Canonical Classics ← 第十六回
第十六回
觀guān音yīn院yuàn僧sēng謀móu寶bǎo貝bèi
黑hēi風fēng山shān怪guài竊qiè袈jiā裟shā

At the Guanyin Monastery the Monks Plot for the Treasure · At Black Wind Mountain the Fiend Steals the Cassock

借辟火罩
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

借辟火罩 Borrowing the Fire-Shield

快kuài些xiē拿ná來lái使shǐ使shǐ,即jí刻kè返fǎn上shàng。」天tiān王wáng道dào:「你nǐ差chà了le。既jì是shì歹dǎi人rén放fàng火huǒ,只zhǐ該gāi借jiè水shuǐ救jiù他tā,如rú何hé要yào辟bì火huǒ罩zhào?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ裡lǐ曉xiǎo得dé就jiù裡lǐ。借jiè水shuǐ救jiù之zhī,卻què燒shāo不bù起qǐ來lái,倒dào相xiāng應yìng了le他tā;只zhǐ是shì借jiè此cǐ罩zhào,護hù住zhù了le唐táng僧sēng無wú傷shāng,其qí餘yú管guǎn他tā,盡jìn他tā燒shāo去qù。快kuài些xiē,快kuài些xiē,此cǐ時shí恐kǒng已yǐ無wú及jí,莫mò誤wù了le我wǒ下xià邊biān幹gàn事shì。」那nà天tiān王wáng笑xiào道dào:「這zhè猴hóu子zi還hái是shì這zhè等děng起qǐ不bú善shàn之zhī心xīn,只zhǐ顧gù了le自zì家jiā,就jiù不bù管guǎn別bié人rén。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「快kuài著zhe,快kuài著zhe,莫mò要yào調tiáo嘴zuǐ,害hài了le大dà事shì。」那nà天tiān王wáng不bù敢gǎn不bú借jiè,遂suì將jiāng罩zhào兒ér遞dì與yǔ行xíng者zhě。快kuài些xiē拿ná来lái使shǐ使shǐ,即jí刻kè返fǎn上shàng。」天tiān王wáng道dào:「你nǐ差chà了le。既jì是shì歹dǎi人rén放fàng火huǒ,只zhǐ该gāi借jiè水shuǐ救jiù他tā,如rú何hé要yào辟bì火huǒ罩zhào?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ里lǐ晓xiǎo得dé就jiù里lǐ。借jiè水shuǐ救jiù之zhī,却què烧shāo不bù起qǐ来lái,倒dào相xiāng应yìng了le他tā;只zhǐ是shì借jiè此cǐ罩zhào,护hù住zhù了le唐táng僧sēng无wú伤shāng,其qí余yú管guǎn他tā,尽jìn他tā烧shāo去qù。快kuài些xiē,快kuài些xiē,此cǐ时shí恐kǒng已yǐ无wú及jí,莫mò误wù了le我wǒ下xià边biān干gàn事shì。」那nà天tiān王wáng笑xiào道dào:「这zhè猴hóu子zi还hái是shì这zhè等děng起qǐ不bú善shàn之zhī心xīn,只zhǐ顾gù了le自zì家jiā,就jiù不bù管guǎn别bié人rén。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「快kuài着zhe,快kuài着zhe,莫mò要yào调tiáo嘴zuǐ,害hài了le大dà事shì。」那nà天tiān王wáng不bù敢gǎn不bú借jiè,遂suì将jiāng罩zhào儿ér递dì与yǔ行xíng者zhě。


逐句解 Line by line

快kuài些xiē拿ná來lái使shǐ使shǐ,即jí刻kè返fǎn上shàng。」天tiān王wáng道dào:「你nǐ差chà了le。 快kuài些xiē拿ná来lái使shǐ使shǐ,即jí刻kè返fǎn上shàng。」天tiān王wáng道dào:「你nǐ差chà了le。

"Quick, hand it over and let me use it; I will return it this instant." The Deva King said, "You are mistaken.

你差了: 差 is chà, "in error" — the same reading and very nearly the same rebuke that a young monk delivered to his abbot an hour ago. Heaven and the monastery speak the same idiom. And note the promise Wukong has just made: 即刻返上, "I will send it straight back up." Remember it. He is the only person in this chapter who keeps such a promise.

既jì是shì歹dǎi人rén放fàng火huǒ,只zhǐ該gāi借jiè水shuǐ救jiù他tā,如rú何hé要yào辟bì火huǒ罩zhào?」 既jì是shì歹dǎi人rén放fàng火huǒ,只zhǐ该gāi借jiè水shuǐ救jiù他tā,如rú何hé要yào辟bì火huǒ罩zhào?」

"If villains are setting a fire, you should borrow water to save him. What do you want with a fire-shield?"

The Deva King raises the moral objection without knowing that is what he is doing. Water saves; a shield saves only whatever stands beneath it. He assumes Wukong means to put the fire out. Nobody in Heaven has yet understood what has actually been asked for.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ裡lǐ曉xiǎo得dé就jiù裡lǐ。借jiè水shuǐ救jiù之zhī,卻què燒shāo不bù起qǐ來lái,倒dào相xiāng應yìng了le他tā; 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ那nǎ里lǐ晓xiǎo得dé就jiù里lǐ。借jiè水shuǐ救jiù之zhī,却què烧shāo不bù起qǐ来lái,倒dào相xiāng应yìng了le他tā;

The Pilgrim said, "How should you know the inside of it? Borrow water, save him, and the fire never takes hold — which would only suit them.

