Canonical Classics ← 第十六回
第十六回
guānyīnyuànsēngmóubǎobèi
hēifēngshānguàiqièjiāshā

At the Guanyin Monastery the Monks Plot for the Treasure · At Black Wind Mountain the Fiend Steals the Cassock

好火
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

好火 A Fine Fire

xíngzhěleànzheyúntóujìngdàochántángfángshàngzhàozhùletángsēngbáixíngquèhòumiànlǎoshàngzhùdefāngzhàngfángshàngtóuzuòzhebǎojiāshākànxiērénfànghuǒláizhuǎnniǎnjuéniànzhòuwàngxùnshàngkǒuchuījiāngzhènfēnghuǒzhuǎnchuīdehōnghōngluànhǎohuǒhǎohuǒdànjiànxíngzhěleànzheyúntóujìngdàochántángfángshàngzhàozhùletángsēngbáixíngquèhòumiànlǎoshàngzhùdefāngzhàngfángshàngtóuzuòzhebǎojiāshākànxiērénfànghuǒláizhuǎnniǎnjuéniànzhòuwàngxùnshàngkǒuchuījiāngzhènfēnghuǒzhuǎnchuīdehōnghōngluànhǎohuǒhǎohuǒdànjiàn

hēiyānhóngyànténgténghēiyānhóngyànténgténg
hēiyānchángkōngjiàntiānxīnghēiyānchángkōngjiàntiānxīng
hóngyànténgténgyǒuguāngqiānchìhóngyànténgténgyǒuguāngqiānchì
chūshízhuózhuójīnshéchūshízhuózhuójīnshé
hòuláiwēiwēixuèhòuláiwēiwēixuè
nánfāngsānchěngyīngxiónghuí祿shénshīnánfāngsānchěngyīngxiónghuíshénshī
zàogāncháishāolièhuǒxìngshuōshénmesuìrénzuānzàogāncháishāolièhuǒxìngshuōshénmesuìrénzuān
yóuménqiánpiāocǎiyànsàiguòlelǎokāiyóuménqiánpiāocǎiyànsàiguòlelǎokāi
zhèngshìqínghuǒzěnjìnzhèyǒuxíngxiōngzhèngshìqínghuǒzěnjìnzhèyǒuxíngxiōng
zāifǎnxíngzhùnüèzāifǎnxíngzhùnüè
fēngsuíhuǒshìyànfēiyǒuqiānzhànggāofēngsuíhuǒshìyànfēiyǒuqiānzhànggāo
huǒchěngfēngwēihuībèngshàngjiǔxiāoyúnwàihuǒchěngfēngwēihuībèngshàngjiǔxiāoyúnwài
pīngpīngpāngpānghǎo便biàncánniánbàozhúpīngpīngpāngpānghǎo便biàncánniánbàozhú
quèjiùjūnzhōngpàoshēngquèjiùjūnzhōngpàoshēng
shāodedāngchǎngxiàngnéngtáodōngyuànqiélánchùduǒshāodedāngchǎngxiàngnéngtáodōngyuànqiélánchùduǒ
shèngchìáobīngsàiguòēpánggōngnèihuǒshèngchìáobīngsàiguòēpánggōngnèihuǒ

逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěleànzheyúntóujìngdàochántángfángshàngzhàozhùletángsēngbáixíng xíngzhěleànzheyúntóujìngdàochántángfángshàngzhàozhùletángsēngbáixíng

The Pilgrim took it, pressed down his cloud-head, went straight to the roof-ridge of the meditation hall, and covered over the Tang monk with the white horse and the baggage.

按著雲頭 is zhe. The shield goes over the meditation hall: the Tang monk, the dragon-horse, the luggage. Everything Wukong is responsible for, and nothing else at all.

quèhòumiànlǎoshàngzhùdefāngzhàngfángshàngtóuzuòzhebǎojiāshā quèhòumiànlǎoshàngzhùdefāngzhàngfángshàngtóuzuòzhebǎojiāshā

Then he went and sat upon the roof of the abbot's quarters behind, where the old monk lodged, to guard the cassock.

