Canonical Classics ← 第五十三回
第五十三回
禪chán主zhǔ吞tūn餐cān懷huái鬼guǐ孕yùn
黃huáng婆pó運yùn水shuǐ解jiě邪xié胎tāi

The Master of Dhyāna, Swallowing His Meal, Conceives a Ghostly Pregnancy · The Yellow Dame Draws Water and Dissolves the Demon Foetus

道人索禮
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script 繁
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

道人索禮 The Daoist Demands His Presents

不bù時shí來lái至zhì門mén首shǒu,見jiàn一yí個gè老lǎo道dào人rén盤pán坐zuò在zài綠lǜ茵yīn之zhī上shàng。大dà聖shèng放fàng下xià瓦wǎ缽bō,近jìn前qián道dào問wèn訊xùn。那nà道dào人rén欠qiàn身shēn還huán禮lǐ道dào:「那nà方fāng來lái者zhě?至zhì小xiǎo庵ān有yǒu何hé勾gòu當dàng?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「貧pín僧sēng乃nǎi東dōng土tǔ大dà唐táng欽qīn差chāi西xī天tiān取qǔ經jīng者zhě。因yīn我wǒ師shī父fù誤wù飲yǐn了le子zǐ母mǔ河hé之zhī水shuǐ,如rú今jīn腹fù疼téng腫zhǒng脹zhàng難nán禁jīn。問wèn及jí土tǔ人rén,說shuō是shì結jié成chéng胎tāi氣qì,無wú方fāng可kě治zhì。訪fǎng得dé解jiě陽yáng山shān破pò兒ér洞dòng有yǒu落luò胎tāi泉quán可kě以yǐ消xiāo得de胎tāi氣qì。故gù此cǐ特tè來lái拜bài見jiàn如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān,求qiú些xiē泉quán水shuǐ,搭dā救jiù師shī父fù。累lèi煩fán老lǎo道dào指zhǐ引yǐn指zhǐ引yǐn。」那nà道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「此cǐ間jiān就jiù是shì破pò兒ér洞dòng,今jīn改gǎi為wéi聚jù仙xiān庵ān了le。我wǒ卻què不bú是shì別bié人rén,即jí是shì如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān老lǎo爺yé的de大dà徒tú弟dì。你nǐ叫jiào做zuò甚shén麼me名míng字zì?待dài我wǒ好hǎo與yǔ你nǐ通tōng報bào。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì唐táng三sān藏zàng法fǎ師shī的de大dà徒tú弟dì,賤jiàn名míng孫sūn悟wù空kōng。」那nà道dào人rén問wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ的de花huā紅hóng、酒jiǔ禮lǐ都dōu在zài那nǎ裡lǐ?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì個gè過guò路lù的de掛guà搭dā僧sēng,不bù曾céng辦bàn得de來lái。」道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ好hǎo痴chī呀ya,我wǒ老lǎo師shī父fù護hù住zhù山shān泉quán,並bìng不bù曾céng白bái送sòng與yǔ人rén。你nǐ回huí去qù辦bàn將jiāng禮lǐ來lái,我wǒ好hǎo通tōng報bào。不bù然rán請qǐng回huí。莫mò想xiǎng,莫mò想xiǎng。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「人rén情qíng大dà似sì聖shèng旨zhǐ。你nǐ去qù說shuō我wǒ老lǎo孫sūn的de名míng字zì,他tā必bì然rán做zuò個gè人rén情qíng,或huò者zhě連lián井jǐng都dōu送sòng我wǒ也yě。」不bù时shí来lái至zhì门mén首shǒu,见jiàn一yí个gè老lǎo道dào人rén盘pán坐zuò在zài绿lǜ茵yīn之zhī上shàng。大dà圣shèng放fàng下xià瓦wǎ钵bō,近jìn前qián道dào问wèn讯xùn。那nà道dào人rén欠qiàn身shēn还huán礼lǐ道dào:「那nà方fāng来lái者zhě?至zhì小xiǎo庵ān有yǒu何hé勾gòu当dàng?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「贫pín僧sēng乃nǎi东dōng土tǔ大dà唐táng钦qīn差chāi西xī天tiān取qǔ经jīng者zhě。因yīn我wǒ师shī父fù误wù饮yǐn了le子zǐ母mǔ河hé之zhī水shuǐ,如rú今jīn腹fù疼téng肿zhǒng胀zhàng难nán禁jīn。问wèn及jí土tǔ人rén,说shuō是shì结jié成chéng胎tāi气qì,无wú方fāng可kě治zhì。访fǎng得dé解jiě阳yáng山shān破pò儿ér洞dòng有yǒu落luò胎tāi泉quán可kě以yǐ消xiāo得de胎tāi气qì。故gù此cǐ特tè来lái拜bài见jiàn如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān,求qiú些xiē泉quán水shuǐ,搭dā救jiù师shī父fù。累lèi烦fán老lǎo道dào指zhǐ引yǐn指zhǐ引yǐn。」那nà道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「此cǐ间jiān就jiù是shì破pò儿ér洞dòng,今jīn改gǎi为wéi聚jù仙xiān庵ān了le。我wǒ却què不bú是shì别bié人rén,即jí是shì如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān老lǎo爷yé的de大dà徒tú弟dì。你nǐ叫jiào做zuò甚shén么me名míng字zì?待dài我wǒ好hǎo与yǔ你nǐ通tōng报bào。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì唐táng三sān藏zàng法fǎ师shī的de大dà徒tú弟dì,贱jiàn名míng孙sūn悟wù空kōng。」那nà道dào人rén问wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ的de花huā红hóng、酒jiǔ礼lǐ都dōu在zài那nǎ里lǐ?」行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì个gè过guò路lù的de挂guà搭dā僧sēng,不bù曾céng办bàn得de来lái。」道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ好hǎo痴chī呀ya,我wǒ老lǎo师shī父fù护hù住zhù山shān泉quán,并bìng不bù曾céng白bái送sòng与yǔ人rén。你nǐ回huí去qù办bàn将jiāng礼lǐ来lái,我wǒ好hǎo通tōng报bào。不bù然rán请qǐng回huí。莫mò想xiǎng,莫mò想xiǎng。」行xíng者zhě道dào:「人rén情qíng大dà似sì圣shèng旨zhǐ。你nǐ去qù说shuō我wǒ老lǎo孙sūn的de名míng字zì,他tā必bì然rán做zuò个gè人rén情qíng,或huò者zhě连lián井jǐng都dōu送sòng我wǒ也yě。」


