Canonical Classics ← 第十六回
第十六回
guānyīnyuànsēngmóubǎobèi
hēifēngshānguàiqièjiāshā

At the Guanyin Monastery the Monks Plot for the Treasure · At Black Wind Mountain the Fiend Steals the Cassock

拜佛撞鐘
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

拜佛撞鐘 Bowing to the Bodhisattva, Striking the Bell

shàngzhǐtóngsānzàngxíngzhějìnleshānménshānményòujiànzhèng殿diànshàngshūshìguānyīnchányuàn」。sānzàngyòudào:「gǎnshèngēnwèikòuxièjīnchányuànjiùjiànbānshènhǎobàixiè。」shàngwényánmìngdàorénkāile殿diànménqǐngsānzàngcháobàixíngzhěshuānlediūlexíngtóngsānzàngshàng殿diànsānzàngzhǎnbèishūshēnxiōngwàngjīnxiàngkòutóushàng便biànxíngzhějiùzhuàngzhōngsānzàngtáiqiánqīngxīndǎozhùzhùbàishàngzhùlexíngzhěháizhǐguǎnzhuàngzhōngxiēhuòjǐnhuòmànzhuànglejiǔdàoréndào:「bàileháizhuàngzhōngzěnme?」xíngzhěfāngdiūlezhōngchǔxiàodào:「xiǎozhèshìzuòshàngzhuàngzhōngde。」shàngzhǐtóngsānzàngxíngzhějìnleshānménshānményòujiànzhèng殿diànshàngshūshìguānyīnchányuàn」。sānzàngyòudào:「gǎnshèngēnwèikòuxièjīnchányuànjiùjiànbānshènhǎobàixiè。」shàngwényánmìngdàorénkāile殿diànménqǐngsānzàngcháobàixíngzhěshuānlediūlexíngtóngsānzàngshàng殿diànsānzàngzhǎnbèishūshēnxiōngwàngjīnxiàngkòutóushàng便biànxíngzhějiùzhuàngzhōngsānzàngtáiqiánqīngxīndǎozhùzhùbàishàngzhùlexíngzhěháizhǐguǎnzhuàngzhōngxiēhuòjǐnhuòmànzhuànglejiǔdàoréndào:「bàileháizhuàngzhōngzěnme?」xíngzhěfāngdiūlezhōngchǔxiàodào:「xiǎozhèshìzuòshàngzhuàngzhōngde。」


逐句解 Line by line

shàngzhǐtóngsānzàngxíngzhějìnleshānmén shàngzhǐtóngsānzàngxíngzhějìnleshānmén

The monk had no choice but to go in through the mountain gate together with Sanzang and the Pilgrim.

只得 takes . This is the reading Chinese uses for what a speaker can or cannot manage, as against what he chooses — grammarians call it the potential, and the sense here is "could do nothing but." The monk who has just called Wukong a thing must now walk in through his own gate beside him.

shānményòujiànzhèng殿diànshàngshūshìguānyīnchányuàn」。 shānményòujiànzhèng殿diànshàngshūshìguānyīnchányuàn」。

Within the gate they saw, inscribed above the main hall, four great characters: Guanyin Chan Monastery.

上書 is "inscribed above." A 禪院 is a Chan cloister, Chan being the school the Japanese call Zen. The name over the door carries the chapter's whole irony in four characters: this is Guanyin's own house, the Bodhisattva of Compassion's, and it is the house that will plot a murder before the night is out.

sānzàngyòudào:「gǎnshèngēnwèikòuxiè sānzàngyòudào:「gǎnshèngēnwèikòuxiè

Sanzang was greatly pleased. "This disciple has felt the Bodhisattva's holy grace many times over, and has never yet had the chance to knock his head in thanks.

屢感 is "to have received, again and again." Sanzang has good cause to say so: nearly every rescue on the road so far — the golden fillet, the dragon turned into his horse, the guardian spirits riding unseen behind him — has been Guanyin's arrangement.

jīnchányuànjiùjiànbānshènhǎobàixiè。」 jīnchányuànjiùjiànbānshènhǎobàixiè。」

"To come upon this cloister today is as good as beholding the Bodhisattva herself. It is most fitting that I bow my thanks."

一般, "just the same as" ( is bān), collapses the image into the person, which is exactly how a devout man is supposed to read an icon. 甚好 is shèn hǎo, "very good."

shàngwényánmìngdàorénkāile殿diànménqǐngsānzàngcháobài shàngwényánmìngdàorénkāile殿diànménqǐngsānzàngcháobài

Hearing this, the monk at once ordered the lay servant to open the doors of the hall, and invited Sanzang to make his devotions.

