Canonical Classics ← 第三十七回
第三十七回
鬼guǐ王wáng夜yè謁yè唐táng三sān藏zàng
悟wù空kōng神shén化huà引yǐn嬰yīng兒ér

The Ghost-King Visits Tang Tripitaka by Night · Wukong, by Divine Transformation, Leads the Infant

留珪為記
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

留珪為記 The Jade Tablet Left as Proof

又yòu問wèn道dào:「你nǐ縱zòng有yǒu太tài子zǐ在zài朝cháo,我wǒ怎zěn的de與yǔ他tā相xiāng見jiàn?」那nà人rén道dào:「如rú何hé不bù得dé見jiàn?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā被bèi妖yāo魔mó拘jū轄xiá,連lián一yí個gè生shēng身shēn之zhī母mǔ尚shàng不bù得dé見jiàn,我wǒ一yí個gè和hé尚shàng,欲yù見jiàn何hé由yóu?」那nà人rén道dào:「他tā明míng早zǎo出chū朝cháo來lái也yě。」三sān藏zàng問wèn:「出chū朝cháo作zuò甚shén?」那nà人rén道dào:「明míng日rì早zǎo朝cháo,領lǐng三sān千qiān人rén馬mǎ,架jià鷹yīng犬quǎn,出chū城chéng採cǎi獵liè,師shī父fù斷duàn得dé與yǔ他tā相xiāng見jiàn。見jiàn時shí肯kěn將jiāng我wǒ的de言yán語yǔ說shuō與yǔ他tā,他tā便biàn信xìn了le。」三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā本běn是shì肉ròu眼yǎn凡fán胎tāi,被bèi妖yāo魔mó哄hǒng在zài殿diàn上shàng,那nǎ一yí日rì不bú叫jiào他tā幾jǐ聲shēng父fù王wáng?他tā怎zěn肯kěn信xìn我wǒ的de言yán語yǔ?」那nà人rén道dào:「既jì恐kǒng他tā不bú信xìn,我wǒ留liú下xià一yí件jiàn表biǎo記jì與yǔ你nǐ罷bà。」三sān藏zàng問wèn:「是shì何hé物wù件jiàn?」那nà人rén把bǎ手shǒu中zhōng執zhí的de金jīn廂xiāng白bái玉yù珪guī放fàng下xià道dào:「此cǐ物wù可kě以yǐ為wéi記jì。」又yòu问wèn道dào:「你nǐ纵zòng有yǒu太tài子zǐ在zài朝cháo,我wǒ怎zěn的de与yǔ他tā相xiāng见jiàn?」那nà人rén道dào:「如rú何hé不bù得dé见jiàn?」三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā被bèi妖yāo魔mó拘jū辖xiá,连lián一yí个gè生shēng身shēn之zhī母mǔ尚shàng不bù得dé见jiàn,我wǒ一yí个gè和hé尚shàng,欲yù见jiàn何hé由yóu?」那nà人rén道dào:「他tā明míng早zǎo出chū朝cháo来lái也yě。」三sān藏zàng问wèn:「出chū朝cháo作zuò甚shén?」那nà人rén道dào:「明míng日rì早zǎo朝cháo,领lǐng三sān千qiān人rén马mǎ,架jià鹰yīng犬quǎn,出chū城chéng采cǎi猎liè,师shī父fù断duàn得dé与yǔ他tā相xiāng见jiàn。见jiàn时shí肯kěn将jiāng我wǒ的de言yán语yǔ说shuō与yǔ他tā,他tā便biàn信xìn了le。」三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā本běn是shì肉ròu眼yǎn凡fán胎tāi,被bèi妖yāo魔mó哄hǒng在zài殿diàn上shàng,那nǎ一yí日rì不bú叫jiào他tā几jǐ声shēng父fù王wáng?他tā怎zěn肯kěn信xìn我wǒ的de言yán语yǔ?」那nà人rén道dào:「既jì恐kǒng他tā不bú信xìn,我wǒ留liú下xià一yí件jiàn表biǎo记jì与yǔ你nǐ罢bà。」三sān藏zàng问wèn:「是shì何hé物wù件jiàn?」那nà人rén把bǎ手shǒu中zhōng执zhí的de金jīn厢xiāng白bái玉yù珪guī放fàng下xià道dào:「此cǐ物wù可kě以yǐ为wéi记jì。」


