Canonical Classics ← 第九十回
第九十回
師shī獅shī授shòu受shòu同tóng歸guī一yī
盜dào道dào纏chán禪chán靜jìng九jiǔ靈líng

Master and Lion, Giving and Receiving, Return Together to the One · Thieving the Way and Snaring Chan, the Nine Spirits Are Stilled

手不拈兵
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

手不拈兵 No Armour And No Weapon

我wǒ師shī兄xiōng已yǐ得dé勝shèng,捉zhuō了le眾zhòng妖yāo,尋xún到dào此cǐ間jiān救jiù拔bá吾wú等děng也yě。」說shuō罷bà,又yòu聽tīng得dé老lǎo妖yāo叫jiào:「小xiǎo的de們men,好hǎo生shēng在zài此cǐ看kān守shǒu,等děng我wǒ出chū去qù拿ná那nà兩liǎng個gè和hé尚shàng進jìn來lái,一yì發fā懲chéng治zhì。」你nǐ看kàn他tā身shēn無wú披pī掛guà,手shǒu不bù拈niān兵bīng,大dà踏tà步bù走zǒu到dào前qián邊biān,只zhǐ聞wén得dé孫sūn行xíng者zhě吆yāo喝hè哩li。他tā就jiù大dà開kāi了le洞dòng門mén,不bù答dá話huà,徑jìng奔bèn行xíng者zhě。行xíng者zhě使shǐ鐵tiě棒bàng,當dāng頭tóu支zhī住zhù。沙shā僧sēng掄lūn寶bǎo杖zhàng就jiù打dǎ。那nà老lǎo妖yāo把bǎ頭tóu搖yáo一yì搖yáo,左zuǒ右yòu八bā個gè頭tóu,一yì齊qí張zhāng開kāi口kǒu,把bǎ行xíng者zhě、沙shā僧sēng輕qīng輕qīng的de又yòu啣xián於yú洞dòng內nèi。我wǒ师shī兄xiōng已yǐ得dé胜shèng,捉zhuō了le众zhòng妖yāo,寻xún到dào此cǐ间jiān救jiù拔bá吾wú等děng也yě。」说shuō罢bà,又yòu听tīng得dé老lǎo妖yāo叫jiào:「小xiǎo的de们men,好hǎo生shēng在zài此cǐ看kān守shǒu,等děng我wǒ出chū去qù拿ná那nà两liǎng个gè和hé尚shàng进jìn来lái,一yì发fā惩chéng治zhì。」你nǐ看kàn他tā身shēn无wú披pī挂guà,手shǒu不bù拈niān兵bīng,大dà踏tà步bù走zǒu到dào前qián边biān,只zhǐ闻wén得dé孙sūn行xíng者zhě吆yāo喝hè哩li。他tā就jiù大dà开kāi了le洞dòng门mén,不bù答dá话huà,径jìng奔bèn行xíng者zhě。行xíng者zhě使shǐ铁tiě棒bàng,当dāng头tóu支zhī住zhù。沙shā僧sēng抡lūn宝bǎo杖zhàng就jiù打dǎ。那nà老lǎo妖yāo把bǎ头tóu摇yáo一yì摇yáo,左zuǒ右yòu八bā个gè头tóu,一yì齐qí张zhāng开kāi口kǒu,把bǎ行xíng者zhě、沙shā僧sēng轻qīng轻qīng的de又yòu啣xián于yú洞dòng内nèi。


逐句解 Line by line

我wǒ師shī兄xiōng已yǐ得dé勝shèng,捉zhuō了le眾zhòng妖yāo,尋xún到dào此cǐ間jiān救jiù拔bá吾wú等děng也yě。」 我wǒ师shī兄xiōng已yǐ得dé胜shèng,捉zhuō了le众zhòng妖yāo,寻xún到dào此cǐ间jiān救jiù拔bá吾wú等děng也yě。」

"My elder brother has already won the day, taken the whole crowd of fiends, and traced us here to get us out."

Eight Rules has assembled a rescue out of one overheard sentence, and he is not wrong about any of it except the timing. 救拔 is to haul somebody out of trouble, the same word Buddhist texts use for being lifted out of suffering.

說shuō罷bà,又yòu聽tīng得dé老lǎo妖yāo叫jiào:「小xiǎo的de們men,好hǎo生shēng在zài此cǐ看kān守shǒu,等děng我wǒ出chū去qù拿ná那nà兩liǎng個gè和hé尚shàng進jìn來lái,一yì發fā懲chéng治zhì。」 说shuō罢bà,又yòu听tīng得dé老lǎo妖yāo叫jiào:「小xiǎo的de们men,好hǎo生shēng在zài此cǐ看kān守shǒu,等děng我wǒ出chū去qù拿ná那nà两liǎng个gè和hé尚shàng进jìn来lái,一yì发fā惩chéng治zhì。」

When he had finished, he heard the old fiend call again: "Little ones, keep a sharp watch here. I am going out to bring those two monks in, and settle the lot of them at once."

