Canonical Classics ← 第五十三回
第五十三回
禪chán主zhǔ吞tūn餐cān懷huái鬼guǐ孕yùn
黃huáng婆pó運yùn水shuǐ解jiě邪xié胎tāi

The Master of Dhyāna, Swallowing His Meal, Conceives a Ghostly Pregnancy · The Yellow Dame Draws Water and Dissolves the Demon Foetus

不得囫圇
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

不得囫圇 You Would Not Come Away Whole

行xíng者zhě咄duō的de一yì聲shēng道dào:「汝rǔ等děng女nǚ流liú之zhī輩bèi,敢gǎn傷shāng那nǎ個gè?」老lǎo婆pó子zi笑xiào道dào:「爺yé爺ye呀ya!還hái是shì你nǐ們men有yǒu造zào化huà,來lái到dào我wǒ家jiā!若ruò到dào第dì二èr家jiā,你nǐ們men也yě不bù得dé囫hú圇lún了le。」八bā戒jiè哼hēng哼hēng的de道dào:「不bù得dé囫hú圇lún,是shì怎zěn麼me的de?」婆pó婆po道dào:「我wǒ一yì家jiā兒er四sì五wǔ口kǒu,都dōu是shì有yǒu幾jǐ歲suì年nián紀jì的de,把bǎ那nà風fēng月yuè事shì盡jìn皆jiē休xiū了le,故gù此cǐ不bù肯kěn傷shāng你nǐ;若ruò還hái到dào第dì二èr家jiā,老lǎo小xiǎo眾zhòng大dà,那nà年nián小xiǎo之zhī人rén,那nǎ個gè肯kěn放fàng過guò你nǐ去qù?就jiù要yào與yǔ你nǐ交jiāo合hé。假jiǎ如rú不bù從cóng,就jiù要yào害hài你nǐ性xìng命mìng,把bǎ你nǐ們men身shēn上shàng肉ròu都dōu割gē了le去qù做zuò香xiāng袋dài兒er哩li。」八bā戒jiè道dào:「若ruò這zhè等děng,我wǒ決jué無wú傷shāng。他tā們men都dōu是shì香xiāng噴pēn噴pēn的de,好hǎo做zuò香xiāng袋dài;我wǒ是shì個gè臊sāo豬zhū,就jiù割gē了le肉ròu去qù,也yě是shì臊sāo的de,故gù此cǐ可kě以yǐ無wú傷shāng。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ不bú要yào說shuō嘴zuǐ,省shěng些xiē力lì氣qì,好hǎo生shēng產chǎn也yě。」那nà婆pó婆po道dào:「不bú必bì遲chí疑yí,快kuài求qiú水shuǐ去qù。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ家jiā可kě有yǒu吊diào桶tǒng?借jiè個gè使shǐ使shǐ。」那nà婆pó子zi即jí往wǎng後hòu邊biān取qǔ出chū一yí個gè吊diào桶tǒng,又yòu窩wō了le一yì條tiáo索suǒ子zi,遞dì與yǔ沙shā僧sēng。沙shā僧sēng道dào:「帶dài兩liǎng條tiáo索suǒ子zi去qù,恐kǒng一yì時shí井jǐng深shēn要yào用yòng。」行xíng者zhě咄duō的de一yì声shēng道dào:「汝rǔ等děng女nǚ流liú之zhī辈bèi,敢gǎn伤shāng那nǎ个gè?」老lǎo婆pó子zi笑xiào道dào:「爷yé爷ye呀ya!还hái是shì你nǐ们men有yǒu造zào化huà,来lái到dào我wǒ家jiā!若ruò到dào第dì二èr家jiā,你nǐ们men也yě不bù得dé囫hú囵lún了le。」八bā戒jiè哼hēng哼hēng的de道dào:「不bù得dé囫hú囵lún,是shì怎zěn么me的de?」婆pó婆po道dào:「我wǒ一yì家jiā儿er四sì五wǔ口kǒu,都dōu是shì有yǒu几jǐ岁suì年nián纪jì的de,把bǎ那nà风fēng月yuè事shì尽jìn皆jiē休xiū了le,故gù此cǐ不bù肯kěn伤shāng你nǐ;若ruò还hái到dào第dì二èr家jiā,老lǎo小xiǎo众zhòng大dà,那nà年nián小xiǎo之zhī人rén,那nǎ个gè肯kěn放fàng过guò你nǐ去qù?就jiù要yào与yǔ你nǐ交jiāo合hé。假jiǎ如rú不bù从cóng,就jiù要yào害hài你nǐ性xìng命mìng,把bǎ你nǐ们men身shēn上shàng肉ròu都dōu割gē了le去qù做zuò香xiāng袋dài儿er哩li。」八bā戒jiè道dào:「若ruò这zhè等děng,我wǒ决jué无wú伤shāng。他tā们men都dōu是shì香xiāng喷pēn喷pēn的de,好hǎo做zuò香xiāng袋dài;我wǒ是shì个gè臊sāo猪zhū,就jiù割gē了le肉ròu去qù,也yě是shì臊sāo的de,故gù此cǐ可kě以yǐ无wú伤shāng。」行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ不bú要yào说shuō嘴zuǐ,省shěng些xiē力lì气qì,好hǎo生shēng产chǎn也yě。」那nà婆pó婆po道dào:「不bú必bì迟chí疑yí,快kuài求qiú水shuǐ去qù。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ家jiā可kě有yǒu吊diào桶tǒng?借jiè个gè使shǐ使shǐ。」那nà婆pó子zi即jí往wǎng后hòu边biān取qǔ出chū一yí个gè吊diào桶tǒng,又yòu窝wō了le一yì条tiáo索suǒ子zi,递dì与yǔ沙shā僧sēng。沙shā僧sēng道dào:「带dài两liǎng条tiáo索suǒ子zi去qù,恐kǒng一yì时shí井jǐng深shēn要yào用yòng。」