逐句解 Line by line

又yòu問wèn道dào:「你nǐ縱zòng有yǒu太tài子zǐ在zài朝cháo,我wǒ怎zěn的de與yǔ他tā相xiāng見jiàn?」 又yòu问wèn道dào:「你nǐ纵zòng有yǒu太tài子zǐ在zài朝cháo,我wǒ怎zěn的de与yǔ他tā相xiāng见jiàn?」

He asked further, “Even if you have a crown prince at court, how am I to meet with him?”

The practical objection: a prince at court is not a prince you can walk up to. 太子在朝 takes 子 as zǐ and 朝 as cháo; 相見 is to meet one another.

那nà人rén道dào:「如rú何hé不bù得dé見jiàn?」 那nà人rén道dào:「如rú何hé不bù得dé见jiàn?」

The man said, “How should you not get to meet him?”

The ghost is unbothered, which is itself a clue that he has thought this through. 如何不得見 — "how should you not get to meet him?" 得 is dé.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā被bèi妖yāo魔mó拘jū轄xiá,連lián一yí個gè生shēng身shēn之zhī母mǔ尚shàng不bù得dé見jiàn,我wǒ一yí個gè和hé尚shàng,欲yù見jiàn何hé由yóu?」 三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā被bèi妖yāo魔mó拘jū辖xiá,连lián一yí个gè生shēng身shēn之zhī母mǔ尚shàng不bù得dé见jiàn,我wǒ一yí个gè和hé尚shàng,欲yù见jiàn何hé由yóu?」

Tripitaka said, “Held in the fiend’s grip, he cannot even see the mother who bore him — how then should a mere monk find a way to see him?”

Tripitaka presses, and the argument is a fortiori: if the boy cannot reach his own mother, what chance has a passing monk? 拘轄 is to hold under restraint; 何由 is "by what means."

那nà人rén道dào:「他tā明míng早zǎo出chū朝cháo來lái也yě。」 那nà人rén道dào:「他tā明míng早zǎo出chū朝cháo来lái也yě。」

The man said, “He comes out from court tomorrow at dawn.”

One flat sentence that unlocks the plot: tomorrow he leaves the palace. 出朝 takes 朝 as cháo.

三sān藏zàng問wèn:「出chū朝cháo作zuò甚shén?」 三sān藏zàng问wèn:「出chū朝cháo作zuò甚shén?」

Tripitaka asked, “Out from court to do what?”

出朝作甚 — "out from court to do what?" 甚 is shén, the question word.

那nà人rén道dào:「明míng日rì早zǎo朝cháo,領lǐng三sān千qiān人rén馬mǎ,架jià鷹yīng犬quǎn,出chū城chéng採cǎi獵liè,師shī父fù斷duàn得dé與yǔ他tā相xiāng見jiàn。 那nà人rén道dào:「明míng日rì早zǎo朝cháo,领lǐng三sān千qiān人rén马mǎ,架jià鹰yīng犬quǎn,出chū城chéng采cǎi猎liè,师shī父fù断duàn得dé与yǔ他tā相xiāng见jiàn。

The man said, “Tomorrow at the morning court he will lead three thousand horse and foot, take hawk and hound, and go out from the city to hunt; there, Master, you will surely get to meet him.

The hunt: three thousand men, hawks and hounds, out beyond the walls. It is the one day the impostor's containment has a hole in it, because a prince cannot be kept indoors and also look like a prince. 早朝 is the dawn audience, 朝 read cháo; 斷得 is "will certainly get to," 得 read dé; 相見 again "meet one another."

