Canonical Classics ← 第二十二回
第二十二回
八bā戒jiè大dà戰zhàn流liú沙shā河hé
木mù叉chā奉fèng法fǎ收shōu悟wù淨jìng

Bajie Does Great Battle at the River of Flowing Sands · Mokṣa, Bearing the Dharma-Command, Wins Over Wujing

八戒回罵再鬥
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

八戒回罵再鬥 Bajie Answers the Fiend

八bā戒jiè聞wén言yán大dà怒nù,罵mà道dào:「你nǐ這zhè潑pō物wù!全quán沒méi一yì些xiē兒ér眼yǎn色sè。我wǒ老lǎo豬zhū還hái掐qiā出chū水shuǐ沫mò兒ér來lái哩li,你nǐ怎zěn敢gǎn說shuō我wǒ粗cū糙cāo,要yào剁duò鮓zhǎ醬jiàng?看kàn起qǐ來lái,你nǐ把bǎ我wǒ認rèn做zuò個gè老lǎo走zǒu硝xiāo哩li。休xiū得dé無wú禮lǐ,吃chī你nǐ祖zǔ宗zōng這zhè一yì鈀pá。」那nà怪guài見jiàn鈀pá來lái,使shǐ一yí個gè「鳳fèng點diǎn頭tóu」躲duǒ過guò。兩liǎng個gè在zài水shuǐ中zhōng打dǎ出chū水shuǐ面miàn,各gè人rén踏tà浪làng登dēng波bō。這zhè一yì場cháng賭dǔ鬥dòu,比bǐ前qián不bù同tóng,你nǐ看kàn那nà:八bā戒jiè闻wén言yán大dà怒nù,骂mà道dào:「你nǐ这zhè泼pō物wù!全quán没méi一yì些xiē儿ér眼yǎn色sè。我wǒ老lǎo猪zhū还hái掐qiā出chū水shuǐ沫mò儿ér来lái哩li,你nǐ怎zěn敢gǎn说shuō我wǒ粗cū糙cāo,要yào剁duò鲊zhǎ酱jiàng?看kàn起qǐ来lái,你nǐ把bǎ我wǒ认rèn做zuò个gè老lǎo走zǒu硝xiāo哩li。休xiū得dé无wú礼lǐ,吃chī你nǐ祖zǔ宗zōng这zhè一yì钯pá。」那nà怪guài见jiàn钯pá来lái,使shǐ一yí个gè「凤fèng点diǎn头tóu」躲duǒ过guò。两liǎng个gè在zài水shuǐ中zhōng打dǎ出chū水shuǐ面miàn,各gè人rén踏tà浪làng登dēng波bō。这zhè一yì场cháng赌dǔ斗dòu,比bǐ前qián不bù同tóng,你nǐ看kàn那nà:

捲juǎn簾lián將jiàng,天tiān蓬péng帥shuài,各gè顯xiǎn神shén通tōng真zhēn可kě愛ài。卷juǎn帘lián将jiàng,天tiān蓬péng帅shuài,各gè显xiǎn神shén通tōng真zhēn可kě爱ài。
那nà個gè降xiáng妖yāo寶bǎo杖zhàng著zháo頭tóu輪lún,這zhè個gè九jiǔ齒chǐ釘dīng鈀pá隨suí手shǒu快kuài。那nà个gè降xiáng妖yāo宝bǎo杖zhàng着zháo头tóu轮lún,这zhè个gè九jiǔ齿chǐ钉dīng钯pá随suí手shǒu快kuài。
躍yuè浪làng振zhèn山shān川chuān,推tuī波bō昏hūn世shì界jiè。跃yuè浪làng振zhèn山shān川chuān,推tuī波bō昏hūn世shì界jiè。
兇xiōng如rú太tài歲suì撞zhuàng幢chuáng幡fān,惡è似sì喪sāng門mén掀xiān寶bǎo蓋gài。凶xiōng如rú太tài岁suì撞zhuàng幢chuáng幡fān,恶è似sì丧sāng门mén掀xiān宝bǎo盖gài。
這zhè一yí個gè赤chì心xīn凜lǐn凜lǐn保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,那nà一yí個gè犯fàn罪zuì滔tāo滔tāo為wéi水shuǐ怪guài。这zhè一yí个gè赤chì心xīn凛lǐn凛lǐn保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,那nà一yí个gè犯fàn罪zuì滔tāo滔tāo为wéi水shuǐ怪guài。
鈀pá抓zhuā一yí下xià九jiǔ條tiáo痕hén,杖zhàng打dǎ之zhī時shí魂hún魄pò敗bài。钯pá抓zhuā一yí下xià九jiǔ条tiáo痕hén,杖zhàng打dǎ之zhī时shí魂hún魄pò败bài。
努nǔ力lì喜xǐ相xiāng持chí,用yòng心xīn要yào賭dǔ賽sài。努nǔ力lì喜xǐ相xiāng持chí,用yòng心xīn要yào赌dǔ赛sài。
算suàn來lái只zhǐ為wèi取qǔ經jīng人rén,怒nù氣qì沖chōng天tiān不bù忍rěn耐nài。算suàn来lái只zhǐ为wèi取qǔ经jīng人rén,怒nù气qì冲chōng天tiān不bù忍rěn耐nài。
攪jiǎo得de那nà鯁gěng鮊bó鯉lǐ鱖guì退tuì鮮xiān鱗lín,龜guī鱉biē黿yuán鼉tuó傷shāng嫩nèn蓋gài;搅jiǎo得de那nà鲠gěng鲌bó鲤lǐ鳜guì退tuì鲜xiān鳞lín,龟guī鳖biē鼋yuán鼍tuó伤shāng嫩nèn盖gài;
紅hóng蝦xiā紫zǐ蟹xiè命mìng皆jiē亡wáng,水shuǐ府fǔ諸zhū神shén朝cháo上shàng拜bài。红hóng虾xiā紫zǐ蟹xiè命mìng皆jiē亡wáng,水shuǐ府fǔ诸zhū神shén朝cháo上shàng拜bài。
只zhǐ聽tīng得dé波bō翻fān浪làng滾gǔn似sì雷léi轟hōng,日rì月yuè無wú光guāng天tiān地dì怪guài。只zhǐ听tīng得dé波bō翻fān浪làng滚gǔn似sì雷léi轰hōng,日rì月yuè无wú光guāng天tiān地dì怪guài。