逐句解 Line by line

行xíng者zhě咄duō的de一yì聲shēng道dào:「汝rǔ等děng女nǚ流liú之zhī輩bèi,敢gǎn傷shāng那nǎ個gè?」 行xíng者zhě咄duō的de一yì声shēng道dào:「汝rǔ等děng女nǚ流liú之zhī辈bèi,敢gǎn伤shāng那nǎ个gè?」

Pilgrim gave a snort and said, "You are a pack of womenfolk — who would you dare harm?"

咄 is a bark of contempt, closer to a noise than a word. 那個 takes 那 as nǎ, the rhetorical which one. His scorn is misplaced, and the rest of the passage exists to correct it.

老lǎo婆pó子zi笑xiào道dào:「爺yé爺ye呀ya!還hái是shì你nǐ們men有yǒu造zào化huà,來lái到dào我wǒ家jiā! 老lǎo婆pó子zi笑xiào道dào:「爷yé爷ye呀ya!还hái是shì你nǐ们men有yǒu造zào化huà,来lái到dào我wǒ家jiā!

The old woman laughed and said, "Gracious sir! It is your good fortune that you came to my house!

造化 takes 化 as huà — good fortune, luck. 還是 here means it is after all, rather than offering a choice.

若ruò到dào第dì二èr家jiā,你nǐ們men也yě不bù得dé囫hú圇lún了le。」 若ruò到dào第dì二èr家jiā,你nǐ们men也yě不bù得dé囫hú囵lún了le。」

Had you gone to a second house, you would not have come away whole."

不得囫圇 takes 得 as dé. 囫圇 is whole, entire, in one piece — the word survives in modern Chinese in the phrase for swallowing a date without chewing it. The threat is left unspecified for exactly one segment.

八bā戒jiè哼hēng哼hēng的de道dào:「不bù得dé囫hú圇lún,是shì怎zěn麼me的de?」 八bā戒jiè哼hēng哼hēng的de道dào:「不bù得dé囫hú囵lún,是shì怎zěn么me的de?」

Eight Rules said with a groan, "Not come away whole — and what would that be?"

Bajie asks the question that lets the explanation happen, exactly as he did about the circle in the chapter's first passage. It is his standing office in the narrative and he discharges it here at the worst possible moment for his own peace of mind.