And then he moves. He does not stay above his master; he goes and sits on the roof of the abbot's quarters, because that is where the cassock is. 坐著 takes zhe. Two roofs are guarded tonight, and neither of them is a monk's.

kànxiērénfànghuǒláizhuǎnniǎnjuéniànzhòuwàngxùnshàngkǒuchuījiāng kànxiērénfànghuǒláizhuǎnniǎnjuéniànzhòuwàngxùnshàngkǒuchuījiāng

Watching the men set their fire, he turned, made the magic sign, recited the spell, faced the quarter of Xun, drew in a breath and blew it out;

捻訣念咒 is to make the finger-sign and recite the spell. (xùn) is Wind, ☴ — a trigram, one of the eight three-line figures of the Yijing, the Book of Changes, each of which stands for an element of the world and for a compass direction. So to face the Xun quarter and breathe out is to summon wind by the book. The magic is done in Daoist grammar, on a Buddhist roof, against a Buddhist monastery.

zhènfēnghuǒzhuǎnchuīdehōnghōngluànhǎohuǒhǎohuǒdànjiàn zhènfēnghuǒzhuǎnchuīdehōnghōngluànhǎohuǒhǎohuǒdànjiàn

and a wind rose, and blew that fire until it roared and raged. A fine fire! A fine fire! Behold:

吹得烘烘亂發: is the neutral de, tying the verb to the manner of it. 好火好火! — "A fine fire! A fine fire!" — is the storyteller's own delight, and it is genuinely delight. 但見 then cues the fire-rhapsody, the longest set-piece in the chapter.

hēiyānhóngyànténgténg hēiyānhóngyànténgténg

Black smoke in billows, red flame in surges.

The description opens on the two doubled pairs it will immediately take up one at a time: 漠漠 (spreading, obscuring) for the smoke, 騰騰 (leaping, surging) for the flame.

hēiyānchángkōngjiàntiānxīng hēiyānchángkōngjiàntiānxīng

Black smoke in billows — through the long sky not one star is seen;

長空 takes cháng. The smoke blots out the whole sky — and so there is not a star to be seen anywhere above the monastery of the Bodhisattva.

hóngyànténgténgyǒuguāngqiānchì hóngyànténgténgyǒuguāngqiānchì

red flame in surges — over the wide earth is light, a thousand lǐ of crimson.

And the answering line puts the light where the darkness was: not in heaven but on the earth, and red instead of white. The is left untranslated.

chūshízhuózhuójīnshé chūshízhuózhuójīnshé

At the first, glittering golden serpents;

灼灼金蛇, "glittering golden serpents," are the first darting tongues of flame. is zhuó.

hòuláiwēiwēixuè hòuláiwēiwēixuè

and after, blood-red horses in their fury.

威威血馬 is "blood-horses in their might": the fire has grown from serpent to cavalry in the space of two lines. Note that there is a horse under the shield below.

nánfāngsānchěngyīngxiónghuí祿shénshī nánfāngsānchěngyīngxiónghuíshénshī

The Three Breaths of the South display their prowess; Huilu, the Great Fire God, puts forth his power.

三炁 (sān qì) are the three primal breaths, and the South is the quarter of fire in the scheme of Five Phases — so a southern fire is fire behaving as it ought. 回祿 (Huí lù) is the ancient god of fire, invoked here by name.

zàogāncháishāolièhuǒxìngshuōshénmesuìrénzuān zàogāncháishāolièhuǒxìngshuōshénmesuìrénzuān

Parched firewood burns out the nature of fierce fire — what talk is there now of Suiren drilling wood?

燥乾柴: is gān, dry. 燧人 is Suiren, the culture-hero who first drilled wood to make fire — the Chinese Prometheus. The line waves him away: what need is there of drilling, when the monks have stacked the tinder themselves?

yóuménqiánpiāocǎiyànsàiguòlelǎokāi yóuménqiánpiāocǎiyànsàiguòlelǎokāi

Hot oil before the doors sends coloured flame flying — it outdoes the Patriarch's opened furnace.

老祖開爐 — the "old patriarch" is Laozi, whose Brazier of the Eight Trigrams held Wukong for forty-nine days in chapter seven, and out of which he came with the fire-tempered eyes he still has. He knows this particular furnace from the inside.

zhèngshìqínghuǒzěnjìnzhèyǒuxíngxiōng zhèngshìqínghuǒzěnjìnzhèyǒuxíngxiōng

This is a fire without feeling; how shall it be checked, when the cruelty is by design?

無情火 and 有意行兇 are the couplet's hinge and the moral centre of the whole description: fire is without feeling, but the cruelty here is by design. And the design, as the reader knows and the poem does not say, is now shared between the arsonists and the man on the roof.

zāifǎnxíngzhùnüè zāifǎnxíngzhùnüè

It goes not to quell the calamity, but rather to abet the outrage.

