Canonical Classics ← 第五十三回
第五十三回
chánzhǔtūncānhuáiguǐyùn
huángyùnshuǐjiěxiétāi

The Master of Dhyāna, Swallowing His Meal, Conceives a Ghostly Pregnancy · The Yellow Dame Draws Water and Dissolves the Demon Foetus

行不更名
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

行不更名 A Gentleman Does Not Change His Name

xíngzhějiànlezhǎngzuòdào:「pínsēng便biànshìsūnkōng。」xiānshēngxiàodào:「zhēnshìsūnkōngquèshìjiǎmíngtuōxìngzhě?」xíngzhědào:「kànxiānshēngshuōhuàchángyándào:『jūnxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìng。』便biànshìkōngyǒujiǎtuōzhī?」xiānshēngdào:「rèndeme?」xíngzhědào:「yīnguīzhèngshìménbǐngchéngsēngjiàozhèxiàngdēngshānshèshuǐyòushídepéngyǒudōushūshīwèibàifǎngshǎoshízūnyánshìjiānwèndào西xiāngrénjiāyánxiānshēngnǎizhēnxiānzhīzhī。」xiānshēngdào:「zǒudexiūdezhēnláifǎngzěnde?」xíngzhědào:「yīnshīyǐnleshuǐténgchéngtāiláixiānbàiqiúwǎnluòtāiquánshuǐjiùjiěshīnàn。」xíngzhějiànlezhǎngzuòdào:「pínsēng便biànshìsūnkōng。」xiānshēngxiàodào:「zhēnshìsūnkōngquèshìjiǎmíngtuōxìngzhě?」xíngzhědào:「kànxiānshēngshuōhuàchángyándào:『jūnxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìng。』便biànshìkōngyǒujiǎtuōzhī?」xiānshēngdào:「rèndeme?」xíngzhědào:「yīnguīzhèngshìménbǐngchéngsēngjiàozhèxiàngdēngshānshèshuǐyòushídepéngyǒudōushūshīwèibài访fǎngshǎoshízūnyánshìjiānwèndào西xiāngrénjiāyánxiānshēngnǎizhēnxiānzhīzhī。」xiānshēngdào:「zǒudexiūdezhēnlái访fǎngzěnde?」xíngzhědào:「yīnshīyǐnleshuǐténgchéngtāiláixiānbàiqiúwǎnluòtāiquánshuǐjiùjiěshīnàn。」


逐句解 Line by line

xíngzhějiànlezhǎngzuòdào:「pínsēng便biànshìsūnkōng。」 xíngzhějiànlezhǎngzuòdào:「pínsēng便biànshìsūnkōng。」

Pilgrim, seeing him, joined his palms in salutation and said, "This poor monk is indeed Sun Wukong."

合掌作禮 is the Buddhist greeting, palms together — offered here to a Daoist who has just come out of doors carrying a weapon. Wukong is still being scrupulously polite.

xiānshēngxiàodào:「zhēnshìsūnkōngquèshìjiǎmíngtuōxìngzhě?」 xiānshēngxiàodào:「zhēnshìsūnkōngquèshìjiǎmíngtuōxìngzhě?」

The gentleman said with a laugh, "Are you really Sun Wukong, or someone passing under a false name and a borrowed surname?"

先生 is the courtesy title for a Daoist master. The question is not curiosity. It is a demand that the name be confirmed before he acts on it.

xíngzhědào:「kànxiānshēngshuōhuàchángyándào:『jūnxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìng。』 xíngzhědào:「kànxiānshēngshuōhuàchángyándào:『jūnxínggēngmíngzuògǎixìng。』

Pilgrim said, "Listen to the gentleman talk! The common saying has it: a gentleman does not change his name in walking, nor alter his surname in sitting.

君子 takes as ; is gēng, to alter. The maxim — a gentleman does not change his name in walking nor alter his surname in sitting — is a commonplace of popular fiction, and it is invariably spoken by somebody who is about to be attacked.

便biànshìkōngyǒujiǎtuōzhī?」 便biànshìkōngyǒujiǎtuōzhī?」

I am Wukong; what reason would there be for a false pretence?"

豈有之理 is the standard frame for dismissing something as absurd: what reason could there be? He is answering a question whose only purpose was to identify him as a target.

xiānshēngdào:「rèndeme?」 xiānshēngdào:「rèndeme?」

The gentleman said, "Do you know who I am?"

