Canonical Classics ← 第二十二回
第二十二回
八bā戒jiè大dà戰zhàn流liú沙shā河hé
木mù叉chā奉fèng法fǎ收shōu悟wù淨jìng

Bajie Does Great Battle at the River of Flowing Sands · Mokṣa, Bearing the Dharma-Command, Wins Over Wujing

再戰無功
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

再戰無功 The Second Stalemate

二èr人rén整zhěng鬥dòu有yǒu兩liǎng個gè時shí辰chén,不bù分fēn勝shèng敗bài。這zhè才cái是shì銅tóng盆pén逢féng鐵tiě帚zhǒu,玉yù磬qìng對duì金jīn鐘zhōng。卻què說shuō那nà大dà聖shèng保bǎo著zhe唐táng僧sēng,立lì於yú左zuǒ右yòu,眼yǎn巴bā巴bā的de望wàng著zhe他tā兩liǎng個gè在zài水shuǐ上shàng爭zhēng持chí,只zhǐ是shì他tā不bù好hǎo動dòng手shǒu。只zhǐ見jiàn那nà八bā戒jiè虛xū幌huǎng一yì鈀pá,佯yáng輸shū詐zhà敗bài,轉zhuǎn回huí頭tóu往wǎng東dōng岸àn上shàng走zǒu。那nà怪guài隨suí後hòu趕gǎn來lái,將jiāng近jìn到dào了le岸àn邊biān。這zhè行xíng者zhě忍rěn耐nài不bú住zhù,撇piē了le師shī父fù,掣chè鐵tiě棒bàng,跳tiào到dào河hé邊biān,望wàng妖yāo精jīng劈pī頭tóu就jiù打dǎ。那nà妖yāo物wù不bù敢gǎn相xiāng迎yíng,颼sōu的de又yòu鑽zuān入rù河hé內nèi。八bā戒jiè嚷rǎng道dào:「你nǐ這zhè弼bì馬mǎ溫wēn,徹chè是shì個gè急jí猴hóu子zi!你nǐ再zài緩huǎn緩huǎn些xiē兒ér,等děng我wǒ哄hǒng他tā到dào了le高gāo處chù,你nǐ卻què阻zǔ住zhù河hé邊biān,教jiào他tā不bù能néng回huí首shǒu啊a,卻què不bù拿ná住zhù他tā也yě?他tā這zhè進jìn去qù,幾jǐ時shí又yòu肯kěn出chū來lái?」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「獃dāi子zi,莫mò嚷rǎng,莫mò嚷rǎng。我wǒ們men且qiě回huí去qù見jiàn師shī父fù去qù來lái。」二èr人rén整zhěng斗dòu有yǒu两liǎng个gè时shí辰chén,不bù分fēn胜shèng败bài。这zhè才cái是shì铜tóng盆pén逢féng铁tiě帚zhǒu,玉yù磬qìng对duì金jīn钟zhōng。却què说shuō那nà大dà圣shèng保bǎo着zhe唐táng僧sēng,立lì于yú左zuǒ右yòu,眼yǎn巴bā巴bā的de望wàng着zhe他tā两liǎng个gè在zài水shuǐ上shàng争zhēng持chí,只zhǐ是shì他tā不bù好hǎo动dòng手shǒu。只zhǐ见jiàn那nà八bā戒jiè虚xū幌huǎng一yì钯pá,佯yáng输shū诈zhà败bài,转zhuǎn回huí头tóu往wǎng东dōng岸àn上shàng走zǒu。那nà怪guài随suí后hòu赶gǎn来lái,将jiāng近jìn到dào了le岸àn边biān。这zhè行xíng者zhě忍rěn耐nài不bú住zhù,撇piē了le师shī父fù,掣chè铁tiě棒bàng,跳tiào到dào河hé边biān,望wàng妖yāo精jīng劈pī头tóu就jiù打dǎ。那nà妖yāo物wù不bù敢gǎn相xiāng迎yíng,飕sōu的de又yòu钻zuān入rù河hé内nèi。八bā戒jiè嚷rǎng道dào:「你nǐ这zhè弼bì马mǎ温wēn,彻chè是shì个gè急jí猴hóu子zi!你nǐ再zài缓huǎn缓huǎn些xiē儿ér,等děng我wǒ哄hǒng他tā到dào了le高gāo处chù,你nǐ却què阻zǔ住zhù河hé边biān,教jiào他tā不bù能néng回huí首shǒu啊a,却què不bù拿ná住zhù他tā也yě?他tā这zhè进jìn去qù,几jǐ时shí又yòu肯kěn出chū来lái?」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「呆dāi子zi,莫mò嚷rǎng,莫mò嚷rǎng。我wǒ们men且qiě回huí去qù见jiàn师shī父fù去qù来lái。」