弭災 is to quell a disaster; 助虐 is to abet a tyranny. The subject of both verbs goes unnamed. It is the wind — and it is Wukong, who made the wind.

fēngsuíhuǒshìyànfēiyǒuqiānzhànggāo fēngsuíhuǒshìyànfēiyǒuqiānzhànggāo

The wind follows the fire's force: flame flies a thousand zhàng and more;

(zhàng) is left untranslated; it runs to some ten , so a thousand of them is a flame taller than any building in the empire. Wind and fire now feed one another in strict parallel, each line borrowing the other's force.

huǒchěngfēngwēihuībèngshàngjiǔxiāoyúnwài huǒchěngfēngwēihuībèngshàngjiǔxiāoyúnwài

the fire vaunts the wind's might: ashes are flung to the ninth heaven.

九霄 is the ninth heaven — which is where, a few minutes ago, the shield was borrowed. The ashes of the monastery are being flung up to the very gate Wukong came through.

pīngpīngpāngpānghǎo便biàncánniánbàozhú pīngpīngpāngpānghǎo便biàncánniánbàozhú

Ping, ping, pang, pang — like firecrackers at the year's end;

Noise in the ear and a festival in the mind: 殘年爆竹 is the firecrackers of New Year's Eve. The comparisons in this description grow steadily more human, and steadily more terrible.

quèjiùjūnzhōngpàoshēng quèjiùjūnzhōngpàoshēng

po, po, la, la — like the roar of cannon in an army's midst.

潑潑喇喇 set against 乒乒乓乓 — and now the comparison is not a festival but artillery, 軍中炮聲, the sound of guns in an army. One line, and New Year has become a battlefield.

shāodedāngchǎngxiàngnéngtáodōngyuànqiélánchùduǒ shāodedāngchǎngxiàngnéngtáodōngyuànqiélánchùduǒ

It burns until the Buddha-images on their pedestals can find no escape, and the Sangharama of the eastern cloister has nowhere to hide.

燒得 takes a neutral de. 伽藍 (qié lán) transliterates Sanskrit saṃghārāma and means both the monastery itself and the deity who guards it. So: the images of the Buddha cannot get away, and the guardian spirit of the cloister has nowhere to hide. It is the sharpest line in the whole description.

shèngchìáobīngsàiguòēpánggōngnèihuǒ shèngchìáobīngsàiguòēpánggōngnèihuǒ

It surpasses the night battle in the fire of Red Cliff; it outdoes the flames within the Palace of Epang.

赤壁 is Red Cliff, where Zhou Yu burned Cao Cao's fleet in 208; 阿房宮 is the palace of the First Emperor, fired by Xiang Yu — read Ē páng in the traditional pronunciation. The description ends by measuring a provincial monastery fire against the two most famous conflagrations in Chinese history, and finding it the greater of the three.


總評 Commentary

Before the description begins, four lines of prose settle the chapter's accounts. Wukong puts the shield over the meditation hall — his master, the horse, the luggage — and then climbs onto a different roof, the abbot's, because the cassock is under it. He guards two things and no persons. Then he faces the quarter of , the trigram of Wind, and blows. The gesture is worth pausing over. He does not light the fire, which absolves him in law; and he raises the wind, which does not absolve him at all.

The fire-rhapsody is one of the great set-pieces of the novel, and its architecture is a steady escalation. Smoke and flame; serpents, then cavalry; the god of fire himself; Suiren's fire-drill and Laozi's furnace waved aside as trifles; wind and fire feeding one another; firecrackers, then cannon; and at last Red Cliff and the Palace of Epang, the two fires by which Chinese memory measures every other. Set squarely in the middle of that ascent is the couplet on which the whole chapter turns: 正是那無情火發怎禁這有意行兇 — the fire has no feeling, but the cruelty is intended. The poem does not say by whom, and it does not have to.

The finest stroke comes late. 燒得那當場佛像莫能逃東院伽藍無處躲: the images of the Buddha cannot flee the flames, and the 伽藍 — the guardian spirit in whose keeping the whole compound rests — has nowhere to hide. In a house that has forgotten what a cassock is, the gods themselves are cornered; and the poem is careful to let us hear that they were burned by the wind of a Buddhist pilgrim's disciple.