Canonical Classics ← 第十回
第十回
lǎolóngwángzhuōfàntiāntiáo
wèichéngxiàngshūtuōmíng

The Old Dragon King's Foolish Scheme Transgresses the Statutes of Heaven · Minister Wei's Bequeathed Letter Is Entrusted to an Officer of the Dead

夢中斬龍
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

夢中斬龍 Wei Zheng Dozes at the Board

jūnchénliǎngduìzhèngxiàdàoshísānpáncánwèizhōngwèizhēngránzàiànbiānhānhāndǔnshuìtàizōngxiàoyuē:「xiánqīngzhēnshìkuāngshèzhīxīnláochuàngjiāngshānzhījuànsuǒjuédǔnshuì。」tàizōngrènshuìzháogènghuànduōshíwèizhēngxǐngláizàidào:「chéngāiwànchéngāiwànquècáijuànkùnzhīsuǒwéiwàngxiàshèchénmànjūnzhīzuì。」tàizōngdào:「qīngyǒumànzuìqiělái退tuìcánqīngcóngxīngèngzhāo。」jūnchénliǎngduìzhèngxiàdàoshísānpáncánwèizhōngwèizhēngránzàiànbiānhānhāndǔnshuìtàizōngxiàoyuē:「xiánqīngzhēnshìkuāngshèzhīxīnláochuàngjiāngshānzhījuànsuǒjuédǔnshuì。」tàizōngrènshuìzháogènghuànduōshíwèizhēngxǐngláizàidào:「chéngāiwànchéngāiwànquècáijuànkùnzhīsuǒwéiwàngxiàshèchénmànjūnzhīzuì。」tàizōngdào:「qīngyǒumànzuìqiělái退tuìcánqīngcóngxīngèngzhāo。」


逐句解 Line by line

jūnchénliǎngduìzhèngxiàdàoshísānpáncánwèizhōngwèizhēngránzàiànbiānhānhāndǔnshuì jūnchénliǎngduìzhèngxiàdàoshísānpáncánwèizhōngwèizhēngránzàiànbiānhānhāndǔnshuì

Ruler and minister played on together, and just as the game reached the third quarter of the hour of wu, with the board's endgame still unfinished, Wei Zheng suddenly slumped forward at the edge of the desk, snoring in a doze.

The clock strikes and the minister falls asleep. 午時三刻, the third quarter of the noon double-hour, is the exact moment appointed for the dragon's execution; 殘局 is the endgame, the board left unfinished; 鼾鼾盹睡 is snoring in a doze; 對弈 is to play against each other. Everything the chapter has been building toward happens inside that snore.

tàizōngxiàoyuē:「xiánqīngzhēnshìkuāngshèzhīxīnláochuàngjiāngshānzhījuànsuǒjuédǔnshuì。」 tàizōngxiàoyuē:「xiánqīngzhēnshìkuāngshèzhīxīnláochuàngjiāngshānzhījuànsuǒjuédǔnshuì。」

Taizong said with a smile: 'My worthy minister is truly worn in heart from upholding the altars of the realm, and spent in strength from founding its rivers and hills — no wonder he has unknowingly dozed off.'

匡扶社稷, sustaining the altars of soil and grain, and 創立江山, founding the rivers and mountains, are lofty ways of describing a lifetime of service to the state. The emperor deploys them to excuse a nap. He reads the sleep as honest exhaustion and never suspects the errand it is on.

tàizōngrènshuìzháogènghuàn tàizōngrènshuìzháogènghuàn

Taizong let him sleep and did not call him.

in 睡著, 'to be asleep,' is zháo, and in 更不, 'and did not even,' is gèng. Here is the hinge of the entire plot, and it is an act of kindness: the emperor lets his tired minister sleep on. That is precisely what allows the execution to proceed.

duōshíwèizhēngxǐngláizàidào:「chéngāiwànchéngāiwànquècáijuànkùnzhīsuǒwéiwàngxiàshèchénmànjūnzhīzuì。」 duōshíwèizhēngxǐngláizàidào:「chéngāiwànchéngāiwànquècáijuànkùnzhīsuǒwéiwàngxiàshèchénmànjūnzhīzuì。」

Before long Wei Zheng awoke and, prostrating himself on the ground, said: 'Your servant deserves ten thousand deaths, ten thousand deaths! Just now I was overcome with weariness and knew not what I did — I beg Your Majesty to pardon my discourtesy to my lord.'

慢君之罪 is the crime of slighting one's sovereign, and in 不知所為, 'knew not what I was doing,' is wéi. Read the apology closely. He grovels about the nap and says nothing whatever about what he did during it.

tàizōngdào:「qīngyǒumànzuìqiělái退tuìcánqīngcóngxīngèngzhāo。」 tàizōngdào:「qīngyǒumànzuìqiělái退tuìcánqīngcóngxīngèngzhāo。」

Taizong said: 'What discourtesy is there in you? Get up; let us sweep away the unfinished game and play afresh, you and I.'

拂退殘棋 is to brush aside an unfinished game; is gèng, 'anew,' and in 更著, 'to play again,' is zhāo, a go move. The emperor is all graciousness, and has no idea that the game he is sweeping away has just cost a life.


總評 Commentary

The execution happens in a gap in the narrative. The two play on until the stroke of the appointed hour, and 魏徵 — his waking body seated at the emperor's own desk, under the emperor's own eye — simply nods off over the unfinished board. Taizong, reading the sleep as the honest fatigue of a hard-working minister, generously leaves him undisturbed; and it is exactly this kindness that lets the dream-execution run its course. The dragon's death is never shown. It takes place offstage, in the mind of a sleeping man, in the space of a doze.

The terrible irony is that every party is doing precisely the thing that dooms the dragon. The emperor keeps his minister close and awake in order to save it, then lets him sleep out of compassion. The minister, apologizing abjectly for the rudeness of dozing, has in that very doze carried out the beheading, and says nothing of it. Taizong's closing invitation to sweep away the unfinished game and play afresh is quietly devastating: the game is over, and its real stakes were never on the board. The passages ahead will show the severed head falling out of the sky, and the emperor's promise of rescue turning to horror.