Canonical Classics ← 第三十七回
第三十七回
鬼guǐ王wáng夜yè謁yè唐táng三sān藏zàng
悟wù空kōng神shén化huà引yǐn嬰yīng兒ér

The Ghost-King Visits Tang Tripitaka by Night · Wukong, by Divine Transformation, Leads the Infant

袈裟有詩
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition 含詞賦 With rhapsody

袈裟有詩 The Cassock Bears a Verse

那nà太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ是shì那nǎ方fāng來lái的de,使shǐ這zhè般bān隱yǐn身shēn法fǎ欺qī我wǒ?」三sān藏zàng上shàng前qián施shī禮lǐ道dào:「貧pín僧sēng無wú隱yǐn身shēn法fǎ,乃nǎi是shì東dōng土tǔ唐táng僧sēng,上shàng雷léi音yīn寺sì拜bài佛fó求qiú經jīng進jìn寶bǎo的de和hé尚shàng。」太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà東dōng土tǔ雖suī是shì中zhōng原yuán,其qí窮qióng無wú比bǐ,有yǒu甚shén寶bǎo貝bèi,你nǐ說shuō來lái我wǒ聽tīng。」三sān藏zàng道dào:「我wǒ身shēn上shàng穿chuān的de這zhè袈jiā裟shā,是shì第dì三sān樣yàng寶bǎo貝bèi。還hái有yǒu第dì一yī等děng、第dì二èr等děng更gèng好hǎo的de物wù哩li。」太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà衣yī服fú,半bàn邊biān苫shān身shēn,半bàn邊biān露lù臂bì,能néng值zhí多duō少shǎo物wù,敢gǎn稱chēng寶bǎo貝bèi?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「這zhè袈jiā裟shā雖suī不bù全quán體tǐ,有yǒu詩shī幾jǐ句jù。詩shī曰yuē:那nà太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ是shì那nǎ方fāng来lái的de,使shǐ这zhè般bān隐yǐn身shēn法fǎ欺qī我wǒ?」三sān藏zàng上shàng前qián施shī礼lǐ道dào:「贫pín僧sēng无wú隐yǐn身shēn法fǎ,乃nǎi是shì东dōng土tǔ唐táng僧sēng,上shàng雷léi音yīn寺sì拜bài佛fó求qiú经jīng进jìn宝bǎo的de和hé尚shàng。」太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà东dōng土tǔ虽suī是shì中zhōng原yuán,其qí穷qióng无wú比bǐ,有yǒu甚shén宝bǎo贝bèi,你nǐ说shuō来lái我wǒ听tīng。」三sān藏zàng道dào:「我wǒ身shēn上shàng穿chuān的de这zhè袈jiā裟shā,是shì第dì三sān样yàng宝bǎo贝bèi。还hái有yǒu第dì一yī等děng、第dì二èr等děng更gèng好hǎo的de物wù哩li。」太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà衣yī服fú,半bàn边biān苫shān身shēn,半bàn边biān露lù臂bì,能néng值zhí多duō少shǎo物wù,敢gǎn称chēng宝bǎo贝bèi?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「这zhè袈jiā裟shā虽suī不bù全quán体tǐ,有yǒu诗shī几jǐ句jù。诗shī曰yuē:

佛fó衣yī偏piān袒tǎn不bù須xū論lùn,內nèi隱yǐn真zhēn如rú脫tuō世shì塵chén。佛fó衣yī偏piān袒tǎn不bù须xū论lùn,内nèi隐yǐn真zhēn如rú脱tuō世shì尘chén。
萬wàn線xiàn千qiān針zhēn成chéng正zhèng果guǒ,九jiǔ珠zhū八bā寶bǎo合hé元yuán神shén。万wàn线xiàn千qiān针zhēn成chéng正zhèng果guǒ,九jiǔ珠zhū八bā宝bǎo合hé元yuán神shén。
仙xiān娥é聖shèng女nǚ恭gōng修xiū製zhì,遺yí賜cì禪chán僧sēng靜jìng垢gòu身shēn。仙xiān娥é圣shèng女nǚ恭gōng修xiū制zhì,遗yí赐cì禅chán僧sēng静jìng垢gòu身shēn。
見jiàn駕jià不bù迎yíng猶yóu自zì可kě,你nǐ的de父fù冤yuān未wèi報bào枉wǎng為wéi人rén。」见jiàn驾jià不bù迎yíng犹yóu自zì可kě,你nǐ的de父fù冤yuān未wèi报bào枉wǎng为wéi人rén。」

逐句解 Line by line

那nà太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ是shì那nǎ方fāng來lái的de,使shǐ這zhè般bān隱yǐn身shēn法fǎ欺qī我wǒ?」 那nà太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ是shì那nǎ方fāng来lái的de,使shǐ这zhè般bān隐yǐn身shēn法fǎ欺qī我wǒ?」

That prince said, “From what quarter do you come, that you use such a hiding-spell to make sport of me?”