逐句解 Line by line

不bù時shí來lái至zhì門mén首shǒu,見jiàn一yí個gè老lǎo道dào人rén盤pán坐zuò在zài綠lǜ茵yīn之zhī上shàng。 不bù时shí来lái至zhì门mén首shǒu,见jiàn一yí个gè老lǎo道dào人rén盘pán坐zuò在zài绿lǜ茵yīn之zhī上shàng。

Before long he came to the gate, and saw an old Daoist sitting cross-legged on the green turf.

綠茵 is a mat of turf. The figure is posed as a picture of cultivated repose, which the next several segments take carefully to pieces.

大dà聖shèng放fàng下xià瓦wǎ缽bō,近jìn前qián道dào問wèn訊xùn。 大dà圣shèng放fàng下xià瓦wǎ钵bō,近jìn前qián道dào问wèn讯xùn。

The Great Sage set down the earthenware bowl, stepped up and made his salutation.

Wukong observes the courtesies exactly. The whole of this passage turns on his doing so and getting nothing at all for it.

那nà道dào人rén欠qiàn身shēn還huán禮lǐ道dào:「那nà方fāng來lái者zhě?至zhì小xiǎo庵ān有yǒu何hé勾gòu當dàng?」 那nà道dào人rén欠qiàn身shēn还huán礼lǐ道dào:「那nà方fāng来lái者zhě?至zhì小xiǎo庵ān有yǒu何hé勾gòu当dàng?」

The Daoist bowed slightly in return and said, "Where is it you come from? What business brings you to our little hermitage?"

還禮 takes 還 as huán, to give back — a salutation returned, not the hái of still. 勾當 takes 當 as dàng, business or affair. Both 那 are nà.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「貧pín僧sēng乃nǎi東dōng土tǔ大dà唐táng欽qīn差chāi西xī天tiān取qǔ經jīng者zhě。 行xíng者zhě道dào:「贫pín僧sēng乃nǎi东dōng土tǔ大dà唐táng钦qīn差chāi西xī天tiān取qǔ经jīng者zhě。

Pilgrim said, "This poor monk is one commissioned by the Great Tang of the Land of the East to fetch scriptures from the Western Heaven.

欽差 takes 差 as chāi, to dispatch somebody on a commission, not chà, to differ. Wukong opens with the imperial credential again, exactly as he did at the cottage door.

因yīn我wǒ師shī父fù誤wù飲yǐn了le子zǐ母mǔ河hé之zhī水shuǐ,如rú今jīn腹fù疼téng腫zhǒng脹zhàng難nán禁jīn。 因yīn我wǒ师shī父fù误wù饮yǐn了le子zǐ母mǔ河hé之zhī水shuǐ,如rú今jīn腹fù疼téng肿zhǒng胀zhàng难nán禁jīn。

Because my master drank by mistake of the water of the Child-and-Mother River, his belly now aches and is swollen past bearing.

