Canonical Classics ← 第二十二回
第二十二回
八bā戒jiè大dà戰zhàn流liú沙shā河hé
木mù叉chā奉fèng法fǎ收shōu悟wù淨jìng

Bajie Does Great Battle at the River of Flowing Sands · Mokṣa, Bearing the Dharma-Command, Wins Over Wujing

菩薩指點法船
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

菩薩指點法船 The Bodhisattva Reveals the Plan

菩pú薩sà問wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ怎zěn麼me不bù保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,為wèi甚shén事shì又yòu來lái見jiàn我wǒ?」行xíng者zhě啟qǐ上shàng道dào:「菩pú薩sà,我wǒ師shī父fù前qián在zài高gāo老lǎo莊zhuāng,又yòu收shōu了le一yí個gè徒tú弟dì,喚huàn名míng豬zhū八bā戒jiè,多duō蒙méng菩pú薩sà又yòu賜cì法fǎ諱huì悟wù能néng。才cái行xíng過guò黃huáng風fēng嶺lǐng,今jīn至zhì八bā百bǎi里lǐ流liú沙shā河hé,乃nǎi是shì弱ruò水shuǐ三sān千qiān,師shī父fù已yǐ是shì難nán渡dù;河hé中zhōng又yòu有yǒu個gè妖yāo怪guài,武wǔ藝yì高gāo強qiáng,甚shèn虧kuī了le悟wù能néng與yǔ他tā水shuǐ面miàn上shàng大dà戰zhàn三sān次cì,只zhǐ是shì不bù能néng取qǔ勝shèng,被bèi他tā攔lán阻zǔ,不bù能néng渡dù河hé。因yīn此cǐ,特tè告gào菩pú薩sà,望wàng垂chuí憐lián憫mǐn,濟jì渡dù他tā一yí濟jì渡dù。」菩pú薩sà道dào:「你nǐ這zhè猴hóu子zi,又yòu逞chěng自zì滿mǎn,不bù肯kěn說shuō出chū保bǎo唐táng僧sēng的de話huà來lái麼me?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ們men只zhǐ是shì要yào拿ná住zhù他tā,教jiào他tā送sòng我wǒ師shī父fù渡dù河hé。水shuǐ裡lǐ事shì,我wǒ又yòu弄nòng不bù得de精jīng細xì。只zhǐ是shì悟wù能néng尋xún著zháo他tā窩wō巢cháo,與yǔ他tā打dǎ話huà,想xiǎng是shì不bù曾céng說shuō出chū取qǔ經jīng的de勾gòu當dàng。」菩pú薩sà道dào:「那nà流liú沙shā河hé的de妖yāo怪guài,乃nǎi是shì捲juǎn簾lián大dà將jiàng臨lín凡fán,也yě是shì我wǒ勸quàn化huà的de善shàn信xìn,教jiào他tā保bǎo護hù取qǔ經jīng之zhī輩bèi。你nǐ若ruò肯kěn說shuō出chū是shì東dōng土tǔ取qǔ經jīng人rén時shí,他tā決jué不bù與yǔ你nǐ爭zhēng持chí,斷duàn然rán歸guī順shùn矣yǐ。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài如rú今jīn怯qiè戰zhàn,不bù肯kěn上shàng崖yá,只zhǐ在zài水shuǐ裡lǐ潛qián蹤zōng,如rú何hé得dé他tā歸guī順shùn?我wǒ師shī如rú何hé得dé渡dù弱ruò水shuǐ?」菩pú薩sà即jí喚huàn惠huì岸àn,袖xiù中zhōng取qǔ出chū一yí個gè紅hóng葫hú蘆lú兒ér,吩fēn咐fu道dào:「你nǐ可kě將jiāng此cǐ葫hú蘆lú,同tóng孫sūn悟wù空kōng到dào流liú沙shā河hé水shuǐ面miàn上shàng,只zhǐ叫jiào『悟wù淨jìng』,他tā就jiù出chū來lái了le。先xiān要yào引yǐn他tā歸guī依yī了le唐táng僧sēng。