Canonical Classics ← 第十六回
第十六回
guānyīnyuànsēngmóubǎobèi
hēifēngshānguàiqièjiāshā

At the Guanyin Monastery the Monks Plot for the Treasure · At Black Wind Mountain the Fiend Steals the Cassock

失瞻問訊
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

失瞻問訊 An Exchange at the Gate

sānzàngjiànleshìménpángdàowènxùnshàngliánmángxiàodào:「shīzhān。」wèn:「shìláideqǐngfāngzhàngxiànchá。」sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngqīnchāishàngléiyīnbàiqiújīngzhìchùtiānjiāngwǎnjièshàngchàxiāo。」shàngdào:「qǐngjìnzuòqǐngjìnzuò。」sānzàngfānghuànxíngzhěqiānjìnláishàngjiànxíngzhěxiàngmàoyǒuxiēhài便biànwèn:「qiāndeshìshénmedōng西?」sānzàngdào:「qiāoyánqiāoyándexìngruòtīngjiànshuōshìshénmedōng西jiùnǎoleshìde。」shànglehánjìnyǎozhezhǐtóudào:「zhèbānchǒutóuguàinǎodehǎozhāozuò?」sānzàngdào:「kànchūláilichǒuchǒushènshìyǒuyòng。」sānzàngjiànleshìménpángdàowènxùnshàngliánmángxiàodào:「shīzhān。」wèn:「shìláideqǐngfāngzhàngxiànchá。」sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngqīnchāishàngléiyīnbàiqiújīngzhìchùtiānjiāngwǎnjièshàngchàxiāo。」shàngdào:「qǐngjìnzuòqǐngjìnzuò。」sānzàngfānghuànxíngzhěqiānjìnláishàngjiànxíngzhěxiàngmàoyǒuxiēhài便biànwèn:「qiāndeshìshénmedōng西?」sānzàngdào:「qiāoyánqiāoyándexìngruòtīngjiànshuōshìshénmedōng西jiùnǎoleshìde。」shànglehánjìnyǎozhezhǐtóudào:「zhèbānchǒutóuguàinǎodehǎozhāozuò?」sānzàngdào:「kànchūláilichǒuchǒushènshìyǒuyòng。」


逐句解 Line by line

sānzàngjiànleshìménpángdàowènxùnshàngliánmángxiàodào:「shīzhān。」 sānzàngjiànleshìménpángdàowènxùnshàngliánmángxiàodào:「shīzhān。」

Sanzang, seeing them, stood attentively beside the gate and made his salutation. The monk hastily returned the courtesy and said, smiling, "Forgive me for not having looked up."

問訊 is the Buddhist greeting done properly: palms together, and a spoken question after the other man's welfare. is read páng, "beside." 失瞻 (shī zhān) is a set apology — "I failed to lift my eyes and see you" — and it is worth registering that the very first words anyone in this house speaks are a formula of good manners.

wèn:「shìláideqǐngfāngzhàngxiànchá。」 wèn:「shìláideqǐngfāngzhàngxiànchá。」

He asked, "Where have you come from? Please come into the abbot's quarters and take tea."

那裡 is a question here and reads , "where," not the demonstrative , "there." 方丈 means "ten feet square," and names the abbot's cell after the room of the layman Vimalakīrti, who is said to have fitted a multitude of visiting bodhisattvas into exactly that space. From the room the word slid across to the man, the way "the Crown" comes to mean the monarch.

sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngqīnchāishàngléiyīnbàiqiújīng sānzàngdào:「nǎidōngqīnchāishàngléiyīnbàiqiújīng

Sanzang said, "This disciple is an imperial commissioner from the Land of the East, bound for the Temple of Thunderclap to worship the Buddha and seek the scriptures.

欽差 (qīn chāi) is an officer sent out under imperial commission — is chāi here, not chà. 弟子 (dì zǐ), "disciple," is the humble first person one uses in front of clergy. 雷音寺, Thunderclap Monastery, is the Buddha's seat on Vulture Peak and the end of the whole journey — still a very long way off.

zhìchùtiānjiāngwǎnjièshàngchàxiāo。」 zhìchùtiānjiāngwǎnjièshàngchàxiāo。」

"Arriving here as the light fails, I would beg one night's lodging of your eminent monastery."