難禁 takes 禁 as jīn, to endure. 子母河 takes 子 as zǐ, child. 腫脹 is distension — the vocabulary here is clinical rather than comic.

問wèn及jí土tǔ人rén,說shuō是shì結jié成chéng胎tāi氣qì,無wú方fāng可kě治zhì。 问wèn及jí土tǔ人rén,说shuō是shì结jié成chéng胎tāi气qì,无wú方fāng可kě治zhì。

On enquiring of the local people, we were told it is a conception formed, for which there is no prescription that can cure it.

無方可治 is the formula for a condition that lies outside medicine: no prescription reaches it. Wukong reports the old woman's diagnosis accurately, hopelessness included.

訪fǎng得dé解jiě陽yáng山shān破pò兒ér洞dòng有yǒu落luò胎tāi泉quán可kě以yǐ消xiāo得de胎tāi氣qì。 访fǎng得dé解jiě阳yáng山shān破pò儿ér洞dòng有yǒu落luò胎tāi泉quán可kě以yǐ消xiāo得de胎tāi气qì。

We learned that there is a Fetus-Dissolving Spring in the Child-Destroying Cave of Mount Dissolving-Yang, which can dissolve the fetal humour.

Two 得 in one sentence with different readings: dé in 訪得, to learn by asking about, and the light de in 消得, which asks whether the thing can be done — able to dissolve it. Having the two side by side in a single line is the clearest illustration of the split anywhere in this stretch.

故gù此cǐ特tè來lái拜bài見jiàn如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān,求qiú些xiē泉quán水shuǐ,搭dā救jiù師shī父fù。 故gù此cǐ特tè来lái拜bài见jiàn如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān,求qiú些xiē泉quán水shuǐ,搭dā救jiù师shī父fù。

For that reason I have come expressly to call upon the True Immortal As-You-Will, to beg a little of the spring water and rescue my master.

拜見 and 求 keep the language of formal petition throughout. He is doing precisely what the old woman said the water required, minus the goods.

累lèi煩fán老lǎo道dào指zhǐ引yǐn指zhǐ引yǐn。」 累lèi烦fán老lǎo道dào指zhǐ引yǐn指zhǐ引yǐn。」

I must trouble the venerable Daoist to show me the way — pray show me the way."

指引指引 doubles the verb to soften it — a politeness English manages with please and a rising tone. 累煩 apologises for the imposition before making it.

那nà道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「此cǐ間jiān就jiù是shì破pò兒ér洞dòng,今jīn改gǎi為wéi聚jù仙xiān庵ān了le。 那nà道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「此cǐ间jiān就jiù是shì破pò儿ér洞dòng,今jīn改gǎi为wéi聚jù仙xiān庵ān了le。

The Daoist said with a laugh, "This place is the Child-Destroying Cave, but it has been changed now into the Convent of Assembled Immortals.

改為 takes 為 as wéi, the verb — changed into. 此間 takes 間 as jiān. He corrects the name before he answers anything, which is the first sign of where this conversation is going.

我wǒ卻què不bú是shì別bié人rén,即jí是shì如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān老lǎo爺yé的de大dà徒tú弟dì。 我wǒ却què不bú是shì别bié人rén,即jí是shì如rú意yì真zhēn仙xiān老lǎo爷yé的de大dà徒tú弟dì。

And I am no other than the senior disciple of His Honour the True Immortal As-You-Will.

老爺 is a term of deference for a master, roughly His Honour, and the gatekeeper applies it to his own teacher while announcing his own rank in the same breath.

你nǐ叫jiào做zuò甚shén麼me名míng字zì?待dài我wǒ好hǎo與yǔ你nǐ通tōng報bào。」 你nǐ叫jiào做zuò甚shén么me名míng字zì?待dài我wǒ好hǎo与yǔ你nǐ通tōng报bào。」

What is your name called? Wait, and I will announce you properly."

甚 is shén in 甚麼. 通報 — to send word in — is the gatekeeper's function, and as it turns out, his leverage.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì唐táng三sān藏zàng法fǎ師shī的de大dà徒tú弟dì,賤jiàn名míng孫sūn悟wù空kōng。」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì唐táng三sān藏zàng法fǎ师shī的de大dà徒tú弟dì,贱jiàn名míng孙sūn悟wù空kōng。」

Pilgrim said, "I am the senior disciple of the Tang Monk Tripitaka, Master of the Law; my humble name is Sun Wukong."

賤名, my worthless name, is the conventional self-deprecation. Wukong offers it straight, with no boast attached, which for him is unusual and will shortly prove to have been a mistake.

