Canonical Classics ← 第十六回
第十六回
guānyīnyuànsēngmóubǎobèi
hēifēngshānguàiqièjiāshā

At the Guanyin Monastery the Monks Plot for the Treasure · At Black Wind Mountain the Fiend Steals the Cassock

黑風山妖
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

黑風山妖 The Fiend of Black Wind Mountain

huǒzhīshíjīngdòngleshānshòuguàizhèguānyīnyuànzhèngnánèrshíyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòhēifēngshānshānzhōngyǒuhēifēngdòngdòngzhōngyǒuyāojīngzhèngzàishuìxǐngfānshēnzhǐjiànchuāngjiāntòuliàngzhǐdàoshìtiānmíngláikànshíquèshìzhèngběixiàdehuǒguānghuǎngliàngyāojīngjīngdào:「yazhèshìguānyīnyuànshīlehuǒzhèxiēshànghǎoxiǎoxīnkànshíjiùjiùlái。」huǒzhīshíjīngdòngleshānshòuguàizhèguānyīnyuànzhèngnánèrshíyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòhēifēngshānshānzhōngyǒuhēifēngdòngdòngzhōngyǒuyāojīngzhèngzàishuìxǐngfānshēnzhǐjiànchuāngjiāntòuliàngzhǐdàoshìtiānmíngláikànshíquèshìzhèngběixiàdehuǒguānghuǎngliàngyāojīngjīngdào:「yazhèshìguānyīnyuànshīlehuǒzhèxiēshànghǎoxiǎoxīnkànshíjiùjiùlái。」


逐句解 Line by line

huǒzhīshíjīngdòngleshānshòuguài huǒzhīshíjīngdòngleshānshòuguài

It happened that when the fire arose, it startled a beast-spirit of the mountains.

不期 is "not looked for" — the storyteller's way of bringing in a consequence nobody in the scene intended. 獸怪 is a beast that has become a spirit through long practice. He will turn out to be a black bear.

zhèguānyīnyuànzhèngnánèrshíyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòhēifēngshān zhèguānyīnyuànzhèngnánèrshíyuǎnjìnyǒuzuòhēifēngshān

Some twenty lǐ due south of this Guanyin Monastery there stands a Black Wind Mountain,

正南二十里: due south, twenty . The distance is given exactly because it is going to be argued over — Sanzang will object that twenty is too far for anyone to have seen the fire, and Wukong will answer that the light carried two hundred. Worth noting that the prior, when he names the same mountain near the end of the chapter, places it 正東南, south-east. The 世德堂本 says both, and the divergence is left standing here rather than tidied away.

shānzhōngyǒuhēifēngdòngdòngzhōngyǒuyāojīngzhèngzàishuìxǐngfānshēn shānzhōngyǒuhēifēngdòngdòngzhōngyǒuyāojīngzhèngzàishuìxǐngfānshēn

and in the mountain there is a Black Wind Cave, and in the cave a fiend, who was just then waking and turning over.

Mountain, then cave within the mountain, then fiend within the cave: nesting the places one inside another is the standard formula for bringing on a demon, and any reader who has come this far knows exactly what it announces. The chapter title promised him before the first word of the story was told.

zhǐjiànchuāngjiāntòuliàngzhǐdàoshìtiānmíngláikànshíquèshìzhèngběixiàdehuǒguānghuǎngliàng zhǐjiànchuāngjiāntòuliàngzhǐdàoshìtiānmíngláikànshíquèshìzhèngběixiàdehuǒguānghuǎngliàng

He saw a light coming through the window and took it for daybreak. Rising to look, he found it was a glare of fire in the north.

只道是天明: "took it for daybreak." Of every being within twenty of the Guanyin cloister, the one who mistakes the fire for the dawn is the monster.

yāojīngjīngdào:「yazhèshìguānyīnyuànshīlehuǒ yāojīngjīngdào:「yazhèshìguānyīnyuànshīlehuǒ

The fiend started up. "Ah! This must be a fire in the Guanyin Monastery. How careless those monks are!

好不小心 is "how very careless" — the here intensifies rather than negates, a trap for the unwary reader. A demon of Black Wind Mountain is tutting at the fire safety of a Buddhist monastery.

zhèxiēshànghǎoxiǎoxīnkànshíjiùjiùlái。」 zhèxiēshànghǎoxiǎoxīnkànshíjiùjiùlái。」

"I will go and see, and lend them a hand to put it out."

與他救一救來: "I will go and help them save it." He means it, too. The one creature in this chapter who runs toward a burning monastery intending to help is the fiend — and the running is what destroys him.


總評 Commentary

The chapter's second half opens with a joke so quiet it is easy to miss. A monster wakes in a cave, sees the sky red, thinks it is morning, and then works out that the Guanyin Monastery is on fire. His first thought — his immediate, unreflecting thought — is that the monks have been careless and that he had better go and help. 我看時與他救一救來. Two hundred and thirty monks have just tried to burn two men alive for a robe, and the bear-spirit of Black Wind Mountain is putting on his cloud to run to their aid.

The next passage takes the joke back with both hands, and Wú Chéng'ēn plainly intends it to. But the sequence matters. The demon arrives as a neighbour, on good terms with the abbot — the two of them discuss doctrine together, as we learn later — and moved by exactly the reflex the monastery could not manage. He turns thief only once he has seen the cassock. Which is to say he falls in the identical manner, and by the identical light, as the old man who set his own house on fire an hour earlier. The cassock does not sort monks from monsters. It shows each of them what he is, and it does not take long about it.