Canonical Classics ← 第三十三回
第三十三回
wàidàozhēnxìng
yuánshénzhùběnxīn

The Heterodox Way Deludes the True Nature · The Primal Spirit Aids the Fundamental Mind

甚相應也
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

甚相應也 A Most Fitting Trade

língchóngdào:「azhuāngtiāndebǎobèihuànleba。」jīngguǐdào:「zhuāngtiāndezěnkěnzhuāngréndexiānghuàn?」língchóngdào:「ruòkěnatiēzhèjìngpíng。」xíngzhěxīnzhōngàndào:「huànwàitiējìngpíngjiànhuànliǎngjiànshíshènxiāngyìng。」shàngqiánchězhùlíngchóngdào:「zhuāngtiānhuànme?」guàidào:「dànzhuāngtiānjiùhuànhuànshìdeérzi。」xíngzhědào:「zhuāngmenkànkàn。」língchóngdào:「azhuāngtiāndebǎobèihuànleba。」jīngguǐdào:「zhuāngtiāndezěnkěnzhuāngréndexiānghuàn?」língchóngdào:「ruòkěnatiēzhèjìngpíng。」xíngzhěxīnzhōngàndào:「huànwàitiējìngpíngjiànhuànliǎngjiànshíshènxiāngyìng。」shàngqiánchězhùlíngchóngdào:「zhuāngtiānhuànme?」guàidào:「dànzhuāngtiānjiùhuànhuànshìdeérzi。」xíngzhědào:「zhuāngmenkànkàn。」


逐句解 Line by line

língchóngdào:「azhuāngtiāndebǎobèihuànleba。」 língchóngdào:「azhuāngtiāndebǎobèihuànleba。」

Clever-Bug said: "Brother — a treasure that bottles the sky! Let's trade for it."

與他換了罷 (yǔ tā huàn le ba), "let's trade for it," with the (ba) of a proposal. Greed has now taken over the negotiation on Pilgrim's behalf.

jīngguǐdào:「zhuāngtiāndezěnkěnzhuāngréndexiānghuàn?」 jīngguǐdào:「zhuāngtiāndezěnkěnzhuāngréndexiānghuàn?」

Fine-and-Keen said: "His bottles the sky — why would he trade it for ours that only bottle men?"

相換 (xiāng huàn), "swap with each other," read xiāng. Fine-and-Keen is the cautious one, but note what he is cautious about: not whether the gourd is real, only whether its owner would ever agree.

língchóngdào:「ruòkěnatiēzhèjìngpíng。」 língchóngdào:「ruòkěnatiēzhèjìngpíng。」

Clever-Bug said: "If he won't, we'll throw in this jade vase to sweeten it."

(tiē) is to add something on to even up an unequal exchange -- the makeweight you throw in to close a deal. 也罷 (yě bà), "that'll do," here the verb . The vase is now on the table, and Pilgrim has not asked for anything.

xíngzhěxīnzhōngàndào:「huànwàitiējìngpíngjiànhuànliǎngjiànshíshènxiāngyìng。」 xíngzhěxīnzhōngàndào:「huànwàitiējìngpíngjiànhuànliǎngjiànshíshènxiāngyìng。」

Pilgrim rejoiced in secret: "Gourd for gourd, and the jade vase thrown in besides — one for two! Truly a most fitting bargain."

餘外 (yú wài), "on top of that." 甚相應 (shèn xiāng yìng) is "a very good fit" -- the intensifier shèn, and read yìng yet again, its third distinct job in this chapter after answering a call and answering to a name. One character for a swindler's satisfaction and a victim's doom. His own arithmetic, one for two, is worth remembering when the oath is sworn a few passages later.

shàngqiánchězhùlíngchóngdào:「zhuāngtiānhuànme?」 shàngqiánchězhùlíngchóngdào:「zhuāngtiānhuànme?」

He stepped forward at once, took hold of Clever-Bug, and said: "Bottle the sky, and we'll trade?"

扯住 (chě zhù), "grabbed hold of." He physically takes the imp by the sleeve before anyone can reconsider, which is a salesman's instinct and a monkey's.

guàidào:「dànzhuāngtiānjiùhuànhuànshìdeérzi。」 guàidào:「dànzhuāngtiānjiùhuànhuànshìdeérzi。」

The imps said: "Just bottle the sky and we'll trade — if we don't, I'm your son."

不換我是你的兒子 (bù huàn wǒ shì nǐ de ér zi), "if I don't trade, I'm your son," is a coarse oath of good faith -- claiming the junior position is the crudest way to bind yourself. 兒子 takes as the full noun ér. They mean it as a guarantee; it reads as a prophecy.

xíngzhědào:「zhuāngmenkànkàn。」 xíngzhědào:「zhuāngmenkànkàn。」

Pilgrim said: "Very well, very well — I'll bottle it for you to see."

也罷也罷 (yě bà, yě bà), "very well, very well," again the verb , conceding. Pilgrim allows himself to be talked into the thing he has been steering toward since he first mentioned his gourd.


總評 Commentary

Greed finishes what Pilgrim started. Clever-Bug, dazzled, presses to trade at once; Fine-and-Keen hesitates only over terms, and his hesitation sweetens the deal, since the jade vase goes in to make up the difference. Pilgrim will get two treasures for one worthless hair, and his private glee -- one for two, a very good fit -- names the swindle exactly.

The imps then seal their own ruin with a coarse oath, and Pilgrim, feigning reluctance, allows himself to be talked into the demonstration he has been angling for from the start. This is the pivot of the whole confidence trick: everything now depends on him actually appearing to bottle the sky, which sends him, in the next passage, to petition Heaven for the loan of it.