His first theory is that he is being conjured at. 隱身法 is a vanishing-spell — reasonable, given a rabbit that turned into an arrow. 那方 has 那 as the question word nǎ, "which quarter"; 那太子 in the same line has the same character as the pointing nà. Two words, one shape — Ming printing had not yet split off 哪.

三sān藏zàng上shàng前qián施shī禮lǐ道dào:「貧pín僧sēng無wú隱yǐn身shēn法fǎ,乃nǎi是shì東dōng土tǔ唐táng僧sēng,上shàng雷léi音yīn寺sì拜bài佛fó求qiú經jīng進jìn寶bǎo的de和hé尚shàng。」 三sān藏zàng上shàng前qián施shī礼lǐ道dào:「贫pín僧sēng无wú隐yǐn身shēn法fǎ,乃nǎi是shì东dōng土tǔ唐táng僧sēng,上shàng雷léi音yīn寺sì拜bài佛fó求qiú经jīng进jìn宝bǎo的de和hé尚shàng。」

Tripitaka came forward, made his bow, and said, “This poor monk has no hiding-spell; I am the Tang Monk of the Eastern Land, a monk going up to Thunderclap Monastery to worship the Buddha, seek the scriptures, and present treasures.”

Tripitaka finally stands up and behaves, and gives the full credentials. 貧僧 pín sēng, "this poor monk," is the standard humble self-reference of a cleric — the monastic answer to the king's 寡人 earlier. 佛 is always fó.

太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà東dōng土tǔ雖suī是shì中zhōng原yuán,其qí窮qióng無wú比bǐ,有yǒu甚shén寶bǎo貝bèi,你nǐ說shuō來lái我wǒ聽tīng。」 太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà东dōng土tǔ虽suī是shì中zhōng原yuán,其qí穷qióng无wú比bǐ,有yǒu甚shén宝bǎo贝bèi,你nǐ说shuō来lái我wǒ听tīng。」

The prince said, “Though your Eastern Land is the Central Plain, its poverty is beyond compare; what treasures have you? Tell me and let me hear.”

The prince's snobbery is geographical and rather good: your Central Plain may be the centre of the world, but it is famously poor. Then the fatal question — what treasures? — which is the one Wukong scripted for him two passages ago, almost word for word. 中原 takes the locative zhōng; 有甚 has 甚 as shén; 那東土 takes the pointing nà.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「我wǒ身shēn上shàng穿chuān的de這zhè袈jiā裟shā,是shì第dì三sān樣yàng寶bǎo貝bèi。 三sān藏zàng道dào:「我wǒ身shēn上shàng穿chuān的de这zhè袈jiā裟shā,是shì第dì三sān样yàng宝bǎo贝bèi。

Tripitaka said, “This cassock I wear upon my body is a treasure of the third kind.

And the pitch begins, exactly as rehearsed. 袈裟 jiā shā transcribes the Sanskrit kāṣāya, the monastic robe — literally "dyed off-colour," since the cloth was deliberately stained to something no layman would wear.

還hái有yǒu第dì一yī等děng、第dì二èr等děng更gèng好hǎo的de物wù哩li。」 还hái有yǒu第dì一yī等děng、第dì二èr等děng更gèng好hǎo的de物wù哩li。」

There are yet finer things of the first grade and the second.”

The hook, delivered on cue. 第一等 keeps 一 as yī, the ordinal; 還有 has 還 as hái.

太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà衣yī服fú,半bàn邊biān苫shān身shēn,半bàn邊biān露lù臂bì,能néng值zhí多duō少shǎo物wù,敢gǎn稱chēng寶bǎo貝bèi?」 太tài子zǐ道dào:「你nǐ那nà衣yī服fú,半bàn边biān苫shān身shēn,半bàn边biān露lù臂bì,能néng值zhí多duō少shǎo物wù,敢gǎn称chēng宝bǎo贝bèi?」

The prince said, “That garment of yours, covering half the body and baring half the arm — how much can it be worth, that you dare call it a treasure?”