逐句解 Line by line

八bā戒jiè聞wén言yán大dà怒nù,罵mà道dào:「你nǐ這zhè潑pō物wù!全quán沒méi一yì些xiē兒ér眼yǎn色sè。 八bā戒jiè闻wén言yán大dà怒nù,骂mà道dào:「你nǐ这zhè泼pō物wù!全quán没méi一yì些xiē儿ér眼yǎn色sè。

Bajie, hearing this, flew into a rage and cursed: 'You filthy thing! You've not a scrap of discernment.'

The demon has just sung fifty-two lines about his ruined celestial career, and Bajie has taken in none of it. 潑物, 'filthy thing,' and 沒一些兒眼色, 'not a scrap of eye for things' — meaning no judgement, no ability to read who is standing in front of you. Which, given what he has just failed to hear, is a charge he might have applied to himself.

我wǒ老lǎo豬zhū還hái掐qiā出chū水shuǐ沫mò兒ér來lái哩li,你nǐ怎zěn敢gǎn說shuō我wǒ粗cū糙cāo,要yào剁duò鮓zhǎ醬jiàng? 我wǒ老lǎo猪zhū还hái掐qiā出chū水shuǐ沫mò儿ér来lái哩li,你nǐ怎zěn敢gǎn说shuō我wǒ粗cū糙cāo,要yào剁duò鲊zhǎ酱jiàng?

'Why, old Hog can still wring the water-froth out of himself — how dare you call me coarse and mean to mince me into paste?'

還掐出水沫兒, 'can still have the water-froth pinched out of me' (還 is hái, 'still') — vernacular boasting about being fresh and juicy, the way you would test a piece of meat. And then he throws the demon's own 剁鮓醬, 'chop me into fish-paste,' straight back at him.

看kàn起qǐ來lái,你nǐ把bǎ我wǒ認rèn做zuò個gè老lǎo走zǒu硝xiāo哩li。休xiū得dé無wú禮lǐ,吃chī你nǐ祖zǔ宗zōng這zhè一yì鈀pá。」 看kàn起qǐ来lái,你nǐ把bǎ我wǒ认rèn做zuò个gè老lǎo走zǒu硝xiāo哩li。休xiū得dé无wú礼lǐ,吃chī你nǐ祖zǔ宗zōng这zhè一yì钯pá。」

'It seems you've taken me for some old dried-out hide. Mind your manners — and take this rake from your grandsire!'

老走硝 is abuse for something worn out past use. It comes from the tanning yard: 硝 is the saltpetre that cures a hide, and a hide that has 'walked its saltpetre' has gone stiff and dead. 休得無禮, 'none of your rudeness' — here 得 is dé, the modal 'may not,' the same one as in 不得. Then 這一鈀, 'this rake' (鈀 pá), and the talking is over.

