Canonical Classics ← 第二十二回
第二十二回
八bā戒jiè大dà戰zhàn流liú沙shā河hé
木mù叉chā奉fèng法fǎ收shōu悟wù淨jìng

Bajie Does Great Battle at the River of Flowing Sands · Mokṣa, Bearing the Dharma-Command, Wins Over Wujing

何不馱師過河
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

何不馱師過河 Why Not Carry Him Across?

行xíng者zhě急jí縱zòng雲yún跳tiào起qǐ去qù,正zhèng到dào直zhí北běi下xià人rén家jiā化huà了le一yì缽bō素sù齋zhāi,回huí獻xiàn師shī父fù。師shī父fù見jiàn他tā來lái得de甚shèn快kuài,便biàn叫jiào:「悟wù空kōng,我wǒ們men去qù化huà齋zhāi的de人rén家jiā,求qiú問wèn他tā一yí個gè過guò河hé之zhī策cè,不bù強qiáng似sì與yǔ這zhè怪guài爭zhēng持chí?」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「這zhè家jiā子zi遠yuǎn得de狠hěn哩li,相xiāng去qù有yǒu五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ之zhī路lù,他tā那nǎ裡lǐ得dé知zhī水shuǐ性xìng?問wèn他tā何hé益yì?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge又yòu來lái扯chě謊huǎng了le,五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ路lù,你nǐ怎zěn麼me這zhè等děng去qù來lái得de快kuài?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ裡lǐ曉xiǎo得dé,老lǎo孫sūn的de觔jīn斗dǒu雲yún,一yí縱zòng有yǒu十shí萬wàn八bā千qiān里lǐ。像xiàng這zhè五wǔ七qī千qiān路lù,只zhǐ消xiāo把bǎ頭tóu點diǎn上shàng兩liǎng點diǎn,把bǎ腰yāo躬gōng上shàng一yì躬gōng,就jiù是shì個gè往wǎng回huí,有yǒu何hé難nán哉zāi?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,既jì是shì這zhè般bān容róng易yì,你nǐ把bǎ師shī父fù背bèi著zhe,只zhǐ消xiāo點diǎn點diǎn頭tóu,躬gōng躬gōng腰yāo,跳tiào過guò去qù罷bà了le,何hé必bì苦kǔ苦kǔ的de與yǔ這zhè怪guài廝sī戰zhàn?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ不bú會huì駕jià雲yún?你nǐ把bǎ師shī父fù馱tuó過guò去qù不bú是shì?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「師shī父fù的de凡fán胎tāi肉ròu骨gǔ,重zhòng似sì泰tài山shān,我wǒ這zhè駕jià雲yún的de,怎zěn稱chēng得de起qǐ?須xū是shì你nǐ的de觔jīn斗dǒu方fāng可kě。」行xíng者zhě急jí纵zòng云yún跳tiào起qǐ去qù,正zhèng到dào直zhí北běi下xià人rén家jiā化huà了le一yì钵bō素sù斋zhāi,回huí献xiàn师shī父fù。师shī父fù见jiàn他tā来lái得de甚shèn快kuài,便biàn叫jiào:「悟wù空kōng,我wǒ们men去qù化huà斋zhāi的de人rén家jiā,求qiú问wèn他tā一yí个gè过guò河hé之zhī策cè,不bù强qiáng似sì与yǔ这zhè怪guài争zhēng持chí?」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「这zhè家jiā子zi远yuǎn得de狠hěn哩li,相xiāng去qù有yǒu五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ之zhī路lù,他tā那nǎ里lǐ得dé知zhī水shuǐ性xìng?问wèn他tā何hé益yì?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge又yòu来lái扯chě谎huǎng了le,五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ路lù,你nǐ怎zěn么me这zhè等děng去qù来lái得de快kuài?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ里lǐ晓xiǎo得dé,老lǎo孙sūn的de觔jīn斗dǒu云yún,一yí纵zòng有yǒu十shí万wàn八bā千qiān里lǐ。像xiàng这zhè五wǔ七qī千qiān路lù,只zhǐ消xiāo把bǎ头tóu点diǎn上shàng两liǎng点diǎn,把bǎ腰yāo躬gōng上shàng一yì躬gōng,就jiù是shì个gè往wǎng回huí,有yǒu何hé难nán哉zāi?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,既jì是shì这zhè般bān容róng易yì,你nǐ把bǎ师shī父fù背bèi着zhe,只zhǐ消xiāo点diǎn点diǎn头tóu,躬gōng躬gōng腰yāo,跳tiào过guò去qù罢bà了le,何hé必bì苦kǔ苦kǔ的de与yǔ这zhè怪guài厮sī战zhàn?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ不bú会huì驾jià云yún?你nǐ把bǎ师shī父fù驮tuó过guò去qù不bú是shì?」八bā戒jiè道dào:「师shī父fù的de凡fán胎tāi肉ròu骨gǔ,重zhòng似sì泰tài山shān,我wǒ这zhè驾jià云yún的de,怎zěn称chēng得de起qǐ?须xū是shì你nǐ的de觔jīn斗dǒu方fāng可kě。」