那裡 is nǎ, "how would you." 就裡 is the inner truth of a matter, what is really going on. 相應 is xiāng yìng — "it would suit them," meaning it would spare them the loss they had prepared for other people. The reasoning is impeccable, and its unstated premise is that they deserve to lose everything.

只zhǐ是shì借jiè此cǐ罩zhào,護hù住zhù了le唐táng僧sēng無wú傷shāng,其qí餘yú管guǎn他tā,盡jìn他tā燒shāo去qù。 只zhǐ是shì借jiè此cǐ罩zhào,护hù住zhù了le唐táng僧sēng无wú伤shāng,其qí余yú管guǎn他tā,尽jìn他tā烧shāo去qù。

"Lend me this shield instead: it will guard the Tang monk from harm, and as for the rest, let them look to it; let the whole of it burn."

其餘管他 ("as for the rest, let him mind it") and 盡他燒去 ("let it burn to the end"; 盡 is always jìn). Two clauses, and two hundred and thirty men lose their house. The verb Wukong wants is not extinguish but enclose.

快kuài些xiē,快kuài些xiē,此cǐ時shí恐kǒng已yǐ無wú及jí,莫mò誤wù了le我wǒ下xià邊biān幹gàn事shì。」 快kuài些xiē,快kuài些xiē,此cǐ时shí恐kǒng已yǐ无wú及jí,莫mò误wù了le我wǒ下xià边biān干gàn事shì。」

"Quick, quick — I fear it is already too late. Do not make me miss my business down below."

幹事 is "the business to be done." He is being impatient with a god because a fire he intends to feed may burn itself out before he can get down there to feed it.

那nà天tiān王wáng笑xiào道dào:「這zhè猴hóu子zi還hái是shì這zhè等děng起qǐ不bú善shàn之zhī心xīn,只zhǐ顧gù了le自zì家jiā,就jiù不bù管guǎn別bié人rén。」 那nà天tiān王wáng笑xiào道dào:「这zhè猴hóu子zi还hái是shì这zhè等děng起qǐ不bú善shàn之zhī心xīn,只zhǐ顾gù了le自zì家jiā,就jiù不bù管guǎn别bié人rén。」

The Deva King laughed. "This monkey is still the same: he raises an unkind heart, thinks only of his own, and cares nothing for anyone else."

The Deva King's laugh is the novel's verdict, and it is delivered by a bystander with no stake in the matter: 起不善之心 ("raises a heart that is not good"), 只顧了自家,就不管別人 ("looks after his own and lets others be"). It is said lightly, the way old friends tease. It is exactly true. And the shield is lent anyway.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「快kuài著zhe,快kuài著zhe,莫mò要yào調tiáo嘴zuǐ,害hài了le大dà事shì。」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「快kuài着zhe,快kuài着zhe,莫mò要yào调tiáo嘴zuǐ,害hài了le大dà事shì。」

The Pilgrim said, "Hurry, hurry. Don't stand wagging your tongue and ruin a great matter."

快著,快著 — the sentence-final modal 著, read zhe, which turns a word into a nudge. 調嘴 is tiáo zuǐ, to wag the tongue, to bandy words. He is telling a Deva King of Heaven to stop talking.

那nà天tiān王wáng不bù敢gǎn不bú借jiè,遂suì將jiāng罩zhào兒ér遞dì與yǔ行xíng者zhě。 那nà天tiān王wáng不bù敢gǎn不bú借jiè,遂suì将jiāng罩zhào儿ér递dì与yǔ行xíng者zhě。

The Deva King dared not refuse to lend it, and handed the shield over to the Pilgrim.

不敢不借, "dared not not lend it." That double negative is the whole of Heaven's position with respect to this creature. Nobody up here has forgotten chapter five either.


總評 Commentary

This is the most morally exposed conversation in the chapter, and it is conducted entirely in the register of a favour between old acquaintances. The Deva King, hearing of a fire, proposes water. Wukong explains, patiently, that water would ruin everything: 卻燒不起來,倒相應了他 — the fire would fail to catch, and that would suit the arsonists. He wants a shield not because a shield saves more but because a shield saves less. It saves precisely one hall, one horse and one sleeping man, and lets everything else go.

And Heaven lends it. 那天王不敢不借 — "the Deva King dared not not lend it." Before handing it over he pronounces the verdict the narrator never pronounces: 這猴子還是這等起不善之心,只顧了自家,就不管別人. Still the same creature, raising an unkind heart, minding his own and nobody else's. He says it laughing, the way a friend teases a friend. Before long Guanyin herself will say something very like it, and she will not be laughing. Wú Chéng'ēn has arranged the whole episode so that the gods of the celestial bureaucracy are implicated in what follows: they saw what he intended, they named it correctly, and they gave him the equipment.