然rán後hòu把bǎ他tā那nà九jiǔ個gè骷kū髏lóu穿chuān在zài一yí處chù,按àn九jiǔ宮gōng佈bù列liè,卻què把bǎ這zhè葫hú蘆lú安ān在zài當dāng中zhōng,就jiù是shì法fǎ船chuán一yì隻zhī,能néng渡dù唐táng僧sēng過guò流liú沙shā河hé界jiè。」菩pú萨sà问wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ怎zěn么me不bù保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,为wèi甚shén事shì又yòu来lái见jiàn我wǒ?」行xíng者zhě启qǐ上shàng道dào:「菩pú萨sà,我wǒ师shī父fù前qián在zài高gāo老lǎo庄zhuāng,又yòu收shōu了le一yí个gè徒tú弟dì,唤huàn名míng猪zhū八bā戒jiè,多duō蒙méng菩pú萨sà又yòu赐cì法fǎ讳huì悟wù能néng。才cái行xíng过guò黄huáng风fēng岭lǐng,今jīn至zhì八bā百bǎi里lǐ流liú沙shā河hé,乃nǎi是shì弱ruò水shuǐ三sān千qiān,师shī父fù已yǐ是shì难nán渡dù;河hé中zhōng又yòu有yǒu个gè妖yāo怪guài,武wǔ艺yì高gāo强qiáng,甚shèn亏kuī了le悟wù能néng与yǔ他tā水shuǐ面miàn上shàng大dà战zhàn三sān次cì,只zhǐ是shì不bù能néng取qǔ胜shèng,被bèi他tā拦lán阻zǔ,不bù能néng渡dù河hé。因yīn此cǐ,特tè告gào菩pú萨sà,望wàng垂chuí怜lián悯mǐn,济jì渡dù他tā一yí济jì渡dù。」菩pú萨sà道dào:「你nǐ这zhè猴hóu子zi,又yòu逞chěng自zì满mǎn,不bù肯kěn说shuō出chū保bǎo唐táng僧sēng的de话huà来lái么me?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ们men只zhǐ是shì要yào拿ná住zhù他tā,教jiào他tā送sòng我wǒ师shī父fù渡dù河hé。水shuǐ里lǐ事shì,我wǒ又yòu弄nòng不bù得de精jīng细xì。只zhǐ是shì悟wù能néng寻xún着zháo他tā窝wō巢cháo,与yǔ他tā打dǎ话huà,想xiǎng是shì不bù曾céng说shuō出chū取qǔ经jīng的de勾gòu当dàng。」菩pú萨sà道dào:「那nà流liú沙shā河hé的de妖yāo怪guài,乃nǎi是shì卷juǎn帘lián大dà将jiàng临lín凡fán,也yě是shì我wǒ劝quàn化huà的de善shàn信xìn,教jiào他tā保bǎo护hù取qǔ经jīng之zhī辈bèi。你nǐ若ruò肯kěn说shuō出chū是shì东dōng土tǔ取qǔ经jīng人rén时shí,他tā决jué不bù与yǔ你nǐ争zhēng持chí,断duàn然rán归guī顺shùn矣yǐ。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài如rú今jīn怯qiè战zhàn,不bù肯kěn上shàng崖yá,只zhǐ在zài水shuǐ里lǐ潜qián踪zōng,如rú何hé得dé他tā归guī顺shùn?我wǒ师shī如rú何hé得dé渡dù弱ruò水shuǐ?」菩pú萨sà即jí唤huàn惠huì岸àn,袖xiù中zhōng取qǔ出chū一yí个gè红hóng葫hú芦lú儿ér,吩fēn咐fu道dào:「你nǐ可kě将jiāng此cǐ葫hú芦lú,同tóng孙sūn悟wù空kōng到dào流liú沙shā河hé水shuǐ面miàn上shàng,只zhǐ叫jiào『悟wù净jìng』,他tā就jiù出chū来lái了le。先xiān要yào引yǐn他tā归guī依yī了le唐táng僧sēng。然rán后hòu把bǎ他tā那nà九jiǔ个gè骷kū髅lóu穿chuān在zài一yí处chù,按àn九jiǔ宫gōng布bù列liè,却què把bǎ这zhè葫hú芦lú安ān在zài当dāng中zhōng,就jiù是shì法fǎ船chuán一yì只zhī,能néng渡dù唐táng僧sēng过guò流liú沙shā河hé界jiè。」