將晚: is jiāng, the adverb of "about to," the light on the point of going. 上剎 repeats the honorific from the quatrain, and is again chà. To borrow a night's lodging (一宵) is the ordinary traveller's idiom — and , "to borrow," is the verb this entire chapter turns on. Watch it.

shàngdào:「qǐngjìnzuòqǐngjìnzuò。」sānzàngfānghuànxíngzhěqiānjìnlái shàngdào:「qǐngjìnzuòqǐngjìnzuò。」sānzàngfānghuànxíngzhěqiānjìnlái

"Come in and sit, come in and sit," said the monk. Only then did Sanzang call the Pilgrim to lead the horse in.

, "only then," is doing careful work here. Sanzang waits for the invitation before calling his disciple: courtesy first, and the horse — with the horse's keeper — brought forward only afterwards. He is managing the introduction. The precaution is about to prove entirely insufficient.

shàngjiànxíngzhěxiàngmàoyǒuxiēhài便biànwèn:「qiāndeshìshénmedōng西?」 shàngjiànxíngzhěxiàngmàoyǒuxiēhài便biànwèn:「qiāndeshìshénmedōng西?」

The monk, catching sight of the Pilgrim's face, took some fright and asked, "What kind of thing is that, leading the horse?"

相貌 (xiàng mào) is countenance, and is xiàng. To ask 是個甚麼東西 — "what thing is that?" — is an insult in any register of Chinese, then or now: 東西 is still the word for an object, and calling a person one is still rude. The monk cannot make himself reach for a word that would grant Wukong personhood.

sānzàngdào:「qiāoyánqiāoyándexìngruòtīngjiànshuōshìshénmedōng西jiùnǎoleshìde。」 sānzàngdào:「qiāoyánqiāoyándexìngruòtīngjiànshuōshìshénmedōng西jiùnǎoleshìde。」

Sanzang said, "Softly, softly. His temper is quick, and if he hears you call him a thing, he will take it ill. He is my disciple."

悄言: "speak low." Notice that Sanzang's warning is practical rather than moral, and it is the plainest thing said so far — not do not insult him but he will hear you. 性急 is quick-tempered; is to be provoked.

shànglehánjìnyǎozhezhǐtóudào:「zhèbānchǒutóuguàinǎodehǎozhāozuò?」 shànglehánjìnyǎozhezhǐtóudào:「zhèbānchǒutóuguàinǎodehǎozhāozuò?」

The monk gave a shudder, bit his finger, and said, "And you took on so ugly-headed, so freakish-skulled a creature for a disciple?"

寒噤 (hán jìn) is the shudder that goes through a man at a fright. In 咬著指頭 the particle is zhe: the finger stays between the teeth while he talks, an ongoing state rather than something achieved. 醜頭怪腦 is a colloquial abuse-compound, "ugly of head, monstrous of skull," built on a frame Chinese uses over and over — X-headed, Y-brained — and always for something wrong with a person.

sānzàngdào:「kànchūláilichǒuchǒushènshìyǒuyòng。」 sānzàngdào:「kànchūláilichǒuchǒushènshìyǒuyòng。」

Sanzang said, "You cannot see it. Ugly he is, but he is very useful indeed."

here is the adverb shèn, "very," not the shén of 甚麼. 醜自醜 concedes the entire charge in three characters — "ugly is ugly" — and then walks straight past it. Fifteen chapters have taught Sanzang exactly what his disciple is worth, and he does not spend a word arguing the point that does not matter.


總評 Commentary

Two hundred words of pure courtesy, and the chapter's engine already turning underneath them. The monk at the gate opens with 失瞻, a formal apology for not having looked up, and closes by calling Wukong a thing. Between those two remarks lies the whole distance this house keeps between its manners and its mind. Wú Chéng'ēn stages the meeting as a small comedy of hospitality — bows, tea offered, an invitation repeated twice over — and plays it on a stage the descriptive verses have just finished making suspiciously spotless.

Sanzang's handling of the insult repays attention. He does not rebuke the monk; he warns him. 悄言悄言speak low — is the caution of a man who has travelled with this disciple long enough to know that Wukong's dignity is a hazard to bystanders rather than a principle worth defending. And when he does defend him, it is on grounds of usefulness: 醜自醜甚是有用, "ugly he is, but very useful." That is the pilgrim's honest estimate at this stage of the road, and everything that comes later can be measured against it. Hold onto the monk's shudder and bitten finger as well: fear of the ugly is the first appetite this monastery displays, and it is by a long way not the worst.