Canonical Classics ← 第二十二回
第二十二回
八bā戒jiè大dà戰zhàn流liú沙shā河hé
木mù叉chā奉fèng法fǎ收shōu悟wù淨jìng

Bajie Does Great Battle at the River of Flowing Sands · Mokṣa, Bearing the Dharma-Command, Wins Over Wujing

岸上定計
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

岸上定計 Counsel on the Bank

他tā兩liǎng個gè攙chān著zhe手shǒu,說shuō說shuō笑xiào笑xiào,轉zhuǎn回huí見jiàn了le唐táng僧sēng。唐táng僧sēng道dào:「可kě曾céng捉zhuō得de妖yāo怪guài?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà妖yāo怪guài不bú奈nài戰zhàn,敗bài回huí鑽zuān入rù水shuǐ去qù也yě。」三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,這zhè怪guài久jiǔ住zhù于yú此cǐ,他tā知zhī道dào淺qiǎn深shēn。似sì這zhè般bān無wú邊biān的de弱ruò水shuǐ,又yòu沒méi了le舟zhōu楫jí,須xū是shì得de個gè知zhī水shuǐ性xìng的de引yǐn領lǐng引yǐn領lǐng才cái好hǎo哩li。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「正zhèng是shì這zhè等děng說shuō。常cháng言yán道dào:『近jìn硃zhū者zhě赤chì,近jìn墨mò者zhě黑hēi。』那nà怪guài在zài此cǐ,斷duàn知zhī水shuǐ性xìng。我wǒ們men如rú今jīn拿ná住zhù他tā,且qiě不bú要yào打dǎ殺shā,只zhǐ教jiào他tā送sòng師shī父fù過guò河hé,再zài做zuò理lǐ會huì。」八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge不bú必bì遲chí疑yí,讓ràng你nǐ先xiān去qù拿ná他tā,等děng老lǎo豬zhū看kān守shǒu師shī父fù。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「賢xián弟dì呀ya,這zhè樁zhuāng兒ér我wǒ不bù敢gǎn說shuō嘴zuǐ,水shuǐ裡lǐ勾gòu當dàng,老lǎo孫sūn不bú大dà十shí分fēn熟shú。若ruò是shì空kōng走zǒu,還hái要yào捻niǎn訣jué,又yòu念niàn念niàn避bì水shuǐ咒zhòu,方fāng才cái走zǒu得de;不bù然rán,就jiù要yào變biàn化huà做zuò甚shén麼me魚yú蝦xiā蟹xiè鱉biē之zhī類lèi,我wǒ才cái去qù得de。若ruò論lùn賭dǔ手shǒu段duàn,憑píng你nǐ在zài高gāo山shān雲yún裡lǐ,幹gàn甚shén麼me蹊qī蹺qiāo異yì樣yàng事shì兒ér,老lǎo孫sūn都dōu會huì;只zhǐ是shì水shuǐ裡lǐ的de買mǎi賣mài,有yǒu些xiē兒ér榔láng杭háng。」他tā两liǎng个gè搀chān着zhe手shǒu,说shuō说shuō笑xiào笑xiào,转zhuǎn回huí见jiàn了le唐táng僧sēng。唐táng僧sēng道dào:「可kě曾céng捉zhuō得de妖yāo怪guài?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà妖yāo怪guài不bú奈nài战zhàn,败bài回huí钻zuān入rù水shuǐ去qù也yě。」三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,这zhè怪guài久jiǔ住zhù于yú此cǐ,他tā知zhī道dào浅qiǎn深shēn。似sì这zhè般bān无wú边biān的de弱ruò水shuǐ,又yòu没méi了le舟zhōu楫jí,须xū是shì得de个gè知zhī水shuǐ性xìng的de引yǐn领lǐng引yǐn领lǐng才cái好hǎo哩li。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「正zhèng是shì这zhè等děng说shuō。常cháng言yán道dào:『近jìn朱zhū者zhě赤chì,近jìn墨mò者zhě黑hēi。』那nà怪guài在zài此cǐ,断duàn知zhī水shuǐ性xìng。我wǒ们men如rú今jīn拿ná住zhù他tā,且qiě不bú要yào打dǎ杀shā,只zhǐ教jiào他tā送sòng师shī父fù过guò河hé,再zài做zuò理lǐ会huì。」八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge不bú必bì迟chí疑yí,让ràng你nǐ先xiān去qù拿ná他tā,等děng老lǎo猪zhū看kān守shǒu师shī父fù。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「贤xián弟dì呀ya,这zhè桩zhuāng儿ér我wǒ不bù敢gǎn说shuō嘴zuǐ,水shuǐ里lǐ勾gòu当dàng,老lǎo孙sūn不bú大dà十shí分fēn熟shú。若ruò是shì空kōng走zǒu,还hái要yào捻niǎn诀jué,又yòu念niàn念niàn避bì水shuǐ咒zhòu,方fāng才cái走zǒu得de;不bù然rán,就jiù要yào变biàn化huà做zuò甚shén么me鱼yú虾xiā蟹xiè鳖biē之zhī类lèi,我wǒ才cái去qù得de。若ruò论lùn赌dǔ手shǒu段duàn,凭píng你nǐ在zài高gāo山shān云yún里lǐ,干gàn甚shén么me蹊qī跷qiāo异yì样yàng事shì儿ér,老lǎo孙sūn都dōu会huì;只zhǐ是shì水shuǐ里lǐ的de买mǎi卖mài,有yǒu些xiē儿ér榔láng杭háng。」