逐句解 Line by line

菩pú薩sà問wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ怎zěn麼me不bù保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,為wèi甚shén事shì又yòu來lái見jiàn我wǒ?」 菩pú萨sà问wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ怎zěn么me不bù保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,为wèi甚shén事shì又yòu来lái见jiàn我wǒ?」

The Bodhisattva asked: 'Why are you not guarding the Tang Monk? On what business have you come to see me again?'

為甚事, 'on what business?' (為 wèi; 甚 is shén, standing for 什麼). Her first words assume he has walked off the job. It is a gentle reproof, and he has to answer it before he can ask for anything.

行xíng者zhě啟qǐ上shàng道dào:「菩pú薩sà,我wǒ師shī父fù前qián在zài高gāo老lǎo莊zhuāng,又yòu收shōu了le一yí個gè徒tú弟dì,喚huàn名míng豬zhū八bā戒jiè, 行xíng者zhě启qǐ上shàng道dào:「菩pú萨sà,我wǒ师shī父fù前qián在zài高gāo老lǎo庄zhuāng,又yòu收shōu了le一yí个gè徒tú弟dì,唤huàn名míng猪zhū八bā戒jiè,

The Pilgrim reported: 'Bodhisattva, at Old Gao's Manor my master took on another disciple, called Zhu Bajie,

高老莊, Old Gao's Manor, is where Bajie was recruited a few chapters back — hired as a farmhand son-in-law, and rather good at the work until his face gave him away. The monkey opens with the company's recent history, the way you would brief a superior before asking a favour.

多duō蒙méng菩pú薩sà又yòu賜cì法fǎ諱huì悟wù能néng。才cái行xíng過guò黃huáng風fēng嶺lǐng,今jīn至zhì八bā百bǎi里lǐ流liú沙shā河hé, 多duō蒙méng菩pú萨sà又yòu赐cì法fǎ讳huì悟wù能néng。才cái行xíng过guò黄huáng风fēng岭lǐng,今jīn至zhì八bā百bǎi里lǐ流liú沙shā河hé,

'and by your grace, Bodhisattva, he was given the religious name Wuneng. We have just passed Yellow Wind Ridge, and now we have reached the eight-hundred-lǐ River of Flowing Sands,

法諱悟能, 'the dharma-name Wuneng' — 'Awakened to Ability' — was Guanyin's own gift (行 xíng). Notice the shape of these names. Wukong, Wuneng, and shortly Wujing: all three begin with the same character, 悟, 'awakened to.' The Bodhisattva names her converts in a matched set, which is a quiet way of telling you that she has been assembling this company on purpose.

乃nǎi是shì弱ruò水shuǐ三sān千qiān,師shī父fù已yǐ是shì難nán渡dù;河hé中zhōng又yòu有yǒu個gè妖yāo怪guài, 乃nǎi是shì弱ruò水shuǐ三sān千qiān,师shī父fù已yǐ是shì难nán渡dù;河hé中zhōng又yòu有yǒu个gè妖yāo怪guài,

'which is three thousand of Weak Water — already too hard for the master to cross; and in the river there is besides a monster,

弱水三千, 'three thousand of Weak Water' — the same figure the stele gave in the opening scene, in lǐ (難 nán, 中 zhōng). The river alone would have stopped them. The demon is an additional problem on top of an already impossible one.

武wǔ藝yì高gāo強qiáng,甚shèn虧kuī了le悟wù能néng與yǔ他tā水shuǐ面miàn上shàng大dà戰zhàn三sān次cì, 武wǔ艺yì高gāo强qiáng,甚shèn亏kuī了le悟wù能néng与yǔ他tā水shuǐ面miàn上shàng大dà战zhàn三sān次cì,

'mighty in the martial arts; it was much thanks to Wuneng that we fought him three times on the water's face,

甚虧了, 'very much thanks to' — here 甚 is shèn, 'greatly,' and 了 is the ordinary toneless le; the two are not a fixed compound. The monkey gives Bajie full credit for the three duels, which is handsome of him, given whose cudgel spoiled two of them.