The prince declines to be impressed, and his objection is a good one: half the garment is missing. 苫身 is to cover the body; 露臂 is to bare the arm; 那衣服 takes the pointing nà.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「這zhè袈jiā裟shā雖suī不bù全quán體tǐ,有yǒu詩shī幾jǐ句jù。 三sān藏zàng道dào:「这zhè袈jiā裟shā虽suī不bù全quán体tǐ,有yǒu诗shī几jǐ句jù。

Tripitaka said, “Though this cassock does not clothe the whole body, there are some lines of verse upon it.

So Tripitaka answers the objection with a poem — the standard move when a Chinese narrative wants to raise the stakes on an object. 不全體 is "does not clothe the whole body."

詩shī曰yuē: 诗shī曰yuē:

The verse says:

詩曰 — "the verse says." The plainest of the verse cues.

佛fó衣yī偏piān袒tǎn不bù須xū論lùn,內nèi隱yǐn真zhēn如rú脫tuō世shì塵chén。 佛fó衣yī偏piān袒tǎn不bù须xū论lùn,内nèi隐yǐn真zhēn如rú脱tuō世shì尘chén。

The Buddha-robe, bared at one shoulder, needs no debate; within it hides the True Suchness, freed from worldly dust.

The poem answers the prince's mockery head-on: the bared shoulder is not a defect but the correct way to wear the robe. 偏袒 piān tǎn is that bared right shoulder, a mark of respect in Indian and Buddhist practice. 真如 zhēn rú is Suchness, the Sanskrit tathatā — reality just as it is, hidden inside the cloth, which is the whole argument. 佛 is always fó.

萬wàn線xiàn千qiān針zhēn成chéng正zhèng果guǒ,九jiǔ珠zhū八bā寶bǎo合hé元yuán神shén。 万wàn线xiàn千qiān针zhēn成chéng正zhèng果guǒ,九jiǔ珠zhū八bā宝bǎo合hé元yuán神shén。

Ten thousand threads and a thousand stitches make the true fruit; nine pearls and eight jewels join the primal spirit.

The needlework becomes soteriology. 正果 is the true fruit, the goal of practice; 元神 is the primal spirit, a term borrowed from Daoist inner alchemy — the poem is quietly mixing its vocabularies, which the novel does constantly.

仙xiān娥é聖shèng女nǚ恭gōng修xiū製zhì,遺yí賜cì禪chán僧sēng靜jìng垢gòu身shēn。 仙xiān娥é圣shèng女nǚ恭gōng修xiū制zhì,遗yí赐cì禅chán僧sēng静jìng垢gòu身shēn。

Immortal maids and holy women reverently wrought it, bestowed on the Chan monk to still and cleanse his body.

Its makers are named: immortal maidens sewed it. 仙娥 are immortal maids; 遺賜 is to bestow; 靜垢身 is to still and cleanse a body that is by nature defiled.

見jiàn駕jià不bù迎yíng猶yóu自zì可kě,你nǐ的de父fù冤yuān未wèi報bào枉wǎng為wéi人rén。」 见jiàn驾jià不bù迎yíng犹yóu自zì可kě,你nǐ的de父fù冤yuān未wèi报bào枉wǎng为wéi人rén。」

To fail to rise before the sovereign might yet be borne; but your father’s wrong unavenged — in vain, then, are you a man!”

And here the poem turns and stabs. The first seven lines run to seven characters each; this last one runs to nine — the metre breaking open at precisely the moment the subject stops being a robe and becomes the boy standing in front of it. Read it aloud and the line overruns, which is the point. 見駕不迎 is failing to rise before the sovereign; 枉為人 is "in vain a man," with 為 as wéi, to be, not wèi, for the sake of.


總評 Commentary

A quarrel about a garment turns into a sermon. The prince dismisses the cassock as half a piece of cloth, and Tripitaka answers with a poem claiming it was sewn by immortal maidens and holds Suchness itself inside the stitching — the Buddhist mystery concealed in an unpromising object, which is more or less the novel's method in miniature.

But the poem is a trap, and its last line is where it closes. Seven lines of seven characters praise the robe; the eighth runs to nine characters and turns on the listener: your father's wrong is unavenged, and in vain, then, are you a man. The metre breaks exactly where the subject does. From here the scene can no longer be about a cassock, and the prince cannot wave the monk away.