逐句解 Line by line

他tā兩liǎng個gè攙chān著zhe手shǒu,說shuō說shuō笑xiào笑xiào,轉zhuǎn回huí見jiàn了le唐táng僧sēng。 他tā两liǎng个gè搀chān着zhe手shǒu,说shuō说shuō笑xiào笑xiào,转zhuǎn回huí见jiàn了le唐táng僧sēng。

The two of them, hand in hand and laughing together, turned back to see the Tang Monk.

攙著手, 'arm in arm' (著 zhe). One page ago Bajie was hopping with rage. Now the two of them walk back linked and laughing. They quarrel like this constantly and it never survives a scene change.

唐táng僧sēng道dào:「可kě曾céng捉zhuō得de妖yāo怪guài?」 唐táng僧sēng道dào:「可kě曾céng捉zhuō得de妖yāo怪guài?」

The Tang Monk asked: 'Did you manage to catch the monster?'

可曾捉得, 'did you manage to catch it?' — with 得 as de, marking whether or not you could. It is the master's first question and, given what he has just watched from the high bank, an optimistic one.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà妖yāo怪guài不bú奈nài戰zhàn,敗bài回huí鑽zuān入rù水shuǐ去qù也yě。」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà妖yāo怪guài不bú奈nài战zhàn,败bài回huí钻zuān入rù水shuǐ去qù也yě。」

The Pilgrim said: 'That monster couldn't stand the fight — he fell back and bored down into the water.'

不奈戰, 'couldn't stand the fight' — a fine piece of spin, considering whose cudgel did the frightening. (奈 is nài; before a falling tone like that, 不 lifts to bú.) 鑽入水去 restates the deadlock: he has gone where nobody can follow.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,這zhè怪guài久jiǔ住zhù于yú此cǐ,他tā知zhī道dào淺qiǎn深shēn。似sì這zhè般bān無wú邊biān的de弱ruò水shuǐ,又yòu沒méi了le舟zhōu楫jí, 三sān藏zàng道dào:「徒tú弟dì,这zhè怪guài久jiǔ住zhù于yú此cǐ,他tā知zhī道dào浅qiǎn深shēn。似sì这zhè般bān无wú边biān的de弱ruò水shuǐ,又yòu没méi了le舟zhōu楫jí,

Sanzang said: 'Disciples, this creature has long dwelt here and knows its shallows and depths. With Weak Water as boundless as this, and no boat or oar to be had,

And here, unexpectedly, the least capable member of the party out-thinks the other two. 他知道淺深, 'he knows the shallows and the deeps': the thing blocking the river is also the only creature alive who knows how to get across it. 似這般 … 弱水, 'Weak Water like this' (似 is sì), and not an oar to be had either. In one sentence Sanzang has turned the obstacle into the solution.