見jiàn時shí肯kěn將jiāng我wǒ的de言yán語yǔ說shuō與yǔ他tā,他tā便biàn信xìn了le。」 见jiàn时shí肯kěn将jiāng我wǒ的de言yán语yǔ说shuō与yǔ他tā,他tā便biàn信xìn了le。」

When you meet, if you will but take my words and tell them to him, he will then believe.”

The ghost's confidence in his own words is touching and completely misplaced, as the next line points out. 將 is jiāng, taking up the words to hand on.

三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā本běn是shì肉ròu眼yǎn凡fán胎tāi,被bèi妖yāo魔mó哄hǒng在zài殿diàn上shàng,那nǎ一yí日rì不bú叫jiào他tā幾jǐ聲shēng父fù王wáng? 三sān藏zàng道dào:「他tā本běn是shì肉ròu眼yǎn凡fán胎tāi,被bèi妖yāo魔mó哄hǒng在zài殿diàn上shàng,那nǎ一yí日rì不bú叫jiào他tā几jǐ声shēng父fù王wáng?

Tripitaka said, “He is but flesh-and-blood of mortal eye, deceived by the fiend upon the throne — which day does he not call him ‘father-king’ many times over?

Tripitaka's counter is the best argument in the passage. The boy is 肉眼凡胎 — "mortal eyes, common flesh," the standard phrase for someone who cannot see through a disguise — and he calls the impostor "father-king" several times a day, every day. Habit is a stronger witness than a stranger. 那一日 is rhetorical, "which day does he not," with 那 as the question word nǎ, the character Ming printing used before 哪 was differentiated.

他tā怎zěn肯kěn信xìn我wǒ的de言yán語yǔ?」 他tā怎zěn肯kěn信xìn我wǒ的de言yán语yǔ?」

How should he be willing to believe my words?”

怎肯 — "how would he be willing?" Not could: would.

那nà人rén道dào:「既jì恐kǒng他tā不bú信xìn,我wǒ留liú下xià一yí件jiàn表biǎo記jì與yǔ你nǐ罷bà。」 那nà人rén道dào:「既jì恐kǒng他tā不bú信xìn,我wǒ留liú下xià一yí件jiàn表biǎo记jì与yǔ你nǐ罢bà。」

The man said, “If you fear he will not believe, then let me leave a token with you.”

So the ghost offers a token. 表記 biǎo jì is a proof-object, the thing produced in a recognition scene to settle what words cannot. 那 is the pointing nà.

三sān藏zàng問wèn:「是shì何hé物wù件jiàn?」 三sān藏zàng问wèn:「是shì何hé物wù件jiàn?」

Tripitaka asked, “What object is it?”

Tripitaka, sensibly, wants to know what it is before he agrees to carry it. 何物件 is "what object."

那nà人rén把bǎ手shǒu中zhōng執zhí的de金jīn廂xiāng白bái玉yù珪guī放fàng下xià道dào:「此cǐ物wù可kě以yǐ為wéi記jì。」 那nà人rén把bǎ手shǒu中zhōng执zhí的de金jīn厢xiāng白bái玉yù珪guī放fàng下xià道dào:「此cǐ物wù可kě以yǐ为wéi记jì。」

The man set down the gold-mounted white-jade tablet he held in his hand, and said, “This object may serve as a proof.”

He sets down the tablet he has been holding since he first appeared — the one item in that opening portrait that had a job to do. 金廂 is "gold-mounted," 廂 standing for 鑲, to inlay; 為記 has 為 as wéi, to serve as, not wèi, for the sake of; 手中 takes the locative zhōng.


總評 Commentary

The mechanism of the reunion is set up here. The prince leaves the fiend's reach only for the hunt, and on that one morning Tripitaka can reach him. But the monk raises the objection that actually matters: the boy calls the impostor "father-king" every day of his life, and no stranger's word is going to outweigh that.

The answer is the white-jade tablet, set down on the floor of a dream. It is the classic proof-object of romance — the ring, the token, the half-broken coin — the one thing that can convince a son against the evidence of his own eyes. Note that it was hanging in the opening portrait all along, in the ghost's hand, waiting to be needed. The next passage explains why this object in particular has such force.