只zhǐ是shì不bù能néng取qǔ勝shèng,被bèi他tā攔lán阻zǔ,不bù能néng渡dù河hé。 只zhǐ是shì不bù能néng取qǔ胜shèng,被bèi他tā拦lán阻zǔ,不bù能néng渡dù河hé。

'only we could not win, and being barred by him, we cannot cross the river.'

不能取勝, could not take the victory, and 攔阻, blocked. The report ends where the chapter has been stuck for two days.

因yīn此cǐ,特tè告gào菩pú薩sà,望wàng垂chuí憐lián憫mǐn,濟jì渡dù他tā一yí濟jì渡dù。」 因yīn此cǐ,特tè告gào菩pú萨sà,望wàng垂chuí怜lián悯mǐn,济jì渡dù他tā一yí济jì渡dù。」

'And so I come expressly to inform you, Bodhisattva, hoping you will show compassion and help us across.'

望垂憐憫, 'hoping you will bend down your pity' — the verb 垂 is 'to let hang down,' the motion of a superior stooping toward an inferior, and it is the standard verb for divine favour. 濟渡他一濟渡, 'deliver us, do just deliver us across,' doubles the word the way a petition does. Note that 渡 means both to ferry over water and to carry across to salvation; the whole chapter lives in that double sense.

菩pú薩sà道dào:「你nǐ這zhè猴hóu子zi,又yòu逞chěng自zì滿mǎn,不bù肯kěn說shuō出chū保bǎo唐táng僧sēng的de話huà來lái麼me?」 菩pú萨sà道dào:「你nǐ这zhè猴hóu子zi,又yòu逞chěng自zì满mǎn,不bù肯kěn说shuō出chū保bǎo唐táng僧sēng的de话huà来lái么me?」

The Bodhisattva said: 'You monkey, showing off your conceit again — you wouldn't come out and say you were guarding the Tang Monk, would you?'

逞自滿, 'parading your own conceit' (子 the light zi). She is teasing him, and the joke has teeth: she knows exactly who is in that river, and she can see that he has spent two days hitting somebody he could have recruited with one sentence.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ們men只zhǐ是shì要yào拿ná住zhù他tā,教jiào他tā送sòng我wǒ師shī父fù渡dù河hé。水shuǐ裡lǐ事shì,我wǒ又yòu弄nòng不bù得de精jīng細xì。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ们men只zhǐ是shì要yào拿ná住zhù他tā,教jiào他tā送sòng我wǒ师shī父fù渡dù河hé。水shuǐ里lǐ事shì,我wǒ又yòu弄nòng不bù得de精jīng细xì。

The Pilgrim said: 'We only meant to take him and make him ferry my master across. As for doings in the water, I'm not too deft at them.'

弄不得精細, 'can't manage it finely' (得 de, 教 jiào). He owns the water problem again. It is the honest half of the answer, and it is not the half that matters.

只zhǐ是shì悟wù能néng尋xún著zháo他tā窩wō巢cháo,與yǔ他tā打dǎ話huà,想xiǎng是shì不bù曾céng說shuō出chū取qǔ經jīng的de勾gòu當dàng。」 只zhǐ是shì悟wù能néng寻xún着zháo他tā窝wō巢cháo,与yǔ他tā打dǎ话huà,想xiǎng是shì不bù曾céng说shuō出chū取qǔ经jīng的de勾gòu当dàng。」

'It was only Wuneng who found his lair and had words with him; I suppose he never told him about the scripture-quest.'

尋著他窩巢, 'found out his den' (著 zháo, the reading for arriving at a result). And here, without knowing it, the monkey names the actual mistake: Bajie went down, found him, exchanged words with him — and, he supposes, never mentioned the scriptures. He is right, and he has just diagnosed his own chapter.

