Canonical Classics ← 第二十回
第二十回
huángfēnglǐngtángsēngyǒunàn
bànshānzhōngjièzhēngxiān

On Yellow Wind Ridge the Tang Monk Meets Adversity · Halfway Up the Mountain Bajie Strives for the Lead

行者抓風
模式 Mode Read Study
拼音 Pinyin Off
字體 Script
原文 Original text 繁體 Traditional Reader's edition

行者抓風 The Pilgrim Catches the Wind

jièshàngqiánchězhùxíngzhědào:「shīxiōngshífēnfēngmenqiěduǒduǒergānjìng。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiōngfēngshíjiùduǒtǎnghuòqīnmiànzhuàngjiànyāojīngzěndeshìhǎo?」jièdào:「acéngwénchóufēngjiànlimenduǒduǒkuīrén。」xíngzhědào:「qiěyánděngzhèfēngzhuāláiwénwénkàn。」jièxiàodào:「shīxiōngyòuchěkōngtóuhuǎnglefēngyòuhǎozhuāguòláiwénjiùshìzhuālái便biànzuānlele。」xíngzhědào:「xiōngzhīdàolǎosūnyǒuzhuāfēngzhī。」hǎoshèngràngguòfēngtóufēngwěizhuāguòláiwénlewényǒuxiēxīngdào:「guǒránshìhǎofēngzhèfēngdewèidàoshìfēngdìngshìguàifēngduànyǒuxiēqiāo。」jièshàngqiánchězhùxíngzhědào:「shīxiōngshífēnfēngmenqiěduǒduǒergānjìng。」xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiōngfēngshíjiùduǒtǎnghuòqīnmiànzhuàngjiànyāojīngzěndeshìhǎo?」jièdào:「acéngwénchóufēngjiànlimenduǒduǒkuīrén。」xíngzhědào:「qiěyánděngzhèfēngzhuāláiwénwénkàn。」jièxiàodào:「shīxiōngyòuchěkōngtóuhuǎnglefēngyòuhǎozhuāguòláiwénjiùshìzhuālái便biànzuānlele。」xíngzhědào:「xiōngzhīdàolǎosūnyǒuzhuāfēngzhī。」hǎoshèngràngguòfēngtóufēngwěizhuāguòláiwénlewényǒuxiēxīngdào:「guǒránshìhǎofēngzhèfēngdewèidàoshìfēngdìngshìguàifēngduànyǒuxiēqiāo。」


逐句解 Line by line

jièshàngqiánchězhùxíngzhědào:「shīxiōngshífēnfēngmenqiěduǒduǒergānjìng。」 jièshàngqiánchězhùxíngzhědào:「shīxiōngshífēnfēngmenqiěduǒduǒergānjìng。」

Bajie came up and caught hold of the Pilgrim. "Brother, the wind is very great. We had best get under cover, and have done."

躲一躲兒乾淨: 乾淨 is here the adverb "and be done with it," taking gān, and the is the suffix, er. Bajie's instinct is sound, and the chapter will vindicate it twice.

xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiōngfēngshíjiùduǒtǎnghuòqīnmiànzhuàngjiànyāojīngzěndeshìhǎo?」 xíngzhěxiàodào:「xiōngfēngshíjiùduǒtǎnghuòqīnmiànzhuàngjiànyāojīngzěndeshìhǎo?」

The Pilgrim laughed. "Brother, you are no use at all. If we hide whenever the wind blows hard, what shall we do when we come face to face with a fiend?"

不濟, "no use." 親面撞見, to meet something face to face — which is exactly what happens in the very next passage.

jièdào:「acéngwénchóufēngjiànlimenduǒduǒkuīrén。」 jièdào:「acéngwénchóufēngjiànlimenduǒduǒkuīrén。」

Bajie said, "Brother, have you never heard it said, 'Shun lust as you would shun an enemy; shun the wind as you would shun an arrow'? If we take cover, we wrong nobody."