那nà道dào人rén問wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ的de花huā紅hóng、酒jiǔ禮lǐ都dōu在zài那nǎ裡lǐ?」 那nà道dào人rén问wèn曰yuē:「你nǐ的de花huā红hóng、酒jiǔ礼lǐ都dōu在zài那nǎ里lǐ?」

The Daoist asked, "Where are your gifts of silk and your presents of wine?"

Two 那 with different readings in one sentence: nà, that, in 那道人, and nǎ, where, in 都在那裡. Note that the question about gifts arrives before any acknowledgement of the name just given.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì個gè過guò路lù的de掛guà搭dā僧sēng,不bù曾céng辦bàn得de來lái。」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「我wǒ是shì个gè过guò路lù的de挂guà搭dā僧sēng,不bù曾céng办bàn得de来lái。」

Pilgrim said, "I am a wandering monk passing through, and did not manage to provide any."

辦得來 asks whether the thing could be managed, so 得 is the light de. 掛搭僧 is a monk who hangs up his bundle wherever he lodges — one with no fixed house and nothing to his name, which is the whole of his answer.

道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ好hǎo痴chī呀ya,我wǒ老lǎo師shī父fù護hù住zhù山shān泉quán,並bìng不bù曾céng白bái送sòng與yǔ人rén。 道dào人rén笑xiào道dào:「你nǐ好hǎo痴chī呀ya,我wǒ老lǎo师shī父fù护hù住zhù山shān泉quán,并bìng不bù曾céng白bái送sòng与yǔ人rén。

The Daoist laughed and said, "How simple you are! My old master guards the mountain spring, and has never once given it away for nothing.

並不曾白送 states the policy plainly: never once given free. 白 here means gratis, for nothing, and it carries the entire weight of the refusal.

你nǐ回huí去qù辦bàn將jiāng禮lǐ來lái,我wǒ好hǎo通tōng報bào。 你nǐ回huí去qù办bàn将jiāng礼lǐ来lái,我wǒ好hǎo通tōng报bào。

Go back and get the gifts together, and then I will announce you.

辦將禮來 slips 將, read jiāng, in between the verb and its direction — go and get the gifts and bring them here. The instruction is delivered as though it were helpfulness.

不bù然rán請qǐng回huí。莫mò想xiǎng,莫mò想xiǎng。」 不bù然rán请qǐng回huí。莫mò想xiǎng,莫mò想xiǎng。」

Otherwise, please go home. Don't think of it, don't think of it."

The doubled 莫想 — don't think of it, don't think of it — has the finality of a door closing.

行xíng者zhě道dào:「人rén情qíng大dà似sì聖shèng旨zhǐ。你nǐ去qù說shuō我wǒ老lǎo孫sūn的de名míng字zì,他tā必bì然rán做zuò個gè人rén情qíng,或huò者zhě連lián井jǐng都dōu送sòng我wǒ也yě。」 行xíng者zhě道dào:「人rén情qíng大dà似sì圣shèng旨zhǐ。你nǐ去qù说shuō我wǒ老lǎo孙sūn的de名míng字zì,他tā必bì然rán做zuò个gè人rén情qíng,或huò者zhě连lián井jǐng都dōu送sòng我wǒ也yě。」

Pilgrim said, "A favour done outweighs an imperial edict. Go and speak my name, Old Sun's name, and he will surely do me the favour — he might even make me a present of the whole well."

人情大似聖旨 is a proverb, and still a recognisable one: a favour owed carries further than an imperial edict. It is the Ming version of it's not what you know, it's who you know. 似 is sì. Wukong is proposing that his own reputation counts as currency, and that is exactly the miscalculation the next passage turns on.


總評 Commentary

The passage is a study in the failure of correct procedure. Wukong sets down his bowl, makes his salutation, states where he is from, explains his master's condition, cites his authority and asks politely — and the gatekeeper's only substantive question is about the gifts. Every courtesy is observed on both sides, and nothing whatever is accomplished.

The gatekeeper is drawn with some economy. He corrects the cave's name to the convent's before answering any question; he announces his own rank as senior disciple in the act of deferring to his master; and he frames the tariff as friendly advice — go back, get the gifts, and then I will announce you. The word he uses for the policy is 白, gratis: nothing here is given for nothing. He is not cruel, and that is rather the point. He is an officer of a system.

Wukong's closing gambit is the most interesting thing in the passage and it is a misjudgement. 人情大似聖旨 — a favour outweighs an imperial edict — proposes that personal standing can stand in for goods, and he offers his own name as the standing in question. The proposal is not absurd. In most of this novel it would work, since Wukong's name opens doors across three realms. What he does not know is that here it will act as a detonator, and the next passage opens with the immortal reaching for a weapon at the sound of it.