認得 takes as the light de. The question inverts the exchange just concluded: having established who Wukong is, the immortal now requires his own identity to be recognised.

xíngzhědào:「yīnguīzhèngshìménbǐngchéngsēngjiàozhèxiàngdēngshānshèshuǐyòushídepéngyǒudōushūshīwèibàifǎngshǎoshízūnyán xíngzhědào:「yīnguīzhèngshìménbǐngchéngsēngjiàozhèxiàngdēngshānshèshuǐyòushídepéngyǒudōushūshīwèibài访fǎngshǎoshízūnyán

Pilgrim said, "Since I turned to the True Gate and took up the monk's teaching in sincerity, I have all this while been climbing mountains and fording waters, and have let slip the friends of my younger days; I have not managed to call on them, and know few honoured faces.

僧教 takes as jiào; 少識 takes as shǎo, few. The reply is a courteous evasion that also happens to be true. Wukong really does not recognise the man, and he says so in the politest form available.

shìjiānwèndào西xiāngrénjiāyánxiānshēngnǎizhēnxiānzhīzhī。」 shìjiānwèndào西xiāngrénjiāyánxiānshēngnǎizhēnxiānzhīzhī。」

Just now, asking the way of the country folk west of the Child-and-Mother River, I heard mention that the gentleman is the True Immortal As-You-Will, and so I know it."

適間 takes as jiān — just now. He is explicit that his knowledge of the name is second-hand and a few hours old, which is the last thing his interlocutor wants to hear.

xiānshēngdào:「zǒudexiūdezhēnláifǎngzěnde?」 xiānshēngdào:「zǒudexiūdezhēnlái访fǎngzěnde?」

The gentleman said, "You go your road and I cultivate my truth. What do you come calling on me for?"

你走你的路我修我的真 — you go your road, I cultivate my truth — sets two vocations side by side and denies that they touch at any point. It is the argument of a man who has withdrawn from the world and is charging it for admission.

xíngzhědào:「yīnshīyǐnleshuǐténgchéngtāiláixiānbàiqiúwǎnluòtāiquánshuǐjiùjiěshīnàn。」 xíngzhědào:「yīnshīyǐnleshuǐténgchéngtāiláixiānbàiqiúwǎnluòtāiquánshuǐjiùjiěshīnàn。」

Pilgrim said, "Because my master drank by mistake of the water of the Child-and-Mother River, his belly aches with a conception formed; I have come expressly to the immortal's residence to beg one bowl of the Fetus-Dissolving Spring water, and relieve my master's calamity."

師難 takes as nàn, the noun calamity, as against the nán, difficult, of 難禁 earlier. 救解 takes as jiě. This is the third time in this stretch that Wukong has stated his business, in nearly the same words each time.


總評 Commentary

The exchange is conducted entirely in the forms of courtesy and is a quarrel from end to end. Wukong puts his palms together for a man holding a hooked weapon; the immortal addresses him properly and asks whether he is using a false name. Neither drops the polite manner, and all the hostility is carried by what is being asked rather than by how it is put.

Two questions structure the passage and they mirror each other. The first — are you really Sun Wukong? — establishes the target. The second — do you know who I am? — demands acknowledgement of a grievance Wukong cannot yet identify. His answer is the most disarming thing he could have said and the most inflammatory: he has been walking and fording for years, has lost touch with his old acquaintance, and knows the immortal's name only because some villagers mentioned it that morning. To a man nursing an injury, being told he is not remembered is worse than being defied.

The proverb Wukong quotes is worth noticing for where it lands. 君子行不更名坐不改姓 insists that a gentleman stands by his name whatever he is doing, and it is exactly the wrong thing to be proud of here, because the name is what produced the weapon. He is planting his flag on the very identity that has made him a target, and doing it with a maxim about integrity.

The immortal's own position — 你走你的路我修我的真 — deserves scrutiny. It is the language of principled withdrawal: you have your road, I have my practice, leave me to it. Set against what the reader already knows about the tariff on the spring, the claim to detachment is hard to take at face value. A man who has cornered the only cure for a whole countryside's affliction and priced it in mutton and silk is not walking a separate road from anybody.