Canonical Classics ← 第三十二回
第三十二回
píngdǐngshāngōngcáochuánxìn
liánhuādòngféngzāi

On Level-Top Mountain the Merit-Officer Brings Word · In the Lotus-Flower Cave the Wood-Mother Meets Disaster

風和尚
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

風和尚 You Crazy Monk

qiáoziwényányǎngtiānxiàodào:「yuánláishìfēngshàng。」xíngzhědào:「fēngazhèshìlǎoshíhuà。」qiáozidào:「shuōshìlǎoshí便biànzěngǎnshuōjièshēn?」xíngzhědào:「zhèděngzhǎngwēifēngyánluàndelánbàoxìnshìyǒuqīnqīnlínlínyǒu。」qiáozixiàodào:「zhèfēngshàngméidàodàoshìhǎoláibàomenjiàomenzǒushízǎowǎnjiānfángbèidàozhuǎnlàizàishēnshàngqiěshuōxiǎodeyāochūchùjiùxiǎodeagǎnzěnmedejièjièwǎngchù?」qiáoziwényányǎngtiānxiàodào:「yuánláishìfēngshàng。」xíngzhědào:「fēngazhèshìlǎoshíhuà。」qiáozidào:「shuōshìlǎoshí便biànzěngǎnshuōjièshēn?」xíngzhědào:「zhèděngzhǎngwēifēngyánluàndelánbàoxìnshìyǒuqīnqīnlínlínyǒu。」qiáozixiàodào:「zhèfēngshàngméidàodàoshìhǎoláibàomenjiàomenzǒushízǎowǎnjiānfángbèidàozhuǎnlàizàishēnshàngqiěshuōxiǎodeyāochūchùjiùxiǎodeagǎnzěnmedejièjièwǎngchù?」


逐句解 Line by line

qiáoziwényányǎngtiānxiàodào:「yuánláishìfēngshàng。」 qiáoziwényányǎngtiānxiàodào:「yuánláishìfēngshàng。」

Hearing this, the woodcutter laughed up at the sky and said: "So you are a crazy monk after all."

仰天大笑, yǎng tiān dà xiào, "threw his head back and roared." 風和尚 is "the mad monk" — in Ming vernacular stands in for , crazy, the two being homophones. Calling someone a 風和尚 is calling him a crackpot in robes.

xíngzhědào:「fēngazhèshìlǎoshíhuà。」 xíngzhědào:「fēngazhèshìlǎoshíhuà。」

Said Pilgrim: "I am not crazy — this is honest talk."

老實話, lǎo shi huà, "honest talk, the plain truth" — still exactly what it means today.

qiáozidào:「shuōshìlǎoshí便biànzěngǎnshuōjièshēn?」 qiáozidào:「shuōshìlǎoshí便biànzěngǎnshuōjièshēn?」

Said the woodcutter: "You call it honest — then how dare you speak of having him escorted off under guard?"

遞解起身, dì jiè qǐ shēn, "to send off under escort," again jiè. The woodcutter has fastened onto the one absurd word in Pilgrim's speech and will not let it go.

xíngzhědào:「zhèděngzhǎngwēifēngyánluàndelánbàoxìnshìyǒuqīn xíngzhědào:「zhèděngzhǎngwēifēngyánluàndelánbàoxìnshìyǒuqīn

Said Pilgrim: "You, puffing up his prestige like this, talking wild nonsense as you block the road to bring word — could it be you are kin to him?

長他那威風, zhǎng tā nà wēi fēng, "to build up his prestige" — read zhǎng, "to increase," the same character as in 長老 but a different job. Pilgrim's counterattack is pure schoolyard: you seem awfully keen to talk him up, are you related? is .

qīnlínlínyǒu。」 qīnlínlínyǒu。」

If not kin, then surely a neighbor; if not a neighbor, then surely a friend."

不親必鄰不鄰必友, bù qīn bì lín, bù lín bì yǒu — "if not family, then a neighbour; if not a neighbour, then a friend." A stock escalating figure, and a piece of rhetoric with no argument in it whatsoever. Pilgrim is needling, not reasoning.

qiáozixiàodào:「zhèfēngshàngméidào qiáozixiàodào:「zhèfēngshàngméidào

The woodcutter laughed: "You crazy, brazen monk — you make no sense at all.

風潑和尚, fēng pō héshang, "mad, brazen monk" — adds insolence to the madness. 忒沒道理, "you make no sense at all."

dàoshìhǎoláibàomenjiàomenzǒushízǎowǎnjiānfángbèidàozhuǎnlàizàishēnshàng dàoshìhǎoláibàomenjiàomenzǒushízǎowǎnjiānfángbèidàozhuǎnlàizàishēnshàng

I, on the contrary, meant well, coming specially to warn you, so that on your road you might be on guard morning and night; and you turn it round and lay the blame on me.

The woodcutter's protest, and the sting is in a single character used twice: , dào, "on the contrary" — I meant well, and you go and turn it round on me. 倒轉 is "to flip a thing over." in 早晚間 is jiān.

qiěshuōxiǎodeyāochūchùjiùxiǎodeagǎnzěnmedejièjièwǎngchù?」 qiěshuōxiǎodeyāochūchùjiùxiǎodeagǎnzěnmedejièjièwǎngchù?」

And say nothing of my not knowing where the fiends come from — even if I did know, how would you dare have him escorted off? Escorted off to where?"

He finishes with the practical objection. 曉得, xiǎo de, "to know" — is the light de, twice over. 遞解 and 解往 both take as jiè. Deport him where, exactly?


總評 Commentary

The woodcutter plays straight man, laughing at Pilgrim as a 風和尚, a crackpot monk, and pressing the obvious objection: deport him how, and to where, when you cannot even find him? Pilgrim declines the question entirely and switches to accusation — anyone this eager to talk up the monsters' reputation must be in with them.

The whole exchange is vernacular banter of a kind the novel does very well, its comedy resting on the collision between an official's earnest warning and a monkey who refuses to take anything at face value. His escalating triad — not family, then a neighbour; not a neighbour, then a friend — is a stock rhetorical shape that sounds like reasoning and is entirely insult.