菩pú薩sà道dào:「那nà流liú沙shā河hé的de妖yāo怪guài,乃nǎi是shì捲juǎn簾lián大dà將jiàng臨lín凡fán, 菩pú萨sà道dào:「那nà流liú沙shā河hé的de妖yāo怪guài,乃nǎi是shì卷juǎn帘lián大dà将jiàng临lín凡fán,

The Bodhisattva said: 'That monster of the Flowing Sands is the Curtain-Raising General come down to the mortal world,

捲簾大將臨凡, 'the Curtain-Raising Grand General come down to the mortal world' (那 nà, 將 jiàng). The reader has known this since the demon sang it himself, down on the river-bed. The pilgrims have not, because nobody was listening.

也yě是shì我wǒ勸quàn化huà的de善shàn信xìn,教jiào他tā保bǎo護hù取qǔ經jīng之zhī輩bèi。 也yě是shì我wǒ劝quàn化huà的de善shàn信xìn,教jiào他tā保bǎo护hù取qǔ经jīng之zhī辈bèi。

'and he too is a convert I won over, whom I bade await and protect the scripture-pilgrims.'

And here is the part nobody could have guessed. 我勸化的善信, 'a devout convert I talked round' (教 jiào) — the demon is not an obstacle placed in the road but a recruit posted at it, told to wait for these very travellers and protect them. He has been on the payroll the whole time.

你nǐ若ruò肯kěn說shuō出chū是shì東dōng土tǔ取qǔ經jīng人rén時shí,他tā決jué不bù與yǔ你nǐ爭zhēng持chí,斷duàn然rán歸guī順shùn矣yǐ。」 你nǐ若ruò肯kěn说shuō出chū是shì东dōng土tǔ取qǔ经jīng人rén时shí,他tā决jué不bù与yǔ你nǐ争zhēng持chí,断duàn然rán归guī顺shùn矣yǐ。」

'If you had only been willing to say you were the scripture-seekers from the Eastern Land, he would never have fought you, but would surely have submitted.'

東土取經人, 'the scripture-seekers from the Eastern Land,' is the password, and it was in their pockets all along. Say it, and the fight never happens. Two days of combat, three rhapsodies and a trip to the Southern Sea, all because nobody thought to introduce themselves.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài如rú今jīn怯qiè戰zhàn,不bù肯kěn上shàng崖yá,只zhǐ在zài水shuǐ裡lǐ潛qián蹤zōng, 行xíng者zhě道dào:「那nà怪guài如rú今jīn怯qiè战zhàn,不bù肯kěn上shàng崖yá,只zhǐ在zài水shuǐ里lǐ潜qián踪zōng,

The Pilgrim said: 'That monster now shrinks from fighting, won't come up on the bank, but only lurks hidden in the water —

怯戰, shy of fighting, and 潛蹤, keeping his tracks hidden (那 nà). The monkey raises the practical snag, and it is a real one: the demon is now too wary to be reached at all, even by someone who only wants to talk.

如rú何hé得dé他tā歸guī順shùn?我wǒ師shī如rú何hé得dé渡dù弱ruò水shuǐ?」 如rú何hé得dé他tā归guī顺shùn?我wǒ师shī如rú何hé得dé渡dù弱ruò水shuǐ?」

'how are we to get him to submit? And how is my master to cross the Weak Water?'

如何得他歸順, 'how are we to get his submission?' — and both instances of 得 here are dé, the modal of managing to bring something off, which is the reading this 如何得 pattern always takes. Two questions: how to win the demon, and how to cross the water. The answer she gives turns out to be one object that solves both.

菩pú薩sà即jí喚huàn惠huì岸àn,袖xiù中zhōng取qǔ出chū一yí個gè紅hóng葫hú蘆lú兒ér,吩fēn咐fu道dào:「你nǐ可kě將jiāng此cǐ葫hú蘆lú, 菩pú萨sà即jí唤huàn惠huì岸àn,袖xiù中zhōng取qǔ出chū一yí个gè红hóng葫hú芦lú儿ér,吩fēn咐fu道dào:「你nǐ可kě将jiāng此cǐ葫hú芦lú,

The Bodhisattva at once summoned Hui'an, took from her sleeve a little red gourd, and instructed him: 'Take this gourd,

惠岸, Hui'an, is the religious name of Mokṣa, Guanyin's disciple — the same envoy who brought Bajie in. Out of her sleeve comes a 紅葫蘆, a little red gourd (中 zhōng, 將 jiāng). Against eight hundred lǐ of water that floats nothing, the remedy is a bottle gourd.

