Canonical Classics ← 第三十七回
第三十七回
guǐwángtángsānzàng
kōngshénhuàyǐnyīngér

The Ghost-King Visits Tang Tripitaka by Night · Wukong, by Divine Transformation, Leads the Infant

辨個真假
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

辨個真假 To Sort the True from the False

xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiāoshuōleláituōmèngfēnmíngshìzhàolǎosūnchángshēngránshìyāoguàizàicuànwèimóuguóděngbiànzhēnjiǎxiǎngyāogùndàochùchénggōng。」sānzàngdào:「shuōguàishéntōngguǎngli。」xíngzhědào:「shénmeguǎngzǎozhīlǎosūndàojiàozǒufāng。」sānzàngdào:「yòuliúxiàjiànbǎobèizuòbiǎo。」jièdào:「shīyàochánzuòmèng便biànlezěnmezhǐguǎndàngzhēn?」shāsēngdào:「『xìnzhízhōngzhífángrénrén。』menhuǒkāileménkànkàn便biànshì。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiāoshuōleláituōmèngfēnmíngshìzhàolǎosūnchángshēngránshìyāoguàizàicuànwèimóuguóděngbiànzhēnjiǎxiǎngyāogùndàochùchénggōng。」sānzàngdào:「shuōguàishéntōng广guǎngli。」xíngzhědào:「shénme广guǎngzǎozhīlǎosūndàojiàozǒufāng。」sānzàngdào:「yòuliúxiàjiànbǎobèizuòbiǎo。」jièdào:「shīyàochánzuòmèng便biànlezěnmezhǐguǎndàngzhēn?」shāsēngdào:「『xìnzhízhōngzhífángrénrén。』menhuǒkāileménkànkàn便biànshì。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiāoshuōleláituōmèngfēnmíngshìzhàolǎosūnchángshēng xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiāoshuōleláituōmèngfēnmíngshìzhàolǎosūnchángshēng

Pilgrim laughed and said, “No need to say more — his coming to lodge a dream with you is plainly a piece of business thrown old Sun’s way.

Wukong reframes a murdered king's plea as an opportunity, and does it in commercial language: 一場生意, a piece of trade thrown his way. Demon-catching is his line of business and someone has just put work on the table. 託夢 is to send a dream to someone; 分明 is "plainly." (In 一場生意 the is cháng, the measure word for an occasion or a bout — the sealed note gave chǎng, which belongs to as a physical place.)

ránshìyāoguàizàicuànwèimóuguóděngbiànzhēnjiǎ ránshìyāoguàizàicuànwèimóuguóděngbiànzhēnjiǎ

Surely it is some fiend there, usurping the throne and seizing the state; let me sort out for him the true from the false.

And the job is defined in four characters that could stand as the chapter's title: 辨個真假, sort out the true from the false. 篡位謀國 is to usurp the throne and scheme for the state; 那裡 here is nà lǐ, "there," the pointing use.

xiǎngyāogùndàochùchénggōng。」 xiǎngyāogùndàochùchénggōng。」

I fancy that where old Sun’s cudgel reaches that fiend, the work will be done and the deed accomplished.”

The method, stated with total confidence: apply cudgel, collect merit. 棍到處 is "wherever the cudgel arrives"; 立業成功 is to get the job done; is the pointing .

sānzàngdào:「shuōguàishéntōngguǎngli。」 sānzàngdào:「shuōguàishéntōng广guǎngli。」

Tripitaka said, “Disciple, he says that fiend’s powers are vast.”

Tripitaka relays the warning he was given. 神通廣大 shén tōng guǎng dà — vast supernatural powers — is said of this fiend four times across the chapter, by the ghost, by Tripitaka twice, and finally by Wukong himself. 那怪 takes the pointing .

xíngzhědào:「shénmeguǎng xíngzhědào:「shénme广guǎng

Pilgrim said, “What do I care how vast his powers?

Wukong is unimpressed, as a matter of principle. 甚麼 has as shén.

zǎozhīlǎosūndàojiàozǒufāng。」 zǎozhīlǎosūndàojiàozǒufāng。」

Let him but learn old Sun has come, and I will make him bolt with nowhere to run.”

走無方 — flee with no direction left to flee in. 教他 has as jiào, the causative: make him.

sānzàngdào:「yòuliúxiàjiànbǎobèizuòbiǎo。」 sānzàngdào:「yòuliúxiàjiànbǎobèizuòbiǎo。」

Tripitaka said, “And I recall, too, that he left a treasure behind as a token.”

The detail that will decide the argument, remembered almost as an afterthought. 表記 is the proof-token; 記得 has as .

jièdào:「shīyàochánzuòmèng便biànlezěnmezhǐguǎndàngzhēn?」 jièdào:「shīyàochánzuòmèng便biànlezěnmezhǐguǎndàngzhēn?」

Bajie answered, “Master, do not talk nonsense; it was only a dream and there is an end of it — why keep taking it for real?”

Bajie's contribution is flat scepticism, and on any ordinary night he would be right. 胡纏 is to babble; 當真 has as dàng, to treat as, not dāng.

shāsēngdào:「『xìnzhízhōngzhífángrénrén。』 shāsēngdào:「『xìnzhízhōngzhífángrénrén。』

Sha Seng said, “‘Trust not the straight within the straight; be wary of the kindly-that-is-unkind.’

Sha Seng, who speaks least, quotes a proverb: 不信直中直 / 須防仁不仁 — do not trust the straight within the straight, beware the kindness that is not kind. It is a warning against taking appearances at face value, which in a chapter about a flawless impersonation is almost too apt. The edition sets it inside its own citation brackets 『』, which is how the printer marks a quotation — and why the line carries no verse flag whatever its shape. 直中直 takes the locative zhōng.

menhuǒkāileménkànkàn便biànshì。」 menhuǒkāileménkànkàn便biànshì。」

Let us strike a light, open the door, and take a look — that will settle it.”

And the sensible proposal that ends the debate: go and look. 打起火 is to strike a light; 開了門 takes the completive le.


總評 Commentary

Wukong translates a ghost's petition into his own idiom — "a piece of business thrown old Sun's way" — and waves off the fiend's much-advertised powers with the swagger that is his default setting. The comedy of treating demon-catching as a trade sits oddly and deliberately against the gravity of what he has just agreed to do.

The three disciples' voices calibrate the scene neatly: Wukong eager, Bajie flatly unconvinced, Sha Seng cautious and given to proverbs — and his proverb, against trusting what looks straight, could serve as an epigraph for the whole chapter. The decision to go outside and check turns the argument from a dream into a matter of evidence, and the evidence is lying on the step.