Canonical Classics ← 第十六回
第十六回
guānyīnyuànsēngmóubǎobèi
hēifēngshānguàiqièjiāshā

At the Guanyin Monastery the Monks Plot for the Treasure · At Black Wind Mountain the Fiend Steals the Cassock

有眼無珠
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

有眼無珠 Eyes without Pupils

jiānyǒuliǎngdǎnliàngdeshàngdào:「lǎomenzàichántángshāolejīnyòuláitǎojiāshāduānháishìrénshìguǐ?」xíngzhěxiàodào:「zhèhuǒnièchùyǒushénmehuǒláiqiánmiànkànkànchántángzàiláishuōhuà。」zhòngsēngmenláiwǎngqiánguānkànchántángwàimiàndeménchuāngshàngèngcéngliáozhuólebànfēnzhòngrénsǒngcáirènsānzàngshìzhǒngshénsēngxíngzhěshìzūnshàngqiánkòutóudào:「děngyǒuyǎnzhūshízhēnrénxiàjièdejiāshāzàihòumiànfāngzhàngzhōnglǎoshīchùli。」sānzàngxíngguòlesāncéngbàiqiángjiētànzhǐjiànfāngzhàngguǒránhuǒzhòngsēngqiǎngmiànjiàodào:「gōnggongtángsēngnǎishìshénrénwèicéngshāojīnfǎnhàilejiādàngchènzǎochūjiāshāhuán。」jiānyǒuliǎngdǎnliàngdeshàngdào:「lǎomenzàichántángshāolejīnyòuláitǎojiāshāduānháishìrénshìguǐ?」xíngzhěxiàodào:「zhèhuǒnièchùyǒushénmehuǒláiqiánmiànkànkànchántángzàiláishuōhuà。」zhòngsēngmenláiwǎngqiánguānkànchántángwàimiàndeménchuāngshàngèngcéngliáozhuólebànfēnzhòngrénsǒngcáirènsānzàngshìzhǒngshénsēngxíngzhěshìzūnshàngqiánkòutóudào:「děngyǒuyǎnzhūshízhēnrénxiàjièdejiāshāzàihòumiànfāngzhàngzhōnglǎoshīchùli。」sānzàngxíngguòlesāncéngbàiqiángjiētànzhǐjiànfāngzhàngguǒránhuǒzhòngsēngqiǎngmiànjiàodào:「gōnggongtángsēngnǎishìshénrénwèicéngshāojīnfǎnhàilejiādàngchènzǎochūjiāshāhuán。」


逐句解 Line by line

jiānyǒuliǎngdǎnliàngdeshàngdào:「lǎomenzàichántángshāole jiānyǒuliǎngdǎnliàngdeshàngdào:「lǎomenzàichántángshāole

Among them were two monks of bolder spirit, who said, "Your Worship, you were burned to death in the meditation hall.

膽量大的 is "the large of gall" — in Chinese physiology courage sits in the gall-bladder, not the heart, which is why a brave man is big-gallbladdered and a coward has none. is liàng, the noun. Only two men out of two hundred and thirty are brave enough to address the thing they take for a ghost.

jīnyòuláitǎojiāshāduānháishìrénshìguǐ?」 jīnyòuláitǎojiāshāduānháishìrénshìguǐ?」

"Now you come again to ask for the cassock. Are you truly a man, or a ghost?"

端的 ("truly, in fact") takes duān dì. 還是人是鬼? — is hái, "after all." Two men have walked unharmed out of a hall that was heaped with firewood and set alight, and the monks want to know whether they are alive or dead. It is a perfectly reasonable question. It is also, of all the questions available to them this morning, the wrong one.

xíngzhěxiàodào:「zhèhuǒnièchùyǒushénmehuǒláiqiánmiànkànkànchántángzàiláishuōhuà。」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「zhèhuǒnièchùyǒushénmehuǒláiqiánmiànkànkànchántángzàiláishuōhuà。」

The Pilgrim laughed. "You pack of sinful brutes! Where has there been any fire? Go and look at the meditation hall in front, and then come back and talk."

孽畜 is "sin-beasts," creatures whose animal birth is the fruit of past evil. And Wukong tells them to go and look — which is the one instruction nobody in this monastery has been capable of following all night.

zhòngsēngmenláiwǎngqiánguānkànchántángwàimiàndeménchuāngshàngèngcéngliáozhuólebànfēn zhòngsēngmenláiwǎngqiánguānkànchántángwàimiàndeménchuāngshàngèngcéngliáozhuólebànfēn

The monks scrambled up and went forward to look. The doors, the windows, the lattice-leaves on the outside of that meditation hall — not half a part of them had been so much as scorched.