同tóng孫sūn悟wù空kōng到dào流liú沙shā河hé水shuǐ面miàn上shàng,只zhǐ叫jiào『悟wù淨jìng』,他tā就jiù出chū來lái了le。先xiān要yào引yǐn他tā歸guī依yī了le唐táng僧sēng。 同tóng孙sūn悟wù空kōng到dào流liú沙shā河hé水shuǐ面miàn上shàng,只zhǐ叫jiào『悟wù净jìng』,他tā就jiù出chū来lái了le。先xiān要yào引yǐn他tā归guī依yī了le唐táng僧sēng。

'go with Sun Wukong to the surface of the River of Flowing Sands, and just call "Wujing" — he will come out at once. First bring him to take refuge with the Tang Monk;

悟淨, 'Awakened to Purity' — the third of the matched names, and it was assigned before any of this happened. Call it and he will come. Then 歸依, take refuge: the formal act of putting oneself under the protection of the Buddha, the teaching and the community, which is what makes somebody a monk rather than merely a follower. Conversion first, transport second.

然rán後hòu把bǎ他tā那nà九jiǔ個gè骷kū髏lóu穿chuān在zài一yí處chù,按àn九jiǔ宮gōng佈bù列liè,卻què把bǎ這zhè葫hú蘆lú安ān在zài當dāng中zhōng, 然rán后hòu把bǎ他tā那nà九jiǔ个gè骷kū髅lóu穿chuān在zài一yí处chù,按àn九jiǔ宫gōng布bù列liè,却què把bǎ这zhè葫hú芦lú安ān在zài当dāng中zhōng,

'then string his nine skulls together in one place, set them out in the pattern of the Nine Palaces, and put this gourd in the middle —

九個骷髏, the nine skulls (那 nà), strung together and laid out 九宮佈列, in the pattern of the Nine Palaces (中 zhōng) — the three-by-three magic square in which every row, column and diagonal adds to the same total. It is the oldest and most reliable diagram in Chinese cosmology, the grid on which everything from divination to city planning was laid out. The gourd goes in the centre square.

就jiù是shì法fǎ船chuán一yì隻zhī,能néng渡dù唐táng僧sēng過guò流liú沙shā河hé界jiè。」 就jiù是shì法fǎ船chuán一yì只zhī,能néng渡dù唐táng僧sēng过guò流liú沙shā河hé界jiè。」

'and it becomes a dharma-boat, able to ferry the Tang Monk across the bounds of the Flowing Sands.'

法船, a 'dharma-boat.' The image is an old one in Chinese Buddhism — the teaching as the vessel that carries beings over the sea of suffering to the far shore — and here the novel simply builds one. The ornament of horror from the demon's first appearance turns out to be the ferry.


總評 Commentary

At Potalaka the whole design is disclosed, and it turns out nothing has been accidental. The Bodhisattva teases the monkey for fighting where a word would have done: the monster of the Flowing Sands is the Curtain-Raising General come down to earth — the fall he sang himself, and nobody listened — and, more than that, he is her own convert, posted at this river expressly to wait for these travellers and guard them. Two days of battle were a failure of introduction. Had the pilgrims simply named themselves as the seekers 東土取經人, 'from the Eastern Land,' he would have submitted on the spot.

The remedy completes the pattern. She sends Hui'an with a small red gourd and precise instructions: call the demon by his religious name, Wujing; bring him to take refuge; then string his nine skulls into the figure of the Nine Palaces with the gourd at the centre, and the whole thing becomes a dharma-boat. The skulls that hung at his throat from his first appearance, pure horror when we met them, are revealed as the makings of the crossing. The barrier is to be undone not by force but by conversion — and by a vessel assembled out of the barrier itself.