逐句解 Line by line

行xíng者zhě急jí縱zòng雲yún跳tiào起qǐ去qù,正zhèng到dào直zhí北běi下xià人rén家jiā化huà了le一yì缽bō素sù齋zhāi,回huí獻xiàn師shī父fù。 行xíng者zhě急jí纵zòng云yún跳tiào起qǐ去qù,正zhèng到dào直zhí北běi下xià人rén家jiā化huà了le一yì钵bō素sù斋zhāi,回huí献xiàn师shī父fù。

The Pilgrim quickly leapt up on a cloud, made straight for a household to the due north, begged a bowl of vegetarian fare, and brought it back to offer the master.

化了一缽素齋, 'begged an alms-bowl of vegetarian food.' The errand takes him no time at all, and the speed of it is what starts the argument.

師shī父fù見jiàn他tā來lái得de甚shèn快kuài,便biàn叫jiào:「悟wù空kōng,我wǒ們men去qù化huà齋zhāi的de人rén家jiā, 师shī父fù见jiàn他tā来lái得de甚shèn快kuài,便biàn叫jiào:「悟wù空kōng,我wǒ们men去qù化huà斋zhāi的de人rén家jiā,

The master, seeing how quickly he had come and gone, called out: 'Wukong, this household where you begged the food —'

來得甚快, 'came back extremely fast' (得 de, 甚 shèn, 'exceedingly'). The master draws the natural inference — if he was back that quickly, the house must be close — and the whole comic argument of this passage grows out of that one wrong assumption.

求qiú問wèn他tā一yí個gè過guò河hé之zhī策cè,不bù強qiáng似sì與yǔ這zhè怪guài爭zhēng持chí?」 求qiú问wèn他tā一yí个gè过guò河hé之zhī策cè,不bù强qiáng似sì与yǔ这zhè怪guài争zhēng持chí?」

'wouldn't it be better to go and ask them for a way across the river than to keep grappling with this monster?'

不強似, 'would it not be better than' (似 is sì). Sanzang's suggestion is entirely sensible on its own terms: never mind fighting the monster, go and ask the neighbours how people cross.

行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「這zhè家jiā子zi遠yuǎn得de狠hěn哩li,相xiāng去qù有yǒu五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ之zhī路lù, 行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「这zhè家jiā子zi远yuǎn得de狠hěn哩li,相xiāng去qù有yǒu五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ之zhī路lù,

The Pilgrim said with a laugh: 'That house is a fearful distance off — five or seven thousand lǐ away —

遠得狠, 'fearfully far' (得 de), and 相去有五七千里, 'five or seven thousand lǐ apart' (相 xiāng, mutually). The neighbours are roughly the width of a continent away.

他tā那nǎ裡lǐ得dé知zhī水shuǐ性xìng?問wèn他tā何hé益yì?」 他tā那nǎ里lǐ得dé知zhī水shuǐ性xìng?问wèn他tā何hé益yì?」

'how would they know anything of the water? What use would it be to ask them?'

他那裡得知水性, 'however would they come to know the water?' — with 那 as nǎ, the question word, and 得 as dé, to come by. Two objections in one line: they are too far away, and they would not know anything useful anyway.

八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge又yòu來lái扯chě謊huǎng了le,五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ路lù,你nǐ怎zěn麼me這zhè等děng去qù來lái得de快kuài?」 八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge又yòu来lái扯chě谎huǎng了le,五wǔ七qī千qiān里lǐ路lù,你nǐ怎zěn么me这zhè等děng去qù来lái得de快kuài?」

Bajie said: 'Elder brother's spinning yarns again — five or seven thousand lǐ, and how did you come and go so fast?'

扯謊, 'spinning yarns' — Bajie says out loud what any reader is thinking (去來得快, 'came and went so fast,' 得 de). His scepticism is the cue the monkey has been waiting for.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ裡lǐ曉xiǎo得dé,老lǎo孫sūn的de觔jīn斗dǒu雲yún,一yí縱zòng有yǒu十shí萬wàn八bā千qiān里lǐ。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ里lǐ晓xiǎo得dé,老lǎo孙sūn的de觔jīn斗dǒu云yún,一yí纵zòng有yǒu十shí万wàn八bā千qiān里lǐ。

The Pilgrim said: 'What would you know of it? Old Sun's somersault cloud carries a hundred and eight thousand lǐ at a single bound.'

觔斗雲, the somersault cloud (斗 is dǒu, as in 筋斗, a tumble), covers 十萬八千里 — a hundred and eight thousand lǐ — in one bound. Readers of the novel will recognise the figure, which is the one it gives for the whole span of the journey west. In a single somersault he can cover the entire pilgrimage. Remember that for what comes next.