道人 looks like "Daoist" and is nothing of the kind: in a Ming monastery it is the lay servant who does the heavy work. The usage is a small reminder of how porous the two clergies were where people actually lived. 朝拜 (cháo bài) is to worship facing the image.

xíngzhěshuānlediūlexíngtóngsānzàngshàng殿diàn xíngzhěshuānlediūlexíngtóngsānzàngshàng殿diàn

The Pilgrim tethered the horse, flung down the baggage, and went up into the hall with Sanzang.

The verbs betray the man. Sanzang is about to lay his whole body on the floor; Wukong (shuān, ties up) the horse and (flings down) the luggage. His reverence, when it arrives, is never fussy — and never quite reverent.

sānzàngzhǎnbèishūshēnxiōngwàngjīnxiàngkòutóu sānzàngzhǎnbèishūshēnxiōngwàngjīnxiàngkòutóu

Sanzang spread out his back and stretched his frame, laid his breast to the ground, and knocked his head before the golden image.

鋪胸納地 is , "to spread out" — describes the full prostration, in which back, breast and forehead all come to the floor together. The four verbs of the line trace the body's entire descent, one joint at a time.

shàng便biànxíngzhějiùzhuàngzhōngsānzàngtáiqiánqīngxīndǎozhù shàng便biànxíngzhějiùzhuàngzhōngsānzàngtáiqiánqīngxīndǎozhù

The monk went to beat the drum. The Pilgrim went straight to strike the bell. Sanzang lay prostrate before the dais and prayed with all his heart.

打鼓 and 撞鐘, beating the drum and striking the bell, are the ritual accompaniment to worship; nobody does this casually. That Wukong seizes the bell unbidden, and that the text gives him 就去, "went straight at it," is the first crack in the decorum. 傾心 is to pour out the heart.

zhùbàishàngzhùlexíngzhěháizhǐguǎnzhuàngzhōngxiēhuòjǐnhuòmànzhuànglejiǔ zhùbàishàngzhùlexíngzhěháizhǐguǎnzhuàngzhōngxiēhuòjǐnhuòmànzhuànglejiǔ

The prayers and prostrations done, the monk stilled his drum; but the Pilgrim only kept on ringing the bell without a pause, now fast, now slow, and rang it a long while.

還只管: is hái, "still," and 只管 is "kept right on regardless." 或緊或慢 — "now tight, now slack" — is the rhythm of somebody having a very good time. The bell that calls an entire monastery to prayer has become a toy.

dàoréndào:「bàileháizhuàngzhōngzěnme?」 dàoréndào:「bàileháizhuàngzhōngzěnme?」

The lay servant said, "The worship is finished. What are you still ringing the bell for?"

The servant's 還撞鐘怎麼 is flat exasperation, again hái. It is a neat piece of stagecraft: the whole house is about to come boiling out, and the text lets one bystander ask the obvious question first.

xíngzhěfāngdiūlezhōngchǔxiàodào:「xiǎozhèshìzuòshàngzhuàngzhōngde。」 xíngzhěfāngdiūlezhōngchǔxiàodào:「xiǎozhèshìzuòshàngzhuàngzhōngde。」

Only then did the Pilgrim let go the bell-hammer. He laughed and said, "How would you know? With me it is a case of: be a monk for a day, ring the bell for a day."

Here is the joke everybody remembers from this scene. 那裡曉得 is , "how would you," and 曉得 takes a neutral de. Then the proverb: 做一日和尚撞一日鐘, "be a monk for a day, ring the bell for a day." It is still in daily use, and it is normally a shrug — what a man says about a job he means to do adequately and not one scrap more, the clock-watcher's motto. Wukong produces it with a completely straight face, having been a monk for rather less than a season.


總評 Commentary

The passage sets two devotions side by side. Sanzang, on learning whose house this is, performs the full prostration — 展背舒身鋪胸納地 — and prays with his whole heart to the Bodhisattva who has been rescuing him since the Double-Fork Ridge. Wukong strikes the bell. Then he goes on striking it, fast and slow, long after the prayer is over, until the entire monastery comes pouring out of its cells. Both are acts of worship in a Guanyin cloister. Only one of them is what the liturgy had in mind.

The joke Wukong makes is better than it first looks. 做一日和尚撞一日鐘 is ordinarily a shrug about doing the bare minimum. In his mouth it turns into something close to a doctrine of the road: he is a monk today, therefore today he rings the bell, and he rings it until the ringing is finished. Wú Chéng'ēn is fond of letting his monkey blunder into orthodoxy by way of insolence. And the noise is not wasted — the bell brings out every monk in the house, which is exactly the introduction the next passage requires, and which no amount of polite knocking would have produced.