道人索禮 The Daoist Demands His Presents
不時來至門首,見一個老道人盤坐在綠茵之上。大聖放下瓦缽,近前道問訊。那道人欠身還禮道:「那方來者?至小庵有何勾當?」行者道:「貧僧乃東土大唐欽差西天取經者。因我師父誤飲了子母河之水,如今腹疼腫脹難禁。問及土人,說是結成胎氣,無方可治。訪得解陽山破兒洞有落胎泉可以消得胎氣。故此特來拜見如意真仙,求些泉水,搭救師父。累煩老道指引指引。」那道人笑道:「此間就是破兒洞,今改為聚仙庵了。我卻不是別人,即是如意真仙老爺的大徒弟。你叫做甚麼名字?待我好與你通報。」行者道:「我是唐三藏法師的大徒弟,賤名孫悟空。」那道人問曰:「你的花紅、酒禮都在那裡?」行者道:「我是個過路的掛搭僧,不曾辦得來。」道人笑道:「你好痴呀,我老師父護住山泉,並不曾白送與人。你回去辦將禮來,我好通報。不然請回。莫想,莫想。」行者道:「人情大似聖旨。你去說我老孫的名字,他必然做個人情,或者連井都送我也。」不时来至门首,见一个老道人盘坐在绿茵之上。大圣放下瓦钵,近前道问讯。那道人欠身还礼道:「那方来者?至小庵有何勾当?」行者道:「贫僧乃东土大唐钦差西天取经者。因我师父误饮了子母河之水,如今腹疼肿胀难禁。问及土人,说是结成胎气,无方可治。访得解阳山破儿洞有落胎泉可以消得胎气。故此特来拜见如意真仙,求些泉水,搭救师父。累烦老道指引指引。」那道人笑道:「此间就是破儿洞,今改为聚仙庵了。我却不是别人,即是如意真仙老爷的大徒弟。你叫做甚么名字?待我好与你通报。」行者道:「我是唐三藏法师的大徒弟,贱名孙悟空。」那道人问曰:「你的花红、酒礼都在那里?」行者道:「我是个过路的挂搭僧,不曾办得来。」道人笑道:「你好痴呀,我老师父护住山泉,并不曾白送与人。你回去办将礼来,我好通报。不然请回。莫想,莫想。」行者道:「人情大似圣旨。你去说我老孙的名字,他必然做个人情,或者连井都送我也。」
逐句解 Line by line
Before long he came to the gate, and saw an old Daoist sitting cross-legged on the green turf.
綠茵 is a mat of turf. The figure is posed as a picture of cultivated repose, which the next several segments take carefully to pieces.
The Great Sage set down the earthenware bowl, stepped up and made his salutation.
Wukong observes the courtesies exactly. The whole of this passage turns on his doing so and getting nothing at all for it.
The Daoist bowed slightly in return and said, "Where is it you come from? What business brings you to our little hermitage?"
還禮 takes 還 as huán, to give back — a salutation returned, not the hái of still. 勾當 takes 當 as dàng, business or affair. Both 那 are nà.
Pilgrim said, "This poor monk is one commissioned by the Great Tang of the Land of the East to fetch scriptures from the Western Heaven.
欽差 takes 差 as chāi, to dispatch somebody on a commission, not chà, to differ. Wukong opens with the imperial credential again, exactly as he did at the cottage door.
Because my master drank by mistake of the water of the Child-and-Mother River, his belly now aches and is swollen past bearing.
難禁 takes 禁 as jīn, to endure. 子母河 takes 子 as zǐ, child. 腫脹 is distension — the vocabulary here is clinical rather than comic.
On enquiring of the local people, we were told it is a conception formed, for which there is no prescription that can cure it.
無方可治 is the formula for a condition that lies outside medicine: no prescription reaches it. Wukong reports the old woman's diagnosis accurately, hopelessness included.
We learned that there is a Fetus-Dissolving Spring in the Child-Destroying Cave of Mount Dissolving-Yang, which can dissolve the fetal humour.