婆pó婆po道dào:「我wǒ一yì家jiā兒er四sì五wǔ口kǒu,都dōu是shì有yǒu幾jǐ歲suì年nián紀jì的de,把bǎ那nà風fēng月yuè事shì盡jìn皆jiē休xiū了le,故gù此cǐ不bù肯kěn傷shāng你nǐ;若ruò還hái到dào第dì二èr家jiā,老lǎo小xiǎo眾zhòng大dà,那nà年nián小xiǎo之zhī人rén,那nǎ個gè肯kěn放fàng過guò你nǐ去qù? 婆pó婆po道dào:「我wǒ一yì家jiā儿er四sì五wǔ口kǒu,都dōu是shì有yǒu几jǐ岁suì年nián纪jì的de,把bǎ那nà风fēng月yuè事shì尽jìn皆jiē休xiū了le,故gù此cǐ不bù肯kěn伤shāng你nǐ;若ruò还hái到dào第dì二èr家jiā,老lǎo小xiǎo众zhòng大dà,那nà年nián小xiǎo之zhī人rén,那nǎ个gè肯kěn放fàng过guò你nǐ去qù?

The old woman said, "There are four or five of us in this household, all of us women of some years, who have given over the business of love entirely; so we were not willing to harm you. But had you gone on to a second house, where the household is large and mixed in age, which of the younger ones there would have let you pass?

一家兒 takes 兒 as the light suffix er; 盡 is jìn. Three 那 in this sentence and they are not alike: nà, that, twice over, and then nǎ, which, in 那個肯放過你去 — which of them would let you pass?

就jiù要yào與yǔ你nǐ交jiāo合hé。 就jiù要yào与yǔ你nǐ交jiāo合hé。

They would have had you couple with them.

Six characters, stated without euphemism. The novel gives the threat one short sentence and moves straight on to what refusal would cost.

假jiǎ如rú不bù從cóng,就jiù要yào害hài你nǐ性xìng命mìng,把bǎ你nǐ們men身shēn上shàng肉ròu都dōu割gē了le去qù做zuò香xiāng袋dài兒er哩li。」 假jiǎ如rú不bù从cóng,就jiù要yào害hài你nǐ性xìng命mìng,把bǎ你nǐ们men身shēn上shàng肉ròu都dōu割gē了le去qù做zuò香xiāng袋dài儿er哩li。」

And if you would not consent, they would have taken your lives and cut the flesh from your bodies to make scent-bags of."

香袋兒 takes 兒 as the light suffix er; 哩 is li. 香袋 are the scented sachets worn at the waist — an ordinary accessory, which is what makes the sentence land. In fourteen characters the danger turns from coercion into butchery, and the product named is a trinket.

八bā戒jiè道dào:「若ruò這zhè等děng,我wǒ決jué無wú傷shāng。 八bā戒jiè道dào:「若ruò这zhè等děng,我wǒ决jué无wú伤shāng。

Eight Rules said, "In that case I am certainly safe from harm.

決無傷 asserts the conclusion before any reasoning arrives, which is the shape of every joke Bajie makes.

他tā們men都dōu是shì香xiāng噴pēn噴pēn的de,好hǎo做zuò香xiāng袋dài;我wǒ是shì個gè臊sāo豬zhū,就jiù割gē了le肉ròu去qù,也yě是shì臊sāo的de,故gù此cǐ可kě以yǐ無wú傷shāng。」 他tā们men都dōu是shì香xiāng喷pēn喷pēn的de,好hǎo做zuò香xiāng袋dài;我wǒ是shì个gè臊sāo猪zhū,就jiù割gē了le肉ròu去qù,也yě是shì臊sāo的de,故gù此cǐ可kě以yǐ无wú伤shāng。」

They are all sweet-smelling and make good scent-bags; I am a rank pig, and if they cut my flesh away it would be rank too — so I can come to no harm."

臊 is the rank smell of a boar. The joke works by accepting the premise of the butchery whole and then reasoning about product quality, which is a colder piece of comedy than it first appears.

