Canonical Classics ← 第五十九回
第五十九回
唐táng三sān藏zàng路lù阻zǔ火huǒ焰yàn山shān
孫sūn行xíng者zhě一yí調tiáo芭bā蕉jiāo扇shàn

Tripitaka's Road Is Blocked at the Mountain of Flames · Sun the Pilgrim Contrives the First Fetching of the Banana-Leaf Fan

避火訣
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

避火訣 The Fire Averting Charm

八bā戒jiè笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ常cháng說shuō雷léi打dǎ不bù傷shāng,火huǒ燒shāo不bù損sǔn,如rú今jīn何hé又yòu怕pà火huǒ?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ這zhè獃dāi子zi,全quán不bù知zhī事shì。那nà時shí節jié用yòng心xīn防fáng備bèi,故gù此cǐ不bù傷shāng;今jīn日rì只zhǐ為wèi搧shān息xī火huǒ光guāng,不bù曾céng捻niǎn避bì火huǒ訣jué,又yòu未wèi使shǐ護hù身shēn法fǎ,所suǒ以yǐ把bǎ兩liǎng股gǔ毫háo毛máo燒shāo了le。」八bā戒jiè笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ常cháng说shuō雷léi打dǎ不bù伤shāng,火huǒ烧shāo不bù损sǔn,如rú今jīn何hé又yòu怕pà火huǒ?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ这zhè呆dāi子zi,全quán不bù知zhī事shì。那nà时shí节jié用yòng心xīn防fáng备bèi,故gù此cǐ不bù伤shāng;今jīn日rì只zhǐ为wèi扇shān息xī火huǒ光guāng,不bù曾céng捻niǎn避bì火huǒ诀jué,又yòu未wèi使shǐ护hù身shēn法fǎ,所suǒ以yǐ把bǎ两liǎng股gǔ毫háo毛máo烧shāo了le。」


逐句解 Line by line

八bā戒jiè笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ常cháng說shuō雷léi打dǎ不bù傷shāng,火huǒ燒shāo不bù損sǔn,如rú今jīn何hé又yòu怕pà火huǒ?」 八bā戒jiè笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ常cháng说shuō雷léi打dǎ不bù伤shāng,火huǒ烧shāo不bù损sǔn,如rú今jīn何hé又yòu怕pà火huǒ?」

Eight Rules said with a laugh, 'You are always telling us that thunder cannot hurt you and fire cannot harm you. How is it you are afraid of fire now?'

雷打不傷,火燒不損 is a matched pair. Eight Rules has caught a real inconsistency, and for once the novel lets him land it.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ這zhè獃dāi子zi,全quán不bù知zhī事shì。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ这zhè呆dāi子zi,全quán不bù知zhī事shì。

Pilgrim said, 'You idiot, you understand nothing at all.'

獃子 with the light ending, as always from Pilgrim. 全不知事, "wholly ignorant of how things are" — the abuse comes first and, unusually, an actual explanation follows.

那nà時shí節jié用yòng心xīn防fáng備bèi,故gù此cǐ不bù傷shāng;今jīn日rì只zhǐ為wèi搧shān息xī火huǒ光guāng,不bù曾céng捻niǎn避bì火huǒ訣jué,又yòu未wèi使shǐ護hù身shēn法fǎ,所suǒ以yǐ把bǎ兩liǎng股gǔ毫háo毛máo燒shāo了le。」 那nà时shí节jié用yòng心xīn防fáng备bèi,故gù此cǐ不bù伤shāng;今jīn日rì只zhǐ为wèi扇shān息xī火huǒ光guāng,不bù曾céng捻niǎn避bì火huǒ诀jué,又yòu未wèi使shǐ护hù身shēn法fǎ,所suǒ以yǐ把bǎ两liǎng股gǔ毫háo毛máo烧shāo了le。」

'On those occasions I was guarding myself with care, and so took no hurt; today, because I was wholly taken up with fanning the fire out, I never made the fire-averting sign nor used the body-protecting spell, and that is why the hair on both my legs got burnt.'

曾 is céng, marking something already done. 捻…訣 is to make a hand-sign, to work a charm with the fingers; 避火訣 is the charm against fire. 為 is wèi. The source runs the two halves together and they are rejoined here: 那時節 against 今日, each with its own reason and result, strictly parallel and opposed rather than climbing.


總評 Commentary

Eight Rules catches a real inconsistency and the novel lets him have it. You are always saying thunder cannot hurt you and fire cannot harm you — 雷打不傷,火燒不損 — so why are you afraid of fire now? It is a fair question, put in a matched pair of four-character clauses, and it is the only time in the chapter anyone successfully challenges Pilgrim on a point of fact.

The answer is technical and it is convincing. On those occasions I was guarding myself; today I was wholly taken up with fanning, made no fire-averting sign and used no body-protecting spell. His invulnerability is not a property he has but a practice he performs, and it takes attention he was spending elsewhere.

That is a more interesting proposition than it first looks, and it holds throughout the novel. Pilgrim is nearly always hurt when he is distracted, over-confident, or busy with something else — and here he was concentrating on the very thing that was supposed to solve the problem, with a fan that was making it worse.