Canonical Classics ← 第三十七回
第三十七回
guǐwángtángsānzàng
kōngshénhuàyǐnyīngér

The Ghost-King Visits Tang Tripitaka by Night · Wukong, by Divine Transformation, Leads the Infant

屏退左右
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

屏退左右 Dismissing the Attendants

xíngzhěwényánshěnxiàojuétàizàiwènzhǐshìshěnxiàotàidào:「zhèdāngyányánzhèděngshěnxiào?」xíngzhěyòudào:「háiyǒuduōhuàlinàizuǒyòurénzhòngshìshuōchù。」tàijiànyányǒuyīnjiāngpáoxiùzhǎnjiàojūnshìqiě退tuìjiàshàngguānjiàngchuánlìngjiāngsānqiānréndōuchūménwàizhùzhāshí殿diànshàngréntàizuòzàishàngmiànzhǎnglǎozàiqiánbiānzuǒshǒupángzhexíngzhěběnzhūsēngjiē退tuìxíngzhěcáizhèngshàngqiándào:「殿diànxiàhuàfēngdeshìshēngshēnzhījiànzuòwèideshìzhīquánzhēn。」xíngzhěwényánshěnxiàojuétàizàiwènzhǐshìshěnxiàotàidào:「zhèdāngyányánzhèděngshěnxiào?」xíngzhěyòudào:「háiyǒuduōhuàlinàizuǒyòurénzhòngshìshuōchù。」tàijiànyányǒuyīnjiāngpáoxiùzhǎnjiàojūnshìqiě退tuìjiàshàngguānjiàngchuánlìngjiāngsānqiānréndōuchūménwàizhùzhāshí殿diànshàngréntàizuòzàishàngmiànzhǎnglǎozàiqiánbiānzuǒshǒupángzhexíngzhěběnzhūsēngjiē退tuìxíngzhěcáizhèngshàngqiándào:「殿diànxiàhuàfēngdeshìshēngshēnzhījiànzuòwèideshìzhīquánzhēn。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhěwényánshěnxiàojué xíngzhěwényánshěnxiàojué

Hearing this, Pilgrim smiled a mocking smile without cease.

Wukong's response to all that certainty is to laugh, and keep laughing. 哂笑 shěn xiào is a derisive smile, not a friendly one; 不絕 is without stopping.

tàizàiwènzhǐshìshěnxiào tàizàiwènzhǐshìshěnxiào

The prince asked again, but he gave no answer, only smiling on.

The silence is tactical. He has nothing more to say in front of an audience, and he wants the prince to notice.

tàidào:「zhèdāngyányánzhèděngshěnxiào?」 tàidào:「zhèdāngyányánzhèděngshěnxiào?」

The prince said angrily, “This fellow — when he should speak, he speaks not; why does he smile so?”

It works. 當言不言 — when he ought to speak he does not — with as dāng, ought. Being smiled at is more provoking than being contradicted.

xíngzhěyòudào:「háiyǒuduōhuàlinàizuǒyòurénzhòngshìshuōchù。」 xíngzhěyòudào:「háiyǒuduōhuàlinàizuǒyòurénzhòngshìshuōchù。」

Pilgrim said again, “There is yet much to tell, but with so many attendants to left and right, this is no place to speak.”

And the real reason surfaces: too many ears. 不是說處 is "no place for speaking"; 奈何 is "but what can one do"; 還有 has as hái.

tàijiànyányǒuyīnjiāngpáoxiùzhǎnjiàojūnshìqiě退tuì tàijiànyányǒuyīnjiāngpáoxiùzhǎnjiàojūnshìqiě退tuì

The prince, seeing there was ground to his words, gave a wave of his robe-sleeve and bade the soldiers withdraw.

One flick of a sleeve, and three thousand men leave. 言語有因 is "there is ground to his words" — the boy has decided the monkey is worth hearing. 將袍袖一展 has as jiāng; 教軍士 has as jiào, the causative.

jiàshàngguānjiàngchuánlìngjiāngsānqiānréndōuchūménwàizhùzhā jiàshàngguānjiàngchuánlìngjiāngsānqiānréndōuchūménwàizhùzhā

The officers of the escort quickly passed the order, and took the three thousand horse and men all out beyond the gate to encamp.

The escort camps outside the gate — which will matter shortly, when the prince has to slip back into the city without them. 官將 has standing alone as jiàng, an officer, while 將三千 in the same line is as jiāng, taking the three thousand: the same character twice in one sentence, two different words. is dōu; is the pointing .

shí殿diànshàngréntàizuòzàishàngmiànzhǎnglǎozàiqiánbiānzuǒshǒupángzhexíngzhě shí殿diànshàngréntàizuòzàishàngmiànzhǎnglǎozàiqiánbiānzuǒshǒupángzhexíngzhě

Now, with none upon the hall, the prince sat above, the elder stood before, and at his left hand stood Pilgrim beside him.

The staging is deliberate and worth picturing: prince seated above, monk standing below, monkey at his left hand. An audience chamber with three people in it. 傍立著 has as páng, alongside, and as zhe; 長老 takes as zhǎng; 太子 keeps as . (The sealed note glossed this as bàng in passing while ruling it páng in the same breath; páng is the reading.)

běnzhūsēngjiē退tuì běnzhūsēngjiē退tuì

The monks of the monastery had all withdrawn.

Even the monastery's own monks are gone. The room is finally empty enough for the truth.

xíngzhěcáizhèngshàngqiándào:「殿diànxiàhuàfēngdeshìshēngshēnzhī xíngzhěcáizhèngshàngqiándào:「殿diànxiàhuàfēngdeshìshēngshēnzhī

Only then did Pilgrim, with a grave face, step forward and say, “Your Highness, the one who went off upon the wind was the father who begot you;

And he says it, without any of the performance. 正色 is to compose the face into gravity — the physical opposite of the smirking he was doing a moment ago. Note the wording: 生身之父母 uses the two-character word for both parents where only the father can be meant, a looseness the edition prints and the translation resolves. 化風去的 — "the one who went off on the wind" — is the prince's own phrase, handed back to him with its meaning reversed.

jiànzuòwèideshìzhīquánzhēn。」 jiànzuòwèideshìzhīquánzhēn。」

and the one you see upon the throne is that rain-praying Quanzhen adept.”

Seven characters to finish the reversal: the man on the throne is the rain-praying adept. 那祈雨之全真 takes the pointing .


總評 Commentary

Wukong's mocking silence is a manoeuvre. By refusing to speak in front of the crowd he forces the prince to clear the hall, and three thousand men go out to camp beyond the gate. The boy is now isolated — which is precisely what the fiend once did to his father, and what the fiend has been doing to him for three years.

In the emptied hall, with the prince seated above and monk and monkey standing before him, Wukong finally drops the levity and states the chapter's hidden fact in two clauses: the one blown away on the wind was your father, and the one on the throne is the adept. The long stratagem — dream, tablet, casket, rabbit, arrest — existed to make those two sentences sayable to this one listener.