The proverb 避色如避仇避風如避箭 — shun lust as you would an enemy, shun a draught as you would an arrow — was a medical commonplace of the Song and Yuan: cold air and lechery alike shorten your life. Bajie produces it in a discussion about demons, and the misapplication is the joke. But this is his second proverb of the chapter, after the one about judging men by their faces, and on both occasions he is nearer right than his brother. 聞得 takes toneless de; is li.

xíngzhědào:「qiěyánděngzhèfēngzhuāláiwénwénkàn。」 xíngzhědào:「qiěyánděngzhèfēngzhuāláiwénwénkàn。」

The Pilgrim said, "Say no more. Let me take a handful of this wind and give it a smell."

抓一把來聞一聞看. The proposal is absurd, is taken literally, and works.

jièxiàodào:「shīxiōngyòuchěkōngtóuhuǎnglefēngyòuhǎozhuāguòláiwén jièxiàodào:「shīxiōngyòuchěkōngtóuhuǎnglefēngyòuhǎozhuāguòláiwén

Bajie laughed. "There goes my brother telling his empty lies again. How should a wind be caught and brought over to be smelled?

扯空頭謊, to spin an empty lie. 好抓得過來聞 takes as the "can it be done" reading .

jiùshìzhuālái便biànzuānlele。」 jiùshìzhuālái便biànzuānlele。」

And if you did catch it, it would only bore its way out and be gone."

抓得來, again the "can it be done" reading, . 鑽了去了 — bore its way out and be gone. The pig has thought harder about the physics of the thing than the monkey has.

xíngzhědào:「xiōngzhīdàolǎosūnyǒuzhuāfēngzhī。」 xíngzhědào:「xiōngzhīdàolǎosūnyǒuzhuāfēngzhī。」

The Pilgrim said, "Brother, you do not know that Old Monkey has a method he calls the wind-catch."

The source sets 抓風之法 between inner quotation marks, 『』: it is the name of a technique, and the Pilgrim produces it as though he were quoting from a manual.

hǎoshèngràngguòfēngtóufēngwěizhuāguòláiwénlewényǒuxiēxīng hǎoshèngràngguòfēngtóufēngwěizhuāguòláiwénlewényǒuxiēxīng

Excellent Great Sage! He let the head of the wind go past, caught its tail, drew it over and gave it a smell; and there was a rankness in it.

讓過風頭把那風尾抓過來 — he lets the head of the wind go past and takes it by the tail. The precision is deadpan. 腥氣 is a raw, fishy rankness, the standing sign in this book of a beast-demon.

dào:「guǒránshìhǎofēngzhèfēngdewèidàoshìfēngdìngshìguàifēngduànyǒuxiēqiāo。」 dào:「guǒránshìhǎofēngzhèfēngdewèidàoshìfēngdìngshìguàifēngduànyǒuxiēqiāo。」

He said, "It is no good wind indeed. The savor of this wind is no tiger's wind. It must be a fiend's wind, and there is certainly something strange about it."

不是虎風定是怪風. He is exactly half right: the wind belongs to a fiend, and the fiend has sent a tiger. 蹊蹺, qī qiāo, "queer, out of true" — a word the novel keeps for the moment just before an ambush.


總評 Commentary

A comic exchange that turns into the plot without any change of tone. Bajie wants to hide; the Pilgrim calls him useless; Bajie produces a proverb about draughts and lechery; the Pilgrim announces that he will catch a handful of the wind and smell it. Bajie objects on grounds of physics. Sun Wukong then does precisely what he said he would do: lets the head of the wind pass, takes it by the tail, brings it to his nose. It is the single most characteristic thing he does in the chapter — the impossible performed as a matter of routine, and used for reconnaissance.

His conclusion, 不是虎風定是怪風, is a fine piece of misplaced confidence. It is a fiend's wind. It is also, within half a page, a tiger's. The Great Sage can smell the difference between a beast and a demon and cannot conceive that a demon might keep one. And Bajie, who wanted to get out of the wind, is about to be the one who fights.