逐句解 Line by line

二èr人rén整zhěng鬥dòu有yǒu兩liǎng個gè時shí辰chén,不bù分fēn勝shèng敗bài。這zhè才cái是shì銅tóng盆pén逢féng鐵tiě帚zhǒu,玉yù磬qìng對duì金jīn鐘zhōng。 二èr人rén整zhěng斗dòu有yǒu两liǎng个gè时shí辰chén,不bù分fēn胜shèng败bài。这zhè才cái是shì铜tóng盆pén逢féng铁tiě帚zhǒu,玉yù磬qìng对duì金jīn钟zhōng。

The two fought a full two double-hours without either gaining the day. It was, in truth, a bronze basin meeting an iron broom, a jade chime answering a golden bell.

兩個時辰 is two double-hours, about four hours of continuous fighting, and 不分勝敗, nothing to choose between them (分 fēn, to divide, hence to decide). Then two similes with the same shape: 銅盆逢鐵帚, a bronze basin meeting an iron broom, and 玉磬對金鐘, a jade chime answering a golden bell. Both pairs are hard, both are loud, and neither can dent the other.

卻què說shuō那nà大dà聖shèng保bǎo著zhe唐táng僧sēng,立lì於yú左zuǒ右yòu,眼yǎn巴bā巴bā的de望wàng著zhe他tā兩liǎng個gè在zài水shuǐ上shàng爭zhēng持chí, 却què说shuō那nà大dà圣shèng保bǎo着zhe唐táng僧sēng,立lì于yú左zuǒ右yòu,眼yǎn巴bā巴bā的de望wàng着zhe他tā两liǎng个gè在zài水shuǐ上shàng争zhēng持chí,

Now the Great Sage, guarding the Tang Monk and standing close at his side, watched with staring eyes as the two contended upon the water,

保著 … 望著, guarding and watching (著 zhe in both, the marker of an action held). 眼巴巴的 is the phrase for staring with helpless longing — the look of someone shut out of something they badly want. He is not worried about the fight. He wants to be in it.

只zhǐ是shì他tā不bù好hǎo動dòng手shǒu。只zhǐ見jiàn那nà八bā戒jiè虛xū幌huǎng一yì鈀pá,佯yáng輸shū詐zhà敗bài,轉zhuǎn回huí頭tóu往wǎng東dōng岸àn上shàng走zǒu。 只zhǐ是shì他tā不bù好hǎo动dòng手shǒu。只zhǐ见jiàn那nà八bā戒jiè虚xū幌huǎng一yì钯pá,佯yáng输shū诈zhà败bài,转zhuǎn回huí头tóu往wǎng东dōng岸àn上shàng走zǒu。

only he could not well lend a hand. Then he saw Bajie feint with his rake, make a show of losing, turn tail and head for the eastern bank.

虛幌一鈀, a feint with the rake (鈀 pá), and 佯輸詐敗 — four characters that say 'pretending to lose' twice over, once with 佯 and once with 詐, for emphasis. Bajie is executing the plan exactly as given.

那nà怪guài隨suí後hòu趕gǎn來lái,將jiāng近jìn到dào了le岸àn邊biān。 那nà怪guài随suí后hòu赶gǎn来lái,将jiāng近jìn到dào了le岸àn边biān。

The monster came chasing after, and had all but reached the bank,

將近到了岸邊, 'was all but at the bank' (將 jiāng, 'about to'). The bait is working. The demon is four strides from dry land and the monkey is waiting on it.

這zhè行xíng者zhě忍rěn耐nài不bú住zhù,撇piē了le師shī父fù,掣chè鐵tiě棒bàng,跳tiào到dào河hé邊biān,望wàng妖yāo精jīng劈pī頭tóu就jiù打dǎ。 这zhè行xíng者zhě忍rěn耐nài不bú住zhù,撇piē了le师shī父fù,掣chè铁tiě棒bàng,跳tiào到dào河hé边biān,望wàng妖yāo精jīng劈pī头tóu就jiù打dǎ。

when the Pilgrim, unable to hold back, left the master, drew his iron rod, sprang to the riverside, and struck straight down at the monster's head.

忍耐不住: could not hold himself in. The same failing wrecked the first duel, and here it is again, at the exact moment the plan was about to work. He strikes before the demon is clear of the water, which is the one thing that could have spoiled it.