說罷 - the saying done - is the storyteller's cut, and here it cuts straight from Eight Rules celebrating to the reason he should not be. 一發懲治 means to deal with them all in one go, which is exactly what is about to happen.

你nǐ看kàn他tā身shēn無wú披pī掛guà,手shǒu不bù拈niān兵bīng,大dà踏tà步bù走zǒu到dào前qián邊biān,只zhǐ聞wén得dé孫sūn行xíng者zhě吆yāo喝hè哩li。 你nǐ看kàn他tā身shēn无wú披pī挂guà,手shǒu不bù拈niān兵bīng,大dà踏tà步bù走zǒu到dào前qián边biān,只zhǐ闻wén得dé孙sūn行xíng者zhě吆yāo喝hè哩li。

Look at him: no armour on his body, no weapon in his hand, striding out to the front, where he heard nothing but Sun Pilgrim bawling away.

The detail that should frighten everyone. 身無披掛,手不拈兵 is a matched pair - nothing on the body, nothing in the hand - and this book has spent two chapters cataloguing everybody's weapons. He does not need one. And 喝 is hè inside 吆喝, the shouting reading, not the hē that means to drink.

他tā就jiù大dà開kāi了le洞dòng門mén,不bù答dá話huà,徑jìng奔bèn行xíng者zhě。 他tā就jiù大dà开kāi了le洞dòng门mén,不bù答dá话huà,径jìng奔bèn行xíng者zhě。

So he threw the cave door wide, and without a word of talk went straight at Pilgrim.

不答話 - no answering talk - is worth marking. Every fight in this chapter so far has opened with challenge and counter-challenge. This one skips it. 奔 is bèn, the reading for heading somewhere: Pilgrim is what he is going at.

行xíng者zhě使shǐ鐵tiě棒bàng,當dāng頭tóu支zhī住zhù。 行xíng者zhě使shǐ铁tiě棒bàng,当dāng头tóu支zhī住zhù。

Pilgrim used his iron cudgel and blocked him head on.

Five characters. The novel gives the greatest fighter in the book one short clause to make his stand, and then does not come back to him.

沙shā僧sēng掄lūn寶bǎo杖zhàng就jiù打dǎ。 沙shā僧sēng抡lūn宝bǎo杖zhàng就jiù打dǎ。

Sha Monk swung his precious staff and struck.

Five characters again, in exactly the same shape. Two heroes, two clauses, both of them over before the sentence ends.

那nà老lǎo妖yāo把bǎ頭tóu搖yáo一yì搖yáo,左zuǒ右yòu八bā個gè頭tóu,一yì齊qí張zhāng開kāi口kǒu,把bǎ行xíng者zhě、沙shā僧sēng輕qīng輕qīng的de又yòu啣xián於yú洞dòng內nèi。 那nà老lǎo妖yāo把bǎ头tóu摇yáo一yì摇yáo,左zuǒ右yòu八bā个gè头tóu,一yì齐qí张zhāng开kāi口kǒu,把bǎ行xíng者zhě、沙shā僧sēng轻qīng轻qīng的de又yòu啣xián于yú洞dòng内nèi。

That old fiend gave his head one shake, and the eight heads to left and right opened their mouths all together, and quite lightly took Pilgrim and Sha Monk up in them and carried them into the cave.

輕輕的 - quite lightly, easily - is the word the whole passage turns on. He is not described as strong, or fast, or terrible. He is described as finding it no trouble. And 啣 is to hold something in the mouth the way an animal carries its young, which is a good deal more insulting than being seized.


總評 Commentary

The fight everyone has been waiting for lasts three segments and the pilgrims do not land a blow. Pilgrim blocks, Sha Monk swings, the fiend shakes his head and eats them both.

The novel prepares this with one detail and then trusts it. He comes out with nothing on his body and nothing in his hand, and in a book that has just spent eleven lines of verse naming everybody's ironmongery, that is the loudest statement available. Weapons are for creatures who need them.

The word to keep is the one attached to the swallowing: lightly. Not savagely, not swiftly - easily, the way you would pick up something that had been left lying about. Two chapters of fighting have established what these pilgrims can do, and the chapter's answer is that it does not signify.