槅扇 (gé shàn) are the latticed leaves of a Chinese door, the most burnable thing in any building. 更不曾燎灼了半分: not scorched by half a part. The proof of the miracle is a door-frame — and the shield that saved it was borrowed from Heaven by the creature who then blew the fire the other way.

zhòngrénsǒngcáirènsānzàngshìzhǒngshénsēngxíngzhěshìzūn zhòngrénsǒngcáirènsānzàngshìzhǒngshénsēngxíngzhěshìzūn

The crowd was struck with awe, and knew at last that Sanzang was a monk of the gods, and the Pilgrim a guardian of the Law.

認得 takes a neutral de. 種神僧 is a monk of the divine kind; 尊護法 an honoured Dharma-protector. They arrive at the correct theology by way of an unburnt window.

shàngqiánkòutóudào:「děngyǒuyǎnzhūshízhēnrénxiàjiè shàngqiánkòutóudào:「děngyǒuyǎnzhūshízhēnrénxiàjiè

Together they came forward and knocked their heads. "We have eyes but no pupils in them; we did not know that True Men had come down to the world.

有眼無珠 — "eyes but no pupils in them," blind to what is directly in front of you — is still one of the commonest self-reproaches in Chinese, and it is exactly the right one here. It is the same organ the old monk blamed when he could not see the cassock by lamplight. 真人下界, "Perfected Men come down to the world," is a Daoist formula, used in a Chan monastery, about a Buddhist pilgrim.

dejiāshāzàihòumiànfāngzhàngzhōnglǎoshīchùli。」 dejiāshāzàihòumiànfāngzhàngzhōnglǎoshīchùli。」

"Your cassock is at the back, in the abbot's quarters, with our old Grand Master."

And here is the sentence they have been dreading having to say. 在後面方丈中老師祖處哩 — the cassock is exactly where it has been all night: with the old man, behind the one door in the whole compound that the fire could not reach.

sānzàngxíngguòlesāncéngbàiqiángjiētàn sānzàngxíngguòlesāncéngbàiqiángjiētàn

Sanzang walked through three or four courses of ruined wall and broken brick, sighing without ceasing.

敗壁破牆 is ruined walls and broken brick. 嗟嘆不已 is sighing without end. It is Sanzang's only response to the destruction, and it is more than anyone else in the chapter will offer.

zhǐjiànfāngzhàngguǒránhuǒzhòngsēngqiǎngmiàn zhǐjiànfāngzhàngguǒránhuǒzhòngsēngqiǎngmiàn

He found the abbot's quarters indeed untouched by fire. The monks rushed inside, calling,

搶入裡面 — they rush in, and the verb is the same one used of their snatching at cooking-pots in the ashes an hour ago.

jiàodào:「gōnggongtángsēngnǎishìshénrénwèicéngshāojīnfǎnhàilejiādàng jiàodào:「gōnggongtángsēngnǎishìshénrénwèicéngshāojīnfǎnhàilejiādàng

"Grandfather! The Tang monk is a divine man. He has not burned to death, and now we have destroyed nothing but our own property.

家當 is read jiā dàng, "household property." Listen to the arithmetic: the Tang monk did not burn, therefore we have destroyed nothing but our own goods. Two hundred and thirty men have just discovered that they are not murderers, and are appalled to find that they are merely paupers.

chènzǎochūjiāshāhuán。」 chènzǎochūjiāshāhuán。」

"Bring out the cassock at once, and give it back to him."

還他去也: is huán, give it back. Twelve hours ago it was borrowed for a single night's viewing, on a promise, with the morning named as the hour of return. The monks are now shouting through a door for it, and the man behind the door cannot produce it.


總評 Commentary

The monastery is converted by a window-frame. Told to go and look, the monks find the meditation hall's doors and lattices 更不曾燎灼了半分 — not scorched by half a part — and instantly know what they are dealing with: 三藏是種神僧行者是尊護法, a monk of the gods and a guardian of the Law. It is correct. It is also arrived at by exactly the faculty with which they appraised eight hundred cassocks: they have looked at a surface and priced it. Their confession, 有眼無珠, "eyes with no pupils in them," is truer than they can know — it is the abbot's own excuse, that he could not see the robe by lamplight, promoted into a general condition.

And then the finest line in the passage, shouted through a door: 如今反害了自己家當. "Now we have only destroyed our own property." Not we tried to murder two men. Not we burned a house consecrated to the Bodhisattva of Compassion. 家當 — household goods. The horror they feel is a horror of loss, and it arrives at the precise moment they learn that nobody died. Between them and the Way stands, as it has stood the whole chapter, an inventory.