Canonical Classics ← 第一百回
第一百回
徑jìng回huí東dōng土tǔ
五wǔ聖shèng成chéng真zhēn

Straight Back to the Eastern Land · The Five Saints Attain the True

挑得經擔
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

挑得經擔 Who Is To Carry the Load

大dà聖shèng道dào:「尊zūn者zhě之zhī言yán雖suī當dàng,但dàn吾wú師shī如rú何hé挑tiāo得de經jīng擔dàn?如rú何hé牽qiān得de這zhè馬mǎ?須xū得dé我wǒ等děng同tóng去qù一yí送sòng。煩fán你nǐ在zài空kōng少shǎo等děng,諒liàng不bù敢gǎn誤wù。」大dà圣shèng道dào:「尊zūn者zhě之zhī言yán虽suī当dàng,但dàn吾wú师shī如rú何hé挑tiāo得de经jīng担dàn?如rú何hé牵qiān得de这zhè马mǎ?须xū得dé我wǒ等děng同tóng去qù一yí送sòng。烦fán你nǐ在zài空kōng少shǎo等děng,谅liàng不bù敢gǎn误wù。」


逐句解 Line by line

大dà聖shèng道dào:「尊zūn者zhě之zhī言yán雖suī當dàng,但dàn吾wú師shī如rú何hé挑tiāo得de經jīng擔dàn? 大dà圣shèng道dào:「尊zūn者zhě之zhī言yán虽suī当dàng,但dàn吾wú师shī如rú何hé挑tiāo得de经jīng担dàn?

The Great Sage said, “What the venerable ones say is apt enough — but how is our master to carry the scripture-load?”

雖當 — apt though it is. The last character is read dàng here, meaning fitting or right. Read dāng it means at the time of, a different word entirely. Monkey concedes the point politely and then demolishes it. 挑得 — the second character is the light one that turns a verb into a question of capability: can he manage to carry it? Not dé, to obtain. 經擔, the scripture-load. Its second character is read dàn here — the noun, a shoulder-pole load — not dān, the verb of shouldering. It is the same distinction English keeps between a load and to load, and Chinese keeps it in the tone.

如rú何hé牽qiān得de這zhè馬mǎ? 如rú何hé牵qiān得de这zhè马mǎ?

“How is he to lead this horse?”

The second objection, and it is the same shape as the first: 牽得, can he manage to lead it. Monkey is not arguing about honour or about the end of the journey. He is pointing out that his master cannot carry the luggage.

須xū得dé我wǒ等děng同tóng去qù一yí送sòng。 须xū得dé我wǒ等děng同tóng去qù一yí送sòng。

“We shall have to go along and see him there.”

須得 — it must be had that. Both characters are full verbs: the first means must, the second means to have, and what follows is what must be had, namely the three of them. Chinese in this novel builds the phrase the same way at nine other places in the book, and every one of them puts a thing after it rather than an action. 一送 — see him the one stretch. Monkey asks for the last mile.

煩fán你nǐ在zài空kōng少shǎo等děng,諒liàng不bù敢gǎn誤wù。」 烦fán你nǐ在zài空kōng少shǎo等děng,谅liàng不bù敢gǎn误wù。」

“Trouble yourselves to wait a little in the air; we shall not dare be late.”

煩你 — may I trouble you. Monkey being courteous is rare enough to notice, and he is courteous here because he has just overruled heaven's escort and wants it to go smoothly. 不敢誤, we would not dare be late. He is quoting their own vocabulary back at them: the phrase attached to every order in this book is no failure and no delay.


總評 Commentary

Monkey overrules heaven, and the grounds he chooses are luggage. The venerable ones are quite right, he says, but how is the master to carry the scripture-load, and how is he to lead the horse?

It is the perfect argument because it cannot be answered. The Tang monk has become a buddha, floats in water and suppresses fiends by existing — and he still cannot shoulder a carrying-pole. Nothing about attaining the Way has made him able to manage his own bags.

And notice what Monkey actually asks for. Not glory, not a share of the audience: we shall have to go along and see him there. One stretch of road, on foot, carrying things. After all the flying, the last mile of the greatest journey in Chinese literature is walked because somebody has to hold the horse.