那nà怪guài見jiàn鈀pá來lái,使shǐ一yí個gè「鳳fèng點diǎn頭tóu」躲duǒ過guò。兩liǎng個gè在zài水shuǐ中zhōng打dǎ出chū水shuǐ面miàn, 那nà怪guài见jiàn钯pá来lái,使shǐ一yí个gè「凤fèng点diǎn头tóu」躲duǒ过guò。两liǎng个gè在zài水shuǐ中zhōng打dǎ出chū水shuǐ面miàn,

The monster, seeing the rake come, ducked it with a 'phoenix nodding its head,' and the two, fighting, drove up from the water to its surface,

鳳點頭, 'the phoenix nods its head,' is a named dodge out of the martial repertoire — the sort of thing a Ming reader recognised as a specific move rather than general ducking. 鈀 is pá. The fight then leaves the river-bed (水中, 中 zhōng) and comes up through the surface.

各gè人rén踏tà浪làng登dēng波bō。這zhè一yì場cháng賭dǔ鬥dòu,比bǐ前qián不bù同tóng,你nǐ看kàn那nà: 各gè人rén踏tà浪làng登dēng波bō。这zhè一yì场cháng赌dǔ斗dòu,比bǐ前qián不bù同tóng,你nǐ看kàn那nà:

each treading the billows and mounting the waves. This bout was unlike the last — behold:

踏浪登波, 'treading the billows, mounting the waves' — the second duel is fought standing on the water rather than under it. The tag 你看那, 'now look at that' (那 nà), is the same stage direction as before: prose out, verse in.

捲juǎn簾lián將jiàng,天tiān蓬péng帥shuài,各gè顯xiǎn神shén通tōng真zhēn可kě愛ài。 卷juǎn帘lián将jiàng,天tiān蓬péng帅shuài,各gè显xiǎn神shén通tōng真zhēn可kě爱ài。

The Curtain-Raising General, Marshal Tianpeng — each showed his powers, a marvel to behold.

捲簾將, the Curtain-Raising General (將 jiàng, a rank), and 天蓬帥, Marshal Tianpeng. The second rhapsody opens exactly as the first did — by their old job titles, neither of which either of them still holds.

那nà個gè降xiáng妖yāo寶bǎo杖zhàng著zháo頭tóu輪lún,這zhè個gè九jiǔ齒chǐ釘dīng鈀pá隨suí手shǒu快kuài。 那nà个gè降xiáng妖yāo宝bǎo杖zhàng着zháo头tóu轮lún,这zhè个gè九jiǔ齿chǐ钉dīng钯pá随suí手shǒu快kuài。

That one's demon-quelling staff came whirling down at the head; this one's nine-toothed rake flew quick as the hand could move.

降妖寶杖 (降 xiáng, to subdue) coming down 著頭輪, 'whirling onto the head' — 著 as zháo, the reading for a blow that lands. Against it the nine-toothed 鈀 (pá), quick as the hand. Staff and rake, weighed line for line.

躍yuè浪làng振zhèn山shān川chuān,推tuī波bō昏hūn世shì界jiè。 跃yuè浪làng振zhèn山shān川chuān,推tuī波bō昏hūn世shì界jiè。

Leaping the waves, they shook the hills and streams; heaving the swells, they darkened the very world.

振山川, 'shook the hills and rivers,' and 昏世界, 'darkened the world.' Two men are hitting each other with farm tools and the verse has already reached the scale of geography. The overstatement is not a slip; it is what the form is for.

兇xiōng如rú太tài歲suì撞zhuàng幢chuáng幡fān,惡è似sì喪sāng門mén掀xiān寶bǎo蓋gài。 凶xiōng如rú太tài岁suì撞zhuàng幢chuáng幡fān,恶è似sì丧sāng门mén掀xiān宝bǎo盖gài。

Fierce as the Year-God ramming the banners; grim as the Mourning-Gate lifting the jewelled canopy.

Both similes are drawn from the almanac rather than the bestiary. 太歲 is the Year Star, the deity of the year's ill fortune — still alive in the everyday warning about digging earth on Taisui's head, which is what you are said to be doing when you provoke somebody far above your weight. 喪門, the 'Gate of Mourning,' is another baleful star (似 is sì). The two fighters are being compared to bad dates in the calendar.

這zhè一yí個gè赤chì心xīn凜lǐn凜lǐn保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,那nà一yí個gè犯fàn罪zuì滔tāo滔tāo為wéi水shuǐ怪guài。 这zhè一yí个gè赤chì心xīn凛lǐn凛lǐn保bǎo唐táng僧sēng,那nà一yí个gè犯fàn罪zuì滔tāo滔tāo为wéi水shuǐ怪guài。

This one, red-hearted and stern, guards the Tang Monk; that one, steeped in crime, has become a water-fiend.

The couplet stops describing and starts judging. 赤心凜凜保唐僧, 'red-hearted and stern, he guards the Tang Monk,' set against 犯罪滔滔為水怪, 'crime-sodden, he has become a water-fiend' (為 wéi, to become; 那 nà). The irony is that both of them are convicted criminals of Heaven; only one has been recruited yet.

