比前更勝 A Better Bout Than the Last
真仙聞言,喜孜孜滿懷春意,笑盈盈一陣威風,挺如意鉤子,走出門來喝道:「潑猢猻!你又來作甚?」大聖道:「我來只是取水。」真仙道:「泉水乃吾家之井,憑是帝王宰相,也須表禮羊酒來求,方才僅與些須;況你又是我的仇人,擅敢白手來取?」大聖道:「真個不與?」真仙道:「不與,不與。」大聖罵道:「潑孽障!既不與水,看棍!」丟一個架子,搶個滿懷,不容說,著頭便打;那真仙側身躲過,使鉤子急架相還。這一場比前更勝,好殺:真仙闻言,喜孜孜满怀春意,笑盈盈一阵威风,挺如意钩子,走出门来喝道:「泼猢狲!你又来作甚?」大圣道:「我来只是取水。」真仙道:「泉水乃吾家之井,凭是帝王宰相,也须表礼羊酒来求,方才仅与些须;况你又是我的仇人,擅敢白手来取?」大圣道:「真个不与?」真仙道:「不与,不与。」大圣骂道:「泼孽障!既不与水,看棍!」丢一个架子,抢个满怀,不容说,着头便打;那真仙侧身躲过,使钩子急架相还。这一场比前更胜,好杀:
逐句解 Line by line
The True Immortal, hearing this, was all beaming satisfaction, a whole bosom of spring; smiling broadly, with a gust of imposing air he levelled the as-you-will hook, came out of the gate and shouted, "Impudent ape! What have you come for now?"
作甚 takes 甚 as shén, what — not the intensifier shèn of greatly. 喜孜孜 and 笑盈盈 are both doubled descriptions of a man in high good humour. The counsel has worked.
The Great Sage said, "I have come only for water."
Nine characters, and the fourth time in the chapter he has said it. The request has never once changed and has never once been granted.
The True Immortal said, "The spring water is the well of my own household; though it were an emperor or a chief minister, he too must come with presentation silk and mutton and wine to ask for it, and only then would he get so much as a trifle; and you, who are moreover my enemy, dare to come for it empty-handed?"
宰相 takes 相 as xiàng, the minister. 吾家之井 — my household's well — is the whole legal theory of his position, asserted over a natural spring. 些須 is the merest trifle.
The Great Sage said, "You really will not give it?"
真個不與 asks for the refusal to be put on the record, which is exactly what Wukong needs before he can strike.
The True Immortal said, "I will not, I will not."
Seven characters, doubled for finality. The exchange is now formally complete and both men know it.
The Great Sage cursed, "You impudent obstruction! If you will not give the water — then look to my rod!"
看棍 takes 看 as kàn — look to my rod — the same formula he used before the first fight.
He threw himself into a stance, closed right in, and without waiting to talk struck straight at the head; and the True Immortal twisted aside to avoid it and brought up the hook to parry and return the blow.
著頭 takes 著 as zhuó, the same construction as 著腳 in the earlier battle verse; 相還 takes 相 as xiāng and 還 as huán, to give back. Both 子 are the light suffix zi.
This bout was better than the last. A fine fight:
更 is gèng, the comparative. The tag explicitly measures this description against the one at the first battle, which is unusual — the novel rarely cross-references its own set-pieces, and here it is inviting the reader to compare.
The gold-banded rod, the as-you-will hook; two men in fury, each nursing his grudge.
The verse opens on a three-three-seven measure rather than a flat seven, naming the two weapons before either man. 各懷仇 gives them a grievance apiece, which the first battle piece did not do.
Flying sand and rolling stones, and heaven and earth went dark; scattered earth and driven dust, and sun and moon were grieved.
乾坤 takes 乾 as qián, the trigram, against the gān, dry, of 乾飯. 走石 takes 石 as shí. The couplet is the standard heaven-and-earth-in-uproar formula of the form.
The Great Sage came for water to save his master; the demon immortal, for his nephew's sake, would not allow the asking.
為侄 takes 為 as wèi, for the sake of. The couplet restates the balanced pair from the first battle in almost the same grammar, and the word 妖仙 — demon immortal — is the narrator's own verdict slipped into the parallel.
Both households put out all their strength; in one place they staked it on peace or ruin.
一處 takes 處 as chù, and the 一 in front of it is yí, since it shifts before a falling tone. 賭安休 — to gamble on whether it ends — turns the fight into a wager, which is what the immortal proposed before the first one.
Teeth clenched, they fought for the mastery; jaws set, they settled hard against soft.
剛柔 — hard and soft — is the vocabulary of the Book of Changes pressed into service for a brawl. It is the kind of joke this form makes without signalling that it has made one.
Wits added, spirits roused the higher, they spewed cloud and belched mist till the ghosts and spirits grieved.
噯 is ǎi, to belch something forth, matching the 噴 beside it. The same character also serves as a sighing interjection, read āi, but an interjection cannot occupy a verb's slot, and this one is spewing mist.
Clack and clatter the hook and rod rang out; their shouts roared and bellowed till the hills shook.
哮 is xiào by the modern standard, in 咆哮 and 哮喘 alike; the reading xiāo is often seen and is not the standard one. 樸樸兵兵 imitates weapons striking and keeps its ordinary reading.
A wild wind rolled up and bowed the woods; the killing air spread thick and passed the Dipper and the Ox.
斗牛 takes 斗 as dǒu, never dòu. The Dipper and the Ox are lunar mansions, and naming them lifts the fight from the treeline to the sky.
The Great Sage, the more he strove, the better pleased he grew; the True Immortal, the more he struck, the closer he clung.
綢繆 is to be bound tightly together, and applied to a man in a fight it means he will not disengage. The couplet distinguishes the two temperaments precisely: one is enjoying himself, the other cannot let go.
With set heart and fixed purpose they contended; till life or death were settled there would be no leaving off.
相 is xiāng; 罷休 takes 罷 as bà, to leave off. Both 不 in this line stand before falling tones and so shift to bú. The verse closes on deadlock, as the first one did, and the prose again breaks it.
The second battle is staged as a deliberate rerun of the first, and the tag says so: 這一場比前更勝, this bout was better than the last. The novel rarely measures its set-pieces against one another, and the comparison invites the reader to notice what has changed. Structurally almost nothing has — the same two men, the same weapons, the same deadlock at the close. What has changed is that this fight is a diversion, and only one of the two combatants knows it.
The negotiation that precedes it is the fullest statement of the immortal's case. 泉水乃吾家之井 — the spring water is my household's well — asserts private ownership of a natural source, and the tariff follows from that premise: emperors and chief ministers would have to bring silk and mutton, so an enemy arriving empty-handed can hardly expect better. It is a coherent position, stated without embarrassment, and the novel lets it stand unanswered by anything except a rod.
The verse is more accomplished than its predecessor. It opens on a three-three-seven measure rather than a flat seven; it moves outward from the weapons to sand and stones, then to sun and moon, then to the Dipper and the Ox, so that the fight expands through three orders of magnitude; and its closing couplet separates the two men by temperament rather than by armament — 愈爭愈喜悅 against 越打越綢繆.
That last distinction is the joke the whole passage is built around. The immortal has been persuaded by his gatekeeper that his opponent's heart is not in the fight. In fact Wukong is delighted, and for a reason nobody on the other side can see: every line of this verse is a line during which Sha Monk is at the well with a bucket.