Two 得 in one sentence with different readings: dé in 訪得, to learn by asking about, and the light de in 消得, which asks whether the thing can be done — able to dissolve it. Having the two side by side in a single line is the clearest illustration of the split anywhere in this stretch.
For that reason I have come expressly to call upon the True Immortal As-You-Will, to beg a little of the spring water and rescue my master.
拜見 and 求 keep the language of formal petition throughout. He is doing precisely what the old woman said the water required, minus the goods.
I must trouble the venerable Daoist to show me the way — pray show me the way."
指引指引 doubles the verb to soften it — a politeness English manages with please and a rising tone. 累煩 apologises for the imposition before making it.
The Daoist said with a laugh, "This place is the Child-Destroying Cave, but it has been changed now into the Convent of Assembled Immortals.
改為 takes 為 as wéi, the verb — changed into. 此間 takes 間 as jiān. He corrects the name before he answers anything, which is the first sign of where this conversation is going.
And I am no other than the senior disciple of His Honour the True Immortal As-You-Will.
老爺 is a term of deference for a master, roughly His Honour, and the gatekeeper applies it to his own teacher while announcing his own rank in the same breath.
What is your name called? Wait, and I will announce you properly."
甚 is shén in 甚麼. 通報 — to send word in — is the gatekeeper's function, and as it turns out, his leverage.
Pilgrim said, "I am the senior disciple of the Tang Monk Tripitaka, Master of the Law; my humble name is Sun Wukong."
賤名, my worthless name, is the conventional self-deprecation. Wukong offers it straight, with no boast attached, which for him is unusual and will shortly prove to have been a mistake.
The Daoist asked, "Where are your gifts of silk and your presents of wine?"
Two 那 with different readings in one sentence: nà, that, in 那道人, and nǎ, where, in 都在那裡. Note that the question about gifts arrives before any acknowledgement of the name just given.
Pilgrim said, "I am a wandering monk passing through, and did not manage to provide any."
辦得來 asks whether the thing could be managed, so 得 is the light de. 掛搭僧 is a monk who hangs up his bundle wherever he lodges — one with no fixed house and nothing to his name, which is the whole of his answer.
The Daoist laughed and said, "How simple you are! My old master guards the mountain spring, and has never once given it away for nothing.
並不曾白送 states the policy plainly: never once given free. 白 here means gratis, for nothing, and it carries the entire weight of the refusal.
Go back and get the gifts together, and then I will announce you.
辦將禮來 slips 將, read jiāng, in between the verb and its direction — go and get the gifts and bring them here. The instruction is delivered as though it were helpfulness.
Otherwise, please go home. Don't think of it, don't think of it."
The doubled 莫想 — don't think of it, don't think of it — has the finality of a door closing.
Pilgrim said, "A favour done outweighs an imperial edict. Go and speak my name, Old Sun's name, and he will surely do me the favour — he might even make me a present of the whole well."
人情大似聖旨 is a proverb, and still a recognisable one: a favour owed carries further than an imperial edict. It is the Ming version of it's not what you know, it's who you know. 似 is sì. Wukong is proposing that his own reputation counts as currency, and that is exactly the miscalculation the next passage turns on.
The passage is a study in the failure of correct procedure. Wukong sets down his bowl, makes his salutation, states where he is from, explains his master's condition, cites his authority and asks politely — and the gatekeeper's only substantive question is about the gifts. Every courtesy is observed on both sides, and nothing whatever is accomplished.
The gatekeeper is drawn with some economy. He corrects the cave's name to the convent's before answering any question; he announces his own rank as senior disciple in the act of deferring to his master; and he frames the tariff as friendly advice — go back, get the gifts, and then I will announce you. The word he uses for the policy is 白, gratis: nothing here is given for nothing. He is not cruel, and that is rather the point. He is an officer of a system.
Wukong's closing gambit is the most interesting thing in the passage and it is a misjudgement. 人情大似聖旨 — a favour outweighs an imperial edict — proposes that personal standing can stand in for goods, and he offers his own name as the standing in question. The proposal is not absurd. In most of this novel it would work, since Wukong's name opens doors across three realms. What he does not know is that here it will act as a detonator, and the next passage opens with the immortal reaching for a weapon at the sound of it.