鈀pá抓zhuā一yí下xià九jiǔ條tiáo痕hén,杖zhàng打dǎ之zhī時shí魂hún魄pò敗bài。 钯pá抓zhuā一yí下xià九jiǔ条tiáo痕hén,杖zhàng打dǎ之zhī时shí魂hún魄pò败bài。

One rake-blow claws nine gashes; when the staff strikes home, the very souls give way.

九條痕, 'nine furrows' — one for each tooth of the rake (鈀 pá). The arithmetic is exact and rather horrible, and it is the sort of detail that keeps these set-pieces from floating off entirely. 魂魄敗, 'the souls routed,' does the same job for the staff.

努nǔ力lì喜xǐ相xiāng持chí,用yòng心xīn要yào賭dǔ賽sài。 努nǔ力lì喜xǐ相xiāng持chí,用yòng心xīn要yào赌dǔ赛sài。

Straining with a will, they grapple with relish; setting their hearts on it, each means to win the match.

喜相持, 'gladly locked together' (相 xiāng), and 要賭賽, 'set on winning the match.' They are, on the evidence, enjoying themselves.

算suàn來lái只zhǐ為wèi取qǔ經jīng人rén,怒nù氣qì沖chōng天tiān不bù忍rěn耐nài。 算suàn来lái只zhǐ为wèi取qǔ经jīng人rén,怒nù气qì冲chōng天tiān不bù忍rěn耐nài。

Reckon it up: it is all for the scripture-seeker's sake that their wrath surges to Heaven past all bearing.

And then the verse remembers why any of this is happening. 只為取經人, 'all for the scripture-seeker's sake' (為 wèi). A quiet, deflating line: strip away the thunder and the cosmic disorder and it is two ex-officers scrapping over whether one frightened monk may cross a river.

攪jiǎo得de那nà鯁gěng鮊bó鯉lǐ鱖guì退tuì鮮xiān鱗lín,龜guī鱉biē黿yuán鼉tuó傷shāng嫩nèn蓋gài; 搅jiǎo得de那nà鲠gěng鲌bó鲤lǐ鳜guì退tuì鲜xiān鳞lín,龟guī鳖biē鼋yuán鼍tuó伤shāng嫩nèn盖gài;

They churn the water till carp and perch shed their bright scales, and turtles and terrapins bruise their tender shells;

攪得那, 'churned it until' (得 de, 那 nà) — and now the damage report from below. 鯁鮊鯉鱖 is four kinds of fish in four characters, and 龜鱉黿鼉 four kinds of shelled and armoured river creature. The line ends on a semicolon and is kept as its own unit.

紅hóng蝦xiā紫zǐ蟹xiè命mìng皆jiē亡wáng,水shuǐ府fǔ諸zhū神shén朝cháo上shàng拜bài。 红hóng虾xiā紫zǐ蟹xiè命mìng皆jiē亡wáng,水shuǐ府fǔ诸zhū神shén朝cháo上shàng拜bài。

red shrimp and purple crabs all lose their lives, and the gods of the water-palace bow upward in dread.

水府諸神朝上拜, 'the gods of the water-mansion bow upward' (朝 cháo). The river has its own court, with its own officials, and they are cowering. The disorder has spread from the fish to the civil service.

只zhǐ聽tīng得dé波bō翻fān浪làng滾gǔn似sì雷léi轟hōng,日rì月yuè無wú光guāng天tiān地dì怪guài。 只zhǐ听tīng得dé波bō翻fān浪làng滚gǔn似sì雷léi轰hōng,日rì月yuè无wú光guāng天tiān地dì怪guài。

One hears only the waves rolling and tumbling like thunder-claps, sun and moon gone lightless, Heaven and Earth aghast.

波翻浪滾似雷轟, waves rolling like thunderclaps (得 de, 似 sì), and then 日月無光: sun and moon put out. The rhapsody ends where these always end, with the sky itself disturbed — and then the prose resumes and nothing whatever has been decided.


總評 Commentary

Bajie's reply to the cannibal song is pure bluster. He calls the demon a filthy thing with no judgement, boasts that old Hog is still fresh enough to have the water pinched out of him, and flings the threat of mincing straight back. What he does not do is answer the song, or notice that the creature opposite him has just described a heavenly career very like his own. The rake restarts the fight, and it comes up out of the depths to the surface.

The rhapsody that follows is the chapter's second formal battle-piece, and it sharpens the moral point the first one raised: 赤心凜凜保唐僧 ('red-hearted, he guards the Tang Monk') against 犯罪滔滔為水怪 ('crime-sodden, he has become a water-fiend'). One couplet names the real stake — 只為取經人, 'all for the scripture-seeker's sake' — and the closing lines widen out to the water-palace gods bowing in terror and the sun and moon going dark. The form takes a stalemated brawl and makes it an image of the whole pilgrimage's contested order.