Canonical Classics ← 第十六回
第十六回
guānyīnyuànsēngmóubǎobèi
hēifēngshānguàiqièjiāshā

At the Guanyin Monastery the Monks Plot for the Treasure · At Black Wind Mountain the Fiend Steals the Cassock

好借好還
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

好借好還 Well Borrowed, Well Returned

quèshuōxíngzhělehuǒzhàojīndǒusòngshàngnántiānménjiāoguǎngtiānwángdào:「xièjièxièjiè。」tiānwángshōuledào:「shèngzhìchénglezhèngchóuhuándebǎobèichùxúntǎoqiějiùsònglái。」xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnshìdāngmiànpiànzhīrénzhèjiàozuòhǎojièhǎohuánzàijiènán』。」tiānwángdào:「jiǔmiànqǐngdàogōngshǎozuòshí?」xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnzàiqiántónglànbǎndènggāotánkuòlùnlejīnbǎotángsēngshēnxiánróngróng。」biézhuìyúnyòujiàntàiyángxīngshàngjìngláidàochántángqiányáoshēnbiànbiànzuòfēngerfēijiāngjìnxiànleběnxiàngkànshíshīháichénshuìliquèshuōxíngzhělehuǒzhàojīndǒusòngshàngnántiānménjiāo广guǎngtiānwángdào:「xièjièxièjiè。」tiānwángshōuledào:「shèngzhìchénglezhèngchóuhuándebǎobèichùxúntǎoqiějiùsònglái。」xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnshìdāngmiànpiànzhīrénzhèjiàozuòhǎojièhǎohuánzàijiènán』。」tiānwángdào:「jiǔmiànqǐngdàogōngshǎozuòshí?」xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnzàiqiántónglànbǎndènggāotánkuòlùnlejīnbǎotángsēngshēnxiánróngróng。」biézhuìyúnyòujiàntàiyángxīngshàngjìngláidàochántángqiányáoshēnbiànbiànzuòfēngerfēijiāngjìnxiànleběnxiàngkànshíshīháichénshuìli


逐句解 Line by line

quèshuōxíngzhělehuǒzhàojīndǒusòngshàngnántiānménjiāoguǎngtiānwángdào:「xièjièxièjiè。」 quèshuōxíngzhělehuǒzhàojīndǒusòngshàngnántiānménjiāo广guǎngtiānwángdào:「xièjièxièjiè。」

Now, the Pilgrim took up the fire-shield and with one somersault sent it back to the Southern Gate of Heaven, handing it to the Broad-Eyed Deva King. "Thanks for the loan, thanks for the loan."

觔斗, the somersault; is dǒu. The shield goes back before the ashes are cold, and the first words he says in Heaven are thanks.

tiānwángshōuledào:「shèngzhìchénglezhèngchóuhuándebǎobèichùxúntǎoqiějiùsònglái。」 tiānwángshōuledào:「shèngzhìchénglezhèngchóuhuándebǎobèichùxúntǎoqiějiùsònglái。」

The Deva King took it back. "The Great Sage is a man of his word. I was just worrying that you would not return my treasure, and that I should have nowhere to go after it — and here you are, bringing it back. I am glad."

不還我的寶貝 is huán, "to give back." The Deva King admits, to his face, that he had expected to be robbed. He is speaking to the creature who once walked off with the Dragon King's cudgel, Laozi's elixir and the peaches of the Queen Mother.

xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnshìdāngmiànpiànzhīrénzhèjiàozuòhǎojièhǎohuánzàijiènán』。」 xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnshìdāngmiànpiànzhīrénzhèjiàozuòhǎojièhǎohuánzàijiènán』。」

The Pilgrim said, "Is old Sun the sort of man who cheats another to his face? This is what they call: borrow well and return well, and borrowing again is easy."

當面騙物 is "to cheat a man of his goods to his face"; is dāng. And then the proverb: 好借好還再借不難, "borrow well and return well, and the next loan comes easy" — a household saying about credit, and still exactly what a Chinese parent tells a child about other people's belongings. is again huán. Wukong keeps a promise about a borrowed thing on the very morning a monk's identical promise has been broken.

tiānwángdào:「jiǔmiànqǐngdàogōngshǎozuòshí?」 tiānwángdào:「jiǔmiànqǐngdàogōngshǎozuòshí?」

The Deva King said, "It is long since I saw you. Come to the palace and sit a while — what do you say?"

許久不面 is "long unseen face to face." 少坐 takes shǎo, "a little while." Heaven would like to entertain him.

xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnzàiqiántónglànbǎndènggāotánkuòlùnlejīnbǎotángsēngshēnxiánróngróng。」 xíngzhědào:「lǎosūnzàiqiántónglànbǎndènggāotánkuòlùnlejīnbǎotángsēngshēnxiánróngróng。」

The Pilgrim said, "Old Sun is not what he was before, sprawling on a broken bench and talking grandly at large. Now I am guarding the Tang monk, and I have no leisure. Another time, another time."

爛板凳高談闊論 — "a broken bench and lofty talk" — is a wonderfully exact image of his old idleness among the gods, the immortal equivalent of holding forth in the pub. 不得身閑 takes . The Great Sage declines a seat in Heaven on the grounds that he has a job.

biézhuìyúnyòujiàntàiyángxīngshàng biézhuìyúnyòujiàntàiyángxīngshàng

He took a hasty leave and dropped down on his cloud; and the sun-star was rising again.

太陽星上: the sun-star rising. The night is over. Only the accounting remains.

jìngláidàochántángqiányáoshēnbiànbiànzuòfēnger jìngláidàochántángqiányáoshēnbiànbiànzuòfēnger

Coming straight before the meditation hall, he shook his body, turned himself into a bee,

蜜蜂兒, with the neutral er. He comes back as he left, by the same transformation — the whole night bracketed, at both ends, by a bee.

fēijiāngjìnxiànleběnxiàngkànshíshīháichénshuìli fēijiāngjìnxiànleběnxiàngkànshíshīháichénshuìli

flew in, resumed his own form, and looked: his master was still fast asleep.

還沉睡哩: is hái, "still." Two hundred men have lost everything they own, a demon has stolen a treasure out of Heaven, a monastery has burned to the ground — and the Tang monk has not woken up. It is the funniest and the bleakest sentence in the chapter.


總評 Commentary

The chapter sets this scene directly against the loan of the cassock, and the parallel is exact enough to be a rebuke. A treasure is borrowed on a promise. It is used. It is returned at once, before anyone asks for it, with thanks — 謝借謝借 — and the lender confesses he had not expected to see it again. 好借好還再借不難: borrow well, return well, and the next loan is easy. In the ruins below, an old monk who said 明早送還老爺西去 is sifting ashes, and the robe he promised to return is on its way to Black Wind Mountain.

And Wukong, of all creatures, is the one who observes the etiquette of borrowing. He declines a seat in Heaven because he has work: 如今保唐僧不得身閑. He remembers what he used to be — 爛板凳高談闊論, sprawled on a broken bench talking grandly — and is no longer. The fillet is doing its work. And yet the shield he returns so scrupulously is the shield he used to make certain a monastery burned, and the Deva King who praises his honesty is the god who told him, laughing, that he raises an unkind heart. Wú Chéng'ēn does not resolve this. He simply lets the sun come up on it, and sends his hero back through a window as a bee, to find his master asleep.