Canonical Classics ← 第三十七回
第三十七回
鬼guǐ王wáng夜yè謁yè唐táng三sān藏zàng
悟wù空kōng神shén化huà引yǐn嬰yīng兒ér

The Ghost-King Visits Tang Tripitaka by Night · Wukong, by Divine Transformation, Leads the Infant

立帝知情
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

立帝知情 The Oracle Knows All

人rén只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān地dì蓋gài載zài,日rì月yuè照zhào臨lín,國guó王wáng水shuǐ土tǔ,那nǎ得dé個gè父fù母mǔ養yǎng育yù來lái?」太tài子zǐ怒nù道dào:「和hé尚shàng是shì那nà遊yóu手shǒu遊yóu食shí削xuē髮fà逆nì君jūn之zhī徒tú!人rén不bù得dé父fù母mǔ養yǎng育yù,身shēn從cóng何hé來lái?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「殿diàn下xià,貧pín僧sēng不bù知zhī。但dàn只zhǐ這zhè紅hóng匣xiá內nèi有yǒu一yí件jiàn寶bǎo貝bèi,叫jiào做zuò立lì帝dì貨huò,他tā上shàng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,中zhōng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,下xià知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,共gòng知zhī一yì千qiān五wǔ百bǎi年nián過guò去qù未wèi來lái之zhī事shì,便biàn知zhī無wú父fù母mǔ養yǎng育yù之zhī恩ēn,令lìng貧pín僧sēng在zài此cǐ久jiǔ等děng多duō時shí矣yǐ。」人rén只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān地dì盖gài载zài,日rì月yuè照zhào临lín,国guó王wáng水shuǐ土tǔ,那nǎ得dé个gè父fù母mǔ养yǎng育yù来lái?」太tài子zǐ怒nù道dào:「和hé尚shàng是shì那nà游yóu手shǒu游yóu食shí削xuē发fà逆nì君jūn之zhī徒tú!人rén不bù得dé父fù母mǔ养yǎng育yù,身shēn从cóng何hé来lái?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「殿diàn下xià,贫pín僧sēng不bù知zhī。但dàn只zhǐ这zhè红hóng匣xiá内nèi有yǒu一yí件jiàn宝bǎo贝bèi,叫jiào做zuò立lì帝dì货huò,他tā上shàng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,中zhōng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,下xià知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,共gòng知zhī一yì千qiān五wǔ百bǎi年nián过guò去qù未wèi来lái之zhī事shì,便biàn知zhī无wú父fù母mǔ养yǎng育yù之zhī恩ēn,令lìng贫pín僧sēng在zài此cǐ久jiǔ等děng多duō时shí矣yǐ。」


逐句解 Line by line

人rén只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān地dì蓋gài載zài,日rì月yuè照zhào臨lín,國guó王wáng水shuǐ土tǔ,那nǎ得dé個gè父fù母mǔ養yǎng育yù來lái?」 人rén只zhǐ有yǒu天tiān地dì盖gài载zài,日rì月yuè照zhào临lín,国guó王wáng水shuǐ土tǔ,那nǎ得dé个gè父fù母mǔ养yǎng育yù来lái?」

A man has only heaven and earth to cover and sustain him, sun and moon to shine upon him, the king’s land and water — whence should he get a father and mother to rear him?”

And there is the heresy, stated baldly: three kindnesses, not four, because nobody has parents. Coming from a monk — a man who left his family — it is calculated to enrage. 那得個 is rhetorical, "where would he get one," with 那 as nǎ and 得 as dé; 蓋載 keeps 載 as zài.

太tài子zǐ怒nù道dào:「和hé尚shàng是shì那nà遊yóu手shǒu遊yóu食shí削xuē髮fà逆nì君jūn之zhī徒tú! 太tài子zǐ怒nù道dào:「和hé尚shàng是shì那nà游yóu手shǒu游yóu食shí削xuē发fà逆nì君jūn之zhī徒tú!

The prince said angrily, “You, monk, are one of those idle-handed, idle-eating, head-shaving, sovereign-defying sorts!

It works, and the abuse that comes back is the standard Confucian case against Buddhism, compressed into a single breath: monks are idle-handed and idle-eating (they do no work and beg their food), they shave their heads (mutilating the body their parents gave them), and they defy the sovereign (owing allegiance to a foreign order). 削髮 is to take the tonsure; 逆君 is to defy the ruler; 那 is the pointing nà, "those sorts."

人rén不bù得dé父fù母mǔ養yǎng育yù,身shēn從cóng何hé來lái?」 人rén不bù得dé父fù母mǔ养yǎng育yù,身shēn从cóng何hé来lái?」

If a man got no rearing from father and mother, whence should his body come?”

And the unanswerable retort, which is also the exact question Tripitaka wanted asked: if there were no parents, where did your body come from? 不得 has 得 as dé.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「殿diàn下xià,貧pín僧sēng不bù知zhī。 三sān藏zàng道dào:「殿diàn下xià,贫pín僧sēng不bù知zhī。

Tripitaka said, “Your Highness, this poor monk does not know.

The monk immediately disclaims all knowledge, having produced the question he wanted. 不知 — "this poor monk does not know."

但dàn只zhǐ這zhè紅hóng匣xiá內nèi有yǒu一yí件jiàn寶bǎo貝bèi,叫jiào做zuò立lì帝dì貨huò,他tā上shàng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,中zhōng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,下xià知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,共gòng知zhī一yì千qiān五wǔ百bǎi年nián過guò去qù未wèi來lái之zhī事shì,便biàn知zhī無wú父fù母mǔ養yǎng育yù之zhī恩ēn,令lìng貧pín僧sēng在zài此cǐ久jiǔ等děng多duō時shí矣yǐ。」 但dàn只zhǐ这zhè红hóng匣xiá内nèi有yǒu一yí件jiàn宝bǎo贝bèi,叫jiào做zuò立lì帝dì货huò,他tā上shàng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,中zhōng知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,下xià知zhī五wǔ百bǎi年nián,共gòng知zhī一yì千qiān五wǔ百bǎi年nián过guò去qù未wèi来lái之zhī事shì,便biàn知zhī无wú父fù母mǔ养yǎng育yù之zhī恩ēn,令lìng贫pín僧sēng在zài此cǐ久jiǔ等děng多duō时shí矣yǐ。」

But within this red casket is a treasure called Establish-the-Emperor Ware; it knows five hundred years above, five hundred years between, and five hundred years below — one thousand five hundred years of things past and to come; it will know whether there be no kindness of parents’ rearing, and has kept this poor monk here waiting a long while.”

The device is produced on cue: a thing in a box that can settle the matter. Note that Tripitaka gives the fifteen hundred years in the order up-middle-down, where Wukong rehearsed him in up-down-middle — either a nervous man garbling his script or the printer's own slip, preserved as it stands. 立帝貨 is the oracle-name; 中知五百年 takes the locative zhōng.


總評 Commentary

Tripitaka springs the heresy in full — that a man has no parents to thank at all — and it provokes exactly what it was meant to. The prince's abuse is not random: idle-handed, idle-eating, head-shaving, sovereign-defying is the classic Confucian indictment of the monastic life, and a boy raised by court academicians would have it by heart. His closing question is unanswerable and entirely sincere: if not from parents, then where did I come from?

Which is precisely the question the monk wanted on the table. Having driven the argument to the edge of the buried subject, he produces the oracle in the casket, "Establish-the-Emperor Ware," a thing that knows fifteen hundred years and can therefore settle the question of parentage. The doctrinal quarrel has been steered, step by careful step, to the threshold of the revelation.