那nà妖yāo物wù不bù敢gǎn相xiāng迎yíng,颼sōu的de又yòu鑽zuān入rù河hé內nèi。 那nà妖yāo物wù不bù敢gǎn相xiāng迎yíng,飕sōu的de又yòu钻zuān入rù河hé内nèi。

The fiend dared not stand and meet him, and with a whoosh dived once more into the river.

不敢相迎, 'dared not close with him' (相 xiāng). 颼的 is the sound of something going fast — a whoosh — and 又鑽入河內, 'bored into the river again.' The word to feel is 又: again. The chapter is now repeating itself on purpose.

八bā戒jiè嚷rǎng道dào:「你nǐ這zhè弼bì馬mǎ溫wēn,徹chè是shì個gè急jí猴hóu子zi!你nǐ再zài緩huǎn緩huǎn些xiē兒ér, 八bā戒jiè嚷rǎng道dào:「你nǐ这zhè弼bì马mǎ温wēn,彻chè是shì个gè急jí猴hóu子zi!你nǐ再zài缓huǎn缓huǎn些xiē儿ér,

Bajie bawled: 'You Ban-Horse-Plague, you're an out-and-out impatient monkey! If you'd only hold off a bit longer,

弼馬溫 is the joke that never dies. When Heaven first wanted to keep Wukong quiet it invented a grand-sounding office for him and gave him the celestial stables. The title has the shape of a real post, but it puns on a phrase meaning 'ward off horse-plague' — which is to say, stable-hand. He was furious when he worked out how junior it was, and it has been a reliable way to needle him ever since. 急猴子, 'hot-headed monkey' (子 the light zi), names the fault precisely.

等děng我wǒ哄hǒng他tā到dào了le高gāo處chù,你nǐ卻què阻zǔ住zhù河hé邊biān,教jiào他tā不bù能néng回huí首shǒu啊a,卻què不bù拿ná住zhù他tā也yě? 等děng我wǒ哄hǒng他tā到dào了le高gāo处chù,你nǐ却què阻zǔ住zhù河hé边biān,教jiào他tā不bù能néng回huí首shǒu啊a,却què不bù拿ná住zhù他tā也yě?

'wait till I've lured him up to high ground, then bar the riverside so he can't turn back — wouldn't we have him then?'

Bajie's correction is the obvious one and it is right: 哄他到了高處, coax him up to high ground first, and only then 阻住河邊, block the bank behind him (教 jiào, the causative). Cut off the retreat before you swing. The monkey will eventually adopt this, one failure later.

他tā這zhè進jìn去qù,幾jǐ時shí又yòu肯kěn出chū來lái?」 他tā这zhè进jìn去qù,几jǐ时shí又yòu肯kěn出chū来lái?」

'Now that he's gone back in, when will he ever be willing to come out again?'

幾時又肯出來, 'when will he ever agree to come out again?' The plainest statement of the trap the pilgrims have built for themselves: every premature blow drives the demon further into the one place they cannot reach him.

行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「獃dāi子zi,莫mò嚷rǎng,莫mò嚷rǎng。我wǒ們men且qiě回huí去qù見jiàn師shī父fù去qù來lái。」 行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「呆dāi子zi,莫mò嚷rǎng,莫mò嚷rǎng。我wǒ们men且qiě回huí去qù见jiàn师shī父fù去qù来lái。」

The Pilgrim said with a laugh: 'Idiot, stop your bawling, stop your bawling. Let's go back and see the master for now.'

獃子, 'Idiot' (子 the light zi), is what the monkey calls Bajie roughly always. 莫嚷, 'stop bawling,' doubled, brushes the whole complaint aside without answering it, and the two go back up the bank with nothing settled.


總評 Commentary

The second duel runs four hours and ends where the first did, in a dead heat rung out on bronze and jade. The interest is less in the fight than in the Great Sage on the bank, reduced again to a spectator staring 眼巴巴的, helplessly, at something he is not allowed to join. And his own plan does begin to work: Bajie feigns defeat and draws the demon almost onto dry land.

Then the same fault undoes it. He cannot hold back, leaves the master, and swings too early — before the demon is clear of the water — so the fiend simply drops away untouched. Bajie's exasperated 急猴子, 'hot-headed monkey,' names the problem, and his proposal to block the bank first names the remedy; the monkey laughs both off. The repetition is deliberate. What keeps this barrier standing is not the demon's strength but the pilgrims' own characters, and a deadlock of that kind can only be broken from outside.