須xū是shì得de個gè知zhī水shuǐ性xìng的de引yǐn領lǐng引yǐn領lǐng才cái好hǎo哩li。」 须xū是shì得de个gè知zhī水shuǐ性xìng的de引yǐn领lǐng引yǐn领lǐng才cái好hǎo哩li。」

'we simply must get someone who knows the water to lead us across before all will be well.'

得個知水性的引領 — 'get hold of somebody who knows the water, to lead us.' Here 得 is the plain main verb, de, 'to get.' The doubled 引領引領 ('guide us, just guide us a bit') is ordinary spoken softening, the way English doubles a word to make a request smaller.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「正zhèng是shì這zhè等děng說shuō。常cháng言yán道dào:『近jìn硃zhū者zhě赤chì,近jìn墨mò者zhě黑hēi。』 行xíng者zhě道dào:「正zhèng是shì这zhè等děng说shuō。常cháng言yán道dào:『近jìn朱zhū者zhě赤chì,近jìn墨mò者zhě黑hēi。』

The Pilgrim said: 'Just so. As the old saying goes, "Near cinnabar one turns red; near ink one turns black."'

近硃者赤,近墨者黑 — 'stay near cinnabar and you turn red; stay near ink and you turn black.' Chinese schoolchildren still learn this one, and it is the ancestor of the modern line about becoming the average of the company you keep. The monkey puts it to unusual work here: not about morals but about expertise. Live in a river long enough and you cannot help knowing it. Because the saying arrives with 常言道 ('as the old saying goes') rather than a verse tag, it is set as prose.

那nà怪guài在zài此cǐ,斷duàn知zhī水shuǐ性xìng。我wǒ們men如rú今jīn拿ná住zhù他tā,且qiě不bú要yào打dǎ殺shā,只zhǐ教jiào他tā送sòng師shī父fù過guò河hé,再zài做zuò理lǐ會huì。」 那nà怪guài在zài此cǐ,断duàn知zhī水shuǐ性xìng。我wǒ们men如rú今jīn拿ná住zhù他tā,且qiě不bú要yào打dǎ杀shā,只zhǐ教jiào他tā送sòng师shī父fù过guò河hé,再zài做zuò理lǐ会huì。」

'This monster, living here, must surely know the water. Let us seize him now — but not beat him to death; only make him ferry the master across, and then we'll settle the rest.'

只教他送師父過河, 'just make him ferry the master over' — with 教 as jiào, the causative 'have somebody do.' The order is capture, not kill, and it is the first quiet signal that this demon is not meant to be destroyed. Everything the chapter does from here follows from that one decision.

八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge不bú必bì遲chí疑yí,讓ràng你nǐ先xiān去qù拿ná他tā,等děng老lǎo豬zhū看kān守shǒu師shī父fù。」 八bā戒jiè道dào:「哥gē哥ge不bú必bì迟chí疑yí,让ràng你nǐ先xiān去qù拿ná他tā,等děng老lǎo猪zhū看kān守shǒu师shī父fù。」

Bajie said: 'Elder brother, no need to dither — you go and take him first, and let old Hog stand guard over the master.'

不必遲疑, 'no need to dither.' Then Bajie, still sore from the last scene, hands the water-fight over with unusual grace: 讓你先去拿他, you go first. He is about to get an answer he was not expecting.

行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「賢xián弟dì呀ya,這zhè樁zhuāng兒ér我wǒ不bù敢gǎn說shuō嘴zuǐ,水shuǐ裡lǐ勾gòu當dàng,老lǎo孫sūn不bú大dà十shí分fēn熟shú。 行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「贤xián弟dì呀ya,这zhè桩zhuāng儿ér我wǒ不bù敢gǎn说shuō嘴zuǐ,水shuǐ里lǐ勾gòu当dàng,老lǎo孙sūn不bú大dà十shí分fēn熟shú。

The Pilgrim said with a laugh: 'Worthy brother, this is one thing I dare not boast of — old Sun isn't too greatly skilled in doings under the water.'