像xiàng這zhè五wǔ七qī千qiān路lù,只zhǐ消xiāo把bǎ頭tóu點diǎn上shàng兩liǎng點diǎn,把bǎ腰yāo躬gōng上shàng一yì躬gōng,就jiù是shì個gè往wǎng回huí,有yǒu何hé難nán哉zāi?」 像xiàng这zhè五wǔ七qī千qiān路lù,只zhǐ消xiāo把bǎ头tóu点diǎn上shàng两liǎng点diǎn,把bǎ腰yāo躬gōng上shàng一yì躬gōng,就jiù是shì个gè往wǎng回huí,有yǒu何hé难nán哉zāi?」

'A mere five or seven thousand lǐ — I need only nod my head a couple of times and bend my waist once, and there and back it is. What difficulty in that?'

點上兩點 … 躬上一躬: a couple of nods and one bow of the waist. He has reduced a journey of thousands of lǐ to a shrug — and handed Bajie the obvious question.

八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,既jì是shì這zhè般bān容róng易yì,你nǐ把bǎ師shī父fù背bèi著zhe, 八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē啊a,既jì是shì这zhè般bān容róng易yì,你nǐ把bǎ师shī父fù背bèi着zhe,

Bajie said: 'Brother! If it's as easy as all that, then take the master on your back, give a nod or two,

你把師父背著, 'take the master on your back' (著 zhe). Here it is: the question every first-time reader of this novel asks almost immediately, and the book has waited a long while to let somebody say it out loud.

只zhǐ消xiāo點diǎn點diǎn頭tóu,躬gōng躬gōng腰yāo,跳tiào過guò去qù罷bà了le,何hé必bì苦kǔ苦kǔ的de與yǔ這zhè怪guài廝sī戰zhàn?」 只zhǐ消xiāo点diǎn点diǎn头tóu,躬gōng躬gōng腰yāo,跳tiào过guò去qù罢bà了le,何hé必bì苦kǔ苦kǔ的de与yǔ这zhè怪guài厮sī战zhàn?」

'bend your waist, and just leap across — why go to all this bitter trouble of fighting the monster?'

跳過去罷了, 'just hop over and be done with it,' and 何必苦苦 … 廝戰, 'why go to all this bitter trouble of fighting?' Bajie is not being stupid. He is being completely reasonable, which is why the answer has to be a good one.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ不bú會huì駕jià雲yún?你nǐ把bǎ師shī父fù馱tuó過guò去qù不bú是shì?」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ不bú会huì驾jià云yún?你nǐ把bǎ师shī父fù驮tuó过guò去qù不bú是shì?」

The Pilgrim said: 'Can't you ride a cloud yourself? Why don't you carry the master over?'

The monkey's first move is to pass the question back: 你把師父馱過去不是, 'why don't you carry him over yourself?' It buys him a moment, and it gets Bajie to state the physical half of the problem before he states the spiritual half.

八bā戒jiè道dào:「師shī父fù的de凡fán胎tāi肉ròu骨gǔ,重zhòng似sì泰tài山shān,我wǒ這zhè駕jià雲yún的de, 八bā戒jiè道dào:「师shī父fù的de凡fán胎tāi肉ròu骨gǔ,重zhòng似sì泰tài山shān,我wǒ这zhè驾jià云yún的de,

Bajie said: 'The master's mortal frame of flesh and bone is heavy as Mount Tai; this cloud-riding of mine —'

凡胎肉骨, 'a common womb-born frame of flesh and bone,' and 重似泰山, 'heavy as Mount Tai' (重 is zhòng; 似 is sì). Mount Tai is the standard measure of weight and consequence in Chinese, the mountain you invoke when you want the heaviest thing there is. Bajie states the fact correctly and understands it not at all.

怎zěn稱chēng得de起qǐ?須xū是shì你nǐ的de觔jīn斗dǒu方fāng可kě。」 怎zěn称chēng得de起qǐ?须xū是shì你nǐ的de觔jīn斗dǒu方fāng可kě。」

'how could it bear the weight? It must be your somersault cloud that could do it.'

怎稱得起, 'how could it take the load?' (稱 chēng, to bear weight; 得 de) — and 須是你的觔斗方可, 'only your somersault would do it' (斗 dǒu). The task goes back to the monkey, and with it the need for a real answer.


總評 Commentary

This is comedy built out of the pilgrimage's own machinery. Watching the monkey fetch a meal in the time it takes to blink, Sanzang assumes the neighbours are near and might simply be asked the way across — and has to be told that the 'household' was five or seven thousand lǐ off, reached by a cloud that covers a hundred and eight thousand at a bound. The exchange lets the novel show off the monkey's mobility and then, in Bajie's mouth, turn it into an awkward question.

Because if the cloud makes nothing of such distances, why not carry the master and skip the fighting altogether? Bajie asks it plainly. The monkey bats it back at him, and Bajie's answer — the master's 凡胎肉骨 ('mortal frame of flesh and bone') is 重似泰山 ('heavy as Mount Tai') — gets the fact right and the meaning wrong. The stage is set for the Pilgrim's reply, which turns a question of weight into a question of doctrine.