyōuguànshìguàndedàoshì。」sānzàngdào:「zàiběnguànzhōngshìfèngxiānghuǒyǎnjīngwèizàixiánxíng?」dào:「yīnqiánshānnánshīzhǔjiāyāodàozhòngrángxīngsànláiwǎnshīèrrénérxíngxíngzhìshēnzháozhībānlánměngjiāngxiánpíndàozhànjīngjīngdebēnzǒujiāodiēzàiluànshíshàngshāngletuǐzhīhuí


逐句解 Line by line

guàiqiǎohuāyánqíngjiǎdào:「shīashān西yǒuzuòqīngyōuguànshìguàndedàoshì。」 guàiqiǎohuāyánqíngjiǎdào:「shīashān西yǒuzuòqīngyōuguànshìguàndedàoshì。」

The fiend, all honeyed words and false-faced feeling, said: “Master, west of this mountain there stands a serene abbey, and I am a Daoist of that abbey.”

巧語花言 (qiǎo yǔ huā yán), “clever speech and flowery words,” i.e. glib deceit; 虛情假意, “empty feeling, false intent.” 觀宇 (guàn yǔ) and 那觀裡 take as guàn, “a Daoist abbey,” not guān, “to observe.”

sānzàngdào:「zàiběnguànzhōngshìfèngxiānghuǒyǎnjīngwèizàixiánxíng?」 sānzàngdào:「zàiběnguànzhōngshìfèngxiānghuǒyǎnjīngwèizàixiánxíng?」

Tripitaka said: “If you're not at your own abbey tending the incense-fires and rehearsing the scriptures, why are you idling about out here?”

本觀 (běn guàn), “your own abbey,” again guàn. 侍奉香火 (shì fèng xiāng huǒ), “to tend the incense and lamps” of a temple. 為何 (wèi hé), “for what reason, why” — read wèi, the preposition.

dào:「yīnqiánshānnánshīzhǔjiāyāodàozhòngrángxīngsànláiwǎnshīèrrénérxíng dào:「yīnqiánshānnánshīzhǔjiāyāodàozhòngrángxīngsànláiwǎnshīèrrénérxíng

The demon said: “The day before, a patron's household away south of the mountain had invited us clergy to avert the baleful stars and share out blessings; we were late returning, and my disciple and I were traveling the road together.

施主 (shī zhǔ), “a donor, patron” of a temple. 禳星散福 (ráng xīng sàn fú), “to exorcise ill stars and distribute blessings” — a Daoist rite; is sàn, “to give out.” The fiend furnishes his tale with plausible liturgical detail.

xíngzhìshēnzháozhībānlánměngjiāngxián xíngzhìshēnzháozhībānlánměngjiāngxián

Coming to a deep byway, we suddenly met a great striped tiger, which seized my disciple in its jaws and bore him off.

深衢 (shēn qú), “a deep thoroughfare, a remote road.” 遇著 (yù zháo), “chanced to meet” — the resultative 著 (zháo). is the disposal coverb jiāng, “took (my disciple) and…,” here “seized and carried off.”

píndàozhànjīngjīngdebēnzǒujiāodiēzàiluànshíshàngshāngletuǐzhīhuí píndàozhànjīngjīngdebēnzǒujiāodiēzàiluànshíshàngshāngletuǐzhīhuí

I, poor Daoist, trembling and with no way to flee, took a tumble on a slope of tumbled rocks, hurt my leg, and cannot find the way back.

貧道 (pín dào), “this poor Daoist,” a priest's humble self-reference. 戰兢兢 (zhàn jīng jīng), “trembling with fright.” 一跤跌 (yì jiāo diē), “took a fall.” The tale supplies both a lost companion and a wounded leg to move the master to pity.


總評 Commentary

The demon spins his fabrication with a craftsman's care: a serene abbey to the west, a patron's rite of star-averting, a homeward journey, a man-eating tiger that carried off his disciple, a fall among the rocks. Each element is chosen for plausibility and pathos — liturgical detail to establish him as a genuine adept, a devoured companion and a broken leg to compel rescue. The storyteller labels the performance in advance (“honeyed words and false-faced feeling”), so the reader weighs every particular as fraud.

Tripitaka's single interjection — why is a temple-Daoist idling on the road rather than tending his incense? — is the natural question of a fellow religious, and it only draws the fiend deeper into invention. The passage turns on the graph , read throughout as guàn, “Daoist abbey”: the fictitious temple is the anchor of the whole deceit, the respectable home to which the “injured priest” begs to be carried — and toward which he means to lead the master into ambush.