不敢說嘴, 'I dare not brag' — four characters that almost never come out of this mouth. 水裡勾當, 'business in the water,' is the one department where 不大十分熟, he is 'not too very expert.' Count the hedges stacked in that phrase: even the confession is reluctant.

若ruò是shì空kōng走zǒu,還hái要yào捻niǎn訣jué,又yòu念niàn念niàn避bì水shuǐ咒zhòu,方fāng才cái走zǒu得de; 若ruò是shì空kōng走zǒu,还hái要yào捻niǎn诀jué,又yòu念niàn念niàn避bì水shuǐ咒zhòu,方fāng才cái走zǒu得de;

'If I go simply through it, I must still make the finger-signs and keep muttering a water-repelling spell before I can move at all;

捻訣 is twisting the fingers into a magical sign; 避水咒 is a water-repelling spell (還 here is hái, 'on top of that'). He can go under, but only by conjuring continuously the whole time — the difference between a diver on borrowed air and a fish. 走得, 'able to move' (得 de).

不bù然rán,就jiù要yào變biàn化huà做zuò甚shén麼me魚yú蝦xiā蟹xiè鱉biē之zhī類lèi,我wǒ才cái去qù得de。 不bù然rán,就jiù要yào变biàn化huà做zuò甚shén么me鱼yú虾xiā蟹xiè鳖biē之zhī类lèi,我wǒ才cái去qù得de。

'otherwise I must change myself into some fish or shrimp, crab or turtle, and only then can I go.'

變化做甚麼魚蝦蟹鱉之類, 'turn into some sort of fish, shrimp, crab or turtle' (甚麼 here is shénme, 'some or other'; 得 de). The alternative works perfectly well. It also means arriving as a shrimp, which is no way to swing a cudgel.

若ruò論lùn賭dǔ手shǒu段duàn,憑píng你nǐ在zài高gāo山shān雲yún裡lǐ,幹gàn甚shén麼me蹊qī蹺qiāo異yì樣yàng事shì兒ér, 若ruò论lùn赌dǔ手shǒu段duàn,凭píng你nǐ在zài高gāo山shān云yún里lǐ,干gàn甚shén么me蹊qī跷qiāo异yì样yàng事shì儿ér,

'If it's a matter of matching skills — up on high mountains, among the clouds, whatever strange and cunning feats you like —

賭手段, 'to stake skill against skill.' 蹊蹺異樣事兒 is 'strange, crooked, out-of-the-way business' (甚麼 shénme). On mountains, in cloud, at any oddity you care to name, he is unbeatable. The whole clause exists to set up the exception.

老lǎo孫sūn都dōu會huì;只zhǐ是shì水shuǐ裡lǐ的de買mǎi賣mài,有yǒu些xiē兒ér榔láng杭háng。」 老lǎo孙sūn都dōu会huì;只zhǐ是shì水shuǐ里lǐ的de买mǎi卖mài,有yǒu些xiē儿ér榔láng杭háng。」

'old Sun can do it all; it's only this business in the water that gives me some trouble.'

都會, 'can do the lot' (都 dōu) — and then 水裡的買賣, literally 'the water trade,' the blunt commercial figure the vernacular reaches for when it means any line of work. 榔杭 is a dialect word for awkward, sticky, hard to handle. Old Sun finds it a bit awkward. The job passes to Bajie.


總評 Commentary

The scene turns from fighting to planning, and the surprise is that Sanzang, who has done nothing all chapter but be frightened, reasons better than either disciple. A creature that has lived in this river for ages must know its shallows and its deeps; therefore the obstacle is also the guide. The order goes out to capture rather than kill, and that single decision governs everything that follows — the first sign that this demon has a future in the story rather than merely an end. The proverb about cinnabar and ink lends the plan a copybook logic.

The passage also contains a rare confession. Master of mountain and cloud, the Great Sage admits outright that 水裡勾當, 'doings in the water,' defeat him: he can go under only by conjuring without pause, or by turning into a fish or a crab, and neither leaves him fit to fight. It is funny, but it is also structural. The admission hands the water to Bajie, who once commanded the Heavenly River, and it fixes the limit that will in the end send the monkey to Guanyin for help.