行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ不bú要yào說shuō嘴zuǐ,省shěng些xiē力lì氣qì,好hǎo生shēng產chǎn也yě。」 行xíng者zhě笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ不bú要yào说shuō嘴zuǐ,省shěng些xiē力lì气qì,好hǎo生shēng产chǎn也yě。」

Pilgrim said with a laugh, "Don't talk so big — save your strength, you'll want it for the birth."

說嘴 is to boast, to talk big. 好生產也 swings the conversation back to Bajie's condition in a single clause, and it is the third time in the chapter that Wukong has used the pregnancy to shut him up.

那nà婆pó婆po道dào:「不bú必bì遲chí疑yí,快kuài求qiú水shuǐ去qù。」 那nà婆pó婆po道dào:「不bú必bì迟chí疑yí,快kuài求qiú水shuǐ去qù。」

The old woman said, "No need to delay — go quickly and get the water."

不必遲疑 is brisk to the point of impatience. Having supplied the information that makes the morning's reception intelligible, she points the party at the job.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ家jiā可kě有yǒu吊diào桶tǒng?借jiè個gè使shǐ使shǐ。」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「你nǐ家jiā可kě有yǒu吊diào桶tǒng?借jiè个gè使shǐ使shǐ。」

Pilgrim said, "Have you a well-bucket in the house? Lend me one to use."

使使 doubles the verb to make it casual — just to use, only for a moment. English does the same thing with a diminutive: lend us a bucket, would you.

那nà婆pó子zi即jí往wǎng後hòu邊biān取qǔ出chū一yí個gè吊diào桶tǒng,又yòu窩wō了le一yì條tiáo索suǒ子zi,遞dì與yǔ沙shā僧sēng。 那nà婆pó子zi即jí往wǎng后hòu边biān取qǔ出chū一yí个gè吊diào桶tǒng,又yòu窝wō了le一yì条tiáo索suǒ子zi,递dì与yǔ沙shā僧sēng。

The old woman went straight to the back, brought out a bucket, coiled up a rope as well, and handed them to Sha Monk.

Both 子 are the light suffix zi — 婆子 and 索子. 窩 is to coil. Note the sequence: the household that could not give them water is now supplying the means of fetching it.

沙shā僧sēng道dào:「帶dài兩liǎng條tiáo索suǒ子zi去qù,恐kǒng一yì時shí井jǐng深shēn要yào用yòng。」 沙shā僧sēng道dào:「带dài两liǎng条tiáo索suǒ子zi去qù,恐kǒng一yì时shí井jǐng深shēn要yào用yòng。」

Sha Monk said, "Take two ropes — the well may be deep and we shall want them."

Sha Monk's whole contribution to the expedition, at this point, is a piece of foresight about rope length. It is entirely in character, and it will turn out to have been unnecessary.


總評 Commentary

This is the passage in which the Women's Country stops being a curiosity. Everything the pilgrims have met so far — the ferrywoman's silence, the tittering at the door, the women called out to look at the Tang Monk — has been played for comedy. Here the old woman explains what those receptions ordinarily lead to, and the tone changes without warning.

Her account is exact and unhurried. Her own household is safe because its four or five women are past the age of interest — 把那風月事盡皆休了, they have given over the business of love entirely. Elsewhere the households are large and mixed in age, and the young among them would not let travellers pass; refusal would be answered with killing, and the bodies used for scent-sachets. She offers all of this as an explanation of why the pilgrims were lucky, which is the coldest possible frame for it.

The exchange also darkens the passage before it, retroactively. The same woman said there that her household had felt 愛憐之意 toward the visitors that morning and gave the idea up on seeing Wukong ride a cloud. Set against what she says here, the phrase is not affection but appetite deferred, and the pilgrims' whole comic morning at the cottage was conducted a good deal nearer the edge than any of them knew.

Bajie's joke is the release, and it repays examination rather than mere enjoyment. He does not dispute the account or express horror. He accepts the butchery as a given and argues that his own flesh is too rank to be worth harvesting. The comedy is entirely a matter of tone — a body-horror premise reasoned about as a question of raw materials — and Wukong deflates it by reminding him he has a delivery to get through. The novel then moves straight on to the rope.